Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Al Cramer on December 23, 2024, 10:40:58 PM

Title: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Al Cramer on December 23, 2024, 10:40:58 PM
Have been following with interest the discussion about Playford & music history. I've messed around with his tunes on classical guitar, and am wondering: could you play his tunes on a CF club system? I get that the chords might be iffy; also stuff that wanted more than 1 flat or 3 sharps probably wouldn't work.  But given these restrictions, could you do  a vaguely credible job with a CF club?
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Theo on December 23, 2024, 10:47:29 PM
The tunes are quite varied, some are  playable in a two row, more on a club system, sometime you will need to transpose the tune to suit your keys.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on December 23, 2024, 10:56:47 PM
It is all playable on a club system, in the written keys too, but with some transposing you will be able to add at least some basses
Whether it's worth it is another matter. I'd transpose into a sensible key first as I don't see any merit in making life difficult.
I've moved tunes from Bb to G so the gurdy can play along.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: GBbox on December 24, 2024, 02:30:18 PM
I've learned just a few Playford tunes along the years, but relying on my own limited experience I agree with Theo: some tunes fit the two row instruments pretty well, and some require accidentals and chord progressions that better fit on more flexible instruments. And yes, transposing is an option!

The first of the three I still play today is The New Bourrée or The Indian Queen . 9th edition -, and I I still play it like I first learned in D on the D/G box without transposing. I picked it up from the paper without having previously heard it – no Internet in those days! - from the Jeremy Barlow's The Complete Dancing Master. What had tickled my fancy, although I generally use its alternative title, was the term bourrée, and if I had to play it at a ball folk, using the standard French pattern for the deux temps bourrée, the dancers would go bananas. Also, it has a gorgeous renaissance feeling – I can't help thinking to some of my favourite recordings of the David Munrow's Early Music Consort when I play it!

The second is Portsmouth -11th edition -, in G like in print, that I am sure (almost) everybody here knows well.

The third is Old Marrinet or Moll Peatly (the new way) - Second supplement to the 3rd edition, with  variants in later editions -, that I first heard on one of the Pyewackett's records. An odd tune that's written in F, with a first part that I have heard convincingly played by a period consort on YouTube over a D minor drone, and an irregular 10 bar second part with the sharpened 7th degree of the harmonic minor scale. I've experimented with on both the A/D/G and my 2 1/2 row G/C, trying different keys and different reed combinations, to find both a satisfactory pitch range and a convincing harmonic progression.  I've ended up laying it without transposing on my G/C 2 ½ row box.

Different tunes may require different approaches, and eventually different instruments...


Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Al Cramer on December 24, 2024, 10:33:48 PM
Just wanted to thanks the people who posted!

I like early music and play a few Couperin & Bach pieces that would sound fabulous on the box. But they would require the chromatic notes of the club system, and I'm a long away from facility with the quints, so guess I'll stick with slip jigs and reels for now.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Steve C. on December 25, 2024, 01:02:11 PM
Al, don't be discouraged; there are a lot of Playford easy to play on 2 rows.  Might have to go easy on the chords.  There's always right hand chording every once and a while.  Or "double stopping" on the right hand to give it that harmonic feeling.
--Steve
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: howard mitchell on December 27, 2024, 03:29:18 PM
Might be difficult to find a copy but you could try  https://pjmusic.co.uk/push-pull-playford-with-cd-tony-battilana/ (https://pjmusic.co.uk/push-pull-playford-with-cd-tony-battilana/)

I might have a spare copy, need to check.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Al Cramer on December 28, 2024, 12:59:15 AM
Howard, that book looks very interesting: many thanks for the link.

For now I'm using the tunes as published at this site:

https://playforddances.com/

They're really good for where I'm at as a beginner at the box(am only studying the ones in Gmaj, Dmaj, and Dmin). The tunes are simple enough that it's pretty easy to figure an ok harmony, but training my hands to do the right thing automatically is taking a lot of time.

(When I said the tunes were simple, I didn't mean to disparage them: am somewhat amazed at how strong & good they are! And some really aren't that simple. Am coming from a Celtic music background, and have to say I never properly understood how interesting old  English tunes can be.)

Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Arnold on December 28, 2024, 09:32:34 AM
Playford tunes are generally quite simple on paper. However, in so far as they correspond with other music of the time, the dots are only a shorthand to be interpreted by the musician, who will add melodic decoration, ornamentation etc (so in a way similar to ITM except with different conventions…)

The tunes I’ve looked at myself only require simple harmonisation, and transposition is probably satisfactory 9/10 times if playing solo. It’s the minor tunes that sometimes transpose less readily, since there is only one minor key to transpose to (when playing two handed on a standard 8 bass). There are also tunes in minor keys that utilise the harmonic minor scale, and to make this work on a C/F Club, the C# note would be better on the push to match the A major chord.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Anahata on December 28, 2024, 12:23:49 PM
I'm don't understand sure what the relevance of the Club system is in all of this.

The Club system, compared with the common two row systems with accidentals, gives you:
- one button that plays the same note in both directions.
- A half row with maybe more buttons that play accidentals (2, 4, and 7 are common numbers for these)
- one more chord/bass. On a C/F box that's an Eâ™­

It's no more "fully chromatic" than a standard 2 row or 2.5 row D/G with accidentals. As someone mentioned above, if you really want to play Playford in all the correct keys you need a semitone box like a B /C, but you won't have the chords for most of them.

As for Playford on a standard melodeon, some tunes are simple major scale scale tune with no accidentals and could be played on a 1 row box, many more on a standard
two row.
Some Playford tunes are in minor keys and need a sharp leading note, and for that i find these properties useful:
- stop to cut out thirds in LH chords
- D♯  (on a D/G) or C♯ (on a C/F) of push so they fit B or A bass/chord (as mentioned above) for Emin or Dmin tunes
- G♯ (on a D/G) or F♯ (on a C/F) on pull to go with E or D bass for Amin or Gmin tunes
A standard Club layout doesn't help you with any of those.

Incidentally, this link will take you a list of YT videos I've done that feature Playford tunes (not 100% reliable, but they all have "Playford" in the description!
Some take advantage of the "minor key" features listed above. It might be useful to someone.
https://www.maryanahata.co.uk/music.php?search=playford&action=searchresult
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 28, 2024, 12:39:44 PM

   FYI Anahata I get "untrusted" on that link. I just ploughed ahead of course. (I trust you, even though my browser doesn't) 😉
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Anahata on December 28, 2024, 01:36:26 PM
   I get "untrusted" on that link.
I got that too. My browser said the SSL certificate expired yesterday. The server says it expires on 2025-02-25, so it has updated, but but both Firefox and Chrome seem a bit slow in catching up today!
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Matthew B on December 28, 2024, 03:00:40 PM
Chris Parkinson has a delightful version of Mr Isaac's Maggot, which I believe is a Playford tune, that he knocks out on a two-row.  I don't know how true it is to the written tune, but I love the way it sounds.:
https://soundcloud.com/chrisparkinson-music/mr-isaacs-maggot (https://soundcloud.com/chrisparkinson-music/mr-isaacs-maggot)
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Anahata on December 28, 2024, 03:23:27 PM
Chris Parkinson has a delightful version of Mr Isaac's Maggot, which I believe is a Playford tune, that he knocks out on a two-row.  I don't know how true it is to the written tune, but I love the way it sounds.:
https://soundcloud.com/chrisparkinson-music/mr-isaacs-maggot (https://soundcloud.com/chrisparkinson-music/mr-isaacs-maggot)

Parky's one of the best melodeon players I've heard, but I'm pretty sure that's played on a PA (which he also plays v. well!)
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: rees on December 28, 2024, 04:57:37 PM
Yes, pretty sure Parky is on the piano box there.
Here's Will Allen on melodeon.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYGNUZccPqY (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYGNUZccPqY)
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Arnold on December 28, 2024, 07:04:50 PM
Keeping in the spirit of the thread title, I think it’s worth exploring what the Club system specifically has to offer in this context, although yes many of the tunes can be played effectively on a standard 8 bass…

Whilst it’s technically correct that you only get one extra bass/chord, this is selling the Club system short somewhat, since what this actually offers you is an entire new key, which opens up more options for transposition, and also for modulation within a tune…

If you have an accidentals row that extends beyond 4 buttons, you also get the C# and Eb in the lower octave. I only looked as far as tunes beginning with ‘A’, and came across the tune ‘Astrope Wells’ which has both C#s. They are in the wrong direction of course! Hohner could have designed the Club system to have C# and Eb as both push and pull, but instead opted to have the complete F major scale available in the push (separate discussion :Ph …) They weren’t intending the boxes to be used for Playford mind…
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Anahata on December 28, 2024, 07:11:50 PM
   FYI Anahata I get "untrusted" on that link.

It turns out there was a configuration problem for that site on my server. I think I've fixed it now.
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 29, 2024, 10:48:03 AM

   Are we coming to the conclusion that (fancy/advanced) Playford benefits most from an extended bass?

   I'd throw in that some D/G club systems have C/F buttons on the left, rather than C/C's
Title: Re: Play Playford on a club system?
Post by: Anahata on December 29, 2024, 12:13:40 PM
   I'd throw in that some D/G club systems have C/F buttons on the left, rather than C/C's

Yes, it's a standard part of the Club system. That F is equivalent to the E flat bass on a C/F Club that I mentioned above.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal