Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 05:44:23 AM

Title: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 05:44:23 AM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VwqqvqWaPbs&feature=related

a clip of some great box playing and dancing alike... just wanted to know (I know it's not very clear) if someone perhaps knew the brand of box Philippe played / plays..the thing sounds great!
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: triskel on December 01, 2009, 09:59:25 AM
Impossible to be sure from the images, but it does look like a Cajun box and I know that he has had them made for him by Marc Savoy (whilst it also sounds similar to the one I got off Marc in January), so my money's on it being an Acadian, like the one in this clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXlNUJ60St4
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 10:28:31 AM
Impossible to be sure from the images, but it does look like a Cajun box and I know that he has had them made for him by Marc Savoy (whilst it also sounds similar to the one I got off Marc in January), so my money's on it being an Acadian, like the one in this clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OXlNUJ60St4

I was thinking the same thing, and since viewing the clip on McNeill's music shop, and hearing a sample of your Acadian, I hear the similarities. And I must say, that Acadian of yours does sound pretty good, props to you on that ;D
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: triskel on December 01, 2009, 01:38:24 PM
... since viewing the clip on McNeill's music shop, and hearing a sample of your Acadian, I hear the similarities.

"Sample" is the word I'm afraid, in fact I'm totally embarrassed that people might think they're hearing what I actually played, but it seems the melodeon was so loud it was making the camera's 'safety' trip out all the time.   :|bl

I played the tune "straight" and (fairly) loud the first time through, but it's only picked up the quieter notes from that, then more gently and starting to vary it a bit the second, but the whole thing sounds garbled/jumbled as a result. :(

I want to get her to film me playing it again, with the right camera settings this time...

Quote
And I must say, that Acadian of yours does sound pretty good, props to you on that ;D

That's what I keep trying to tell Jeff; Marc and Tina make mighty fine accordions!  :||:

And who cares what kind of corners they use...  ::)
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 05:27:34 PM
Well this marks the first time I've knowingly heard one of their Quebecois tuned boxes (I've probably heard more players using them without knowing, Stephane Landry by chance?) and I was impressed.

And not trying to open a can of worms here on the corners debate again, but I doubt it has anything to do with the sound of the box, thus not being such a big deal, unless the look of it really ticks you off ;D
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: triskel on December 01, 2009, 07:37:18 PM
Well this marks the first time I've knowingly heard one of their Quebecois tuned boxes ...

It's tuned with one bank of reeds +15, rather than (say) +/-7, which gives it a good bit of "cut".

Quote
... the corners debate ... not being such a big deal, unless the look of it really ticks you off ;D

You can't even see them, under the corner plates...
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 01, 2009, 07:40:14 PM
Stephane Landry plays on a Messervier.

Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 08:39:01 PM
Stephane Landry plays on a Messervier.



If I recall somewhat correctly, I thought I saw an Acadian on the cover of his "Transition" CD, but it's been a while since I've seen it... ???
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 01, 2009, 08:41:27 PM
Stephane Landry plays on a Messervier.



If I recall somewhat correctly, I thought I saw an Acadian on the cover of his "Transition" CD, but it's been a while since I've seen the cover... ???

My mistake ::)

Just checked it again and it says "Artisan" atop the soundboard, not "Acadian"
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: melodeon on December 02, 2009, 03:20:36 PM
Savoy "made" fine accordeons ( minus the amateurish butt joints)

The current Acadians do not measure up to the old Savoy boxes  IMNSHO.

I prefer other Cajun built boxes and prefer other than Cajun built one rows for my own personal use.

Were I to buy a new Cajun built accordeon , it would not be an Acadian; there are other boxes that I consider more suitable to my expectation of design, materials and workmanship. And character counts.

Butt, to each his own.  I am glad you all enjoyed the kool aid.

Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 02, 2009, 05:08:17 PM
Any idea when your new Melodie should arrive?
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: tirpous on December 02, 2009, 05:17:57 PM
Coming back to P. Bruneau's box, I'm not sure it's the same one, but you get a better look at it in the picture on this site: http://musette.free.fr/stchart/ch05bru2.htm (http://musette.free.fr/stchart/ch05bru2.htm) (scroll way down)
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Steve C. on December 02, 2009, 11:37:27 PM
Some of my old Philo 33's of Phillipe Bruneau have him on the Hohner single row.When I say him live last at Festival de Deu Monde (was the 80's tis true) he was playing one practically stock.
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: triskel on December 04, 2009, 01:16:43 AM
Coming back to P. Bruneau's box, I'm not sure it's the same one, but you get a better look at it in the picture on this site: http://musette.free.fr/stchart/ch05bru2.htm (http://musette.free.fr/stchart/ch05bru2.htm) (scroll way down)

That appears to be a different box, but (no more than the rest of us!) I'm sure he's had plenty of different ones in his time, and doesn't always play the same one(s)...

I wonder what year the YouTube clip was filmed?
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: hibbs3 on December 04, 2009, 05:56:14 AM
I believe Gilchrist died sometime in 1984, so I would think this was filmed a few years prior, maybe even later 70s? ???
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 04, 2009, 12:48:25 PM
Just checked it again and it says "Artisan" atop the soundboard, not "Acadian"

Yes, "Artisan" was a model name that Marcel and Marcel Jr. put on their boxes in recent years.
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 04, 2009, 12:58:16 PM
That appears to be a different box, but (no more than the rest of us!) I'm sure he's had plenty of different ones in his time, and doesn't always play the same one(s)...

Absolutely.  Additionally, often pictures of box players come from events where there are many accordionists present -- and like all of us, these guys are eager to try out others' boxes.  So unless the photographer is certain that the box belongs to the player, it doesn't mean a whole lot.
This goes for recordings as well.  One of the great compilations of Quebec's accordionists was recorded at a kind of "conference" up in the Quebec City region many years ago.  There are plenty of recordings of people playing other players' boxes.
Quebec has an interesting traditional music scene where there is not always a strict distinction between "pros" and amateurs.  The fact that someone has a recording, for instance, doesn't necessarily indicate his/her status as a box player.  There are also regional distinctions that would not necessarily be apparent to listeners from the rest of the world. 
Monsieur Bruneau was based in the Montreal area and throughout his time there was known to be in search of better boxes once the Hohner quality began to decline -- he tried out many kinds of accordions.  I've seen pics of Bruneau with Acadians, Messerviers, Hohners, and (in France) Eric Martins.  In the Quebec city area, you'll find that a much greater number of accordionists gravitate to Messervier's boxes, with Mélodie a close second.  However, within certain pockets of trad players, the choice is nearly 100% Messervier.
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: melodeon on December 04, 2009, 11:28:42 PM
Melodie in late spring....  maybe : )

I have no expectations of a handmade box being completed in the original time frame..


I have ordered custom made instruments before(  guitars, banjos, mandolins ,ukuleles,  and accordeons_)

With one exception  none were done on time or were exactly what I ordered...  in spite of written detailed instructions and an acknowledgement of same..

And... I have never contacted  a maker to check progress...  never...

It will get done on their time frame.. which I fully understand


On the other side of the fence... I have never missed a deadline in19 years  .. ever... and only twice did the customer comment that the product was not to their expectation... in spite of detailed instructions to the contrary...  no argument... I'll take it back and you can find someone else ......   I'm  easy.......
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andrel on December 05, 2009, 06:06:02 PM
  My Mélodie was supposed to arrive in August, but it showed up yesterday at my doorstep. Well worth the wait, though. Tight, very responsive and powerful. You'll love it.
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 06, 2009, 12:36:05 PM
  My Mélodie was supposed to arrive in August, but it showed up yesterday at my doorstep.

No pics, didn't happen!!!
;)
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Lars on December 06, 2009, 08:29:49 PM
I was quite impressed with the little Melodié I saw few years ago - very good handling and very responsive. It did, however, not live up to the two Messerviers I've tried. One from the early 80's (small and blue) and one from the early 2000's, both very powerful boxes, but more important, they had that something extra in the tone that just made them more fun to play - in terms of Quebecois music.
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andrel on December 07, 2009, 12:28:53 AM
  I have heard the same thing about Messerviers, Lars, that particular tone. Mélodies are described as *sweet* in comparison. I've never tried a Messervier, but I'm extremely happy with my Mélodie. Played it all weekend. I love the action. I went back and forth between my Acadian (in C) and the Mélodie, but in the end I simply couldn't put the Mélodie down. And I'll have a picture up as soon as I get my camera back, Andy (since you seem to have doubts...) ;)
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: melodeon on December 07, 2009, 03:50:38 PM
I believe it was Denis Pepin that told me that a Messervier was "the" box for loud and traditional dance driven music
Melodie for  the general musicality
and Clement Breton for "character"  and "charm"
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andrel on December 07, 2009, 05:54:03 PM
  A very well-known French builder told me recently he found himself once in a tiny room in Montmagny (during the Carrefour Mondial) with a few old ladies and Marcel playing his box full blast as if he'd been right in the middle of the Plains of Abraham, nearly frightening everyone out of their wits. It was quite a memorable experience apparently...
Title: Re: Bruneau's 4-stop box
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 07, 2009, 06:43:17 PM
  A very well-known French builder told me recently he found himself once in a tiny room in Montmagny (during the Carrefour Mondial) with a few old ladies and Marcel playing his box full blast as if he'd been right in the middle of the Plains of Abraham, nearly frightening everyone out of their wits. It was quite a memorable experience apparently...

I've been in that situation myself: small room, Marcel, extremely loud box.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal