Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: RGF on December 04, 2009, 03:51:50 PM

Title: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: RGF on December 04, 2009, 03:51:50 PM
A good number of times, I've read or heard reference to a keyboard being quite "fast", and have got to wondering exactly what physical characteristics make or break this. (I don't think that, on my own, I'd necessarily recognize a "fast" keyboard if it bit me, as my fingers are certainly the slowest link in the equation.) The conjectures I've come up with are:

Button Travel -- which seems to be at least somewhat adjustable by a variety of means, depending on the instrument.

Spring Tension -- which could be made stiffer for quicker return, but which would then also require more finger effort.

Friction In The Mechanism -- which I would hope would be next to nothing, in terms of practial effect.

Inertial Mass -- which would appear to be quite negligable, and about which very little could be done anyway, I'd think.

Beyond these things, what else comes into play? Button diameter and shape? Or is there also some more nebulous factor that can only be attributed to the lineage of the instrument and the color of the celuloid? (:)

Bob
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: ganderbox on December 04, 2009, 04:26:33 PM
Button travel makes a big difference, but if you limit the button travel too much you may find that the pads don't open  far enough, and you get a muffled sound.
I would say a lightly sprung keyboard was faster than a heavy one.
Having the buttons close together helps, both along the rows and between the rows.
Some say a flat keyboard is faster than a stepped one, but I don't really find any difference.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: george garside on December 04, 2009, 04:42:08 PM
 a fast keyboard, though desirable is not in itself the answer to fast playing. In addition good quality reeds expertly set up for an instant response with the merest breath of air over them  is vital as is the action of the valves. And then there is the question of soft ( not stiff) bellows to give instant note change & the position of air bar and size of airhole to enable fast bellow adjustments without delaying the proceedings so to speak.  All of that usually comes at not inconsiderable cost although some considerable cost boxes fall   short in some of these areas.  Having said all that for many purposes a good old pokerwork is just as good i.e. song accompanyment & slow aires , dance music up to  a reasonable tempo etc it just doesn't have the nice feel of a high quality box.

for 'on row' playing I dont think flat or stepped makes much difference but for cross rowing on Dg or for anything on BC a flat keyboard probably has the edge.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: nfldbox on December 07, 2009, 03:04:42 PM
At least for playing "Irish" on a BC, slightly rounded buttons makes a big difference as you can do a lot of sliding between notes.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Theo on December 07, 2009, 03:13:34 PM
a fast keyboard, though desirable is not in itself the answer to fast playing. In addition good quality reeds expertly set up for an instant response with the merest breath of air over them  is vital ...

I am convinced that George is correct, and I would go further and say that what the player perceives as a fast keyboard is in fact more to do with the reed response, than the actual mechanical parts.  Assuming of course that the keys all move freely.  Virtually all Italian made closed keyboards use the same generic components.  Traditionally built open keyboards with wood levers are more dependent on the skill of the builder.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Andy in Vermont on December 07, 2009, 03:29:24 PM

I am convinced that George is correct, and I would go further and say that what the player perceives as a fast keyboard is in fact more to do with the reed response, than the actual mechanical parts. 

Personally, I've also considered that tight button springs, while increasing the resistance felt when pressing the buttons, also lead to the pallets snapping very quickly to the closed position, clipping the notes off very quickly and leading to the impression of "a fast box."
And I concur with the thesis that reed responsiveness is a major factor.
I _have_ played boxes with sluggish-feeling keyboards. 
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Theo on December 07, 2009, 03:35:24 PM
I _have_ played boxes with sluggish-feeling keyboards. 

I agree that there are some keyboards that are below par,  really the point I was trying to make is that most modern keyboards using Italian components are much the same, unless they are clogged up with dirt, or worn out, whereas there is much more variability between sets of reeds, which are manufactured in a range of grades with significant differences in response.  Add to that there are the subtle differences between the ways that reeds can be tuned and voiced
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Rob2Hook on December 07, 2009, 10:31:33 PM
In terms of keyboard action, I think the list was correct with the ommission of slack in the mechanism.  That and also lack of reed response is what limits my Pokerwork.  I also have an old Castagnari Nik with hand made reeds, which used to be fast, but although the keyboard hasn't changed the uneven response of the reeds now demands a more positive push of each button - you can no longer let your fingers just dance around and guarantee that all the notes will sound.

Rob.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: ganderbox on December 07, 2009, 10:56:53 PM
.... let your fingers just dance around and guarantee that all the notes will sound.

Rob.

Even with good reed response, the keyboard design still has to allow your fingers to move around quickly, and allow the note to sound with a light touch. Unless you have large, strong hands, heavy springs and wide button spacing are bound to slow you down.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: RGF on December 08, 2009, 12:25:29 AM
Wow, a great bunch of interesting responses.

Shall I assume, then, that when I hear people refer to a "fast keyboard", they are not speaking just about the keyboard and the attached mechanicals, but also of the reeds? (Which I had heretofore considered a separate issue, when trying to break these things down into their component parts.)

Bob
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Sandy on December 08, 2009, 12:57:48 AM
In terms of keyboard action, I think the list was correct with the ommission of slack in the mechanism.  That and also lack of reed response is what limits my Pokerwork. 

Rob.

I know John Kirkpatrick manages to get the chinese pokerwork to do amazing things, and JK is a bit spesh! but does anyone know if his pokerwork has been fettled?
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Theo on December 08, 2009, 08:50:05 AM
Shall I assume, then, that when I hear people refer to a "fast keyboard", they are not speaking just about the keyboard and the attached mechanicals, but also of the reeds? (Which I had heretofore considered a separate issue, when trying to break these things down into their component parts.)

Bob


Yes, that is my understanding.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: rees on December 08, 2009, 09:39:58 AM


I know John Kirkpatrick manages to get the chinese pokerwork to do amazing things, and JK is a bit spesh! but does anyone know if his pokerwork has been fettled?

Bog standard as far as I know.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Lester on December 08, 2009, 09:41:13 AM
In terms of keyboard action, I think the list was correct with the ommission of slack in the mechanism.  That and also lack of reed response is what limits my Pokerwork.  

Rob.

I know John Kirkpatrick manages to get the chinese pokerwork to do amazing things, and JK is a bit spesh! but does anyone know if his pokerwork has been fettled?

Think it's standard box but set up by Nils Nielsen which probably makes it better than most.
Title: Re: What makes a "fast" keyboard?
Post by: Andy Next Tune on December 08, 2009, 07:53:24 PM
I never thought a Hohner 4 stop could be fast until I watched JK play one at Witney this year.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal