Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Figgle on August 29, 2024, 03:29:33 PM
-
Hello and thanks for admitting me to this forum! Recently retired I'm looking to get into box playing and buying my first (and hopefully last) melodeon. I'm thinking two row eight bases in D/G for morris style tunes and songs. My question concerns "new or used". For the same price I can get a new Sherwood, Scarlatti or a 30 year old restored Hohner for around the same price. Are the old Hohners really worth that much, or are the newbuilt modern instruments not up to serious playing? I would really value your opinions.
-
Old Hohners are, on balance, the best choice. However, I would add the following caveats:
- The bass straps are usually thin strips of leather that provide no support or comfort
- The air buttons are a weird shape and mechanism (IMHO) and can cause pain over time
- The sharp case edges can dig in - look out for the number of Hohner players that use towelling wrist bands to soften the load
- The treble buttons can disappear into the case if they haven't had their movement limited with padding
- The wet tuning isn't to everyone's taste
Having said that, I own 2 Hohners which have had most of the above fixed and are good fun to play! I still revert to Dino Baffetti as the best maker of D/G morris boxes but that boils down to budget and it's probably worth finding out whether you like the melodeon on something cheaper - you can always upgrade.
This last point is important as the old Hohners will keep their value for resale - the Sherwoods and Scarlattis, not so much.
Having said all that, my advice would be to try as many different boxes as possible and see what you feel most comfortable with.
-
I was messing around on a Hobgoblin stall at a festival over the weekend. I tried a Scarlatti, a Sherwood and an old Hohner Erica. The Hohner was a world apart from the other boxes. I think it must have had a decent amount of work done, it felt lovely beneath the fingers, and even though the tuning was a bit too wet for my taste, it still sounded better than the much drier budget boxes. As a beginner I would definitely try to get one from someone reputable, if you buy a cheap one from eBay it might not be playable at all without a considerable amount of work from a pro.
-
(and hopefully last) melodeon.
You're on the wrong forum if you only intend to ever buy one >:E
Most of squeezebox cost is in the set-up work. A fully set-up 100-year-old hohner will work beautifully. Will a new Scarlatti (Low-end Chinese product with a made-up brand name stamped on it?) be well set up? Unlikely.
Hohners are quite rough and basic unless you go for their top of the range models, but they work. Your problem is that you currently don't know what "perfectly set up" means. You don't want to pay £400-600 for an "attic find" pokerwork that's worth £50.
I recommend that you find a melodeon player near you to explain what to look out for in a box.
-
Speaking as a newbie myself, I'll second what nigelr said. The best move I made was to take a very deep breath, double my original budget and go for a secondhand Hohner which was fettled and set up by Mike Rowbotham. It's an absolute delight to play, and that alone has made learning so much easier. Plus should I ever wish to sell it, it's eminently saleable.
-
An old Hohner over a Sherwood or a Scarlatti every time - and please think carefully about getting rid of when you 'upgrade'. They are lovely beasts, I'm primarily playing a Mory these days but for the ceilidh band and wet-weather morris the ol' Pokerwork comes out to play.
-
Everything that nigelr said. Spot on!
-
It’s not just setup. Reed quality is fundamental to how well a box plays. Poor setup can prevent a good box from playing its best but if the reed quality is not good then even the best setup won’t help much.
Most of the new brands you mention have had most effort put into the nice wood finish.
-
Thankyou all for your replies, I'm now looking at Pokerworks and Erikas and I fully intend to use a reputable dealer! (:)
-
I must admit, I'm not a fan of Hohners (though I have 2)! But I'll choose one over a Scarlatti or Sherwood any day. I can understand the thinking behind starting out with a throwaway box but it doesn't hold up in practice. Learning is doubly difficult on a low-quality box because you're fighting the instrument as well - as I did on a Scarlatti. If you buy something better and don't get on with it, it'll still be saleable
-
Speaking as a newbie myself, I'll second what nigelr said. The best move I made was to take a very deep breath, double my original budget and go for a secondhand Hohner which was fettled and set up by Mike Rowbotham. It's an absolute delight to play, and that alone has made learning so much easier. Plus should I ever wish to sell it, it's eminently saleable.
Definitely this (having gone the opposite way and acquired all sorts of ‘bargains’ along the way)! Unfortunately, I joined Melnet only after making my first purchase and not receiving this kind of advice… My most playable box is probably still my HA112C bought here from Squeaky Pete… As it happens, I also have a Scarlatti Nero, which is in some ways superior in build to a Hohner out of the box, but is lacking in the all important reed responsiveness and sound projection. I spent lots of time re gapping the reeds and tuned it Viennese style, and I quite like it, but it took a lot of work so I’d say it’s not really worth the time, which is better spent learning tunes… :||:
-
Thankyou all for your replies, I'm now looking at Pokerworks and Erikas and I fully intend to use a reputable dealer! (:)
Based on my experience of buying a complete dog of an Erica which was described by the dealer as "in splendid condition", if buying online pay by credit card and make certain that the dealer undertakes to refund if you don't like it. If nothing else, that'll save you having to resort to quoting chapter and verse of the Distance Selling Regulations at them and the whole thing becoming a big PITA.
Also, be sure to read Google reviews of the dealer. I omitted to do that before ordering a strap from one online "music store", and ended up having to wait 30 days to start the card chargeback when it never arrived and he stopped answering emails.
-
Also, be sure to read Google reviews of the dealer.
I'm visiting a dealer on Monday, the reviews online are old and mixed. The good reviews are very good, the bad reviews seem trivial and picky such as "they didn't have any electric guitars!"
-
Think about buying one from somebody on this forum...
We all play melodeons and we love them.
-
Think about buying one from somebody on this forum...
We all play melodeons and we love them.
At the moment there doesn't seem to be one for sale!
-
You can post a "wanted" ad and to be honest, it might be worth a little wait.
I don't have a D/G (I find them too squeaky), so not selling one. Just sharing some honest advice here.
-
nigelr and Disparate Dan have said it all I think. After going through about half a dozen different boxes in 8 years I now have two Hohners and a Dino. Buying and selling is actually part of the fun of it all.
-
Think about buying one from somebody on this forum...
We all play melodeons and we love them.
At the moment there doesn't seem to be one for sale!
Three DG Hohners available here all with my personal guarantee
https://theboxplace.co.uk/product-category/melodeons/
-
Hi Theo, thanks for the link, I saw these when I sent my registration request to the forum. The following comments say more about my ignorance of the instruments as opposed to doubting your reputation; I saw the 1930 model and thought does that mean it's over 90 years old? The next one was converted from a student piano accordion, so maybe pass on that one too. The Erica looks nice and may be what I'm looking for but it leaves me with a choice of one. Again, sorry if that sounds negative but I'm still learning about these instruments and maybe don't understand what I'm looking at.
On Monday I'm taking my wife to Pickering to see friends so I'm calling in at a dealer nearby to try several Pokerworks and Ericas. If that doesn't work out I will come back to you and see what we can work out.
-
Hi Figgle,
Don’t be put off by the age of the 1930s instrument it plays as well as a newer instrument, tone is a little different - sweeter and not so brash. Likewise the Student conversion it’s a nice player.
-
Fwiw, just for your reference,
- My Alfred Arnold bando was built in 1933-34. Exactly 90 years ago. All it needed was a reed overhaul & new valves. Everything else is original and works a treat. (btw fully restored, these sell for thousands of £, not hundreds like old restored melodeons).
- My C-F Hohner Morino is from about 1960. Just over 60 years old. Plays like a dream with everything original. I've had a high-end squeezebox, built in 2020, that did not play as well as the Morino (hence "had").
- My Vostok is from around 1976 (from memory). It needed a full reed overhaul & hot-rod and a wee service here & there, but apart from that it's mostly original. To my ear, on balance, it still plays better than that 2020 box.
If you think a few decades is a lot for a squeezebox, you're mistaken. I'd say at 50 years mark the bellows become nicely played in and supple ;D
It's all about the condition and the amount of set-up work that went into them.
-
I'd concur with Theo.
A well fettled 1930s Hohner is a lovely thing. I'm always looking out for them to refurbish.
A little bonus is that they are likely to be a Club II/Erika, basically the same instrument in a go-faster celluloid or trad polished wood casework. These instruments have a 4 button helper row which can be totally ignored as a beginner, or fully embraced once you find your feet. Marginally bigger than pokerwork boxes, but hardly noticeable.
-
... These instruments have a 4 button helper row ...
Sheer curiosity, but what would those notes normally be on the D/G version?
-
It depends...
Often two buttons will be the same as the normal 2 top chin end buttons on a 2 row - D#/F ( or the other way round ) and Bb/G#.
Plus - possibly - a low D#/Fnat and maybe a reversal such as C/D.
Things like the Erika were only made for about a 2 year period around 1938 and wouldn't have been in the keys of DG.
Therefore the helper row on a DG Erika is down to the fettler's ideas or the person commissioning that conversion to DG.
-
I'm calling in at a dealer nearby to try several Pokerworks and Ericas. If that doesn't work out I will come back to you and see what we can work out.
That's the way to go! Try as many as you can. To echo what others have said, well maintained old boxes knock spots off some of the newer ones.
-
If you haven't got fixed up yet, I see that there is a Saltarelle Bouebe advertised in the for sale section of this forum. They are, in my opinion, a step up in being more refined to play than Pokerworks and Ericas, and in my experience not far off the volume of the Hohners if you want to play outside for dancing - but I am aware that not all Saltarelles sound the same!
-
If you haven't got fixed up yet, I see that there is a Saltarelle Bouebe advertised in the for sale section of this forum. They are, in my opinion, a step up in being more refined to play than Pokerworks and Ericas, and in my experience not far off the volume of the Hohners if you want to play outside for dancing - but I am aware that not all Saltarelles sound the same!
Yes, I noticed that but I'm already sorted thanks. Will post more when I get back from my hols!
-
Just want to say thankyou to all who have contributed to this thread, your advice and input has been invaluable. The postman arrived at just after 7:30 this morning with a parcel from Theo, I am now the proud owner of a black D/G Hohner Erica ;D :||: :|glug
-
Oh well done!
The fun now begins ;)
-
... I am now the proud owner of a black D/G Hohner Erica ;D :||: :|glug
Nice one! Hope it gives you a lot of pleasure. Mine certainly has!
-
Excellent choice, both of melodeon, and vendor.
-
I think the Erica is a great choice. It solves the only significant problem (IMO) with the Pokerwork - the sharp back edge that cuts into one's left wrist. On the other hand, I don't care for the celluloid finish, but perfection is ever elusive.
I had an opportunity to try out some expensive melodeons this weekend, and those heavy hardwood boxes just don't appeal to me at all. I love the Pokerwork because it is light and quick and responsive. Some of those $2,000 boxes felt like I was playing a solid kitchen cabinet rather than a musical instrument.
-
...with the Pokerwork - the sharp back edge that cuts into one's left wrist.
As Rod Stradling once wrote on The Southern Rag, it really can play hell with your wrist. But he also gave an unexpensive solution to the problem: use a wristband! ;)
I spent ten years, more or less, on the Pokerwork, and never really used the Erica. Yet I can rember that the advantage of the former on the latter was that the bass buttons weren't at risk to remain locked into the box when pushed too much... :(
-
boxes felt like I was playing a solid kitchen cabinet rather than a musical instrument.
Having owned a 48cm-tall, 18kg converter concert CBA, I always have a chuckle when I read comments about big & heavy melodeons.
If you exclude really tiny morris boxes that are a class of their own, I reckon anything under 12kg in weight and 38cm in height is "compact" and is just a matter of getting used to their size.
Apologies for an off-topic.
-
I think the Erica is a great choice. It solves the only significant problem (IMO) with the Pokerwork - the sharp back edge that cuts into one's left wrist.
That was my main reason for deciding on the Erica, I already have arthritic wrists which prevent me from playing my main instrument, the figgle (fiddle) as much as I would like! :(