Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ross Dubois on March 19, 2024, 10:13:55 PM
-
Out of curiosity and no real motivation to do such work myself, I was wondering if anyone has installed H reeds in a Non-Hohner machine before. Though it seems almost sacrilegious, surely someone has done this, and if so, how much of the Hohner sound travels with the reeds? I know that H reeds tend to carry a very special tone with them inside of Hohner boxes, and that reeds in general account for a lot of the sound of an accordion, but I am very curious about how hohner-like a different accordion might sound with the 'wrong' reeds in it.
For example, has someone ever slapped H reeds into a Paolo red box? Maybe a Castagnari? I would love to hear a sample of any transplant you folks may have done!
-
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=18184.msg222973#msg222973
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7456.msg92839#msg92839
You may have to scroll to the top of the thread in each of the links.
-
Wow, fascinating! Thanks for the links. From what I hear so far, that Castagnari seems to have morphed into a castagnohner or something, with both Italian qualities and hohner qualities. How interesting. I'm not sure I'd personally be keen on that effect but it's certainly not bad at all.
I hope other folks may also have additional anecdotal evidence, im intrigued
-
I have done it at the request of a customer for a small single row Busilacchio 2 voice. The original Italian reeds were superior, though…
-
I was wondering if anyone has installed H reeds in a Non-Hohner machine before. Though it seems almost sacrilegious, surely someone has done this, and if so, how much of the Hohner sound travels with the reeds? I know that H reeds tend to carry a very special tone with them inside of Hohner boxes, and that reeds in general account for a lot of the sound of an accordion, but I am very curious about how hohner-like a different accordion might sound with the 'wrong' reeds in it.
For example, has someone ever slapped H reeds into a Paolo red box? Maybe a Castagnari? I would love to hear a sample of any transplant you folks may have done!
Guilty as charged 8)
Link to a thread I posted back in 2016, which might be of interest.
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=18184.msg222968#msg222968 (https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=18184.msg222968#msg222968)
Sadly, Soundcloud seem to have removed or mislaid the sound examples referred to from the link mentioned in that post. I can't recall whether I kept a copy, but will search and re-post if found.
The reason I chose aluminium plated H reeds rather than T reeds for this project was that the rivets on the T reeds were marginally larger and caused difficulty in mounting on the acquired reedblocks without fouling the reeds on the adjaicent reedblocks in places. I have been a longtime fan of H reeds anyway, and I was, and still am, quite happy with my choice and the outcome.