Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Al Cramer on January 09, 2025, 04:33:40 AM
-
Hi all--
I have a (almost new) Saltarelle D/G Boube. Today one of the treble D-row keys began to malfunction: when pressed and then released, it fails to spring back up completely, so there's a little gap between the pad-thingy and the air hole, causing unwanted note to faintly sound. I removed the grill & verified that this was happening, but am at a loss as to what to do next. I thought: maybe lubricate something? It it were a Pokerwork, I would know how to do that, thanks to Lester's hot-rod videos. But on this Salterelle I don't see how to get at the underlying key mechanism.
All advice gratefully appreciated!
-
Is it the version of the Bouebe with buttons mounted on wooden levers?
-
yes sir: it has buttons on wooden levers.
-
It’s a fairly common problem on that type of keyboard. You will get various other suggestions of quick fixes and you might find that changes in humidity make the sticking better or worse. Do not put any oil grease or wax into the keyboard, and don’t attempt to slide anything between the levers and the keyboard. One thing that sometimes can ease the sticking is to rotate the axle rod without withdrawing it. It can be difficult to do this because there is often only a very short length to get hold of. A pin vice, or a drill chuck (detached from the drill), are safe tools to do this.
The only way to properly fix this is to strip the keyboard, carefully clean everything, look for roughness on the axle rod signs of rubbing on the sides of levers. Clean and polish the axle rod, gently scrape rubbed areas on levers, ensure all the levers move freely then reassemble everything.
-
Yep, pull the axle and clean the sides of the offending wooden lever..with glass paper or scrape it with a sharp blade. Put it back, test, repeat until it moves freely. As you pull the axle the keys will spring off. Get a tray and lay them in the order they come off. Sometimes it can be tricky to reorder them so it's easier to keep them in the correct sequence.
-
I have a (almost new) Saltarelle D/G Boube.
Could you not get it repaired under warranty, then ??
-
Thanks Theo & Rog --
I used my drill press chuck to rotate the axle (it projects out about 3mm). Helped some but didn't really solve the problem. I guess I'll try to do it the proper way. Looks like a lot of work, but I think I see how to do it (totally get that you have to think about reassembly before taking things apart, also you need to think about springs). The only part that worries me is pulling the axle out, because that looks like it might require force, and I get nervous using force on delicate things.
(Thanks also to Tiprous for suggesting vendor warranty. Will look into that!)
-
It's not that difficult, truly. The tricky bit is threading the axle back through the keys. But I fixed a sticky key like this in an hour past week. If you got a drill on the axle to rotate it, just rotate on a slow speed and gently pull..it will come out easily and the keys will jump off. But…the biggest risk at this point is putting a bend in the axle…if you knock it or forget you have a heavy drill attached to it…so *be careful*. Plus of course, you only need to pull it as far as the sticky key. If the key is near the chin end..happy days. And when pushing the axle back, put something on the jaws of your pliers to avoid damaging the axle …I use a bit of facing leather. I also have a special tool, but I can't always use it, so it has to he pliers.
-
It's not that difficult, truly. The tricky bit is threading the axle back through the keys. But I fixed a sticky key like this in an hour past week. If you got a drill on the axle to rotate it, just rotate on a slow speed and gently pull..it will come out easily and the keys will jump off. But…the biggest risk at this point is putting a bend in the axle…if you knock it or forget you have a heavy drill attached to it…so *be careful*. Plus of course, you only need to pull it as far as the sticky key. If the key is near the chin end..happy days. And when pushing the axle back, put something on the jaws of your pliers to avoid damaging the axle …I use a bit of facing leather. I also have a special tool, but I can't always use it, so it has to he pliers.
And a spare pair of hands is very useful here.
-
It’s one of those jobs that is easy if you know what you are doing, and needs care.
Rog mentions keys popping out when you with draw the axle rod. They will, and in some cases they can travel quite far, so they need to be gently restrained and kept in order so that each goes back in the same place.
It’s a nearly new instrument so it needs to be done right.
-
If you put a long elastic band over the length of the keyboard it stops the keys flying all over the place.
Number each key on the bottom as you take them out.
-
Thanks for the advice & tips! Will try this Sunday & report back..
-
I was only partially successful in freeing the sticky key on my D/G Saltarelle (it's the high octave A on the D row). My plan was to use my drill press chuck to pull the axel, then follow the advice given above. But the axel is in there super tight. Once I got started, I grew doubtful that I was even turning it. So I tried the drill chuck from my lathe. After many attempts & super careful tightening, I was able to turn the axel. I then found that, if turned to the right place, the sticky key would snap down & close completely. This is all in line with Theo's initial advice.
So the sticky key is fixed, at least for now. But I'm worried: what will I do when I really do have to get that axel out? All I can think to do is get a new lathe drill chuck, since the one I have is pretty battered & the jaws must be slightly out of true. Then get a friend to hold the box, so I can both hands to twist & pull. Getting the axel back in safely will be difficult. I usually use a tiny bit of beeswax on screws, before screwing them in: am I right in thinking that would be a bad idea here?
Fortunately this is not something I have to do right now. Am learning "Bear Dance" from Lester's book, transposed up an octave, so I really need that A key. Much thanks for all the excellent advice.
-
If you can get the cable rod out and ensure everything is clean it’s usually easier to get the rod back in terms of the amount of force needed. What is a little more difficult is getting the hole in each lever aligned with the axle. It just takes a bit of care with each lever.
-
You guys are probably tired of me posting about sticky keys. But since other beginners like me may read this thread if they hit the same problem, I'm reporting on latest developments.
The just-rotate-the-axel-solution ceased working after about 3 days - key got sticky again. So I studied the spacing on the left & right side of the lever shaft of the bad key, & saw the shaft was no longer centered in its slot. The gap to the right was big, and the gap to the left wasn't visually discernable. So I took a screw driver, pressed it against the metal rod that connects lever to pad (down at the base, where it enters the lever), and applied gentle pressure to move things up so that the gaps were again equal. This fixed the problem, and so far the fix is holding up.
I think the problem is due to poor technique. When I strike/release keys, I'm probably not doing it cleanly (vertical movement only); instead I'm likely applying some lateral force that causes the key to gradually drift a bit away from its proper position on the axel.
There's also the box itself. I have a Loffet G/C box, which is built exactly like the Salterelle D/G. I noticed that the gaps on the Loffet box are a wee bit larger than the gaps on the Salterelle -- like maybe .25mm vs. .20mm. Also the springs on the Loffet seem a little more forceful.