Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on December 07, 2009, 03:25:23 PM
-
Anyone familiar with this 2 book series on how to play the button accordion? He's a PA accordion player and musicologist with the Chicago Conservatory. This is the first I've run across his books.
http://www.amazon.com/How-Play-Button-Accordion-CD/dp/1585609722/ref=sr_1_4?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1260199385&sr=8-4
-
I saw it read it and placed it back in the rack.
-
Hi - I've purchased some of his music from him - he's without doubt an outstanding accordionist. I would take anything he says seriously concerning the PA. However I've not come across these books.
AL
-
He seems very qualified, but I play mostly by ear so I'm hesitant to purchase something like these books. My interest in these books is the part about playing Basses, however I'm sure he does not cover any of the alternative bass setups like Burke or McComiskey, I have a feeling that his emphasis is on the more G/C, C/F tunings.
-
if you are interested in basses on the b/c you should check out
Damien Connolly. He's come out with a book and dvd which
I find very helpful.
-
Have it and will be looking at it. He uses his own box tab which takes getting used to. Very helpful fingering guide also on his DVD. However he only goes over the Basses as they pertain the few songs in the book. Still a very good system IMHO.
-
I also have Damien Connolly's book and DVD.
To put it simply.. I have "issues" with the book and the DVD
He is no doubt a very fine player, but I find the book poorly "produced", written and misdirected.
The tab is only half a system.. unlike the CADB which has existed for years and is a stand alone system.
The color system is convoluted and unnecessary in my opinion.
One might say the book is intended to be used as a tutorial WITH and instructor.. if that is the case,
the book has limited value.
Had I seen the book before purchase I would have passed on it.
It is near painful to read.
-
I also have Damien Connolly's book and DVD.
To put it simply.. I have "issues" with the book and the DVD
He is no doubt a very fine player, but I find the book poorly "produced", written and misdirected.
The tab is only half a system.. unlike the CADB which has existed for years and is a stand alone system.
The color system is convoluted and unnecessary in my opinion.
One might say the book is intended to be used as a tutorial WITH and instructor.. if that is the case,
the book has limited value.
Had I seen the book before purchase I would have passed on it.
It is near painful to read.
After attempting to use the system I have found it to be difficult and not very user friendly, particularly to the ear learner. It's also definitely not for a beginning player. I agree about his "box tab" being cumbersome and hard to decipher also way too much going on there. I pity the player who doesn't have a teacher around and attempts to learn with any of the current systems around and that included John Williams and the Hanrahan system. I ordered all three and found them to not be helpful at all. Hanrahan assumes from the start that everyone can read music. Williams assumes from the start that everyone can listen to lightening speed examples of scales and tunes and learn them. In my opinion the only way I could learn personally as a complete newbie was to get a teacher and through a lot of handholding (figurative) learn the notes and fingering of each song I learn. Now as I progress I can use my slowdown software and video I take of my teacher playing to learn each new tune. As I progress I find I am learning which note goes with which bellows movement and which button. I'm sure some people learned quite well on some of these systems but they were all a waste of time and money for me personally. As said befoere in another thread everyone learns differently and I happen to be a Kinetic/Aural/Repition learner. I also can't learn something this complex without someone showing me how. Of course I'm an old man of 48 so maybe that has something to do with it also.
-
I still like the Connolly book. I can read music and have played various other squeeze boxes--at a reasonably limited level--but when I bought the Connolly I was quite new at the BC and didn't have a real teacher--I had had some lessons from a C#D player. For me, anyway, the Connolly has been very helpful and very clear. I found the basses stuff helped with the few tunes in the book and also gave me a start at one way of approaching other basses. The section on ornaments seems very clear to me. I find the DVD very clear. Having said that, I haven't even looked at the tab and colour charts other than to note that they exist, so if you don't play from "the dots" it might not be as useful.
-
For me the best way to learn, not having a teacher, is to look and listen to youtube. I can read music very slowly and over the years I've played other instruments so perhaps I already had a leg-up. I pick a tune I like, say "Lament for Limerick" since I was born and raised there, and learn to play it in a few different keys. I've been playing for three months and compared to classical guitar the melodion is way easier to learn. Plus, with lots of other instruments just missing one day of practice becomes a mini disaster. Still, I'm pushing 70 and the ould brain is banjaxed. If I'd only started as a kid....