Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 11:23:51 AM

Title: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 11:23:51 AM
I was watching this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3SU9FNhHPw) and noticed that Monsieur Poutoux's melodeon has been modified from a two row to a one row. It also looks like the bass end has been reduced to two buttons.

I'm wondering why someone would do this? Other than just liking the particular box and being a one row player, therefore converting it.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 26, 2024, 12:36:13 PM
The question:

 
I'm wondering why someone would do this?

The answer:

Quote
...just liking the particular box and being a one row player, therefore converting it.

Here's a link to a site containing examples of the particular type/style of box which Gilles sought:

https://youtube.com/@mr.button_it?si=ff_rTPsXSh-bFrBM

Classified roughly as Irish American...

I believe forum member Squeaky Pete has assembled such a 6-voice box and might explain more about the "why".
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: kenakordeon on December 26, 2024, 12:45:56 PM
Thanks for posting the video of Gilles Poutoux. I have often thought of converting a two-row into a 1 row plus 4-5 buttons on the inner row. I don't have the skills to do it my self but nice to see it can be done successfully. Laurent Jarry is a master craftsman and certainly has the skills to do the conversion. If I lived in Europe I would consider having him do one for me. Especially one with the additional sets of reeds.

https://www.accordina.com/
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 26, 2024, 01:06:34 PM

    That's basically a Calabrian organetto. 1-row+2 is quite common Mine was 1-row+4 with the inner row all reversed scale

    I used to describe it as being in G, and G.   Great Morris box! 

   If you're thinking of e.g a D row with 5 residual G row buttons … that's a different sort of instrument. A choice. They all "work".
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 01:14:04 PM
Are you sure that's the right link, Dick?

OK Chris, now you've confused me.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 26, 2024, 01:22:17 PM
Are you sure that's the right link, Dick?

100%

Try watching the videos.  He has a lot of 6v boxes and classifies them as "Ballroom" accordions...for reasons which should be obvious.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Stiamh on December 26, 2024, 02:08:32 PM
A long time ago I decided that multi-voice one-row instruments are more fun to play than they are to listen to.

It would be difficult to provide more convincing evidence in support of my contention than by learning a wistful Irish tune from the sensitive fiddle playing of Martin Hayes and turning it into... that.  >:E
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 02:42:18 PM
Right, by piecing the cryptic information in this thread together, I've arrived at the simple answer that I was after - the reason to convert a 2 row into a 1 row is if you want more than 4 voices.

I assume that's what Monsieur Poutoux has done in the video in my original link.

Other than that, my very limited knowledge and experience of melodeons doesn't allow me to comment further with regard to suitability for genres etc, although I get what you're saying, Stiamh.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 02:54:41 PM
Although, I could've read the description in Gilles' YouTube video in the first place.... Hahaha!

It is Christmas... All the mince pies have gone to my head.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Squeaky Pete on December 26, 2024, 03:04:46 PM
Yes, I did much the same as Gilles.
The treble end was replaced by a redundant pokerwork treble carcass and a new fondo fitted.
There was room for 3 reedblocks so I was able to fit 6 voices, same as the box in the video.
It can play very loudly, but really it's to give a fuller sound than a standard 4 stop . And if you've got 6 voices, why would you turn some of them off?  So I didn't bother with stops either, less to go wrong.
I made a little series on YouTube if you want to follow the construction.
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLsYCMe7pL75HFEeZaebiDquIxk9JEg4Ic&si=yORxV9LSuQoWfOzx
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 03:23:36 PM
Brilliant, thanks Pete.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: tirpous on December 26, 2024, 03:57:12 PM
Quote
And if you've got 6 voices, why would you turn some of them off?

The old Irish-American boxes made by Baldoni Bartoli, Walters and others often had registers to turn off the low (L) voices.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 26, 2024, 04:38:19 PM
Full sound.

Here's an 8v box.  Pretty much sounds like a carousel band organ.

https://youtu.be/UnEq6iTahzs?si=Hm-ExZEPvQJ_eSDy

6v box

https://youtu.be/6fOAI-kLHOo?si=FN3LpD7TVv0DiEdf
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 26, 2024, 04:51:25 PM
I mean, 8 voice?! Where is the point of diminishing returns?

That does sound kinda odd; Irish music coming out of a fairground organ.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 26, 2024, 05:32:02 PM
Where is the point of diminishing returns?

Any answer to a rhetorical question.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Lars on December 26, 2024, 10:57:02 PM
https://youtu.be/fi0D6M-mJPk?si=i-SckZZQE9BQD3E6

I like 6 voice one rows, but they take a different approach than almost any other type of box IMO. If you like to play Clare-style (not overly fast, and smooth rhythm) like Martin Hayes as mentioned above, they're not that suited. But if you like rhythmic playing like some players recording in the US in the 20s and 30s, they're great. They can cut through the mix and be super loud, but even played softer, they have a 'push' and a full sound it's hard to get from almost any other kind of box.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 27, 2024, 08:03:01 AM
Sounds like a mash up of Irish and trad jazz, especially with the tenor banjo being played the way it is.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: CAB on December 27, 2024, 11:01:58 AM
Sounds like a mash up of Irish and trad jazz, especially with the tenor banjo being played the way it is.

Yup, pretty much that.  It was the Irish response to the big dance hall bands that were becoming popular in American cities.  They needed to be loud in the absence of PA.  You can still see their influence in many modern Irish ceilidh bands, who often use drums and/or piano.  The boxes had to compete with saxophone etc. so the more voices (and tremolo?) the better!
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 27, 2024, 11:11:49 AM
Ah yes, the pre-amplification era volume arms race, or PAEVARâ„¢ for short.

I presume that's the main driver for these 6 voice boxes.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 27, 2024, 12:31:52 PM
Speaking as both musician and audio technician , instrumental volume level is only one of many factors in audibility. 
  Clarity, fidelity and frequency range/spectrum are equal to or more important than sheer loudness.

Forums such as this one field requests for information on a variety of topics.  They also get requests to validate opinions and endless WAG's. ..

Guess again.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 27, 2024, 01:17:40 PM
Nah, i'm good.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 27, 2024, 01:21:01 PM
https://www.musicalmum.com/how-do-musical-instruments-make-sound/
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: tirpous on December 27, 2024, 04:51:53 PM
Quote
Speaking as both musician and audio technician , instrumental volume level is only one of many factors in audibility.
  Clarity, fidelity and frequency range/spectrum are equal to or more important than sheer loudness.

In the specific case of accordions/melodeons, I think we can also add tremolo (voice offset) to the list of factors. 
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: rees on December 27, 2024, 05:29:08 PM
*WAG - wild ass guess.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 27, 2024, 07:22:55 PM
Quote
Speaking as both musician and audio technician , instrumental volume level is only one of many factors in audibility.
  Clarity, fidelity and frequency range/spectrum are equal to or more important than sheer loudness.

In the specific case of accordions/melodeons, I think we can also add tremolo (voice offset) to the list of factors.

This might come under the heading of clarity...or coherence.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 27, 2024, 08:01:59 PM


  In sound (or light) wave terms, multiple close but a few cents away in "incoherence"

  Totally dry tuned reeds are coherent.

 
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 28, 2024, 07:39:36 AM
Quote from: Squeaky Pete
I made a little series on YouTube if you want to follow the construction.

That was fascinating, not least because I'd no real idea how a box worked on the inside.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: -Y- on December 28, 2024, 10:14:14 AM
A long time ago I decided that multi-voice one-row instruments are more fun to play than they are to listen to.

It would be difficult to provide more convincing evidence in support of my contention than by learning a wistful Irish tune from the sensitive fiddle playing of Martin Hayes and turning it into... that.  >:E

What do yo mean by multi-voice one-row? Would a 2-voice fit in that category? What do you make of old MMH one-row that were used in North America?
I understand that they're much fun to play with, and that you have to be careful (or chose the register carefully) in order to not take all the space but its quintessential nature can lead to magnificient phrasing, and truly wonderful playing. Thinking of the Connollys, or Frank Sears, which are, imho, very fine and subtile players. For irish-american instruments one could also think of Dany O'Mahony that does wonders with that Tom Carmody box!
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Stiamh on December 28, 2024, 09:27:49 PM
A long time ago I decided that multi-voice one-row instruments are more fun to play than they are to listen to.

It would be difficult to provide more convincing evidence in support of my contention than by learning a wistful Irish tune from the sensitive fiddle playing of Martin Hayes and turning it into... that.  >:E

What do yo mean by multi-voice one-row? Would a 2-voice fit in that category? What do you make of old MMH one-row that were used in North America?

My post was a bit of a wind-up, -Y-. I meant 4 or more voices, really. I don't want to get into an argument about the merits of various setups or various players.

I habitually say that 4-v one rows are "more fun to play than to listen to" because, yes, I have had fun playing them (although I've never owned one), but I quickly get bored listening to them, and I am far from being the only fiddle player in Québec who doesn't much care to have a powerful player of one sitting next to me.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: tirpous on December 29, 2024, 07:15:53 PM
Quote
I habitually say that 4-v one rows are "more fun to play than to listen to" because, yes, I have had fun playing them (although I've never owned one), but I quickly get bored listening to them, and I am far from being the only fiddle player in Québec who doesn't much care to have a powerful player of one sitting next to me.

Ah yes, some one-row players only like to play loud, and louder, AND LOUDER !!  (:)

But in all fairness, I think the blame should be on the players, not the box. Less noise can be more music.

Just a few days ago this video of a box-fiddle duet appeared on Facebook. It seems to be an ambient recording (no close miking in sight), and fiddler Andrew Caden can be heard fairly well even if Ryan Sheridan plays a big bad 6-voice Globe Gold Medal Professional. Violin not drowning the box by any stretch of the imagination, but to my ear they're playing together, not against each other.

https://www.facebook.com/ryan.sheridan.94801/videos/1010926184111743 (https://www.facebook.com/ryan.sheridan.94801/videos/1010926184111743)
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 29, 2024, 07:21:49 PM
And on YouTube:

https://youtu.be/B2fiL_WtflA?si=sWNmmNjpY9vI6bAf

Of interest:  both instruments belonged to James Morrison who recorded this set of jigs in 1936.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Squeaky Pete on December 29, 2024, 07:56:56 PM
For one tune we play, I move from bassoon to the 6 voice box to thicken up the sound. So there's 9 melodeon reeds chuntering away while Will is playing an Anglo. The balance is fine.
But if I wanted I could drown out anybody at a session.
It's just a versatile box.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 29, 2024, 08:07:01 PM
I don't mind the number of voices in play, but I draw the line at 3 players...and preferably no guitars.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 29, 2024, 08:47:30 PM
Thanks for the Youtube link Dick.
Not normally my cup of tea, but... yes two fine young players, an enjoyable watch.
A lesson for melodeon players too, an almost imperceptible flick of the bellows gives a noticeable pulse and emphasis to the music.
Good stuff.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 29, 2024, 09:17:50 PM
I don't mind the number of voices in play, but I draw the line at 3 players...and preferably no guitars.
  The nice thing about a {collective noun of your choice} of guitars, is that they are predictable.  Folk music is always in G. Blues in E.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 29, 2024, 09:29:02 PM
I don't mind the number of voices in play, but I draw the line at 3 players...and preferably no guitars.
  The nice thing about a {collective noun of your choice} of guitars, is that they are predictable.  Folk music is always in G. Blues in E.

Battery?
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 29, 2024, 09:32:27 PM
a 'chop' of guitars? One at my session seems to play in a very percussive way.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: tirpous on December 29, 2024, 09:43:33 PM
Quote
And on YouTube:

https://youtu.be/B2fiL_WtflA?si=sWNmmNjpY9vI6bAf

Of interest:  both instruments belonged to James Morrison who recorded this set of jigs in 1936.

Thanks for that, I had a quick look on YT but could not find it. Interesting thing is it's a different recording of the same performance, but the same comments apply wrt fiddle/box balance.

And indeed, despite the casual setting and (I assume) phone recordings, this is a well-informed performance.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Arnold on December 30, 2024, 09:54:39 AM
Ego is often the problem when it comes to loudness. In a session, many people want to be heard over everyone else rather than accepting their place as a tenth or whatever fraction of the overall sound. Certain instruments are more enabling in this respect than others, amongst them one rows and various Italian boxes.   

There are also limitations of the instrument to consider. Guitarists often get a bad rap for bashing  away at questionable choices of chords, but a melodeonist to and froing on the row basically ruins any opportunities for chord players to put a coherent chord progression together.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 30, 2024, 10:40:50 AM
... and both groups bringing the speed up to 'their' speed.
Dominant loudness incorporated with speed can destroy a session.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 30, 2024, 11:12:21 AM
Quote from: Arnold
...but a melodeonist to and froing on the row basically ruins any opportunities for chord players to put a coherent chord progression together.

Yo Arnold, (or anyone else), can you explain this a bit more for me? Just thinking about when I accompany a harmonica player (who plays straight melody), it's easy enough. If the box player isn't playing the left hand, how does this effect what chords others play? Am I missing something?
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Lester on December 30, 2024, 11:34:14 AM
Quote from: Arnold
...but a melodeonist to and froing on the row basically ruins any opportunities for chord players to put a coherent chord progression together.

Yo Arnold, (or anyone else), can you explain this a bit more for me? Just thinking about when I accompany a harmonica player (who plays straight melody), it's easy enough. If the box player isn't playing the left hand, how does this effect what chords others play? Am I missing something?
Think he was refering to on the row players playing the 3 chord trick and missing out opportunities for Cdim7 chords :)
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 30, 2024, 11:47:17 AM
As we've often said there are many ways to play a tune. Players will often change or vary their chord selection as they progress the tune.
If someone is playing loudly in a particular way it can stifle any others' attempts at subtle variation... like denying Lester his Cdim 7 opportunity  ;)
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: CAB on December 30, 2024, 12:01:33 PM
To state the obvious, because the chord changes with the bellows it's often impossible to play a coherent chord sequence while playing completely along the row... unless you play the left hand more sparingly, hitting the bass or chord only when it fits.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 30, 2024, 12:09:55 PM

   For the uninitiated … a dim7 chord is the 7th one that you can make taking alternate notes of our diatonic scale.

   In the scale of C note 7 = B. … its C chord is simple … C,E,G "C" or "C triad".  And note 7 of the scale is CDEFGAB

   So we need to look on a different row. C# does the trick. note 7 there is C

   And it's pretty easy. Grab a C# row. Stick four fingers on for adjacent buttons and pull. Easy as that!

   Same trick on your G row => F#dim7.  Is it any use though? 🤔 Actually … yes.

   F#dim7 (as above)
       B7 (needs your Eb acc, or just substitute Bpush on left end 👍
           Em (3 fingers on D row and pull)

  You've just done a classic ii V i chord progression 😎  On a melodeon 👍


 
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: rees on December 30, 2024, 12:33:56 PM
Well, that really simplifies things for Bill, Chris!!!
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Arnold on December 30, 2024, 12:45:15 PM
Quote from: Arnold
...but a melodeonist to and froing on the row basically ruins any opportunities for chord players to put a coherent chord progression together.

Yo Arnold, (or anyone else), can you explain this a bit more for me? Just thinking about when I accompany a harmonica player (who plays straight melody), it's easy enough. If the box player isn't playing the left hand, how does this effect what chords others play? Am I missing something?

Sure, say for example you’re playing in G along the row, with your left hand on the G/D bass/chord... Every time you hit the D note you get a G chord, when sometimes a D chord would be preferable. You could switch to the D/A bass/chord in this instance, but how many melodeonists do this in practice? Not many in my experience!.. I normally play strummy things at sessions and I have tried tracking this random back and forth between G and D chords, but it is virtually impossible, so I end up sitting out... It isn’t anything to do with fancy chords…
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Anahata on December 30, 2024, 01:51:28 PM
To state the obvious, because the chord changes with the bellows it's often impossible to play a coherent chord sequence while playing completely along the row... unless you play the left hand more sparingly, hitting the bass or chord only when it fits.

Well yes, holding down the bass and chord button while waggling your way up a scale on one row is a very bad habit to get into. I suspect morris musicians trying to make as much noise as possible at any cost in order to be heard when playing outside.
It's not hard to make those gaps in the LH, and should make the rhythm more percussive and precise.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 30, 2024, 02:25:28 PM
Well, that really simplifies things for Bill, Chris!!!

 ;D
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 30, 2024, 02:42:21 PM
Quote from: rees
Well, that really simplifies things for Bill, Chris!!!

Yeah, clear as the proverbial. It's irrelevant to my question anyway.

So, I understand that if the box is playing on the row and a thoughtless left hand, that makes things difficult for a chordal accompaniment. However, as per my question, if the box player leaves off the left hand it makes no odds.

When playing with guitars/bouzoukis etc, why play the left hand anyway, unless you're looking for a specific effect. Is it not better to leave space for the chordal instruments to do their thang?
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: rees on December 30, 2024, 03:12:05 PM
Quote from: rees
Well, that really simplifies things for Bill, Chris!!!

When playing with guitars/bouzoukis etc, why play the left hand anyway, unless you're looking for a specific effect. Is it not better to leave space for the chordal instruments to do their thang?

Very good point. When playing with Joe Le Taxi which has guitar (sometimes two) and bass guitar, I very rarely use the left hand basses.
This frees up the backline to be as inventive as they wish. They're playing chords I've never even heard of!
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 30, 2024, 03:19:30 PM
Ah Rees has replied whilst I was typing.

Yes in a band there's reasons for leaving off the left  as others can take their part but  ... in my session often the Guitar/twangy thing frequently plays melody not just chord accompaniment where I play so I always play a left hand.

Yes leaving off your left hand is one way, though spending countless hours building relationships between them makes it feel odd.
I tend to learn tunes through building up my left hand accompaniment. In a session if I don't know the tune I often quietly let my left hand just twiddle through chords then find the melody easier to pin down.

There are no hard and fast rules about any of this, it's often reacting to things on the fly.
Plus, if you've started a tune then the etiquette is its 'your tune'. People should follow your lead in the way you like to play it so others shouldn't blast their accompaniment across it, or speed up etc.
Though sadly it doesn't always follow that people play sympathetically  ::)
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Mike Hirst on December 30, 2024, 03:59:59 PM
When playing with guitars/bouzoukis etc, why play the left hand anyway

In my experience the melodeon, one row included, the bass can change very quickly.

Where the guitar player may be thinking in one bar changes the melodeon can make chord changes within the bar. Harmonizing notes rather than sequences.

This for me is a frequent source of contention.

As a result I often play right hand only when working against chord instruments.

To paraphrase the above:

"Don't keep a dog and bark yourself"  ;D

Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 30, 2024, 04:14:25 PM
Nobody buys a ticket to hear a guitar play chords...
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Bill_S on December 30, 2024, 04:16:11 PM
Yeah, I was thinking band situation, as Rees illustrates. Not having done many sessions, I can't really speak to that.

Quote from: Thrupenny Bit
... in my session often the Guitar/twangy thing frequently plays melody not just chord accompaniment where I play so I always play a left hand.

Makes sense - switching roles. I guess one could also sit it out completely.

Quote from: Thrupenny Bit
...though spending countless hours building relationships between them makes it feel odd.

Yeah, I can see that.

Quote from: Thrupenny Bit
People should follow your lead in the way you like to play it so others shouldn't blast their accompaniment across it, or speed up etc.

Totally. And again, they could also sit out the tune.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: rees on December 30, 2024, 05:54:25 PM
Nobody buys a ticket to hear a guitar play chords...

erm?
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Lester on December 30, 2024, 06:04:32 PM
Nobody buys a ticket to hear a guitar play chords...
What about all the people who paid to see Status Quo
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: rees on December 30, 2024, 06:39:12 PM
Nobody buys a ticket to hear a guitar play chords...

I earn at least half of my performance income playing rhythm guitar in a Country band. No-one has asked for their money back yet.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 30, 2024, 07:41:00 PM
Nobody buys a ticket to hear a guitar play chords...

I earn at least half of my performance income playing rhythm guitar in a Country band. No-one has asked for their money back yet.

Me too, back in the day. And upright bass if there was another guitar player. But...

I've never seen an ad announcing a solo guitarist playing chord progressions. Only occasionally in an elevator...

And being a box player gives you a huge advantage in knowing what NOT to do.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: CAB on December 30, 2024, 10:19:42 PM
In my experience the melodeon, one row included, the bass can change very quickly.
Where the guitar player may be thinking in one bar changes the melodeon can make chord changes within the bar. Harmonizing notes rather than sequences.

 ;D That's a much more positive way of saying what I meant when I said:

To state the obvious, because the chord changes with the bellows it's often impossible to play a coherent chord sequence while playing completely along the row.

I spend much of my time on the melodeon trying to avoid those superfluous chord changes by row-crossing.  For "the melodeon player can make chord changes within the bar", read "finds it hard not to make..."

The answer is, indeed, to let the accompanists take charge of chords.  Unfortunately, the band will doubtless ask me to play both hands at tomorrow night's gig since they find the sound of fiddle, guitar and melodeon right-hand just too thin without those basses.  With any luck the guitariast and I will be playing the same chord around 60% of the time.  :-\

Well yes, holding down the bass and chord button while waggling your way up a scale on one row is a very bad habit to get into. I suspect morris musicians trying to make as much noise as possible at any cost in order to be heard when playing outside.
It's not hard to make those gaps in the LH, and should make the rhythm more percussive and precise.

Not what I meant at all!  No matter how precise and crisp your left hand, you'll still end up with inappropriate changes all over the place unless you either cross rows or play the left hand only on the bits where it fits.
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Dick Rees on December 30, 2024, 10:33:42 PM
I think this discussion needs to re-start in a new thread.  I've lost the connection to Poutoux's Saltarelle
Title: Re: Gilles Poutoux's modified Salterelle
Post by: Pearse Rossa on December 31, 2024, 03:31:56 AM
I was watching this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3SU9FNhHPw) and noticed that Monsieur Poutoux's melodeon has been modified from a two row to a one row. It also looks like the bass end has been reduced to two buttons.

I'm wondering why someone would do this? Other than just liking the particular box and being a one row player, therefore converting it.

A few years ago, I converted an Erica to a one row 4 voice.
My reasons for doing this were; I never liked the left end on traditional one rows.
I wasn't a big fan of the keyboard, either. I also wanted more bass options.
This was something I could do myself, and it wasn't going to cost a huge amount.

This old thread might be of interest to you. https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=23461.msg279450#msg279450

This is how it sounded. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Djfaqq8zt-Y
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal