Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: jacknbox on November 12, 2024, 04:29:03 PM

Title: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 12, 2024, 04:29:03 PM
I finally got my eagerly anticipated new Saltarelle Selkie from France after waiting five months. I like it. It is almost everything I hoped for except for several buttons that make a clicking noise. Is this to be expected? The clicks aren't consistent, and they happen without any bellows movement. You can depress them several times and no click but will then click again for several more depressions. All my other melodeons (Castagnari, Dino Baffetti, even my inexpensive Linnet) have silent buttons. It's wickedly distracting. Is this normal for Saltarelles?  Has anyone else had this issue? Do you think it can be fixed? Sending it back to France would be a huge expense.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: tirpous on November 12, 2024, 06:15:33 PM
If it's only happening on some of the buttons, it can obviously be fixed and could be a minor problem. But really, if it's a new box your best bet may be to contact the selling party (Saltarelle, retailer, distributor??) to let them know of the problem and see what they recommend.

 
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Theo on November 12, 2024, 06:20:04 PM
It needs investigation by someone with experience working on keyboards.  A likely cause is the button or lever coming in contact with something.  That something could be the keyboard top, a nearby lever, the underside of the grill, or something else.   It’s the sort of after sale service that you should get if you buy from a local dealer. 
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 12, 2024, 08:01:21 PM
All good advice, thank you. Sadly, the dealer is 6000 mi away. One of the perils of living in the relative melodeon desert of the US. I suppose I should have looked into trying to order (nothing in stock) through a US based reseller, the closest one is 150 miles, but I was snared by 'worldwide shipping', and the fact they are closer to Italy. Lesson learned. At least now I know it's not something I should have to live with, and I have some ammunition when I do contact the seller. I'll let you know how that turns out. Thanks again.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Matthew B on November 12, 2024, 10:56:22 PM
Where are you based in the US?  (PM me if you choose not to disclose in the public forum).

There are a few melodeon folks here and there on this side of the pond.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 13, 2024, 04:47:44 PM
PM sent.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: tirpous on November 13, 2024, 06:07:35 PM
Should it be necessary Jack, I think Bob Snope (formerly of The Button Box) is in the same general area as you, if not exactly down the street.

https://www.squeezeboxgarage.com/ (https://www.squeezeboxgarage.com/) as
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 13, 2024, 07:36:35 PM
Thanks, I know Bob. He did some work on my Lily when he worked for the Button Box. Good fettler and a pleasure to work with.  He is definitely on my list.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 20, 2024, 04:41:34 PM
Well, I contacted the retailer about the clicking noise and his initial response wasn't very helpful. This is what he wrote:

"Each accordion produces its own mechanical noise, especially when the bellows are not or can be operated, generally, this is only heard by the musician when he practices at low volume, but never by the audience who listens to the sound of the instrument. Honestly, I don't think there is anything to do for this."

I then sent him a video of the problem (link attached), which he dutifully forwarded to Saltarelle. Their reply was that it "might be useful to check the correct lubrication of the springs of the right hand, it costs nothing to try. (You have to unscrew the back plate of the right keyboard to see the springs and to be able to lubricate them correctly)".

Does anyone think this is acceptable? Is this something I should attempt on my own? Honestly, I don't even know what kind of lubricant I should use or where it goes or if this actually addresses the problem or what this would do to the warranty (which doesn't seem to be very useful anyway). I really would like some opinions on this. Keep in mind that this is a brand new $3010 (£2376) instrument.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aq6e_Yq77v8 (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aq6e_Yq77v8)
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Theo on November 20, 2024, 05:12:02 PM
I’ve never heard springs make a percussive sound like that.  Some part of the mechanism is touching/hitting something else.  It could be the pallet touching the underside of the grill.  Take the grill off and try again.  If the sound disappears that is the cause.  Of course it could be something else but the grill is an easy thing to try.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Theo on November 20, 2024, 05:19:08 PM
Just looked at the video again and I’m not sure but I think part of the grill has been pushed in slightly in the area where the loud clicks are happening.  Again not sure but I thought I could see the grill move slightly sometimes when you push a noisy button.  The whole instrument moves slightly sometimes when you demonstrate so I can’t be absolutely sure but I very strongly suspect it’s pallets hitting the grill.

There is another softer sound that happens as the button returns.  That is the sound of the pallet closing and is perfectly normal.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on November 20, 2024, 06:31:31 PM
Thanks Theo, following your lead I shined a light through the grill and pushed it in slightly while depressing the button. I'm pretty sure the pallet is not hitting anything. It may be the lever arm, that I can't tell. It sounds like the click is coming from under the keyboard. It only happens sometimes in succession. It sounds like the clicker used to train dogs. You can push it almost all the way down slowly and then just at the end of the travel it clicks and then clicks again on the way up. I think it is happening at the pivot point. Anyway, I am leery of my skills at disassembling a brand-new melodeon. 
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Lars on November 20, 2024, 09:24:47 PM
I have a suspicion that it's got something to do with the mechanism rod. There'll be a long rod with all the levers pivoting on, as well as probably a good few spacers and possibly washers between some support points. If one of the spacers is too loose, has some burrs etc, it could be that the pushing of a button (and releasing it) is causing a washer or spacer to ping against another part.

The only way to know for sure is to remove the back panel, shine a light inside, and see what moves when you push a button. The eraser end of a pencil (or a chopstick with a rubber band wrapped at the end) can be used to hold parts still to rule out causes of the clicking.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on December 04, 2024, 05:38:47 PM
Thanks to all for the responses and advice. Here is a status update. The clicking became more than I could tolerate, so I did what I did not want to do and removed the back of the keyboard, and when that didn't reveal any hints to the source of the noise, I removed the grill cover. For anyone interested in what the internals of a Saltarelle button mechanism looks like, I've attached a link to a short video. I poked around with an improvised probe as Lars suggested to try to isolate any untoward moving parts, but nothing changed. I then 'lubed' the rotation points as Saltarelle (I thought) recommended. Again, nothing changed.

I stared at the whole mechanism for over an hour, pressing the buttons, listening to the clicks over and over, unable to discern any way to fix it. I was in full despair at this point, thinking I would have to live with the clicks after all. Looking at the aluminum backplane of the button mechanism (see pic) there is a line of crenel-like slots. It appeared as though some debris was in the slots, like maybe some machining slag. When I tried to push it out with the edge of an index card while pressing a button, something moved. It was the tip end of the coiled spring arm attached to the button lever. It was scraping up and down (very slightly) on the inside edge of the slot where it was resting. On some of the buttons and sometimes, the tip would catch on the side of the slot and then snap release when the pressure overcame the resistance and make a discernable click. Same thing happened when the button was released. I pushed the tip of the spring arm to the other side of the slot and no more click.

Problem solved. No more clicks. What a relief. It was the spring after all. This must have been what Saltarelle meant when they said 'lubricate the spring'. I wish they had been more specific. At least now it only makes normal melodeon sounds and I can give this little box the love it deserves.

BTW, a shout-out to Lars for suggesting the chopstick and rubber band. When I first read that, I thought it was silly, but when a pencil eraser proved too fat, this brilliant idea did the deed. I've attached a picture.

https://youtu.be/CUNLM7Dy1ME (https://youtu.be/CUNLM7Dy1ME)
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Dick Rees on December 04, 2024, 06:51:29 PM
Good job.  Congrats!
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: boxcall on December 04, 2024, 07:12:32 PM
That’s great, easy fix after discovering what it was! Play on😀
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Lars on December 05, 2024, 07:42:51 AM
Lovely to hear that you found the problem, and got it solved. It's often the smallest little detail...

For future reference, and others reading - a gentle warning against liquid/oily lubrication; any oil used will not only gunk up over time, but as you're basically playing a musical hoover you will risk sucking dust particles into the exposed oil, and then you'll get a free trip to trouble-town (not next week, but over the years). I like fixing up old boxes, and about half that time is spent just cleaning.

And yes, chopsticks, coffee stirrers, rubber bands, off offcuts and various craft materials... Tools and jigs doesn't always come from the hardware store.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on December 05, 2024, 04:17:07 PM
Warning well taken. This is the reason I didn't want to tackle this task by my unqualified self. I only did it out of desperation. I did ask Saltarelle what kind of lubricant I should use, either oil or a thicker grease type, and they replied they use an oil lubricant. I'm not sure either would be a good idea in retrospect, but I don't manufacture melodeons.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Disparate Dan on December 05, 2024, 05:54:31 PM
Thank you for updating us with the outcome.  I'm glad that your perseverance paid off.  I'm not at all impressed by the position taken either by your dealer or by Saltarelle!
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on December 05, 2024, 06:48:10 PM
Quote
I'm not at all impressed by the position taken either by your dealer or by Saltarelle!

I know, I was taken aback too, but I'm over it. One thing I've learned is that melodeons are quirky instruments, and part of the joy is dealing with the quirks.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: chris hall on December 05, 2024, 06:58:01 PM
i encoutered a similar issue with a saltarelle boebe earlier this week. springs werent causing any clicking but they were groaning and moaning and creaking as buttons were depressed as they move in the slots (on the outside row / inside row was fine) i deduced a good start would be to clean the slots but that didnt help. ptfe solution helped slightly. So i tried a tiny amount of oil where the sping rests in the slot.....which fixed it. yeh not ideal but its my own box and if it gums up in two years i'll clean it again. couldn't see any other other way forward but maybe others have? mine is an old box so maybe saltarelle use a lubricant and over time it dries out?
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Theo on December 05, 2024, 10:44:41 PM
I have springs that creak slightly I have done very fine silicone rubber tubing which I plan to slip over the leg of the spring where it rests on the aluminium comb.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: chris hall on December 06, 2024, 02:51:17 PM
nice idea theo....got any info on silicone tube and a source? ...might also even make action smoother if it reduces friction of spring as it bends.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 06, 2024, 05:37:47 PM
I'm not at all impressed by the position taken either by your dealer or by Saltarelle!

I'd certainly be rather unimpressed with the dealer but not really with the manufacturer. As a buyer your contract is with the retailer and one of the main reasons for buying this way rather than going direct is that they should sort out any issues for the buyer - although in this instance that would have been logistically challenging.

Still, all is well now and the OP has a cracking new box which is always a very lovely thing.

Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: jacknbox on December 22, 2024, 05:27:57 PM
Unfortunately my celebration was premature. Apparently the torsion spring arms had repositioned themselves and the clicks came back with a vengeance. More drastic measures were needed. Emboldened by Theo's use of silicone tubing, I fashioned some PVC sleeves, obtained by stripping the covering from 18 guage solid copper electrical wire, and slipped these over the ends of the spring arm (see pic). I cut a notch in the underside (or top depending on your perspective) of the sleeve to hold it in place on the edge of the frame comb.
 
This seems to be the solution. Without Theo's comment, I would not have attempted it, thank you Theo. It's working so far, no clicking noise, so, optimistically, mission accomplished. My feeling is that I should not have had to do this at all. IMHO this is a design flaw of the Saltarelle melodeon. Perhaps they could have made the slots V-shaped instead of square, whatever, I am going to write them directly to get their feedback on I what I've done. I'll let you know if I get a response.
 
I'm a little annoyed at Saltarelle's replies (via my reseller) to date. I am willing to believe that I am the only one who ever had this issue, but looking at the frame comb, I am skeptical. It wasn't just that I could hear the clicks, I could actually feel them through the button. They were random and felt like something had broken. I am surprised there are not more complaints.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2024, 05:38:12 PM
Glad to hear you have a fix.

To be fair to Saltarelle the comb is a most likely the same standard Italian part used by many makers.
Title: Re: New Saltarelle buttons make clicking noise
Post by: Disparate Dan on December 22, 2024, 06:04:42 PM
To be fair to Saltarelle the comb is a most likely the same standard Italian part used by many makers.

Speaking as an erstwhile production engineer, where Saltarelle get the comb from is irrelevant to anyone outside the factory.  If they decide to use a bought-in component, it's down to them to ensure its fitness for purpose.  Quality control is down to Saltarelle: not their supplier and not the customer.

One reason why snags like this crop up with small-batch production runs, particularly of goods where the final user is generally of an artistic bent, is because the customer tends to give the maker the "benefit of the doubt".  The maker then gets away with whatever caused the snag.  It's just the same as the service in shops: in general, the public gets the lowest standard of service that it'll tolerate.

Yes, I do have a bit of a "thing" about this ...  (:)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal