Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Bill_S on December 11, 2024, 05:26:00 PM

Title: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 11, 2024, 05:26:00 PM
Following the suggestion to learn cross-rowing as soon as possible, I've started incorporating it into some tunes i'm working on and it definitely feels like cheating to me.

It's so much easier to move a right hand finger a cm or two for a reversal than it is to move the bellows twice for a note.

What's more, having seen how easy it is, I'm now looking for other places to incorporate it.... It's like the dark side.

This must stop! Haha!

And yes, I've read all the threads where this has been discussed before and completely understand the justifications for it. But I still feel like I used to when, as a kid, I used cheat codes on computer games for extra lives etc.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Theo on December 11, 2024, 05:38:22 PM
Learn both.  It’s not cheating it’s just different. You might as well tell a string player that you have to play each note on a specific string. It feels different and it sounds different so you can exploit those differences to shape and colour your playing.  Whatever you don’t just do one or you will be artificial limiting your music.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 11, 2024, 06:00:40 PM

   What Theo just said.  There are many ways to play even a simple 2-row accordion, and in the end you'll want to master them all.

   You said elsewhere that you're going to meet up with Rees, of this parish (and your local one, it seems)?

   He's a master of 1-row technique (and also makes them).  Get him to show you your D/G's "built in" F# blues scale (which I learned from him).

   Yup, that's right. A standard D/G plays really fluently in F#, with no "accidentals" involved. 
   It's actually easier than playing "on the row" 😉 May the Force be with you!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 11, 2024, 06:14:14 PM
Hi Theo. I dig it, horses for courses and all that.

I don't think the analogy of the stringed player is correct though, since the physical process of playing a note is essentially the same regardless of which string it's on and the result will be broadly identical (allowing for a slight change in sustain/crispness depending on factors such as where on the neck the note is played and the thickness of the string it's played on). On the melodeon there are two very distinct ways of doing things and they have markedly different outcomes.

I know the received wisdom is to cross-row as soon as possible, but since it's easier to cross-row than manipulate the bellows, as a beginner at least, might this lead the neophyte to favour cross-rowing at the expense of learning tight bellows control?

Received wisdom again states that cross-rowing will be harder to learn later on. I'm not sure about that, it seems pretty straight forward to me. In fact, no different to playing a note anywhere else on the fingerboard.

PS - Thanks for moving the thread to the relevant section!

Chris - Indeed, when I meet up with Rees, I'm going to make like a sponge and absorb as much as I can!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: rees on December 11, 2024, 06:35:12 PM

Chris - Indeed, when I meet up with Rees, I'm going to make like a sponge and absorb as much as I can!

You'll need "wet tuning" then ..........
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Andy Next Tune on December 11, 2024, 07:04:27 PM
To quote that other thread.... "my preference is definitely for tunes played in a highly rhythmic/lumpy/bouncy/staccato style"

Much of that style of playing is driven by the bellows shaping the sound to give it attack, lift and rhythm.

It happens almost automatically when playing on the row with its many necessary bellows reversals.

It can also be achieved when playing 'cross row', but that requires much more skill and practice, and thought. Otherwise cross row playing tends to result in a smoother 'legato' style.

Learning good bellows control to shape a tune is an essential skill irrespective of how you are fingering the melody with the right hand.

Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Tufty on December 11, 2024, 07:07:13 PM
Back in 1978 I bought my first melodeon, a Hohner 1 row which I played for about 5 years before getting a 2 row. As a result I learnt to play on the row, no cross rowing possible! It took me quite some time to start cross rowing and even now my first instinct is to play on the row. If I was starting today I would use both from the start, selecting the most appropriate style for each type of music. It is always going to be best to have as many tools as possible available. We tend to think of cross rowing as "French style" but from what I can discover this seems to be quite recent and up to the folk revival plenty of trad French players played on the row and I love the sound of my C one row combined with a friend's pipes for playing trad Auvergne music. You should listen to everyone's opinion ... then make up your own mind, there is no one right way of approaching the instrument!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Arnold on December 11, 2024, 07:08:35 PM
The essence of the melodeon sound is I think the to-ing and fro-ing of the I and V chords as the tune is played along the row… This creates an element of excitement in the harmonic rhythm even between just those two chords, and carries more energy than say a predictable I vi IV V type chord progression… I think that’s part of what pulls me and others back to the one-row instrument…

On the other hand, if you are playing with other musicians, a more predictable sequence of chords is preferable and so cross-rowing becomes optimal… At a session recently, I tried strumming along to a box player playing a Polka in D on the row and it was virtually impossible to follow the seemingly random pattern of D and A chords!.. So, I think it’s probably a good idea to get comfortable with both approaches as has been said…

Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 11, 2024, 07:24:33 PM
Quote from: rees
You'll need "wet tuning" then ..........

Indeed. Haha!

Quote from: Andy Next Tune
Learning good bellows control to shape a tune is an essential skill irrespective of how you are fingering the melody with the right hand.

Yeah, I can appreciate that. When crossing, the temptation is to slur the notes into each other. Much harder to get a definitive.

Quote from: Tufty
You should listen to everyone's opinion ... then make up your own mind, there is no one right way of approaching the instrument!

I concur. Regarding this notion of being able to do everything, or at least aiming to be able to play in all styles, how does that tally with what Confucius said about playing the melodeon: "man who tries to catch two horses gets neither."?

On the other hand, if you are playing with other musicians, a more predictable sequence of chords is preferable and so cross-rowing becomes optimal… At a session recently, I tried strumming along to a box player playing a Polka in D on the row and it was virtually impossible to follow the seemingly random pattern of D and A chords!.. So, I think it’s probably a good idea to get comfortable with both approaches as has been said…

Now that's another interesting angle I hadn't considered. In my mind, the melody comes first and foremost with the left hand playing something rhythmic for added colour. I'd never have thought of working chords out first, then melody.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Disparate Dan on December 11, 2024, 07:30:37 PM
... Get him to show you your D/G's "built in" F# blues scale ...

Perhaps Rees might explain this for the benefit of those of us not fortunate enough to meet him?
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Anahata on December 11, 2024, 08:17:41 PM
I don't think the analogy of the stringed player is correct though, since the physical process of playing a note is essentially the same regardless of which string it's on and the result will be broadly identical (allowing for a slight change in sustain/crispness depending on factors such as where on the neck the note is played and the thickness of the string it's played on). On the melodeon there are two very distinct ways of doing things and they have markedly different outcomes.
As a cellist, I beg to differ. Choice of which string to play a note on makes a huge difference to your left hand fingering pattern surrounding that note, and also (if it's a bowed instrument) introduces issues slightly similar to bellows reversals, as crossing strings is very different from playing consecutive notes on the same string.

Quote
I know the received wisdom is to cross-row as soon as possible

Not necessarily.
A related piece of frequently repeated advice, though, is to figure out which row to play parts of the tune on based on the left hand chords you want to play, which leads to...

Quote
but since it's easier to cross-row than manipulate the bellows, as a beginner at least, might this lead the neophyte to favour cross-rowing at the expense of learning tight bellows control?
Many players learn on one row and then find cross rowing harder, but in any case the right answer has been given: "learn both". Then get used to the decision making process for where to cross rows and where not, for stylistic and musical reasons and also...

It hasn't really been mentioned yet, but an important reason for cross rowing has nothing to do with style or ease of playing, but the basic requirement of getting the right chords (or at least the best approximation to "right" chords, which on a melodeon isn't always the same thing)
For example
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 11, 2024, 09:05:45 PM

   F# Blues Scale  See attached graphic


  That's the simple "built in" F# Blues scale over 2 octaves.  just run your fingers up and down it and get the double triangles into your muscle memory. Stick to the two octaves initially.  Once that is fluent you can try some little phrases within it.

  Your base buttons are useless. Blue scale is in its essence "out"!   

  Once you have mastered it you may extend by a further two notes below low F#,  but keep the same fingering pattern.

  That's enough for now.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 11, 2024, 09:41:20 PM
Quote from: Anahata
As a cellist, I beg to differ. Choice of which string to play a note on makes a huge difference to your left hand fingering pattern surrounding that note, and also (if it's a bowed instrument) introduces issues slightly similar to bellows reversals, as crossing strings is very different from playing consecutive notes on the same string.

I'm not classically trained, being only a humble self-taught uker, albeit to a fairly decent standard (not merely a 3 chord strummer).

What i'm saying is, broadly speaking, fingering a string is fingering a string. Even barre chords (not sure if you use those on a cello), are still primarily a finger thing. Yes, there are differences between hand shapes depending on voicings and where you come from and go to, but it's a hand/finger movement. If we were being pedantic, the arm does move, but the fingers/hand are doing the work. Fingering a button is similar. It's just finger work.

Moving the bellows is a whole arm movement. It's obviously different to operating the right hand end and physically more difficult, not least because the arm has less capability for fine motor skill than a finger does. In addition, there has to be impeccable coordination between left arm and right fingers to get the note clean and in time. Another factor that doesn't apply to playing a note across the row. Therefore, it seems obvious that cross-rowing is the easier approach. And therefore, cheating!  >:E

This chord thing interests me though. Like I say, and I'm admittedly pretty ignorant when it comes to the box (which is why i'm here), to me it's a melody instrument and chords are of secondary importance. Do people approach the box from a primarily chordal point of view and then fit the melody to that? Seems the wrong way round.

I can see a soloist/virtuoso wanting to have the chordal accompaniment spot on, but then there's always a compromise and from the stuff I've seen and listened to, it would appear that rhythm is what suffers when players get fancy with their chord choices.

Not knocking fancy, but the average listener/dancer doesn't care. What matters to them is a catchy tune and a rhythm that moves people.

The difference between this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yKWuQ4jooNo) and this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkaIf3oKqAc) demonstrate the point perfectly. Paul Young is an awesome player and I can certainly appreciate the musicianship, but I much prefer the second guy. The melody is simple and he's got drive; the left hand is just relentless, it gets you moving.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Dick Rees on December 11, 2024, 09:53:32 PM
It's always interesting when a beginner comes in to offer their opinions and advice to a community of experienced practitioners...
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Arnold on December 11, 2024, 10:05:52 PM
The box is melody, chords and rhythm working together in a single instrument, which is pretty much the idea of it… You could view it as primarily a melody instrument, but then let’s say for example you’ve figured out a lovely legato G major scale passage on the pull, only to go find the G major chord on the left hand to accompany it and discover it isn’t there!..

The examples you provide do demonstrate the two stylistic extremes very well I think. The first by Paul Young is a very nicely figured out arrangement, sensitively played (which that type of box requires), whilst the second perfectly demonstrates the original ‘fool proof’ concept behind the one-row melodeon ie the two chords on the left hand provide a serviceable, if not always strictly correct accompaniment to the melody notes (there is an additional chord on this box but it’s not used in the video even when it possibly should be)
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 11, 2024, 10:57:03 PM
It's always interesting when a beginner comes in to offer their opinions and advice to a community of experienced practitioners...

   Rees 'll sort him out. He took the piss out of me mercilessly in 1992, (Montluçon AFAIR).
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 11, 2024, 11:25:12 PM

    Here's what can be achieved by blending the two. Came up on my feed incidentally.
   Martin Ellison this summer. (Looks to have some reversed chords head of, left end)

    https://youtu.be/wzmfeIFPoMw

   Sublime …
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Al Cramer on December 12, 2024, 04:27:56 AM
As a string player (violin & viola) I totally agree with what Anahata (cellist) posted.

I have this vague childhood memory of reading Jules Verne's "20 Thousand Leagues Under the Sea". At some point in the book there's a scene where the narrator encounters Cpt. Nemo playing the piano, and observes that Nemo played only on the black keys, which gave his music a Scottish air (by which I think Verne meant pentatonic scale). I remember thinking: WTF? Why would anybody not use those other keys?.

So as a beginner I'm totally committed to cross-row from the start. My thinking is that is that it will be a lot easier to move from cross-row quint to single-row box, than to go the other way around. For one thing: if I want to experiment with single row playing, all I have to do is just ignore some buttons on my D/G!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Disparate Dan on December 12, 2024, 07:49:02 AM

   F# Blues Scale  See attached graphic
 ...


Thank you for that.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 12, 2024, 08:13:21 AM
Quote from: Dick Rees
It's always interesting when a beginner comes in to offer their opinions and advice to a community of experienced practitioners...

Hahaha! I've freely admitted my ignorance and am happy to continue to do so. I've also said a number of times that i'm here to learn and absorb the wisdom of the sages, but I'm not the kind of guy who just accepts what i'm told unthinkingly. I'd also disagree that I'm giving advice, at best I'm making suggestions. I always try to keep an open mind and am happy to admit when I'm proved wrong.

However, it does strike me as a bit arrogant to think that one is beyond question as a result of one's experience level. Further, to think that there is a set way to learn or think about playing a musical instrument is ludicrous. There are traditions, certainly, but even they change over time.

After all, many new discoveries have been made by neophytes who bring new perspectives and question established norms. So, if I may be so bold, I'd change your statement to, "it always makes for interesting discussion when a new player gives his thoughts, as, being almost entirely free from bias, they can offer new insight."

Arnold - good points, I dig what you're saying.

Al - as I say, I'm not classically trained, but that doesn't really matter and my earlier points remain extant - it's arm vs fingers. I understand the rest of your points and I hope I'm not taking liberties when I sum them up as, "horses for courses" in terms of what one wants to achieve and how one is wired. Some will find cross-rowing harder, others bellows flicking. Vive la différence, eh.

Chris - great vid and I agree, it's superb playing. As for being sorted out, with the greatest respect to Rees, many have tried but nobody has succeeded yet. Not quite sure how I need sorting out anyway...

PS y'all - when I started this thread, I knew it'd be contentious. Rest assured, I'm not trying to insult anyone's musical pedigree. The "cheating" moniker I've applied is tongue in cheek to explain my personal feeling on the technique. That could very well change as I progress.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: rees on December 12, 2024, 08:19:23 AM
Ha! I need to sort myself out first  ;D
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 12, 2024, 11:25:49 AM
You've made a good point in your last statement 'things could change as I progress...'
They almost certainly will.  It seems to come with the territory.

As you get going with your playing different paths will appear that you may or may not take.
What happens as you progress you may well find your musical tastes can be fundamentally different to your current position of being at Ground Zero on the learning curve. OK, perhaps one up from Ground Zero from your video but...!
That's why people are advising different approaches and possibly mixing them up etc etc. Give everything a go, as at this point you have a blank canvass to work on.
Why restrict yourself to one particular style or mantra?
Keep an open mind... let your fingers have fun and explore everything.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 12, 2024, 11:52:26 AM
Amen to that, TB.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: GBbox on December 12, 2024, 01:01:21 PM
Interesting thread, but as far as my experience goes the choice to play press and draw on one row, or using both the rows, or to play cross row style – i.e. trying to change the bellows direction, as far as possible, in connection with a chord change in the harmonic progression -, is just one side of the coin.

If we do not consider at the same time the different articulations we use to play the melody with the right hand what happens is that we can't see the forest for the trees. Between the staccato and the legato there is the portato, or mezzo staccato, and beyond the legato there is the legatissimo – i.e. letting the attacks of some of the notes overlap with the tail of the preceding ones. The way we mix the different articulations has an impact on the rhythm that's often more relevant that the one of the bellows inversion.

Anyway,  I'm from the a country of lazy melodeon players. I actually don't play music from the South  of Italy, and I occasionally still play the one row four stop, on which you need to use the bellows. Yet the traditional Italian 1 ½ row instruments had four or five reversals to be played across the rows for a whole octave.   

Why just one octave? Because most of the traditional tunes were in the zampogna and other bagpipes range, and an octave was enough. But the Italian modern one row instruments have 19 buttons, and all the notes of the scale are available both on the push and on the pull.

But those who are concerned with playing correct and possibly attractive harmonic progressions and still use the bellows a lot could consider switching from the standard two row melodeon to the trikitixa, !2 double action bass /chord buttons, offering the six chords of a standard 8 single action (except one) bass/chord buttons both on the push and on the pull.

Why the Italian instruments or the Basque one remain oddities, and the standard two instruments, or for the matter the three row instruments in three keys, have single action bass/chords? Well, those who are familiar with economics probably knows that the answer to this question lies in  the Gresham's law!  ;)

 
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Arnold on December 12, 2024, 01:08:26 PM
I think as you get a few more tunes together, your experience will begin to back up the advice already received, to the point where certain things become quite obvious (such as how if you work out a phrase in a certain direction on the right hand first, the chord you seek may not be available on the left hand)… Taking advice from others with lots of experience (not me, although I know what I know), as you might a teacher, ultimately saves time in your journey. On the other hand you can discover things by yourself, which is also valid, but there may be wrong turns and things that remain elusive along the way…
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 12, 2024, 01:28:33 PM
GBbox - that's a interesting point.  A box, or any other instrument played in a single note melody fashion, can certainly get people moving. In that case, as you say, the rhythm is imparted subtly by emphasis, tiny changes in note duration and articulation.

In real world terms, demonstrated by how one person can play a melody and people will tap their feet/clap their hands and another can play the exact same melody, note for note, on the same instrument and it doesn't move people. That's what fascinates me.

Arnold - you're right of course. It's a balance. Heed the signposts, but also carve out your own route. As long as I don't make that many wrong turns that I'm just spinning round on one spot, it'll all come good!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Dick Rees on December 12, 2024, 01:30:24 PM
Interesting thread, but as far as my experience goes the choice to play press and draw on one row, or using both the rows, or to play cross row style – i.e. trying to change the bellows direction, as far as possible, in connection with a chord change in the harmonic progression -, is just one side of the coin.

If we do not consider at the same time the different articulations we use to play the melody with the right hand what happens is that we can't see the forest for the trees. Between the staccato and the legato there is the portato, or mezzo staccato, and beyond the legato there is the legatissimo – i.e. letting the attacks of some of the notes overlap with the tail of the preceding ones. The way we mix the different articulations has an impact on the rhythm that's often more relevant that the one of the bellows inversion.

Well said.

 
Quote
Well, those who are familiar with economics probably knows that the answer to this question lies in  the Gresham's law!  ;)

I'm a Gresham on my mother's side...

Bottom line is technique serves the music...not t'other way 'round.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Dick Rees on December 12, 2024, 03:35:30 PM
And don't forget air management/bellows technique which factor into attack, dynamics and all other components of the music.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 12, 2024, 03:56:47 PM

   Ours is a weird instrument, and playing it is more a "craft" than an exercise in logic.  Here's another legend, Tony Hall. 

   I don't think he ever had a melodeon lesson from anyone, and the "where" he sticks his fingers … is still a mystery to many of us.

   Flowers of Edinburgh:   https://youtu.be/FLJ33Xmj2Sw   it's 27 minutes into the concert, but see also his technique with song.

   Tony's cartoons:  https://youtu.be/6P5KZx6dkb4   (he did some naughty ones too). 
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 12, 2024, 04:14:14 PM

   Here's a set of brief teaching videos by 2 french copins of mine. Totally on the G and C rows of a French melodeon. Nice demo of the "little triangles" and some real music in the 3rd video.  Same rule applies. Blues scale is a ½-tone flat of "main inner" = C scale. So they're in B (Si)Blues  - but the technique, and fingering are exactly the same.

      Basic  https://youtu.be/XnuAcQEKNKc
   Phrases  https://youtu.be/SV53eakGdZI
     Music   https://youtu.be/heu_8bvjihU

  Easy backing tracks for F# major, and minor Blues (i.e. our keys) [edit]
   F#          https://youtu.be/cZRUXNRfAAo
   F#m       https://youtu.be/UWvtvLfTcGI
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 12, 2024, 05:04:20 PM
I've watched that Tony Hall concert a couple of times; I like his style. And nary a lesson, eh? Well I never.......
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 12, 2024, 06:57:28 PM
I think the title of your post sums up your position accurately - this is a beginner's perspective and one that is unlikely to be shared by anyone who has spent serious time with the instrument.

The instrument you have is a two row eight bass melodeon - it is not simply two one row boxes stuck together, this seems to be how you are currently conceptualising it. You freely admit to not having really considered chords, but such considerations are fundamental to decisions about playing approach, phrasing, row and direction and therefore to the discussion you have initiated.

Equally, the choice of cross-row or on-the-row playing is not as simple as the either/or choice you outline. This narrow view leaves no room for the subtleties made possible by combination of approach – for example a quick bellows flick to emphasise a note, or the dynamic effects possible in switching both row and direction at the same time, not to mention the interest that is added for both player in listener in varying the way you play a given phrase.

One of the joys of melodeon playing is that there is no right and wrong, equally it is an instrument that is very easy to play badly. It is also an instrument that repays study, experimentation and an open mind.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 12, 2024, 06:58:47 PM
Ha! I need to sort myself out first  ;D

Nah, just come back out to play as the glorious Rees we all knew before your enforced break. 

Hope to see you for tunes on the festival circuit.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Bill_S on December 12, 2024, 07:25:57 PM
Quote from: Helena Handcart
I think the title of your post sums up your position accurately - this is a beginner's perspective...

Absolutely right, Helena. That's precisely why I titled it as such.

My original post was more about how starting to cross-row made me feel, personally. OK, I may be guilty of an amount of provocation, and I realise that this is a touchy subject amongst the "experienced practitioners", but I'm not for one minute seriously suggesting that people shouldn't cross the rows or that it's an inferior way of playing - that's just daft.

Yeah, I did start thinking in terms of it being two one rows, but that's natural, I think. I'm working on a piece now with more complex left hand stuff and a little cross rowing. It's all good.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Dick Rees on December 12, 2024, 07:55:30 PM
There are several dichotomies to consider.  Among them are LH/RH, inside row/outside row, push/pull and...instrument/music. 

If you know the music, then the path to facility with the instrument is much clearer.  Accordingly, time spent in purposeful, focused listening will help sort things.  I recommend a temporal ratio of 10:1 between listening and practice for at least the first 2-5 years. 
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Toby B on December 13, 2024, 10:03:35 AM
I'm minded to think cross-rowing is everything but cheating, on the contrary, it appears to be the "advanced" option.

I've only a few weeks and the (excellent!) Wolvercote w/e playing ... and the melody only on a single row (except for the E4 drop from the G) seems to be the easiest option ... which when convincing yourself of your progress might be "cheating" (or kidding) yourself. I am contemplating cross-rowing as advanced stuff, for the options of a smoother rather than bumpy melody, or the much more daunting (for me, at the moment!) of getting my left hand bring the bass in ...
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 13, 2024, 10:20:11 AM
Toby, bringing in your left hand might be daunting but really work on it.
You'll find out that the choice of chord dictates whether you're pushing or pulling.
Therefore that in turn dictates whether that melody note you play is either on the push or on the pull, and in turn which row that note lies on.
That's the point, cross rowing lets you access the right bass/chord for that melody note, wherever it is on a row.

The left hand basses are a 'barn door syndrome'.
It's difficult to open, but once opened you've cracked it and got access to tune accompniment.
Keep bashing away, it will come!
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 13, 2024, 10:48:24 AM
I'm minded to think cross-rowing is everything but cheating, on the contrary, it appears to be the "advanced" option.

Hi Toby, glad you enjoyed the weekend at Wolvercote. I thought it was excellent, but then I may be a teeny bit biased.

It sounds like you are making excellent progress, keep up the good work. Certainly in the early days it is more 'advanced' to begin thinking about bringing in some cross-rowing to accommodate desired chords, however I really don't  believe cross-row playing represents a more 'advanced style' of play.

For me, the secret lies in knowing when to blend playing style. I think of 'advanced' playing as the ability to play on or across the rows with little audible difference - so playing smoothly on the row or playing a cross-row phrase but keeping it choppy. Brian Peters introduced me to the latter concept when I had been playing for just a few months, fair blew my mind at the time but it was very useful advice, even if it took me some time to get my head (and fingers) around.



Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: GBbox on December 13, 2024, 11:16:24 AM

You'll find out that the choice of chord dictates whether you're pushing or pulling.
Therefore that in turn dictates whether that melody note you play is either on the push or on the pull, and in turn which row that note lies on.
That's the point, cross rowing lets you access the right bass/chord for that melody note, wherever it is on a row.


Correct... in general. But don't forget that the opposite might be true as well, and that sometimes are the notes you play with your right hand that dictate the chords you use.

For instance, playing in G on a D/G box means that if you play a C or an E note in a bar that clearly requires a G chord – i.e. the tonic -, you have to find a substitution for it, because they are both pull only while the G chord is push only. Or you have to use a bass in place of the chord.

Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 13, 2024, 11:30:21 AM

   I think that it's the "blending" that's advanced!  In Britain, we mostly start on the row, fitting initially 2, then 3 chords to that. And as C is "both ways" it's not rocket science?

   French kids (plenty of melodeon classes in local music schools) are taught that music has a basis of chords, and how to cross-row a melody against those.

  Over in Ireland kids set off on B/C, C/C# or even C#/D kit, generally ignore the left end, focussing on tune, rhythm and decorations.

   These approaches all work! So none is in any way "advanced" you've just learned things in a different order.

   I went the British route (having done Anglo concertina). Started on the G row. Then D, then Em on the pull, then blending Em into G tunes to help fill my bellows. Then realising that the 2 seemingly identical Em's were different! (One has C# as you run a phrase through it, the other C natural). 

    Then exploring mixolydian tunes … Playing in D on the pull, or in A.  Then struggling to get some rhythm into cross rowed tunes (eg bellows tugs, stacatto attack, or accents borrowed from Irish styles.  And I was still breathing in and out with my bellows!! 🥵

   There's no "cheating".  No "right way".  It's a journey, in which you absorb a whole gamut of little workarounds and learn to blend them seamlessly.
Title: Re: Cross-rowing is cheating - a beginner's perspective.
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 13, 2024, 01:35:11 PM
GBbox: yes you're right 'in general' is what I meant.

Toby: sounds like you had an excellent tutor  ;)
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal