Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: saguaro_squeezer on November 30, 2009, 09:38:04 PM

Title: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: saguaro_squeezer on November 30, 2009, 09:38:04 PM
Opinionated colleagues,

I have a pair of G/C Pokerworks now ... 1 low notes, 1 accidentals ... and found a local fellow who'd like to trade me one for a Hohner Lilliput.  I've poked around the forums and found that they're smaller, 2.5 row, some kind of Club tuning and people like to send them to Theo to be worked on  ;D.

If the boxes are in similar condition, would a swap be worth it?

Other than size, what is the appeal of the Lilliput?

I'll be interested in your opinions .....
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: HallelujahAl on November 30, 2009, 10:17:05 PM
Lilliput is a super little box - I'd probably go for the trade if it were me (and providing the condition etc was ok). The more interesting question probably is 'which Pokerwork' would you let go?
Low notes or accidentals???
 ;D
Regards
AL


BTW when you're over here in Blighty you could always pop it into Theo to be fettled while you're at it  ;)
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: saguaro_squeezer on November 30, 2009, 10:29:14 PM
Al,

I'm thinking that I'll keep the low notes.

And yes, I could leave it with Theo to be fettled ... I wasn't thinking that far ahead   >:E
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Theo on November 30, 2009, 10:43:00 PM
Well it is nice to be so popular.  :D

Another thing to consider is the keys.  Liliputs were made in C/F and less commonly in Bb/Eb.  If still at original pitch very likely to be tuned to a reference pitch of A=435.  You should also find out if the Liliput has been overhauled to replace wax and valves, if they are the originals they are likely to be source of trouble.  Because everything in the Liliput is small, there is room for only a very narrow fillet of wax round the reedplates so if the wax is brittle reedplates have a tendency to drop out.  The original valves are very likely to be either stiff, curled, about to drop off, or all three!
Nice boxes once fettled. 
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 01, 2009, 03:00:39 AM
Other than size, what is the appeal of the Lilliput?
I'll be interested in your opinions .....

They are great boxes, and in my opinion they are a higher quality level than the Pokerworks.  (Does anyone know if it is true that the Lilluputs were a higher-end item in the Hohner line?)
Unless it has been maintained, expect to put in some work to get it fit and fettled.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Andrew Culwell on December 01, 2009, 04:22:22 AM
Here is one on Youtube

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gaGYA3iyiGM
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Theo on December 01, 2009, 08:27:29 AM
They are great boxes, and in my opinion they are a higher quality level than the Pokerworks.  (Does anyone know if it is true that the Lilluputs were a higher-end item in the Hohner line?)
Unless it has been maintained, expect to put in some work to get it fit and fettled.

I would have said that they were of similar build quality to the two row Hohners of the same period (1930s)  The Preciosa is even smaller and has some features of a higher quality box eg real mother of pearl buttons, higher standard of finish, extra chord reeds
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 01, 2009, 03:16:36 PM
The Preciosa is even smaller and has some features of a higher quality box eg real mother of pearl buttons, higher standard of finish, extra chord reeds

Aahh, sorry, my memory switched it with my friend's Preciosa!
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Matthew B on December 01, 2009, 05:50:46 PM
I'd add my voice to the chorus of enthusiasm for the Liliput.  They're great little boxes, and highly portable.  Mine has significantly extended my musical-geographical range.  Being designed for children, they can feel a bit cramped if you're used to a full size box.  The buttons are smaller and closer together, and the bass end is all a bit compressed, from the strap to the button layout.  But you can get used to that pretty quickly, so its not a lasting problem.  They're club tuned, so they have a gleichton, and they have only four accidentals.  Consequently Liliputs are only chromatic up on the high octaves, unlike other clubs.  If you use them to play outside the home keys this limits your options a bit for things like Eb chords, and D chords on the draw.  But there are lots of unexpected things hiding in the club layout, even the limited version of the Liliput.  There are lengthy discussions elsewhere on the forum of the merits of the club system, and many people advocate declubbing the boxes, to get rid of the gleichton, or converting them to a custom D/G tuning. 

I prefer mine as built, but overhauled by Theo to modernize the tuning to A=440, and fix such things as wheezing valves and spluttering reeds.  It sounds wonderful.  The Hohner sound, but not a Pokerwork!   

Finally, my kids have started showing an interest in the box, and the Liliput is an ideal starting place for them.  I suspect that the beautiful black gloss paint on the bass soundboard and the treble thumb groove is full of lead, and at some point I'll probably test it, and if guilty as charged I'll strip it, and repaint it.  However, for now, I just make the kids wash their hands between playing and the next PBJ.  It would be nice if I could get them to do that the other way around, as well. 
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on December 01, 2009, 09:32:37 PM
I'd definitely go for the swap, assuming it is in a sensible condition.

The only caveat is the button size which can be too small and too close together for some people.

I'm a great fan - my Liliput tends to be my 'holiday' box; I can always find space to hide it in the car.
And I find it more comfortable to play at home than my pokerwork.

Andy

Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: press on regardless on December 02, 2009, 01:15:43 PM
I'd definitely go for the swap, assuming it is in a sensible condition.

The only caveat is the button size which can be too small and too close together for some people.

I'm a great fan - my Liliput tends to be my 'holiday' box; I can always find space to hide it in the car.
And I find it more comfortable to play at home than my pokerwork.

Andy
 



totally agree. I've had both and Preciosa is IMHO the better of the two due to the basses. I foolishly sold my DG Preciosa to fund something else a while ago but have just got another (:) These little boxes can go everywhere with you
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: ganderbox on December 02, 2009, 02:14:27 PM
I used to have a C/F Liliput, and it was a lovely bouncy little box. Playing polkas and suchlike on the row was great, and brought a smile to everyone's face (after I had it tuned, that is!). I found it a bit too small, though, and very difficult to play across the rows. I'd much prefer the Erika Club that I have just got.
A couple of days ago I also had the chance to play a Preciosa for the first time. I'd agree it's a nicer box than the Liliput, but it's even smaller.

That's just my preference, though, as I have over time sold on all the small melodeons I ever had, including 2 Lillys and a Tommy, and I'm now sticking to standard sized boxes.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Rob Phillips on December 02, 2009, 08:35:41 PM
The Liliput is a great little box and can sound wonderful when played really well (one example being Squeezy's 'Stoney Steps Hornpipe' on Spiers and Boden's 'Tunes'). I tried out a Liliput in November 2008 at Witney but quickly decided the buttons were simply too small and too close together for my liking. However, I took the plunge and bought one about six months ago to take on my travels. It certainly took some getting used to, but I love the tone (including the clacky base buttons which somehow add to the effect) and the fact that for a small box it can really belt out the volume. Provided the Liliput is in good condition (bearing in mind they were produced, I understand, from the mid-1930s to 1940), I think trading a semi-suplus Pokerwork for a Liliput would be a good deal. My Liliput is so well house trained now that it literally follows me from room to room, sometimes sitting up and begging to be played.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Gandy on December 03, 2009, 08:19:59 AM
How much small is the spacing of the keys?  I've occasionally thought a small keyboard might be nice, to be able to reach further.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 03, 2009, 05:54:50 PM
How much small is the spacing of the keys?  I've occasionally thought a small keyboard might be nice, to be able to reach further.
Can't give dimensions right now as my Preciosa is with Theo at the moment - but it is noticeably smaller than a Lilly and the buttons are more reminiscent of concertina buttons!

Rob.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on December 03, 2009, 06:35:53 PM
They are (approx) 8mm buttons on 16mm centres and 3mm between rows..
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: ganderbox on December 03, 2009, 06:40:14 PM
the buttons are more reminiscent of concertina buttons!

Rob.

 The tiny buttons feel very odd when you are used to the larger area of the mushroom shaped buttons you get on most boxes. It feels to me like playing a keyboard with all the button caps removed!
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Gandy on December 03, 2009, 08:16:27 PM
They are (approx) 8mm buttons on 16mm centres and 3mm between rows..
Cheers. 
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Rob Phillips on December 03, 2009, 08:28:37 PM
With luck this should take you to a photo of a Liliput's treble end next to a Pokerwork's:

                          http://tinyurl.com/yh6hdtf

Like Ganderbox, I find playing across the rows tricky at times, but it's getting better.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Theo on December 03, 2009, 09:48:03 PM
Some of the later model Liliputs - the ones with the more rounded shape - have slightly larger diameter buttons, but the same button spacing.  These buttons are the same size as Erica bass buttons probably about 9mm.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: IanD on December 03, 2009, 10:27:19 PM
the buttons are more reminiscent of concertina buttons!

Rob.

 The tiny buttons feel very odd when you are used to the larger area of the mushroom shaped buttons you get on most boxes. It feels to me like playing a keyboard with all the button caps removed!

I've never found any problem with the close spacing of the buttons on my Preciosa, the small diameter means you don't have the problem of pressing two buttons at once which some of the small modern boxes (with normal size buttons) suffer from. The small diameter does mean you don't get the "finger-down-the-hole" problem of Pokerworks and Ericas.

But they do feel *very* different to play compared to a "normal" box -- not more difficult, just different...

Ian
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: press on regardless on December 03, 2009, 11:06:19 PM

I chop between a Presswood and Preciosa all the time with no probs
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: saguaro_squeezer on December 04, 2009, 08:01:53 AM
Sorry, I've been travelling.  Those are small buttons!  I'm going to try it out tomorrow and see if it talks to me or not.  I know that I've got larger hands and have had to let the bass straps out on my Pokerworks.  I'll let you know what happens.
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: squeezy on December 04, 2009, 10:31:49 AM
I reckon most people adapt to the different button spacing pretty quickly myself - I can now go back and forth between the Lilliput and the normal sized boxes without any problem.

Where I do find a problem is with the air-button, which is so close to the bass buttons that my left hand ends up in a scrunched up position and I get awful cramp in the back of the hand within 15 minutes of playing or so.  Hopefully that is just me as I've never heard of anyone else with the cramp problem, but you should probably be aware of it.

Apart from that it's a beautifully made Hohner - I adore the rich tone that can come out of something that small and the miniature reeds are an inspired invention.

Cheers

Squeezy
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: saguaro_squeezer on December 06, 2009, 03:12:12 AM
I met the chap who had the Lilliput today.  I guess it could be a nice box with a lot of work but wasn't near the condition of my Pokerwork.  Very wheezey.  But I appreciate everyones input.  I might just keep my eyes open for a nice one unless I can cure my MAD.  >:E
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: malcolmbebb on January 13, 2011, 10:37:08 PM
.  They're club tuned, so they have a gleichton

What is a gleichton/gleichtone, in layman's terms? Not looking for a translation but an explanation, pref in words of one syllable or less!
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: an bosca ceoil on January 13, 2011, 11:20:16 PM
Gleich =same/identical
i.e. unisonic
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Martin J on January 14, 2011, 01:13:48 AM
.  They're club tuned, so they have a gleichton

What is a gleichton/gleichtone, in layman's terms? Not looking for a translation but an explanation, pref in words of one syllable or less!
Third but_ton in the maj_or key, in_side row, plays the same note on the push and the pull.  (all one syllable -  nearly)
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: old geezer on January 14, 2011, 11:02:42 AM
What is a gleichton/gleichtone, in layman's terms? Not looking for a translation but an explanation, pref in words of one syllable or less!

have a look at any one of the following pages, the gleichton is the middle button of the middle row in these reed charts

http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DGclub30.gif
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/CFclub30.gif
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/BbEbclub30.gif

often a pic' is worth lotsa words

edit to add:   often this button is 'hashed' and all others are plain
Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: Jake Middleton (brinwins) on January 14, 2011, 11:24:49 AM
the buttons are more reminiscent of concertina buttons!

Rob.

 The tiny buttons feel very odd when you are used to the larger area of the mushroom shaped buttons you get on most boxes. It feels to me like playing a keyboard with all the button caps removed!

I've never found any problem with the close spacing of the buttons on my Preciosa, the small diameter means you don't have the problem of pressing two buttons at once which some of the small modern boxes (with normal size buttons) suffer from. The small diameter does mean you don't get the "finger-down-the-hole" problem of Pokerworks and Ericas.

But they do feel *very* different to play compared to a "normal" box -- not more difficult, just different...

Ian

Ian I swear I saw you playing one at Sidmouth for that bedlams/hammersmith/nonesuch thing and it sounded very good, it was an interesting tune as well I think you called it the colliers rant. what benefit did it have over the normal one you play, an oakwood isnt it?



Title: Re: Hohner Lilliput - worth trading for a Pokerwork?
Post by: paulq on January 14, 2011, 03:13:38 PM
I met the chap who had the Lilliput today.  I guess it could be a nice box with a lot of work but wasn't near the condition of my Pokerwork.  Very wheezey.  But I appreciate everyones input.  I might just keep my eyes open for a nice one unless I can cure my MAD.  >:E

Most of them need a lot of work. I guess you need to factor that in. I paid 100 euros for an unrestored eb/bb  from German ebay, then £500 having it restored and retuned to D/G. The whole process took I guess a couple of months, Mike Rowbotham down in St Ives did it relatively quickly (and did a superb job I think). There's obviously a bit of hype around these boxes but I think they're worth it. Very easy to pick up and play and very hard to put down once you've started, I find. And it fits in my cycle panniers! There are sound samples on Mike's site - www.michaelrowbotham.eclipse.co.uk/
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal