Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Sal Rotondo on October 04, 2024, 11:12:18 AM

Title: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Sal Rotondo on October 04, 2024, 11:12:18 AM
I'm looking at three-voice, two-row boxes and am considering the Castagnari Sander and Hascy.

The Sander has super-dural reeds and lists at 2,300 euros while the Hascy has tipo-a-mano reeds and lists for 3,800 euros.

Is there a significant difference in instrument quality or sound quality and/or playability (regarding the reeds) that would warrant such a price difference?

Thank you!

Sal
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: mChavez on October 04, 2024, 11:49:32 AM
Putting Castas pricing aside - that's for them and for the market to decide - machine-stamped reeds tend to be very poor in terms of dynamics and air consumption.
TAMs are second-grade (A mano's the way to go) but not all TAMs and not all AMs are made equal: some are better and some are worse than others. Machine-stamped stuff is third (fourth, fifth) grade in terms of quality.
There might be instances where the difference is more noticeable (e.g. 5-voice bass with "dural" reeds can suck so much air that you can't play legato in the treble side!). I imagine, a 2-row box with a single-voice bass chords the difference will be somewhat less noticeable.
Personally, I wouldn't go for machine stamped stuff, and I'd think twice before going with TAMs unless I really liked their timbre (or got them really cheap). As a very general rule of thumb, the wider the musette, the less noticeable the difference in reed quality.

Difference between a set of machine stamped and tam reeds brand new is unlikely to be more than £300-400 for the whole box, so there must be something else that sets these two models apart.
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 04, 2024, 12:03:14 PM
I haven't tried a Sander but have owned a Hascy for ~ 10 years before trading it in a couple of months back for an instrument more in line with my current playing, ( moving to a 2.5 row/12 bass ).

The Hascy is a beautiful box.
It is a 3 voice instrument, the little black switches on the front of the grill allows you to select M, MM, LM and LMM voices on the treble side. The switches are very accessible, even whilst playing and a quick flick up to them even mid-tune can bring in a voice as you wish.

Looking at the Castagnari catalogue, the Sander is a 3 voice instrument, but with a pull stop to bring in the L reed.
Therefore it will be either MM or LMM.

The price difference is not just about the quality of the reeds, but about the sophistication of the instrument, the Hascy being more refined in the ability to select different voicing on the treble side.
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: CAB on October 04, 2024, 03:15:45 PM
I'd go for TAM over super Dural every time.  You'll get better tone, volume, dynamic range and response.

Having said that, I see that Pete at Acorn does a "Sander Special" with TAM reeds which might be a good option. 

The main difference then lies in the sophistication of the voice selection mechanism, as described by Thrupenny Bit, which in itself is a significant factor.  (My 3 voice box has only the traditional stops to switch voices and there's more than one video of me trying to bring in a voice with my chin!  ;D )

https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=19 (https://www.acorninstruments.co.uk/listing.cfm?inst=19)
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: mselic on October 04, 2024, 03:22:22 PM
Castagnari does not use A-Mano reeds in any of their boxes anymore; they have relied exclusively on either super-dural or TAM (tip-a-mano) from Voci Armoniche for some time now, with the latter being used as their ‘top tier’ reed for most of their boxes.

VA TAM reeds are excellent reeds, btw. I believe Castagnari decided they found them to be more consistent and reliable than their A-Mano counterparts, and more than adequate in terms of performance. The A-Mano line, however, most definitely had different tonal characteristics (a more ‘full’, rich sound) and were also a different shape/profile. The A-Mano line has been replaced with the new BlueStar reed, which are the same but different…I prefer the original reed myself.

If it were me, I’d go with the box with better reeds.
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: pete /acorn on October 04, 2024, 05:12:49 PM
I have sold both over the last 10 years,even a Sander special which had Tipo a Mano reeds.
The Hascy has the edge every time.
If you are in USA I can supply one from stock.
The price would be excluding the vat content plus shipping .
You would pay import duty
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Sal Rotondo on October 05, 2024, 09:44:44 AM
Good morning all and thank you for your input.

The case has been made for the Hascy.
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on October 05, 2024, 10:16:42 AM
Ah good decision!
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Andrel on October 05, 2024, 02:58:05 PM
I agree. I think the Hascy is one of the best diatonic accordions ever built. Gorgeous sound and great action!
Title: Re: Castagnari Sander vs. Hascy
Post by: Tufty on October 06, 2024, 06:25:49 PM
I agree. I recently bought a used Hascy from Pete, tuned and sorted by Mike R. It is my 4th Castagnari and the best two row box I have ever owned. Very flexible, good for English dance music but equally good for French and ITM. I don't think you would regret getting one.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal