Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Dave Sawdon on January 14, 2025, 06:01:38 PM
-
I've never felt comfortable playing 3/2 tunes, such as Rusty Gully, Old Lancashire, etcetera. What should I be doing with my LH to get that characteristic 3/2 feel?
-
Mel Biggs has a few videos on her Youtube channel using Barham Down as an example to teach 3/2 left hand:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CGRAR6TAKm8
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XwDXcfHqV6k
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DaZt_kZsxOk
-
Thanks for the links.
The rhythm she's suggesting in the first video is certainly different to my previous attempts - it would be interesting to discuss what others do with their LH in 3/2 tunes.
-
I will try a small bass runs, often reflecting the melody.
-
The 3/2 is in itself just a simple ternary rhythm. In other words you have, like in the waltz, one strong accent/beat, S, followed by two weak accents/beats, W. In the standard waltz pattern the bass corresponds to the strong beat, and the chords to the weak beats: S-W-W. That's technically called a primary subdivision.
What males the 3/2 different is that you usually have four quavers to the beat, rather than just two like in the waltz. To create an effective rhythmic pattern you usually introduce a so called secondary level of subdivision, using three additional weaker beats after the strong one and the two weak ones, WW. Then you use a bass-chord, bass-chord, bass chord pattern with the basses that correspond to the strong and the weak beats, and the chords that correspond to the weaker beats S-WW, W-WW, W-WW.
That's the same relation that you find between the bass- chord, bass-chord patterns you use for both the quaternary and the binary rhythms, that seems identical but are in fact farily different. In the hornpipe that pattern follows the primary subdivision, with the third beat that is often called the half strong beat, since it's weaker that the first but stronger than the second and the third: S-W-HS-W. In a polka the pattern becomes S-WW, W-WW, with the strong beat and the weak beats that correspond to the basses, and the weaker beats that correspond to the chords.
The bass-chord, bass.chord, bass-chord pattern is usually adopted for the anter dros in Brittany, that are generally notated using a ternary rhythm (even if Yann Dour suggests they should be written alternating a 4/4 bar with a 2/4 bar).
Of course there is nothing wrong im using a more articulated left hand pattern, skipping one or more of the beats, and/or bass runs, and/or eventually playing block chords to give some emphasis to some notes in the melody. It's just a matter of taste...
-
Dave since you mentioned Rusty Gulley, some older versions (Northumbrian Minstrelsey for example) have alternate bars of 3/2 and 6/8. The 6/8 implies two main beats in those bars which give a syncopated feel.
-
In many tunes you can just oom-pah: bass-chord, bass-chord, bass-chord. In practice, many 3/2 tunes have interesting syncopation in the melody that you will often want to echo on the left hand, maybe by playing both bass and chord at the same time to emphasize the "jump".
-
Thanks for the links.
The rhythm she's suggesting in the first video is certainly different to my previous attempts - it would be interesting to discuss what others do with their LH in 3/2 tunes.
Yes, there's a tendency among many players now to give 3/2 tunes a strong 6/4 feel. This is fun but the impact is lost if you do it relentlessly in every bar. As Theo points out in the Rusty Gulley example a mixture of 3/2 and 6/8 rhythms is often appropriate, more interesting and occasionally (but not often) notated in the sheet music.
Maybe Mel has a later lesson in the series where she varies the rhythm from one bar to the next - if not, perhaps she should!
-
I think Rusty Gulley is a classic tune, the rhythm changes so there's nothing 'standard' that you can apply to the accompaniment.
I can't remember who said it, I think a tutor at the Halsway weekend, it was something along the lines of 'the melody carries the accompaniment'. By that they meant the left hand can emphasise or highlight the melody rather than be a constant 'um-pah' accompaniment as in more regular tunes.