Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Ben Kennedy on January 08, 2025, 01:35:52 PM
-
Hello all - I wanted to revisit the BC bass discussion. I have a Saltarelle Shamrock with 12 basses - the top 8 are a standard McComiskey setup, and the bottom 4 are in the layout below:
Top (push/draw)
G/D E/A
Outside C/G D/F Inside
F/C Bb/Eb
Bottom
My main focus is Irish session playing. I rarely use the bottom 4 basses, F chords are relatively rare and a draw on the C is pretty useless given that the entire chord is on the push. B-flat and E-flat have incredibly niche uses.
So, I want to change the basses to fix my biggest issues. My top one is the lack of a B in the bass, there are plenty of common Bm tunes for which this would be useful. While I can drop the thirds, I'm thinking that a straight Bm chord would be fine, hitting a B major chord is also very rare. I'd also like the flexibility of a A chord on the push so I always an A chord option for both push and draw on the E note. I also want both a push and draw on the B, as well as a draw on the E to fully round out playing the key of A. I also think it makes sense to move the McComiskey to the bottom area and put the new buttons on the top, this would effectively group the basses by key.
Top (push/draw)
A/Bm Bm/E
Outside G/D E/A Inside
C/G D/F
Bottom
Thoughts?
-
I can see problems with your existing layout.
Pull C could be useful when combined with right hand E and Bb tritone, giving a nice C7. Similarly push F gives some useful options for playing in F, Dm or G mixolydian, but Bb push and Eb pull are next to useless. Flipping the reeds would give A useful Push Eb, pull Bb option, which makes sense in relation to right hand layout, but would seem an unlikely pairing in terms of ITM.
I like your proposed changes. They open up some useful options. Having both push and pull Bm makes sense in terms of the right hand layout.
-
Your proposed arrangement reminds me of John Williams' layout, which has much the same basses/chords but groups them on the same unisonoric button pairs except for C/F. This would arguably be more convenient, but maybe not feasible with your existing reeds:
John Williams' 2 1/2 row B/C box with 12 basses
(top of instrument)
outside inside
chord E/E A/A
bass E/E A/A
chord D/D G/G
bass D/D G/G
chord C/F B/B
bass C/F B/B
-
Thank you for the feedback
This would arguably be more convenient, but maybe not feasible with your existing reeds
Definitely more convenient, maybe if I were starting over - just don't want to have to unlearn too much
I like your proposed changes. They open up some useful options. Having both push and pull Bm makes sense in terms of the right hand layout.
Yeah, I'm wondering if two Bm is overkill and I'd be ok with just a Bm on the draw. Perhaps F#minor would be a better push option to completely round out the key of A