Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andy Goldfinch on September 13, 2024, 09:00:22 AM
-
Morning folks.
I've been pondering if there's any way to squeeze an F# bass into an 8 bass D/G box, and I've stumbled upon this blog post (https://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/18/inside-and-out-part-1-the-super-preciosa/) by Owen Woods, where he discusses a unique 12 bass layout that replaces the pull D bass with an F#. In his case he puts the corresponding F# minor chord on a button that doesn't exist on a standard 8 bass box, but I think there would still be plenty of benefits of just changing the pull D bass note to F# and leaving the pull D chord unchanged.
These are the advantages I can think of:
- Full G scale available for bass runs
- First inversion D chord now possible
- F# bass + thirdless A chord is a decent substitution for F# minor
And these are some of the disadvantages:
- Playing a D bass against a G tune now requires row crossing to use the push D bass
- No longer have the D bass + C chord on the pull (but it's still there on the push). I use this chord a lot for cadences, but C/E -> D/F# -> G is still a nice cadence if it's essential for it to be on the pull
- Can't do D bass dones/chugs (but can still do it with a D chord)
- It's something non-standard, so shifting between boxes might be complicated. But accidentally hitting an F# instead of a D bass or vice versa probably wouldn't be the end of the world
Has anyone actually tried doing this? Can anyone think of any pros or cons I haven't mentioned?
-
I think both Ollie King of this parish and Roger Watson both had 9 button bass ends. The extra button having bass only reeds of F# and C#.
A search of this website might turn up previous discussions, but it was quite a time ago!
-
Interesting that you should mention that, because that's another avenue I've been investigating as well, and I have read every thread I can find on the topic. I was surprised not to find any other discussions about sticking with 8 basses and just replacing the pull D bass though.
-
Hmmm... I wonder if 'it depends on how you play ' comes into it.
I'd never replace my pull D as I use it depending on bellows direction of the notes before it.
I don't necessarily play along the rows. I think of the entire keyboard as a set of buttons containing the notes for the keys of G and D so I press wherever my fingers lie on it for a given direction of bellows travel, if that makes sense.
Therefore the pull D 'under' the G bass/chord gets used possibly as much as the push D bass and chord.
-
If your tonic and dominant chords (Edit:bass notes) are in the same bellows direction, you’ll run into problems pretty quickly I think… If you really wanted to squeeze the F# note into an 8 bass, a far less intrusive method would be to have it instead of the C push. If you can get used to Club system or Dutch reversal this wouldn’t be too much of a problem… I play with Dutch/Club system myself, and I know instinctively as soon as I go to that ‘C’ chord, all notes are on pull..One option would be to have a F# bass along with a B minor chord, thereby giving you the D 1st inversion, and also solving the B major or minor problem!..
-
If your tonic and dominant chords (Edit:bass notes) are in the same bellows direction, you’ll run into problems pretty quickly I think…
Not sure I understand what you mean with this statement, Arnold...
-
It’s fairly common for a G major tune to spend a good few bars going between only G and D chords, so bellows management becomes an issue if that’s all in the push (unless your content with constant 1st inversion D/F#)… I’m sure some people could train their brain to manage this, but it would be far less mental gymnastics to just replace the push C to F# instead?..
-
Yes, air management is one of the reasons I use my pull D continuously...
-
Also, you’d have no root position dominant D7 chord if you take out the pull D bass, which is basically essential, since the RH C note to complete this chord is only on pull… It’s little things like that which add up to make it not such a good idea…
-
Personally I wouldn't say It’s fairly common for a G major tune to spend a good few bars going between only G and D chords, but rather that is fairly common for a number of melodeon players lo limit themselves to alternate between the tonic and the dominant chords. Playing in G, if you mute the thirds in the A and B chords – assuming the latter is a major chord -, you have all the six diatonic triads available, and plenty of possibilities to build well balanced and varied chord progression.
Another point to consider is that the D note on the RH keyboard of the D/G box is push only. When I played the D/G I not only used alternatively the D bass/chord couples on the push and on the pull, to balance the push and the pull notes like Quinton suggests, but I often splitted them playing the D push bass before the D push chord. I don't need to do it often on the A/D/G, since I have all the notes of the D major scale available both on the push and on the pull, but on my 2 ½ row G/C box I still often play the G pull bass before the G pull chord, even if I have the G notes available on the pull among the reversals.
Also, replacing the D pull bass with an F# sharp bass will still offer you the option to use the A pull bass, that's the fifth of the D chord, rather than F#, that's the third.
Finally, since the C chord on the D/G is the only chord that you can use with any note sequence you play on the RH keyboard, and it is definitely pretty useful to built correct chord progressions both playing in G and in D, I wouldn't do without it.
Yet, yes, to quote Quinton again, this is where 'it depends on how you play ' comes into it.
-
There's no easy way out of this. The best option is to fit another button
-
Personally I wouldn't say It’s fairly common for a G major tune to spend a good few bars going between only G and D chords, but rather that is fairly common for a number of melodeon players lo limit themselves to alternate between the tonic and the dominant chords. Playing in G, if you mute the thirds in the A and B chords – assuming the latter is a major chord -, you have all the six diatonic triads available, and plenty of possibilities to build well balanced and varied chord progression.
Another point to consider is that the D note on the RH keyboard of the D/G box is push only. When I played the D/G I not only used alternatively the D bass/chord couples on the push and on the pull, to balance the push and the pull notes like Quinton suggests, but I often splitted them playing the D push bass before the D push chord. I don't need to do it often on the A/D/G, since I have all the notes of the D major scale available both on the push and on the pull, but on my 2 ½ row G/C box I still often play the G pull bass before the G pull chord, even if I have the G notes available on the pull among the reversals.
Also, replacing the D pull bass with an F# sharp bass will still offer you the option to use the A pull bass, that's the fifth of the D chord, rather than F#, that's the third.
Finally, since the C chord on the D/G is the only chord that you can use with any note sequence you play on the RH keyboard, and it is definitely pretty useful to built correct chord progressions both playing in G and in D, I wouldn't do without it.
Yet, yes, to quote Quinton again, this is where 'it depends on how you play ' comes into it.
It’s not just a melodeon thing, but diatonic music for which the melodeon is well suited is often very heavily based around those two chords. Certain 19th century polkas come to mind eg Sultan’s… And that dominant 7th chord is crucial…
My point was, if the OP considered going to such lengths as reconfiguring the approach to half the D chords, wouldn’t it be far less trouble to learn the Club system, or Dutch reversal, giving them that D note on the pull, and then putting the desired F# bass on the push instead of C? That way nothing is lost, apart from maybe those drony passages you often hear on the C chord ;)
*but you definitely wouldn’t want to change the push C chord, whilst keeping the the right hand unaltered. Being able to play the whole scale over the C chord is essential…
-
A lot of interesting points here, thanks everyone. I hadn't considered the air management perspective, which could well be a big one (particularly at the end of tunes with a bit of a slow down on the penultimate chord to get plenty of air for a big RH/LH G chord).
-
I had a 12 bass Oakwood once, which had push F# and pull F. after I got to know it, both were used a lot! F# is great for bass runs in G as it is the "leading note" to the tonic.
(F facilitated a bit of "bebopping", but was mainly used for playing in the key of C. So not relevant here).
-
It’s not just a melodeon thing, but diatonic music for which the melodeon is well suited is often very heavily based around those two chords. Certain 19th century polkas come to mind eg Sultan’s… And that dominant 7th chord is crucial…
My point was, if the OP considered going to such lengths as reconfiguring the approach to half the D chords, wouldn’t it be far less trouble to learn the Club system, or Dutch reversal, giving them that D note on the pull, and then putting the desired F# bass on the push instead of C? That way nothing is lost, apart from maybe those drony passages you often hear on the C chord ;)
*but you definitely wouldn’t want to change the push C chord, whilst keeping the the right hand unaltered. Being able to play the whole scale over the C chord is essential…
And for other tunes the alternation between the tonic and the dominant isn't enough, and the use of the dominant7 chord isn't crucial at all. I remember John Kirkpatrick stating that the English tunes from the 17th and 18th centuries should be played using just the three major triads, and blaming the guitar players for the introduction in the current folk practice of the dominant 7 chords. Sic transit gloria mundi!
Seriously, the undeniable facts that you often need just two chords to establish the key, the tonic and the dominant, and if you add the subdominant you can play a correct chord progression for virtually any diatonic tune, doesn't imply that you should limit yourself to the major triads, eventually using the dominant 7 but not necessarily, nor even that if you do you always get the most convincing results. And obviously, if you are able to, you can go chromatic!
Anyway, if I were a D/G player I wouldn't consider the idea to use a Club system box – that anyway would not be a two row instrument – or to use the Dutch reversal, because I wouldn't be able to play the tunes I learn on them on a standard D/G instrument. I'd rather choose an instrument ensuring me the backward compatibility with the D/G. And it's in fact what I did switching to the A/D/G.
If I had to replace the D pull bass with an F# sharp – can't see any reason to, but if someone else thinks it's a good idea he has all my respect -, I would have initially to rethink my approach to the use of the D pull chord, but considering the D note on the RH keyboard are push only that wouldn't be that difficult. Yet, I could easily play anything I've learned on my new box on any standard D/G with a D pull bass in a convincing way... and still use my C bass available both on the push and on the pull to go chromatic when II fell inclined to! 8)
-
Yes, but guitarists hammering away at the dominant 7th is another thing, and I could see that being unwelcome (otherwise I’d be making the case for Melodeon’s having a D7 on the left hand, which I definitely am not). What I’m saying is having the D chord available when playing the C note in the melody even just in passing, thereby creating a more transient dominant 7th harmony, is absolutely essential. This would definitely be missed if you suddenly found yourself without that option…
I never implied that anyone should limit themselves at all, but you can’t just remove the ability to play a basic building block of diatonic harmony, ie the dominant 7th, on what is a basic diatonic instrument.
Clearly, when I mentioned Clubbing, I simply implied replacing E pull with D pull on the G row.
-
Yes, but guitarists hammering away at the dominant 7th is another thing, and I could see that being unwelcome (otherwise I’d be making the case for Melodeon’s having a D7 on the left hand, which I definitely am not). What I’m saying is having the D chord available when playing the C note in the melody even just in passing, thereby creating a more transient dominant 7th harmony, is absolutely essential. This would definitely be missed if you suddenly found yourself without that option…
I never implied that anyone should limit themselves at all, but you can’t just remove the ability to play a basic building block of diatonic harmony, ie the dominant 7th, on what is a basic diatonic instrument.
We can probably blame Lonnie Donegan, and "skiffle" for overuse of the 2, and 3-chord "tricks". While it has been a strong influence on play here in Britain, chording elsewhere in Europe is much more subtle. Just listen to people like Stephane Deliq, whose harmonies had 6th (relative minor) element.
The same is true of the Beatles incidentally, who grew up as skiffle fans. Then moved on into much more complicated arrangements in the 1970s?
The V7 chord has its place in folk music, and of course in blues, but actually evolved in the Classical Baroque era. i'm not sure that it really reached the little villages of 19 century England? It is very much a "full stop, new paragraph" in harmonic terms, and folk music doesn't work like that, does it?
It is actually impossible for the left end of a standard Melodeon to play a V7 chord in any case. you always need to dab in an extra note on the right end.
Clearly, when I mentioned Clubbing, I simply implied replacing E pull with D pull on the G row.
I don't know why GB box dislikes the Club system so much. I play with 2 standard main rows, but have absolutely no problem in picking up a club system, and adapting the use of (mainly my ring) finger accordingly. and if you like right-hand chording, the available gamut is extended … considerably!
Theo "clubbed" my little 1984 Lilly for me several years ago and it is presently with my grandson (who is showing more interest in his Dad's banjo - but he's only 2)! 😉
I totally agree with reservations about Dutch inversion. It is a fantastic, efficient, and utterly logical layout. But if you take it up after more than a few months of play on standard keyboard … you will have numerous disasters as you hit a (very) wrong note on the G-row 😳 particularly after a few pints in a session. It basically requires relearning every tune that you have ever learned. Be warned!
-
I just mean harmonising the right hand C note with the left hand D chord in the Key of G, which often sounds better than other available options and is used loads across genres, not just at cadences. I don’t think it’s an option you’d want to be without, and of course nothing I’ve suggested takes anything away with regards to enabling other available approaches (in fact it adds a whole new chord), so that’s a bit of a red herring.
-
Ah... I've often found me pulling a D chord against a C melody and wondering why and thinking 'oh that should be a C chord...'.
Thanks Arnold, I thought it was just my wonkey ear.
-
Ah... I've often found me pulling a D chord against a C melody and wondering why and thinking 'oh that should be a C chord...'.
Thanks Arnold, I thought it was just my wonkey ear.
Logically it would make sense to use a C chord but some tunes actually sound better with the C against a D chord, thus creating the much discussed D7 chord.
Thinking of the humble one-row, four-stop in G, there is no C chord so you have to play the D (pull).
The D chord works fine against all the pull notes on a 1 row in G except the E which sounds a bit "wonky".
Experienced players will drop the D chord briefly when playing the E while also playing the octave E to thicken it up a bit.
-
Thanks Rees.
As you say, sometimes it just sounds right!
When learning I would worry about it, and thought it was a D7 but not sure. Now am much more of 'it sounds ok so why not' frame of mind.
-
Something that has long struck me as significant is the reference in Dan Worrall's Anglo Concertina book to preferring the use of F# over F natural whilst playing tunes in the Key of C amongst certain groups of players (IRC in Australia). This resonates with other texts that I have read. Christian Ferlaino refers to similar usage in his article "Generative Principles of Dance Music in Central Calabria". This is again referenced in Aindrias Hirt's dissertation "The European Folk Music Scale: A New Theory" which proposes a pre standardisation scale with flattened thirds and a sharpened fourth based on study of historical instruments.
-
There are logical reasons to do with voice leading etc why the D chord under the C note often sounds better, and has therefore made its way into conventional harmony. The dominant chord is very versatile and can be extended to include the 9th as well ie E, which is basically how the one row gets away with it. Where I would agree that it does sound wonky, is when the C chord is very obviously spelled out in the tune.
-
Interesting thoughts about the dominant chord. One thing I didn’t mention was that I’m actually considering this for a Club box with a half row, which will have a push C, so I’d still have a D7 chord on the push if needs be.
I’m also not sure if I was completely clear, I was suggesting leaving the pull D chord and only changing the bass, so actually I’d still have first and second inversion D7 chords on the pull with a bass, or a root position D7 chord with no bass.
-
Yes you were clear, but I think the D/F# would only work well in certain contexts. Against the C note you’d have an exposed diminished 5th between the F# bass note and the C melody note which might sound a little too spicy!..
Ah! I see, so is your would be push C bass/chord already occupied by F? Back to the problem of too much push and mental gymnastics!..
-
I was also considering a push F in place of the push C, yes, but I’ve now concluded that adding a 9th button is the best solution.
-
Something that has long struck me as significant is the reference in Dan Worrall's Anglo Concertina book to preferring the use of F# over F natural whilst playing tunes in the Key of C amongst certain groups of players (IRC in Australia). This resonates with other texts that I have read. Christian Ferlaino refers to similar usage in his article "Generative Principles of Dance Music in Central Calabria". This is again referenced in Aindrias Hirt's dissertation "The European Folk Music Scale: A New Theory" which proposes a pre standardisation scale with flattened thirds and a sharpened fourth based on study of historical instruments.
a.k.a Lochrian *Lydian mode. You certainly hear that in within French Massif Central music, and also "Rigaudon" an old Baroque dance, which is still seen in provinces of Vivarais, Languedoc, Dauphiné, and Provence. I can't speak for central Europe.
*I'm not well 🥴
-
Interesting thoughts about the dominant chord. One thing I didn’t mention was that I’m actually considering this for a Club box with a half row, which will have a push C, so I’d still have a D7 chord on the push if needs be.
About 15 years ago I decided more or less abandon the V7 chord unless I was playing blues or wanted a particularly dominant turnaround for some reason (I had very much moved to singing with the instrument).
In this style you use various sus chords for tension. Very much has happened to the so-called "English guitar stuff" in the 1970s. I even tried hitting the instrument but … that works a lot better on guitar! we are a bit off topic here, but it is very easily done. Put a finger across the rows, pull G+A and vary the bass E>C>D. Instant cadence with very fine control on the degree of tension.
Back on topic, a push F#bass with G gets you Gmaj7, a bit soft for folk music but often nice as an "I'm finished" chord?
If your F# is on pull, add it to Emin triad (rt-end EGB outer row) for a really cool Em9 inversion. You can always get Em9 by keeping the E bass, and moving your index finger to F# on inner row. they have a rather different feel. But again that is an exploration of sus chords.
-
What I’m saying is having the D chord available when playing the C note in the melody even just in passing, thereby creating a more transient dominant 7th harmony, is absolutely essential. This would definitely be missed if you suddenly found yourself without that option…
I never implied that anyone should limit themselves at all, but you can’t just remove the ability to play a basic building block of diatonic harmony, ie the dominant 7th, on what is a basic diatonic instrument.
I'm not going to discuss your inclination toward the use of the V7 chord. I personally prefer a I-IV-V-I or I-II-V-I progression over a straight I-V7-I alternation, but when different options are all harmonically correct the one you choose is in the end a matter of taste.
What I can't help saying is that here you were off topic. Andy asked our opinions about replacing the D push bass with an F# bass. If you do this, your D pull chord will remain available, and you will remain able to play a C note in the melody over it. Or play a full D7 chord with your left hand, using the D pull chord and the C pull bass. Or even do both things at the same time.
Of course on such an instrument you will not be able to play a C note, or an E note, over a D bass,. but you will have available both the F# and the A bass, the third and the fifth in the dominant chord, to replace it. And if the harmonic progression requires a D7 chord, or anyway you wish to suggest its use, you could even use the C bass. No missing basic building block of diatonic harmony!
The problem with the melodeons is that they aren't jus simple diatonic instruments. They are in fact highly illogical simple diatonic instruments! :(
-
The problem with the melodeons is that they aren't just simple diatonic instruments. They are in fact highly illogical simple diatonic instruments! :(
Story of my life!
-
Not wanting to be without the option of having a root position D chord under the C note is a far cry from being inclined towards the V7 chord. I don’t want to restate what I’ve already contributed to this thread, but anyway, a first or second inversion chord is not usually a satisfactory substitute for a root position chord…
Throughout the thread I have been consistently on topic, specifically providing my opinion as to where said F# should reside on an 8 bass and my supporting rationale. Really, this was already figured out by Hohner 100 years ago when they devised the club system, except they went one around the flats instead of the sharps.
-
Something that has long struck me as significant is the reference in Dan Worrall's Anglo Concertina book to preferring the use of F# over F natural whilst playing tunes in the Key of C
a.k.a Lochrian mode.
C with an F♯ is Lydian.
The Norwegians still have a lot of music with sharpened 4th.
-
Not wanting to be without the option of having a root position D chord under the C note is a far cry from being inclined towards the V7 chord. I don’t want to restate what I’ve already contributed to this thread, but anyway, a first or second inversion chord is not usually a satisfactory substitute for a root position chord…
The use of a bass that's not the root of a chord before you play the full chord isn't, technically speaking, an inversion. The term inversion is used for a full chord when the root isn't the lowest note.
For the matter, some of the ready made triads on the melodeons, as well as on the piano accordions, aren't generally chords in the root position, but first or second inversions. Like in a number of piano accordions for the dominant7 chords just three reeds are used, and in a number of them the missing one is the root.
The idea that the use of the third or the fifth of the chord as the bass note, before you play the full chord, is a less satisfactory choice than the root is an opinion a lot of piano and guitar players would find amazing. What actually matters is the harmonic relation between the basses, that's relevant as much as the enchainments of the chords. That's why, for instance, when alternating the basses, pianist and guitar players when they get back from the dominant to the tonic, invert the fifth with the root for the former. And they also use a number of inversions when they play the full chords, to remain in a lower pitch range than the one used by the instruments that play the melody.
And talking about playing in G on a D/G, or even on an A/D/G box, I really think that to play an A bass before a D chord is definitely more satisfactory than to play a D bass before a G chord because a delay in the melody implies to start the G bar on the push, especially when that is the last bar in the tune. But that's what the limitations of the instruments often dictate, and as far as the theory goes it remains harmonically correct.
-
Not wanting to be without the option of having a root position D chord under the C note is a far cry from being inclined towards the V7 chord. I don’t want to restate what I’ve already contributed to this thread, but anyway, a first or second inversion chord is not usually a satisfactory substitute for a root position chord…
The use of a bass that's not the root of a chord before you play the full chord isn't, technically speaking, an inversion. The term inversion is used for a full chord when the root isn't the lowest note.
For the matter, some of the ready made triads on the melodeons, as well as on the piano accordions, aren't generally chords in the root position, but first or second inversions. Like in a number of piano accordions for the dominant7 chords just three reeds are used, and in a number of them the missing one is the root.
The idea that the use of the third or the fifth of the chord as the bass note, before you play the full chord, is a less satisfactory choice than the root is an opinion a lot of piano and guitar players would find amazing. What actually matters is the harmonic relation between the basses, that's relevant as much as the enchainments of the chords. That's why, for instance, when alternating the basses, pianist and guitar players when they get back from the dominant to the tonic, invert the fifth with the root for the former. And they also use a number of inversions when they play the full chords, to remain in a lower pitch range than the one used by the instruments that play the melody.
And talking about playing in G on a D/G, or even on an A/D/G box, I really think that to play an A bass before a D chord is definitely more satisfactory than to play a D bass before a G chord because a delay in the melody implies to start the G bar on the push, especially when that is the last bar in the tune. But that's what the limitations of the instruments often dictate, and as far as the theory goes it remains harmonically correct.
Implied harmony. The ear generally relates a chord with the preceding bass note, and it is the bass note that determines the inversion, the rest of the chord determines its voicing. The same thing happens in country music with the ‘boom-chuck’ bass-chord pattern, or in the stride piano of ragtime. Or how about Alberti bass in classical music, or broken chords?..
I play the guitar, and use chord inversion a lot, but certainly not by default. One of the problems with beginner guitarists is hitting the low E string along with the C chord, which generally sounds awful.
Again, the rest of what you are saying is a red herring, since I am not arguing against using any of those inversions, only for keeping the option of playing a D chord in root position under the C note.
-
Whatever the music-theory technicalities, it is the bass note that determines how the human ear interprets a collection of notes played together.
Which is why Jazz trio has a bass player. And in a sense, what this whole thread is "about".