Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Gonk on March 13, 2024, 04:12:44 AM

Title: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Gonk on March 13, 2024, 04:12:44 AM
From the Rules for Fleadh Competitions published by Comhaltas:

Note 1 Comp 2: Bosca Ceoil / Button Accordion: ABCD (this is confined to TWO Row Button Accordion only).

Note 5 Comp 13: Mileoideon / Melodeon: The single row accordion is not a melodeon and is not acceptable in the melodeon competition.

Source: https://comhaltas.ie/images/press_room/rialacha_fleadhanna_ceoil_English.pdf

I cannot imagine what they are calling a "single row accordion" if not a 10-button melodeon.  There is a separate category for "piano accordions," so it's not that.  Can anyone ease my bafflement?
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Lars on March 13, 2024, 09:55:40 AM
From my understanding, their definition requires a melodeon to have a growl-box and pull-stoppers to be a 'melodeon'. Some time ago, someone was disqualified for entering with a box that had a flat bass end - they had to enter into the 'misc.'-category.

For example: Hohner 1040 = accordion. Hohner HA114 = melodeon.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Howard Jones on March 13, 2024, 01:20:46 PM
It seems peculiar to define something only by reference to what it is not, especially when that reference is itself not clearly defined.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Gonk on March 13, 2024, 08:04:26 PM
Thanks Lars, good to know... And how mysterious!  And I'm in agreement with Howard, it really begs the question.

I wonder if the issue with the 1040, etc, is the presence of the IV chord.  But then a 114 could be tuned to have a IV chord, or ii and vi, or any other modification, and still qualify.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Peadar on March 13, 2024, 11:25:23 PM
The way I understand the rule is that Comhaltas as a "traditional" music organisation count the "German Type"  diatonic 1 row as a melodjun and the "Italian Type" (AKA Vienna Type) as an Accordeon. Not entirely sure what they would do if someone rocked up to an accordion competition with one of the old 4 bass German type chromatics.

Not that I am ever going to be in competition.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Matthew B on March 14, 2024, 01:55:07 AM
From my understanding, their definition requires a melodeon to have a growl-box and pull-stoppers to be a 'melodeon'.

So where would one of Karel van der Leeuw's creations fit?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWBF2wOf720&t=5s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWBF2wOf720&t=5s)
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: mChavez on March 14, 2024, 07:52:37 AM
Peadar - don't you have a two-row 10-bass lepelbasser?  ;D That seems to fit the definition of a melodeon.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Peadar on March 14, 2024, 09:28:32 AM
Peadar - don't you have a two-row 10-bass lepelbasser?  ;D That seems to fit the definition of a melodeon.
I think it's the basses that make it an accordion and the limited number of hasses that make it a melodeon. I would understand the term which I think is Hiberno-English *melodeon basses* to mean just playing the 1/5 buttons on the LH end. Don't know how comhaltas would react to either a 2 bass *Italian Type* or a *German Type*  2 or 3 stopper.
But at the end of the day the Fleadh (Anna) is or are Irish national competitions under Irish national rules.
Title: Re: Confusing Comhaltas Code
Post by: Peadar on March 14, 2024, 09:37:07 AM
Oddly enough I am working at Fairview DART Depot today.  Right next to Comhaltas HQ...but as always the wrong side of the tracks 🤣🤣🤣
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal