Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: rileycat on September 09, 2024, 11:18:53 PM
-
Hi all. Has anyone a view on the 4 stop model offered (if you can wait!) by Bertrand Gaillard. It's called the Emeraude and seems to be a fairly limited production item, so maybe noone here has tried one. If there's anyone who has, can you offer insight as to response, tonal quality and so on perhaps referencing some of the obvious other 4 stoppers around - Max, Pariselle, maybe even a cajun maker's instrument. Thanks .
-
Have you seen this thread ?
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=29045.0 (https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=29045.0)
-
Thanks tirpous
- that covers my query. I think Benny's instrument might be a 2 stop, looking at his montage of instruments.
-
I've had the demonstration model in D for a couple of weeks at home last year. It's a good box, as you'd expect from Bertrand. The woodwork is nice, the right-hand keyboard is fine, as is the usual case with his other boxes. The reeds are nicely set up, and it's responsive. All the voices can be heard equally.
I'm not very fond of the air button, which is quite big (long, that is to say), and the overall feeling when playing is not really to my taste. Mind you I'm used to my Mélodie one-row, so that doesn't help, but it's quite hard to describe the playing feels with words. Maybe the Emeraude is on the "tame" end of the available one-rows. Also the asymetrical keyboard groove doesn't work for me on one-row melodeons that you operate with a leather strip around your thumb, I couldn't find a satisfying way to handle it, so I had to resort to shoulder straps.
But it's a quite singular take on what a one-row can be so it's worth trying if you can.
-
I think Benny's instrument might be a 2 stop, looking at his montage of instruments.
It seems to be a 4-voice, but with stops only for the 2 front rows, which probably means MM voices are permanently on.
Sound is definitely not MM in this track linked in the other thread: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VQMUwVbimo&list=OLAK5uy_k8VSV3e6DAbNJnFQdfS5rtfKqPcEOgFm0&index=15 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VQMUwVbimo&list=OLAK5uy_k8VSV3e6DAbNJnFQdfS5rtfKqPcEOgFm0&index=15)
-
I think Benny's instrument might be a 2 stop, looking at his montage of instruments.
It seems to be a 4-voice, but with stops only for the 2 front rows, which probably means MM voices are permanently on.
Sound is definitely not MM in this track linked in the other thread: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VQMUwVbimo&list=OLAK5uy_k8VSV3e6DAbNJnFQdfS5rtfKqPcEOgFm0&index=15 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7VQMUwVbimo&list=OLAK5uy_k8VSV3e6DAbNJnFQdfS5rtfKqPcEOgFm0&index=15)
I agree. The two stops are set well forward leaving plenty of room for the other two voices.
Also the pallets are too long for it to be anything other than a four voice.
-
Benny's is definitely a four-voice box, with two stops.
-
Thanks again, everyone. I wondered about those stops and strayed into bandoneon tuning as a possibility. It didn't occur to me that it might be as you've explained - I should have checked out the pallets. Thanks 'Y' for your personal playing assessment - very helpful. I know what you mean about personal preference often being slightly intangible, it's the summation of several minor attributes to create that whole feeling.
-
Bertrand appears to have switched to VA reeds for his most recent boxes - including a Turquoise I received from him last year. They will naturally sound different than Bincis which are installed in most of the other makers and cajun boxes you'd be comparing to - so that's worth keeping in mind. Also he's announced his retirement and training in of his successor So it's uncertain if an instrument ordered now will be fully made by him (if that even matters - I'm sure he'll still have the final say on everything for a while). Last time I checked his waiting list was 3.5 yrs.