Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Cooper on May 27, 2024, 01:08:54 AM
-
Ok, asking for some ideas/advice.
At some point when i wanted to upgrade from a 2r8b to a 3r i bought myself an 3r18b 3 voice instrument. It took me a year to get rid of the pain in my shoulder, and i made a deal with myself always to aim for lighter instruments.
Since then i have always aimed for 2voice instruments (LM). A Gaillard, a Casta Mas, a Pariselle. All perfect instruments, to play onstage, when the microphnes take care of the volume.
However, i sometimes have to play in a restaurant, or outside, acoustic, without amplification. I really need 3 voices for the volume. (LMM). I have played an Casta Alain in these circumstances, and most of the time that is enough, but i could really use some extra buttons and some extra basses... But i want to have an instrument as light and small as possible, (both in actual weight, as in playing) since i might be walking around with it for long, and i dont want to put my left arm into too much work. :-)
Oh, and it is has to have wooden look :-)
What kind of make and models would you suggest? (Casta Mory is too bulky for what i am looking for).
Any new makers i should check out? Old models?
Thx for your insights!
W
-
The lightest, smallest melodeons that might address your problem description are the "compacts" from the lutherie of Frans v.d. Aa. I think you played my dark blue accs/D/G 18-bass when we last met in Gooik? About 4½kg (3 voices) and importantly also a light left end. I went for the 11/10/9 layout which means fewer notes, but he did a 12/11/10 too. The C/G is more fluent in the play.
Messages out of Boxtel, and their farm in Bulgaria suggest that Frans really has retired this time! But he continues to arrange 2nd hand sales for previous clients and is also still in touch with many via his FB (which probably includes you already)?
The light weight of his kit is … as good as you will get anywhere. Quality is excellent, but not as excellent as Bertrand Gaillard's. Because of the lack of space right end reeds share wax, and can become loose. I've also had palates come off their wire levers. Theo has done most of my maintenance, and might be able to offer some insight about that.
Good luck.
-
The lightest, smallest melodeons that might address your problem description are the "compacts" from the lutherie of Frans v.d. Aa. I think you played my dark blue accs/D/G 18-bass when we last met in Gooik? About 4½kg (3 voices) and importantly also a light left end. I went for the 11/10/9 layout which means fewer notes, but he did a 12/11/10 too. The C/G is more fluent in the play.
Messages out of Boxtel, and their farm in Bulgaria suggest that Frans really has retired this time! But he continues to arrange 2nd hand sales for previous clients and is also still in touch with many via his FB (which probably includes you already)?
The light weight of his kit is … as good as you will get anywhere. Quality is excellent, but not as excellent as Bertrand Gaillard's. Because of the lack of space right end reeds share wax, and can become loose. I've also had palates come off their wire levers. Theo has done most of my maintenance, and might be able to offer some insight about that.
Good luck.
Thx, Chris! Yeah, I know Frans's boxes ofcourse, and they are excellent no doubt. I am looking for an even more light weight option,..if available... can be less buttons too (10/9/6?), but with 12/14 bass. Has to be 3 voice.
And has to be wooden or have a wooden look :-)
W
-
He did make a few wooden ones, but I always felt that if it wasn't painted … it wasn't a vanderAa?
I would be surprised if you get anything lighter, but good luck
-
I might suggest some French makers, for this kind of size/requirements, I can think of Pierrot Thouvenin, based in Poitou, that makes accordions along the same lines than Pariselle, and that has produced lightweight instruments that still sounded great. He's got no website but one contact may be via Facebook here: https://www.facebook.com/p/Pierrot-Accord%C3%A9on-100057208969892/
Similarly, Jérémie Vanglabeke has also made some nice 3-voices models: http://www.accordeon-essouffle.fr/fabricationchameron.php
Other makers are more focused on 2-voices models I think.
Both will be at Le Son Continu this year, with other that might possibly match your criteria.
That being said, I concur with what Chris said, it will be difficult to be much lighter than what Frans or others did (between 4 and 4.5 kgs), if you want 25 buttons, 12 basses, 3 voices.
Also weight, even with physical aches, is not all, some models could weigh 5 kgs and feel lighter and be effortless to play than for instance some 3.5 kgs models. Size has a role, and so does reed set-up, and the amount of air leaks among other things.
-
I might suggest some French makers, for this kind of size/requirements, I can think of Pierrot Thouvenin, based in Poitou, that makes accordions along the same lines than Pariselle, and that has produced lightweight instruments that still sounded great. He's got no website but one contact may be via Facebook here: https://www.facebook.com/p/Pierrot-Accord%C3%A9on-100057208969892/
Similarly, Jérémie Vanglabeke has also made some nice 3-voices models: http://www.accordeon-essouffle.fr/fabricationchameron.php
Other makers are more focused on 2-voices models I think.
Both will be at Le Son Continu this year, with other that might possibly match your criteria.
That being said, I concur with what Chris said, it will be difficult to be much lighter than what Frans or others did (between 4 and 4.5 kgs), if you want 25 buttons, 12 basses, 3 voices.
Also weight, even with physical aches, is not all, some models could weigh 5 kgs and feel lighter and be effortless to play than for instance some 3.5 kgs models. Size has a role, and so does reed set-up, and the amount of air leaks among other things.
Thx, i will check out those builders. I have been in contact with Vanglabeeke before.
Which models do you have in mind with you last comment?
W
-
Hi,
From experience when you put the third row of reeds in a box the sound can be deadened because it restricts the air flow.
If you want a low reed then look at a LM tuned Castagnari Dony with registers to take out the low reed and the M reed or with just MM,have the tuning on the M+ reed opened up a little bit.
This gives you the extra half row and variation in sound or look at a Castagnari 1914 4th button start with high accidentals on the extra buttons and low accidentals on first 2 buttons.
This gives you all a Mory will do and you only loose 2 notes
-
Hi,
From experience when you put the third row of reeds in a box the sound can be deadened because it restricts the air flow.
If you want a low reed then look at a LM tuned Castagnari Dony with registers to take out the low reed and the M reed or with just MM,have the tuning on the M+ reed opened up a little bit.
This gives you the extra half row and variation in sound or look at a Castagnari 1914 4th button start with high accidentals on the extra buttons and low accidentals on first 2 buttons.
This gives you all a Mory will do and you only loose 2 notes
Thx! But i really need the 3voices. I need the volume that it brings to the table :-) a GC, btw, so i dont think 4rg button start is good. I didnt know the 1914, but tat looks a bit like th Alain i already have?
W
-
Would something like the Saltarelle Le Romané have what you're looking for in terms of features ?
https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0 (https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0)
-
Would something like the Saltarelle Le Romané have what you're looking for in terms of features ?
https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0 (https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0)
They are nice to play and have all the features, but I think that it's slightly heavier than the OP was asking about. I had one for a while, but then sold it on for that very reason (I like lighter weight instruments) and had to buy back the 2.5 row 2-voice Bernard Loffet I'd sold to fund it. That extra 0.4/5 of a kilo made all the difference; I gave it a good few months of regular playing, loved the sound and it played well, but it never felt right somehow. It's probably me...
Cheers,
Guy
-
They are nice to play and have all the features, but I think that it's slightly heavier than the OP was asking about.
According to the makers' websites, the Le Romané weights 4.1 kg versus Cooper's current Castagnari Alain weight of 4.0 kg.
-
I wouldn't rely much on what factories are saying regarding weight. For instance there's nearly 0.5kg difference between my Handry 18 and what the official catalogue says.
-
Would something like the Saltarelle Le Romané have what you're looking for in terms of features ?
https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0 (https://www.saltarelle.com/en/romane-0)
The stats sound great and exactly what I am after. Need to find one to try out, thx! And weigh and feel them myself...