Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Disparate Dan on March 20, 2024, 07:54:39 PM
-
If a bog-standard D/G melodeon with 3rd button start is converted to 4th button start, what notes do buttons 1, 2 and 3 produce?
-
I think that is a good question, and I do not know the answer .
-
3rd Button Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (G Scale) Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (Castagnari) Layout (https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=2) (thanks to Acorn Instruments)
Loads of layouts here (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/page,keyboard.html)
-
3rd Button Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (G Scale) Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (Castagnari) Layout (https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=2) (thanks to Acorn Instruments)
Thank you, kind sir. Most helpful. While I'm at it, am I right in guessing that assuming the box is tuned to A=440Hz, concert A is button 3 pull on a standard D/G ?
-
3rd Button Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (G Scale) Layout (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/2%20Row%20-%20D_G%20-%20G%20Scale%20with%20accidentals.jpg)
4th Button (Castagnari) Layout (https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=2) (thanks to Acorn Instruments)
Thank you, kind sir. Most helpful. While I'm at it, am I right in guessing that assuming the box is tuned to A=440Hz, that A is button 3 pull on a standard D/G ?
Yep
-
If a bog-standard D/G melodeon with 3rd button start is converted to 4th button start, what notes do buttons 1, 2 and 3 produce?
Whatever you want! But, as Lester implies, it's usually a variant, or combination, of either Low G scale, Low accidentals and reversals. Deciding what you want is one of the great pleasures of playing around with melodeon layouts.
However, after a bit, you realise that, whatever you try, it's all about compromise. There's a lot of mileage in realising this and working on learning how to bluff, using whatever notes you've got. I have three fourth button start instruments, all different and I'm working on it.
-
Your choice, but 12½ years ago there was a strong preference here for Anahata's layout.
I offered it to the major makers as a new "standard English"
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7727.msg96025
-
The only dumb question is the one you don't ask. In this case how about, "Why do I want extra low notes? What will I do with them?".
I bought a G-Scale box a year or so ago (for the sound, not the extra notes) and have found just two tunes in my repertoire that could usefully use the extra notes. And there are perfectly acceptable ways of fudging the tunes to not use them. This may be because I usually play an LMM box so jumping between octaves is less noticeable than with a MM box.
Some years ago I found that most of the tunes I play will fit on the 12 buttons of a Castagnari Giordi. It was a shock.
I play a couple of hundred tunes from the British Isles and France plus a smattering of music hall choruses, 1960s pop and even classical pieces. They all somehow work with a third button start box. There was a thread (last year?) that asked what the extra notes of a G-Scale box were for. My memory is that there was no sensible conclusion. Please feel free to disagree.
-
You "use them" for right hand pedal notes, right hand chords, or adding a note to a chord that's being expressed on the other end. they are also great for holding a pedal note with your index finger while you play tune with the other fingers. If you listen to, or watch Frederick Paris, he does that a lot.
The Anahata version is particularly versatile when you play in G, or any of it modes. Looking back at our conversation 10 years ago (linked yesterday) I think that's why it was so popular.
Of course if you don't use any of these techniques in your music, that's fine, carry on.
But it's probably not appropriate, and arguably "dumb", to knock them, if you haven't explored them? 🙂
-
Thank you Chris for a simple explanation, in one sentence, explaining how someone might use those notes.
I'm not knocking anyone's way of playing. As always it's about what you play and how you play it.
-
Your choice, but 12½ years ago there was a strong preference here for Anahata's layout.
I offered it to the major makers as a new "standard English"
It doesn't seem to have made any difference. Although 4th button start appears now to be the standard approach what is found on thos other buttons is still pretty much pot luck, unless a particular layout has been specified by a dealer or customer.
-
Interesting. Castagnari replied to my email noting the vote on this website, and said that they would take it up. I guess that the variations might reflect what is ordered by the dealers? Hohner never replied 🥴
For convenience we voted for this
"G-scale" aka "Anahata" optimised for G (*'accidentals' = unspecified)
1 2 3 4
G row | *F\Eb B/C D/F# G/A B/C D/E G/F# B/A D/C G/E
D row | *G#\Bb G/A A/C# D/E F#/G A/B D/C# F#/E A/G D/B F#/C#
-
On the Castagnari website fourth button start is listed as an option but not the Anahata system.
-
On the Castagnari website fourth button start is listed as an option but not the Anahata system.
Ed and I go 'tyre kicking' whenever we're doing workshops at a festival - essentially we spend a happy couple of hours playing a bunch of beginner boxes for sale on music stalls, usually rounded off with coffee and cake. The variety of layouts we find is interesting to say the least.
-
To the OP, I have and AD and a CF each of which have 4th button starts. The low-D AD box is particularly mellow.
Queen of the home at the moment is treasured low G, 4th button start DG from microbot which is a bandoneon tuned Erica. Now that box is mellow! (can get loud though, has the nice old reed sets)
-
I was just starting up when the whole '4th button' discussion kicked off. My new to me 3rd button start box was then quickly changed to 4th button and all my subsequent boxes are 4th button Low G boxes.
The low G note being the lowest note available on a fiddle, and fiddle being the commonest instrument to play English tunes, to me it made sense.
Yes you can play low phrases up an octave to fit onto a 3rd button start, but the conversion looses the top 2 sets of reeds,1 button's worth on each row.
When would you use them?
Apparently best used to call your dog back by a certain Mr Kirkpatrick!
-
the conversion looses the top 2 sets of reeds,1 button's worth on each row.
When would you use them?
I use those high notes so I stick with 3rd button start.
-
Fair enough.
I remember the late Steve Freereeder saying the same, as he right hand chorded a lot.
I don't and value the low notes.
As ever it's what you play that dictates how your box is set up.
-
I use those high notes so I stick with 3rd button start.
It was having to use those high notes that got me onto a 4th button start. On all 3 of the 3rd button start boxes that I had, when I'd moved a tune up an octave to make it fit I found the top notes to be unpleasantly shrill. Maybe just my ear
-
I have just bought a Hasky which came as 4th button start and the first thing I did was have the low notes and accidentals swopped over to allow me to play it as a 3rd button start but with the low notes available. This works for me because I use the accidentals a lot, have quite short fingers and would struggle with accidentals at the end of the fingerboard beyond the low notes. The low notes I use much less often. Mike Rowbotham who set it up tells me he has done quite a few like this. Everytime someone tries to tell me that we should all be playing their "ideal" set up I stop listening, there is no ideal set up, just what works for you!
-
Every time someone tries to tell me that we should all be playing their "ideal" set up I stop listening, there is no ideal set up, just what works for you!
Yes This Yes ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
-
4th start can be a stretch if you use head end acc's a lot. Even for me (size 9 glove).
Yet another example of "it depends what music you play".
But flipping accs is easy enough. I first did it 3 years in … then flipped them back having changed my music style!
-
I have no idea what size my hands are, but they are small.
I use the chin end accidentals frequently and have never had a problem... but we're all different.
We play different sized boxes with different right hand positions from Morris death grip to thumb along the keyboard edge.
There are no hard and fast rules, what works for one might not for another.
-
Every time someone tries to tell me that we should all be playing their "ideal" set up I stop listening, there is no ideal set up, just what works for you!
Yes This Yes ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Seconded. See also a) number of straps and b) on-the-row vs cross-row playing.
-
I have no idea what size my hands are, but they are small.
I use the chin end accidentals frequently and have never had a problem... but we're all different.
Yup, even I manage just fine, even with my teeny lady hands.
-
It was the tune "Stoney Steps" that did me in. Perhaps it started as an Anahata conspiracy.... :-X.
-
;D Steve, I know exactly what you mean!
A tune that blew me away...
-
I've never come across that tune before. Thanks for bringing it to my attention: I've just looked it up and, even with my 4th button start, I shall avoid it ;D
-
Fiddle range is often suggested as a reason for low G scale 4th button start, but even fiddle tunes (ie traditional tunes) rarely go down to G or A, and only occasionally to B or C, in my experience at least. I would consider having the B/C reed pairing of low G scale but forego the low G/A in favour of further accidentals D#4/F4, if I were the position to choose…
-
Not a dumb question as far as I'm concerned.
A very interesting and helpful conversation to 'overhear'.
Thanks to all contributing!
-
Arnold, I agree a low D#/Fnat is something that would fill a huge gap in a 2 row, but... I do use the low G/A that would be sacrificed in the tunes I play.
As mentioned before, repertoire dictates how you've set up your box.
-
Arnold, I agree a low D#/Fnat is something that would fill a huge gap in a 2 row, but... I do use the low G/A that would be sacrificed in the tunes I play.
As mentioned before, repertoire dictates how you've set up your box.
I agree, I was just suggesting out of the many options, which one would appeal to me personally…
-
Yes absolutely.
I remember seeing an Owen Woods Youtube video demonstrating his Bergflodt, specc'd by him. It has a little flick switch at the top of the keyboard. It switched the normal D#/Fnat to a low version. Brilliant!
I have no idea how it worked but was so envious!
-
...even fiddle tunes (ie traditional tunes) rarely go down to G or A, and only occasionally to B or C, in my experience at least. I would consider having the B/C reed pairing of low G scale but forego the low G/A in favour of further accidentals D#4/F4, if I were the position to choose…
The B/C is definitelyrecommended. Tunes like Polperro Bay and Mrs Saggs don't work for me without it. Yes, you can fake it with the basses, but it's not the same. Those notes are the reason I went for a fourth button start. A pull D and push F were a bonus. Stoney Steps persuaded me to adopt Anahata'slayout for the CF, but I rarely use the lowest notes.
When I played the bouzouki I used to retune to match what I was playing...sigh. Owen's switch sounds great.
How about a melodeon capo?
-
Fiddle range is often suggested as a reason for low G scale 4th button start, but even fiddle tunes (ie traditional tunes) rarely go down to G or A, and only occasionally to B or C, in my experience at least. I would consider having the B/C reed pairing of low G scale but forego the low G/A in favour of further accidentals D#4/F4, if I were the position to choose…
I have to disagree with that - Fiddlers that play fiddle the way most morris players seem to play the melodeon (i.e. Home key & lower octave of instrument) Will play in ascending order tunes in G,D,A.
Traditional tunes played in G on the "back strings" will invariably use the low G. Which is why I chose a one row in G as my first melodeon.
-
Having that low scale isn't just about playing tunes that venture down there. It also means you can play a lot of tunes, or parts of them, an octave down for a bit of variety. On an MM box with no low voice, it's nice to be able to play a tune in the low octave 2nd or 3rd time through.
The Bob Ellis Benny (3 row, of course) layout actually takes you down to the D below that bottom G. But on a 2 row instrument with the low G scale there's a lot you can do, as fiddle players know: it's not uncommon in Ireland when two fiddles are playing together for one of them to go down an octave.
-
The essence of arranging a tune is variation. Stony steps a consummate example. you can play tune. You can invert phrases. you can put a in place of tune. Mix the two. Syncopate the rhythm. Omit a note, or two, or even play brief pregnant … silence 😎
And, in your melodic variations you can move up into the second octave or just go up (by a third) or so. Or go down by same degree.
G/C system tends to put the tune … more or less in the middle of the keyboard, but because the D/G setup is very distant (only C#/F# is further) from that sweet spot, we end up with a whole set of upper octave notes that never get played.
That is the musical "elephant" in this debate. 4th button start does … quite a lot to improve things. I was personally quite surprised as to just how much!
When I was still on 3rd button, 25 years ago I had to steal melody notes from the left end of the instrument to play some of my tunes! 😉
-
a whole set of upper octave notes that never get played.
Is this not a 'speak for yourself' kinda thing, though?
But like it is indeed also not rocket science to look at tunes in G, D, and C, and observe that they're still all falling in the same kindsa places on the trebel clef. Ie the range of actual pitches remains relatively consistent regardless of the key.
I've always felt that the fourth apart system kind of works against us in this scenario - of the myriad tunes I've become acquainted with, the midpoint G that many tunes swim around is lower than the midpoint of tunes in D. The range of the fourth apart system however gives us best coverage as though the G that tunes swam around was higher, but the D is right. So you can't transpose the instrument up or down an octave to redress this without making the other... Less right?
So when we do adopt a fourth button start into the system, it's not uncommon now to be keen to use the extra & low vocabulary in favour of that G row, rather than balancing the buttons between both rows. And its also why it may make little sense to transpose that low scale system to other key pairings.
You see the same thing with half button acc rows - transposing a G/C acc row to D/G doesn't seem to quite give you the coverage where many seem to feel they want it.
-
Is this not a 'speak for yourself' kinda thing, though?
I was actually referring to a multitude of comments in this forum over many years. There was even one in this thread? A lot of people don't move outside buttons ±3 to ±8 in their style. "Dusty end", to describe the upper octave of a D/G was incredibly common in Melnet 15 years ago.
That works because so many tunes in our folk repertoire live within a fairly limited range of notes. And there is a lot of fun to be had in it.
Some tunes have much more extended range. The first that I attempted was fis-scottis, which is Swedish (Hedningarna I think). I was working a locum in Queensland and got to spend fairly long evenings by the sea with my Castagnari Lilly. it took a lot of practice, as it used almost the entire keyboard. The upper octave was … incredibly squeaky but as the tune is fairly brisk you've got away with it. It's actually much nicer if you have LM available. Yes, that is a personal note. but it is what got me moving my hand up and down the keyboard.
The more general point is about tune variations, again idiosyncratic, but these can work in a session provided you stay "in" harmonically. And that no idiot medley's to some other tune just as it's getting interesting. 🥴 i've seen some of that on your videos Gina, so you do it too? 🙂
Numerous techniques as per above. But having a couple of extra buttons at head end on a D/G really opens up "drop" rather than "raised" variation. Especially if you like to harmonise on the 6th for minor effect, as per Stéphane Deliq. I think that is a fairly general point. The detail would be idiosyncratic as you say ….. But the upper half of any musical scale tends to be more interesting? The characteristic note of Dorian is a #6? Of mixolydian … a b7?
Bottom line … is the squeaky notes in the high end of higher active aren't of much use. Whereas the upper half of the octave below G4 is full of fun
-
I was actually referring to a multitude of comments in this forum over many years. There was even one in this thread? A lot of people don't move outside buttons ±3 to ±8 in their style. "Dusty end", to describe the upper octave of a D/G was incredibly common in Melnet 15 years ago.
Well, yes? But also featured in the thread:
Rees saying he uses them (https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=30237.msg355309#msg355309)
and
People decrying the idea that there are universal truths about layouts and ways of playing.
Just seemed to me that 'never get played' is a pretty strong way of putting 'I think most people don't like them'.
-
I've not talked about universal truths at all, Gina. Just general principles that underlie any layout.
As always it "depends what you play". If people are happy playing on one row using 5 to 6 buttons that's fine. I find it incredible what some people achieve on a single row instrument. The principals involved there are perhaps courage, and prestidigitation? But having LMMH voices going definitely makes that easier. A "general principle" that I allude to above