Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: David Colpitts on September 28, 2024, 01:08:09 PM

Title: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: David Colpitts on September 28, 2024, 01:08:09 PM
Hello, All.

Just got a nice little old Liliput in Bb Eb, still clubbed, old pitch, I think.  Plays nicely with itself, and I am enjoying it by myself in the kitchen.  It makes me think of playing it in sessions (Irish, Quebecois, Old Time, Americana) and am wondering if I would be committing a grave sin by tuning it to A D?  It seems like I could actually just load the reed tips a bit for a half-tone each, and there I'd be?  I am probably missing something.....I can imagine using heavy nail polish at the tip, as I have seen in YouTube videos for melodicas and harmonicas, and that would even be reversible.

The option, of course, is to simply keep it for my private amusement, and maybe use it for song accompaniment when I am brave enough.

Thanks for any wisdom you can share!

Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Theo on September 28, 2024, 02:16:56 PM
If you want an AD they are not hard to find.  Better IMHO than modifying something else.
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: mChavez on September 28, 2024, 02:18:58 PM
Bb Eb is a very, very sweet key for a squeezebox.
And I believe it's two very easy keys for clarinet and sax. Piano, guitar, chromatic squeezeboxes are all fine in them.

Good box to  keep as is, if you ask me. Gives you a reason to buy n+1 melodeon (as if we need extra reasons >:E).
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Arnold on September 28, 2024, 02:20:33 PM
Thinking a little outside the box, it might be easier to tune the Bb row to D major scale and the Eb row to C# major scale (edit: nope) (or leave it D/Eb)? A bit of reshuffling of the higher and lower reeds and the accidentals might help, not that I’m saying I think it’s a good idea (and haven’t considered the left hand…)  :Ph
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Chris Ryall on September 28, 2024, 02:29:08 PM

   Every 4th-apart box has a "built in" blues scale, completely on the pull, and very fluent. It's a semitone flat of the inner row tonality, i.e F# blues on a D/G.

  So on your Bb/Eb you get a complete D blues:  (a fairly common key in some circles). 

  I once ventured "15 tons" in D, in a "flat keys" session. Sadly, absolutely nobody joined in 🥴
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: David Colpitts on September 28, 2024, 02:40:48 PM
So far, most seem to think it's best left as is....And since I wrote the initial post, I have played it for about an hour, during which time the sweetness did soothe me, and I got (mostly) the hang of the inner row scale with the "gleichton" club key.  But, as a rookie, I don't really "get" what that does for me vs. the normal row playing on that inner row.  Does it open some magic door I can see when I am more experienced with it?  I know it has to do with cross-row play, and already (because of the gleichton) I have done more cross-rowing than heretofore, simply to get that scale (Eb major) but that's it so far.

Thanks for all your thoughts. I knew this was the place!
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Arnold on September 28, 2024, 02:55:38 PM
Good decision! IMO turning an 8 bass into a semitone box severely limits it’s ability to play two handed (eg changing to D/Eb would destroy its ability to play in its one good minor key, C minor, (ok maybe you could do something clever with the accidentals row…)) Yes, the gleichton does indeed open a magic door, and you probably won’t want to be without one once you get used to it, although many of the best players out there manage perfectly well without one themselves…
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Arnold on September 28, 2024, 03:24:23 PM
To give one example of gleichton magic speaking in D/G, when you’re playing in G, and you want the D note over the D chord, on a standard layout you have to play the D push note and move to the D push chord on the left hand. With the gleichton you have the D pull so don’t need to move the left hand, but of course D push is still an option (and on both rows, hence the next logical step - Dutch reversal!)
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 28, 2024, 04:53:01 PM
I have a BbEb Erika.
It doesn't get used a lot but every time I play it.... I love it!!!
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: kenakordeon on September 28, 2024, 08:01:58 PM
Keep it as is. The Bb row, besides giving you the opportunity to play, more-or-less, along with clarinets and saxes, there are Quebecois tunes, and Irish and Old Time and Klezmer etc, in Bb and Gm on which you could join in. Much easier than trying to learn to play in those keys on a semi-tone (D/C#/ C#/D, B/C) box although with a little thought and practice it is very doable.

Does that help!?   🤷‍♂️
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: David Colpitts on September 29, 2024, 09:23:17 PM
It's a done deal!  No change, and I'll find tunes in Bb/Gm. Maybe a couple of valves to do, and a reed or two, but mostly just gonna' play it.  Thanks to all!
Title: Re: Old Liliput Bb Eb what to do?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 29, 2024, 10:06:55 PM
A trick I employ is learn a tune in Bm on your DG.
Play exactly the same fingering on the BbEb and.... out it comes in Gm, and sounds lively and rich!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal