Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Danny Edwards on January 01, 2025, 01:09:49 PM

Title: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Danny Edwards on January 01, 2025, 01:09:49 PM
Hi All

Looking to purchase my first melodeon on a budget and I know the consensus is to purchase used from a known fettler, however that is likely to be outside of my budget.

The maximum I can afford to spend really is £300

I've found a Chanson DG 2 row on eBay for £195 used - apparently excellent condition - they retail for £330 at present

My thinking is that it's affordable at £195, I've heard of Chanson before, and it's barely been used so you would presume it's in tune and ready to learn with. Hopefully I would get my money back if selling used in the future.

What is everyone's opinion? What would you do in my shoes?

Unfortunately £300ish is the top end of my budget at present.

Thanks everyone
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Disparate Dan on January 01, 2025, 01:55:39 PM
"Only been played a few times" could be because the seller just didn't get on with a melodeon, or because it's a dog to play.  Who knows.  Ask the seller if all notes sound properly and it's easy to play, and bear in mind that their reply forms part of the description. The case is worth £20, btw.

Don't rely on getting your money back easily when you want to flog it because you've realised that it's holding you back, as you will do.

Your money, your call though  (:)  If it's no big deal for you to collect it, offer £165 cash?

Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 01, 2025, 02:09:01 PM
I've sent a message Danny.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 01, 2025, 06:55:55 PM
Honestly? I'd give it a miss. With a first instrument like this you'd likely be fighting with the instrument which will make the learning journey dispiriting at best.

I have seen beginner boxes on Ebay that were likely better prospects than this go for money in your stated price range. In your position I would keep looking, maybe rent, borrow or save up a little more.

There is a reason these boxes get sold on after being hardly used and it is not one that is in favour of your success. It's also worth bearing in mind that this box likely came from a music store and not a dedicated melodeon dealer, greatly lessening the chance that it will have had any much-needed fettling before being sold.

I appreciate this probably isn't what you wanted to hear, and you probably kind of knew it already before asking.  I do honestly think all such contraptions are best avoided though.

I can see that Pete has already messaged you, hopefully with some useful advice or a suggested alternative.

Having jumped too soon myself and got a Delicia Popular Deluxe (awful thing, £270) when what I  really wanted was a Pokerwork I do understand the temptation. In my case I made little progress with the unloved Delicia (aka the Decidedly Unpopular) and purchased a Pokerwork five months later (Ebay, £375). It is still used regularly for morris, ceilidh band and workshop teaching although my main instrument these days is a Castagnari Mory,
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Dick Rees on January 01, 2025, 07:01:09 PM
NEVER buy a cheap Chinese box. Period.

Putting "affordability“ as a prime concern will cost you more in the long run.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Theo on January 01, 2025, 08:03:23 PM
I’ve seen the eBay listing for the Chanson.  It’s collect only from Crook Co Durham.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 01, 2025, 08:03:41 PM
Helena, I did make a suggestion that I didn't expect to be taken up, but made it clear I was trying to steer him away from the chanson.
I said I thought he'd find himself frustrated by it very quickly.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Danny Edwards on January 01, 2025, 10:01:14 PM
Thanks for the advice everyone. The seller was willing to post it out to me, but I've decided against it after reading the above!

I think I'll hang fire until a D/G becomes available either on these forums or through some of the recommended dealers from this website. If anyone knows of any coming for sale soon, please do let me know!

Lastly - would you advise against purchasing off eBay for example if i spotted a cheaper Hohner?
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Dick Rees on January 01, 2025, 10:50:01 PM
It's always best to play before you buy.  Or work through a known fettler/dealer who'll stand behind the product.

Set aside that £300 and add something every month during your search. I think you should figure on double your original limit and get either a proven player or a fully fettled used Hohner.

Good luck.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Les C on January 01, 2025, 11:18:09 PM
Before i clued myself up a bit, I went and bought a Frontini Seren online (new) for £500. An impulse buy that I immediately regretted. As soon as it arrived I sent it back without even looking at it. I spent a while actually doing my research and made a few phone calls and have since stuck a deposit down on one of Mike Rowbothams Hohner Pokerworks. It’s quite a bit more than I had intended to spend but I know that I’m going to get a box that’s properly fettled and won’t hold me back. Any cock ups will be down to me and me only. It’s so tempting to buy something because it’s cheap, but in my opinion, you’ll likely regret it in the long run.

All the best!
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 02, 2025, 10:03:25 AM
Before i clued myself up a bit, I went and bought a Frontini Seren online (new) for £500. An impulse buy that I immediately regretted. As soon as it arrived I sent it back without even looking at it.

For reference one of these was recently sold on Ebay. The seller stated they'd paid £795 for it at a festival last spring but got nowhere with it and having failed to sell it on with another dealer they were now willing to take the loss. The box sold for £301. That's really not a great result for the individual concerned.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 02, 2025, 11:44:37 AM
For the OP - you might want to take a look at this thread: https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=31048

Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Les C on January 02, 2025, 05:05:25 PM
Before i clued myself up a bit, I went and bought a Frontini Seren online (new) for £500. An impulse buy that I immediately regretted. As soon as it arrived I sent it back without even looking at it.

For reference one of these was recently sold on Ebay. The seller stated they'd paid £795 for it at a festival last spring but got nowhere with it and having failed to sell it on with another dealer they were now willing to take the loss. The box sold for £301. That's really not a great result for the individual concerned.

Blimey, that’s a hell of a lot of money for a Chinese box, only a tad less the pokerwork I'm having from microbot. I bet the seller at the festival was rubbing their hands together!
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Danny Edwards on January 02, 2025, 07:46:24 PM
Thanks again everyone, the Black Diamond that Helena is selling sounds like a good option. I've read they are a step up from most of the other Chinese boxes and quite playable. Has anyone got any experience with these? Would this be a wise investment to get me into the world of melodeons? Thanks!
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 02, 2025, 11:25:00 PM
It's certainly good value and probably the best way to get a playable DG instrument for your limited budget.


Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Danny Edwards on January 03, 2025, 05:44:49 AM
I've also spotted a Scarlatti Nero in D/G that is local to me for £250

How does this compare to the Black Diamond? It looks like the Nero is a step up from the cheaper Scarlatti model (in price anyway)
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Andy Goldfinch on January 03, 2025, 08:08:10 AM
Having played a Scarlatti Nero in Hobgoblin once or twice, personally I'd group it with the other cheap chinese boxes that don't play very well.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Lester on January 03, 2025, 08:48:05 AM
The Nero and the Chanson probably come off the same production line and are just badged for the retailer.
See also Frontini and various other curiously Italian badged boxes
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: folkloristmark on January 03, 2025, 07:17:37 PM
Did you go for the black diamond a good option . I have a couple and they are much better than the usual cheapos . Not quite a powkerwork but close especialy if newish. I also have  the east german boxs in GD. The east german boxes can be set up to play very well but are very prone to problems if neglected.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Rog on January 03, 2025, 07:28:43 PM
The Nero is considerably better than the Chanson (imo), and quite similar to the Black Diamond. The Black Diamond is pretty good and a step up in quality. It is fitted with Cagnoni reeds and has a decent response and is quite fun to play and is actually quite a smart looking box. When Black Diamond stopped operating I checked all the remaining stock of (various) instruments (over 30 or them). They are Chinese made but essentially pretty good for the price point. The quality control was a bit sketchy, and I was effectively fixing little snags etc that might have been picked up with better controls in China. Obviously it's not a professional instrument, but it is very playable, and I sold a couple after playing a few tunes for customers.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: folkloristmark on January 03, 2025, 07:55:27 PM
There's nothing wrong with the black diamond . I brought two and they all prop come from the closing down sale when there were bargains to be had .Not quite a powker work but close,Better than most cheap boxes .IMHO found the air button sharp edged but nothing a bit os sand paper can't deal with.Broken zips on cases and mould to straps but the boxes were fine and have kept well . How long ago was it 3/4 years?

ps I have a Scarlatti gd the bd is a step up cant see you loosing much value at 250 price. I would say both  models claim 'italian reeds'
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Danny Edwards on January 03, 2025, 09:43:20 PM
I haven't gone for either yet, but the Scarlatti Nero person is willing take £200 for local collection as I'm quite close to them. It will save me around £125 vs the Black Diamond. My current circumstances mean that value for money is quite a big factor for me, I'd love to be able to afford more but I'm quite keen to get started learning on something. I feel quite confident I could get my £200 back or more in the future based on the Nero's retail price if I did need to upgrade.

The lady has a video of her playing a tune - perhaps some of you with an experienced eye/ear can have a look and see if all seems well?

https://www.facebook.com/share/1KSqMuYfzs/

Hopefully if all seems well I can collect Sunday and get started! Any red flags let me know
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Theo on January 03, 2025, 10:50:52 PM
I haven't gone for either yet, but the Scarlatti Nero person is willing take £200 for local collection

Seems like a good price and after all the comments here your expectations won't be too high so it could work well.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Al Cramer on January 04, 2025, 12:40:37 AM
I liked the sound of the reeds, and the clacking of the keys sounds very like a Pokerwork (which can be reduced if you watch Lester's videos about hot rodding Hohners).
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Gena Crisman on January 04, 2025, 02:51:40 AM
I agree with Rog - I'd put either of these options at least two steps ahead of the 'Chanson' originally considered & it's ilk. I do also think I probably agree with Mark too, for that matter, in that I'd probably bet on the Black Diamond, but, well, not by much.

I started on a Scarlatti Nero. I've played decent ones, and I've played bad ones. The worst ones I've played had eg a completely stuck button (so like something just obviously wrong that suggests no one has ever tried to play it, despite it being for sale on a shelf). The slightly less worse (or more worse, kind of?) one felt like it had a set of bellows that just didn't want to open. Ever. I imagine it's like having a manacle attached to your leg, but, for draw notes. It was very challenging to get alternating pull and push notes to be even remotely the same volume, and was exhausting to play.

My one, the air button's lever was a touch heavy and I eventually realised it was straining my thumb. And then also the straps disintegrated - both surmountable concerns & not particularly unique or unusual. Considering the lady in question is able to get a tune out of hers without either wincing, or breaking into a sweat, I suspect this one may tend towards the 'decent' camp. So, like Theo says, it could work well. Best of luck.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Helena Handcart on January 04, 2025, 10:40:58 AM
For £200 I'd probably take a punt on it. It will get you started and give you something to play while you plan for an upgrade and you will very likely be able to get back what you paid when you need to move up.

I'd agree with others that the Nero is a clear step up from the Chanson originally discussed but a clear step down from the Black Diamond. There is an even cheaper Scarlatti model that is almost identical to the Chanson and they also made a wooden one with faux Italian box vibes but haven't seen one of those for a while.

From the video you shared it looks like she is having to work quite hard to get a tune out of the box, and the clack may become annoying but at that price it'll definitely get you started.

Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: mChavez on January 25, 2025, 10:14:59 PM
Well, I just bought a box that looks like it's been built in the Chanson factory.  >:E
Don't know if all of it comes out of the Bai-Li umbrella or whether there's competing factories.

It's a 30-treb 48-bass PA. 2 Voices in the left, 2+2 in the bass.
Badged "Excelsior" but it's one of them "Built in China, quality controlled in Castelfidardo, Italy" jobs. Probably 90s.

Bought it because it's just the right size for my daughter to start squeezing, it's reasonably lightweight for a PA and it goes down to low G on the treble side, so it's the smallest model that goes low enough for fiddle tunes.

Old box, but:
- Compression 9.5/10 despite old Chinese bellows.
- Reeds machined stamped, but of decent quality. No idea of Chinese or Italian. Not murdered by dremel or anything - careful filing for tuning.
- RHS keyboard has a decent feel and is quite light. All mechs are metal, no plastic linkages, no excessive play, etc.
- Wooden fondo on RHS & good quality wooden reedblocks all around. Reedblock quality is better than what I had in my big-French-builder-name diatonic   :-\
- Everything works.

Leather valves are pants, tuning is all over the place and the wax is liquefying, There's a handful of reeds where excess valve glue went into the slots, killing the reed response & tuning stability. But they will be fine after an overhaul.

Overall, I am really impressed, I don't know how much Excelsior had in QC after the box was built in China, but it's an accordion, alright, and not the worst one that I've seen.
The only thing that really lets it down is the 48-bass machine. Very poor quality and they could have fitted a 60- or 72-bass in there. But it's set up pretty well.

If you're just starting out, avoid Chinese stuff, true. But the reality is that an Italian or Hohner loft find off ebay is much much worse, many used higher end boxes are not in a much better shape than a good used China-box, while a hot-rodded squeezebox is closer to £1k territory.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Steve Morrison on March 22, 2025, 07:11:30 PM
We have been selling the “Chanson” D/G Melodeon for many years now and have found them easy to play and are very reliable. It is no use listening to people have no clue about a product when their narrow minds only allow them to read from the same old script. This is an excellent melodeon and has been the launch pad for many a good melodeon player. Some people struggle to get enough money to start and this instrument offers people the chance to enjoy this wonderful musical experience. Steve
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Steve Morrison on August 05, 2025, 03:56:26 PM
The Chanson melodeon is well made and has been a great starting point for any person wishing to take up the melodeon and is on a budget. I sent half a Dozen of these to a school 15 years ago and are still going strong. Steve
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Steve Morrison on September 02, 2025, 05:30:40 PM
The Chanson D/G is a quite excellent melodeon to start on. We have sold tens of this instrument and they have been highly reliable and trouble free. Most if not all of the people who have responded to this message have never played a Chanson in their lives. Buying an old battered Hohner is not a good idea for a beginner and yes I would advice not buying of EBay as this is where all the nightmare instruments end up. I hope you find what you need but not all strangers give good advice.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: mChavez on September 02, 2025, 06:43:42 PM
Nothing wrong with buying on ebay if the seller and the listing looks legitimate. I've sold some wonderful boxes there, as have many other forum members.

Buying a budget chinese box from somebody who repeatedly advertises it on online forums by talking to himself while belittling everyone else... Personally, I'd think twice about that.

"not all strangers give good advice" indeed, especially if they are pursuing personal financial interests when handing out that advice.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Steve C. on September 03, 2025, 01:09:54 PM
Purchase on ebay but just make sure that you leave room in your budget for extra to fix it right if need be (somewhat likely if you cannot do it yourself)
Don't buy something that cannot be resold (to weird, too old, etc.)
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Helena Handcart on September 03, 2025, 01:34:20 PM
Most if not all of the people who have responded to this message have never played a Chanson in their lives.

I have. I've played quite a few. As a tutor of Absolute Beginner melodeon workshops  I make a point of trying as many entry level boxes as possible. I'd recommend a Hohner every time, 'battered' or not.
Title: Re: Chanson 2 Row D/G Opinions?
Post by: Lester on September 03, 2025, 03:03:41 PM
Like Helena I have played many "entry level" boxes in my time as a fettler. I found that a tatty Hohner was alway head and shoulders above the Chanson and its Chinese cousins. In addition after spending the a similar of money with a fettler you will end up with a very much better investment with an old Hohner than you would with a Chanson.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal