Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Juni Hag on January 15, 2025, 07:17:15 PM

Title: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Juni Hag on January 15, 2025, 07:17:15 PM
Hello,

TL;DR:
How is it to play in Amaj and flat keys on a 2.5 row DGacc instrument? Will it be horrible and I should look for a 3 row DGacc instrument, or is it doable and reasonably comfortable?


Some background:
I'm interested in getting a better DGacc box, but am unsure what to buy so any advice would be appreciated.

I live in Sweden and play mostly scandic folk music. Currently I have an quite heavy GCacc Letron/Laloy melodeon as main instrument, with 18 basses (where 2 of the chord buttons are swapped for even more basses). As secondary I have a castagnari lilly AD for all the violin tunes.

I enjoy them but have recently gotten a pokerwork DG for playing some british music and in the local irish sessions, and it is so much fun! I can't say if it's only temporary new love or will persist, but I'm already thinking of getting a better DG box with more accidentials and even thinking of if it could replace at least my AD box and maybe partly the GCacc too.

I would like the instrument/layout to support at least the keys G,D,Amaj and minor parallel counterparts, and preferably all other keys over to Gmin since those are which is common in my scandinavian repertoire. 2.5row DG instruments seem to handle Amaj quite good, but how are those with the flat keys? Will I have a horrible time if I try to play e.g. gm or dm on those instrument and should go for a 3 row DG instead, or is it doable and reasonably comfortable?

I love the dry castagnari sound and aim for one of those, but they are impossible to find here in Sweden so I plan to (hopefully at some point) take a trip to the UK, try as much as possible out and buy one. Therefore I also would like to do as much research as possible beforehand to do an informed choice.

Kind regards, juni


Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 15, 2025, 08:14:03 PM
I play a Pariselle 2½ row. 14 bass DGacc. 8 bass note buttons and 6 chord buttons. Emmanuel makes lovely instruments.
I don't go much into flat keys, but Gmin and Dmin are fine. I play Hökpers Vals in Dmin and Italian Rant in Gmin.
Bb seems ok from trying Playford tunes, actually for me easier then F.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 15, 2025, 08:49:55 PM

   A maj => F is a difference of 4 accidentals and Bb/Gm or Cm are even further away! 
   So you are fighting the diatonic nature of the instrument to some extent 🥴

   On my accs/D/G the accs row is based on C#scale. There are other options but it's a rich source of accidentals for both main rows.

   In particular it naturally has an Ab/Bb button That opens up both of your targets 👍  In flat keys you 'pivot' on that button with a flick of the bellows.  In A you treat it as a G#, switching from pull to push halfway through your scale. (push-A chord on your 18-bass helps).

   The main difference between 2+5, and full 3 row is ability to play fluidly across both octaves. Check the weights: not much more?  And as the luthier is making 3 blocks anyway the cost is also … marginal.

  Will your main rows be simomple diatonic?  or Club system? or Dutch inversion (you mention le Tron)?  Or even the Scandanavian system with a pull Eb?  That makes a difference too. Any pull Eb with make tune phrases, or chording in those minor keys much easier. Not to mention A-blues!  😎
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Theo on January 15, 2025, 09:08:04 PM

   And as the luthier is making 3 blocks anyway the cost is also … marginal.

True in some designs but not in others.
Pariselle, Saltarelle and possibly other 2.5 row boxes only have two reed blocks and consequently are considerably more compact than a full three row.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 15, 2025, 09:37:03 PM
I have a 2.5 row 12 bass Castagnari Mory, DG + accidentals.
I'm interested in some of the unusual tunes in the English repertoire, as well as the more common ones in D and G. The fiddlers in one of my local music sessions often go into tunes in Bb, Gm and Am as well as the standard tunes that are more frequently played.

When I first got the Mory, I hadn't realised how important the layout is if you wish to play in the flat keys. The 'standard' Castagnari layout isn't particularly 'flat key friendly'.

After two attempts to get it right, I've settled on Paul Young's layout here:-

https://www.paulyoungfolk.co.uk/layouts

This makes playing in the flat keys much easier than the standard Castagnari layout, I just wish I'd seen it first!
There are push stops on the bass end to take out thirds, so the left hand chords become 'open' chords, neither major nor minor, which enables you to play in the flat keys.
On the right hand you have levers behind the keyboard to enable you to add/remove the low reed and all combinations fro a single reed M or low reed L, through to LMM with all reeds sounding.
It is a heavy box but I've got used to playing it, always sat down, and it has a huge lovely sound.


Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: GBbox on January 15, 2025, 09:40:58 PM

 2.5row DG instruments seem to handle Amaj quite good...


As far as the melody is concerned... yes. The difference between the D major scale and the A a major scale is that the first requires a G natural, while the second requires a G sharp. If you wish to play correct chord progressions, with both the tonic and the dominant (the A and the E chords) available just as pull chords, definitely they don't, at least with the standard left hand keyboard layouts for both the 8 and 12 bass buttons models.

As a rule of thumb for a 2 ½ row instrument the natural third main key is a fourth above the key of the inner row - F for a G/C box, G for an A/D box, and C for a D/G.  But of course you can try to rework the keyboard layout for both the right and the left hand.

Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: smiley on January 16, 2025, 12:47:53 AM
I like playing A major and Gm tunes on my Castagnari Dony with D/G/acc. The Dony is a 2 voice, 12 bass button box and less expensive than a Mory.
The note arrangement on the half row is important. I've found a G# on the push works well for A major tunes, which I play mainly on the push.
Gm(Bb) & Dm(C) tunes are easier with F nat and Bb in both directions and the chords minus thirds are OK if you play them sparingly.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 16, 2025, 07:43:59 AM
I too have recently got a Dony for my pub session box.
It is a 'no frills' version of the Mory, a 2 voice treble and only a pull stop to take out left hand thirds.
Mine has a mirror layout to my Mory.

After taking ages to make the decision I'm very pleased with it. I swapped a 2 row 8 bass 3 voice box for it and it has a similar weight. Therefore light enough for normal 'rumpty' tunes but with the layout to go off piste into the flat keys if the session heads that way. It is very resonant too, I really enjoy playing it.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Andy Goldfinch on January 16, 2025, 08:17:31 AM
What is it you find so fun about the D/G pokerwork? If it's because it's light and agile, then be aware that adding either a half or full extra row might impact that.

I find playing in A major on D/G relatively ok, although it definitely has a different feel to the home keys, with it being mostly on the pull. You can even get away with quite a few A Major tunes on a standard 2 row, because there are plenty that don't use the G# very much and it can often be substituted for a different note (something that fits with whatever chord you're playing, maybe an E or a B).

The thing I find most important to play in A major is a decent air button that lets you quickly dump a lot of air, otherwise you can quickly find your bellows flapping at arms length. Some careful planning of when to put some push notes in (usually over a D chord) will really help keep the bellows under control when almost everything else is on the pull.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 16, 2025, 10:50:14 AM

   Echo "having F in both directions" 👍

   it is the key to playing in C, or its modes Dm dorian or Am. I wouldn't be without it!  Mine is on one acc button F/F
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 16, 2025, 12:32:23 PM
Yes mine too, it was a game changer for me.
I sometimes wish I had a Bb both ways but haven't enough accidentals for that, and everything on a melodeon is a compromise...  so it's just wish!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Julian S on January 16, 2025, 12:51:16 PM
My last instrument purchase was a DG Castagnari Rik, 3 row, 2 voice, with a layout designed to overcome the limitations (and weight drawback) of my 2.5 DG Mory - only pull Fnat accidentals. On the Rik I have F naturals in both directions and the D and E reversals I like, at the expense of a non standard note spacing on the accidental row. All good so far - and flexibility to play 'off piste ' keys. Except I just don't like its sound compared to the Mory or my favourite 2.4 Saltarelle Pastourelle 2. Maybe it just needs some tweaks to the tuning but I'm now wondering whether I should have bought a 2.5 CF box instead.

Lesson - I spent a lot of time worrying about instrument weight and layout details and forgot the basic lessons - you need to like the sound !

Julian


Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Juni Hag on January 18, 2025, 06:34:27 PM
Thank you all for the great answers! A lot of great info.  (:)

When it comes to instruments, I'm mostly considering the castagnari Rik, Dony or Benny.
Do you know why the Benny is so much lighter than the others? Of course the chassi is smaller and it seem to have one voice less in the bass (?), but 1.3 kg less than Rik is a lot!


   A maj => F is a difference of 4 accidentals and Bb/Gm or Cm are even further away! 
   So you are fighting the diatonic nature of the instrument to some extent 🥴

   On my accs/D/G the accs row is based on C#scale. There are other options but it's a rich source of accidentals for both main rows.

   In particular it naturally has an Ab/Bb button That opens up both of your targets 👍  In flat keys you 'pivot' on that button with a flick of the bellows.  In A you treat it as a G#, switching from pull to push halfway through your scale. (push-A chord on your 18-bass helps).

   The main difference between 2+5, and full 3 row is ability to play fluidly across both octaves. Check the weights: not much more?  And as the luthier is making 3 blocks anyway the cost is also … marginal.

  Will your main rows be simomple diatonic?  or Club system? or Dutch inversion (you mention le Tron)?  Or even the Scandanavian system with a pull Eb?  That makes a difference too. Any pull Eb with make tune phrases, or chording in those minor keys much easier. Not to mention A-blues!  😎

Haha yes I know, maybe I should settle in just bringing more instruments. But it would be so nice to only need 2.

I think I aim for the main rows to be "regular" diatonic DG 4th button start, but haven't completely settled. I'm considering the dutch inversion, but having just the regular has its benefits too. And that's what I'm used to now, even though I haven't been playing that long and would probably be able to relearn.

Does the le Tron layout usually has the dutch inversion? I don't think mine is "standard" le Tron if there are any, I think the previous owner had some adjustments like a push A on button 1 on the middle row. And the extra basses of course.


I have a 2.5 row 12 bass Castagnari Mory, DG + accidentals.
I'm interested in some of the unusual tunes in the English repertoire, as well as the more common ones in D and G. The fiddlers in one of my local music sessions often go into tunes in Bb, Gm and Am as well as the standard tunes that are more frequently played.

When I first got the Mory, I hadn't realised how important the layout is if you wish to play in the flat keys. The 'standard' Castagnari layout isn't particularly 'flat key friendly'.

After two attempts to get it right, I've settled on Paul Young's layout here:-

https://www.paulyoungfolk.co.uk/layouts

This makes playing in the flat keys much easier than the standard Castagnari layout, I just wish I'd seen it first!
There are push stops on the bass end to take out thirds, so the left hand chords become 'open' chords, neither major nor minor, which enables you to play in the flat keys.
On the right hand you have levers behind the keyboard to enable you to add/remove the low reed and all combinations fro a single reed M or low reed L, through to LMM with all reeds sounding.
It is a heavy box but I've got used to playing it, always sat down, and it has a huge lovely sound.

Thank you very much for the tip, will absolutely try it out and consider!

Hearing the layout is so important kind of scares me a bit, of course you can change tones afterwards but its quite a hazzle and expensive as far as I understand, which makes buying an instrument so definite.

Mory seem to have such a lovely sound, but I think its a bit too heavy for my taste unfortunaley.


I like playing A major and Gm tunes on my Castagnari Dony with D/G/acc. The Dony is a 2 voice, 12 bass button box and less expensive than a Mory.
The note arrangement on the half row is important. I've found a G# on the push works well for A major tunes, which I play mainly on the push.
Gm(Bb) & Dm(C) tunes are easier with F nat and Bb in both directions and the chords minus thirds are OK if you play them sparingly.

Thank you for the tips! Do you mean A major on pull? Regular DG 12 basses use to miss both A and E on push I think? Or do you have any special layout in the base too?

Dony seem to be a lovely box and very close to what I would like. You don't find it heavy, is it easy to play push/pull style on it?


What is it you find so fun about the D/G pokerwork? If it's because it's light and agile, then be aware that adding either a half or full extra row might impact that.


Yeah thats a good question...
I think it's mainly a combination both of it being much lighter than my current 3 row, and the sound of the basses.

For the basses, they of course jump the octave at a different position than on regular GC or AD, and having the G lowest on the DG feels much more.. natural. The (3rdless) chords go so much nicer together with both other bases and chords than I think they use to on the GC/AD if I play multiple chords/chord+other bases at the same tame. Often I think that any of the chords available would fit the melody when thinking of what to play.

For the weight, yes thats an concern I have. However, the 3 row box weight ~5 kilos in total, but has only two voices in the RHS and 11 bass buttons and 7 chord buttons, with Bb being the lowest bass, and has both Bb, B, C basses available in both direction, so I'm hoping that it has a unproportional amount of the weight located in the LHS which makes it feel even heavier than it is. I have a 2row 3 voice instrument which I think weights almost as much, but with a lot less weight in the LHS and than one feels much lighter to play. I also think it in addition has a bit too small air button hole for my taste, which in combination with the small bellow (same size as a Castagnari niko) makes me run out of air when playing only pull style which is required for tunes in D and A. Which is common in sweden.

And finnaly, I have so far mostly been playing irish and british stuff on the DG, which of course fits the instrument great and it often feels very natural to play those tunes on it in a way I haven't felt on the GC/AD. The scandi tradition is very centered around the fiddle which I guess have impacted the tunes, of course its possible and even fun to play those too but I more often feel I have to "convince the instrument" to play those tunes rather than getting more out of it than I put in, if you get what I grasp at. Its a bit hard to explain. :)


I'm mostly considering the Castagnari Dony or Rik, which weights 4.1 and 4.4 kilos. Its not that far from my heavy 5 kilo GCacc, but since they have so much less on the bass side I hope they will feel much lighter to play. What do you think, will it feel like a much lighter instrument or will it still be very heavy to play? I usually play with only one shoulder strap and the instrument resting in the lap, or with one or two horizontal straps around my waist and chest to not put strain on my sore shoulders. Or should I be looking more on the Benny, which only weights around 3.1 kilos?


My last instrument purchase was a DG Castagnari Rik, 3 row, 2 voice, with a layout designed to overcome the limitations (and weight drawback) of my 2.5 DG Mory - only pull Fnat accidentals. On the Rik I have F naturals in both directions and the D and E reversals I like, at the expense of a non standard note spacing on the accidental row. All good so far - and flexibility to play 'off piste ' keys. Except I just don't like its sound compared to the Mory or my favourite 2.4 Saltarelle Pastourelle 2. Maybe it just needs some tweaks to the tuning but I'm now wondering whether I should have bought a 2.5 CF box instead.

Lesson - I spent a lot of time worrying about instrument weight and layout details and forgot the basic lessons - you need to like the sound !

Julian


Ah, yes the Rik is together with the Dony and Benny what I'm most interested in. A lot of buttons to a reasonable weight. What is it with the sound you dislike, if you can describe it?
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeo
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 18, 2025, 06:45:19 PM

  If you make the right choice of 3-row you can go "one box per festival". 🙂  That was very liberating for me, as to Finland, France, Australia or N. America I was on a plane.  But even here in Britain it's advantageous. If you are only driving to festivals 2 remains a sensible option. Three is a lot to lug up from the camp site?

  All makers seem to quote weight now. I went for a van der Aa compact about 17 years ago (±4.3kg) and seem to ose that one only now. But Frans vdAa seems to be fully retired now.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 18, 2025, 07:03:37 PM
It took me a while to get used to the weight of the Mory, but learning to rest it on my leg to take the weight was the way for me.

If you look at the sizes of the respective boxes, the Benny has a smaller case. Therefore less wood means less weight!
The Rik and Dony are their full size boxes.
The number of reeds affect weight, a 3 voice box has an extra low reed per note on the treble side.
Also levers and switches to bring in voices or take out thirds also add more weight.

I'm enjoying my Dony more and more as I play it in. It's a full sized box so the size also helps to give it a full sound.
As it has no extra levers or switches, only a pull stop to remove thirds there's no extra things to add weight.
To my mind it's possibly  as light a box as possible for a 2.5 row 12 bass made of solid wood not veneered... maybe!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: smiley on January 18, 2025, 11:42:45 PM
I like playing A major and Gm tunes on my Castagnari Dony with D/G/acc. The Dony is a 2 voice, 12 bass button box and less expensive than a Mory.
The note arrangement on the half row is important. I've found a G# on the push works well for A major tunes, which I play mainly on the push.
Gm(Bb) & Dm(C) tunes are easier with F nat and Bb in both directions and the chords minus thirds are OK if you play them sparingly.

Thank you for the tips! Do you mean A major on pull? Regular DG 12 basses use to miss both A and E on push I think? Or do you have any special layout in the base too?

Dony seem to be a lovely box and very close to what I would like. You don't find it heavy, is it easy to play push/pull style on it?

I don't play bass/chords constantly (especially when in a band or a session with rhythm instruments) and that frees me to play A major tunes on the push if that suits the flow of a tune. Of course I'm happy to play A tunes on the pull too. Having accidentals on the half row naturally encourages more cross-rowing rather than push/pull playing 'on the rows'.

To be totally honest, I've found my Dony is too heavy for playing fast Irish tunes. Instead I play a modified 1930's 3 voice 2.4 row Hohner Erika and leave the Dony for home use.
For me, the Dony is better when playing tunes at a more relaxed pace. I also found the sweet Dony sound seems to get a bit lost in a lively session, but that might be something to do with the reed tuning - or due my poor hearing!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Julian S on January 19, 2025, 06:51:57 AM
I'll respond more fully to the question about the Rik sound later today when I have time to play it again - but my feeling has been that it lacks some resonance.
I actually sold a Dony so I could get the Rik as I felt my Mory was too heavy for prolonged playing and for sessions. On reflection I thought the Dony sounded slightly better, but the Rik has definite advantages with the three row layout.
Other strong contenders when I bought the Rik - a Mas -but I didn't completely like it's LM as opposed to MM.

Julian
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 19, 2025, 09:03:28 AM
As ever, what you want to play has a great effect on what you buy.
I play English tunes with bass/chord accompaniment and cross row at sessions. As said, one session regularly goes off piste into other keys. I find the Dony perfect for it. People have commented on it's lovely sound at both my regular sessions.
I am not an Irish player, it's not what I like and I avoid super fast tunes from any genre. The Dony fits my bill for a lighter session box.

Julian is the perfect choice to comment on Rik vs Dony  having owned both, and I know took ages to sort out a 3 row layout to suit his playing.

Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 19, 2025, 10:36:00 AM

   LM "bandonèon" has a deeper different tone and lacks tremolo. But if you like to use both octaves on any D/G is is immensely stabilising wrt both the volume, and "attack" of the reeds. It's like those squeaky foot-end M's have a "big brother".

  And if you buy a register … solo (either reed) offers massive nuance in song accompaniment. So as ever "it depends what you play" 😉
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: penn on January 19, 2025, 11:15:05 AM
I’ve had a DG Benny for a couple of years, and feel it fits what you’re looking for in your first post. It has a bright and lively sound on the treble, and is quite light. The lightness comes from it being a smaller case, and the button spacing is narrower than full sized boxes. It’s not quite as a narrow as a Lilly though.
The basses aren’t huge but it’s quite well balanced with the treble ( I think the earliest model Benny had a different bass end which was sometimes criticised for its lightness.)

I can play everything I want on it, most of my repertoire is D or G but I have tried tunes in Gm, Bb, A, Dm since I’ve had it with reasonable success.  Mine is Bob Ellis layout, which has G scale with an extra button  down to a lower D and G. Chas Blacker, “CAB” on this forum, has a very similar Benny. His recent klezmerised Atholl Highlanders post is an amazing demonstration of the possibilities.

I have recently been playing a DG Mory, and it is a magnificent beast, the three voice sound is deep and resonant and allows you to play further up the keyboard. Its heaviness is only an issue for me when first lifting it into a playing position or carrying it around in its case. On the lap it’s less noticeable, and from having read the various comments on this site, I was very surprised at how easy it is to play up and down the row. The bellows move a lot of air, and it only takes a delicate pulse to change direction back and forth.
I’m less keen on its 2 voice sound, the Benny just sounds a lot more fun.

I miss a couple of reversals that come with the full three row, but I feel that having the accidentals in around the right position relative to the other rows makes off piste playing less of a drama. I’ve never really been able to properly cope with accidentals on a 4th start 2 row.

I did try a Rik at the time of buying the Benny, and at the time the lightness and the “perky” sound of the Benny drew me in that direction.

This discussion does of course highlight the reason we all need more melodeons, there is no single box that ticks all the boxes.

I think you have to try them for yourself, and do some hard thinking on layout. A pilgrimage to Pete at Acorn would give you the opportunity to try several Castagnaris for sound and feel.

Good luck!
Gren
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Julian S on January 19, 2025, 11:52:03 AM
I'm relying on my memory, but I think my Dony had slightly more tremolo than my Rik has. One notable advantage of the Rik is the bass registers, as opposed to a bass stop for thirds, and I do think the bass end also sounds much better than the Dony.

 I've just been playing some tunes I've been playing on my old Saltarelle Pastourelle 2, and the Mory, on the Rik for comparison. Pastourelle 2 has a fuller sound than Rik, partly I think because I had the Pasty tuned 'Dedic/Viennese' some years ago by a true expert (sadly departed), and I now think a retune of the Rik would make a big difference. Mory wins hands down for overall sound but it is too heavy for some faster tunes - I play a wide range of English, French, some Scandinavian and also some Scots and Irish tunes.
Rik also seems to be quieter, and less able to cut through other instruments when playing - particularly leading as I do for our French dance evenings.

I echo Penn's advice about a visit to Acorn to try out instruments. Doing so meant all the
difference in my choice (I originally opted for a Mas) but I also realise that the same model of instrument can sound different as it gets played in.

Julian

Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 19, 2025, 12:14:06 PM
Yes a visit to Pete at Acorn would be an ideal resolution as you could play all these and more.
The trouble is, the OP lives in Sweden so bit of a trip!

Before buying the Dony, I happened on the fact that the Dony and Rik are the same dimensions, so could you get a Dony with a Rik left hand instead?
That would mean having bass registers on the left hand which is a great invention, though would have made the Dony a touch heavier.
Pete at Acorn talked to the people at Castagnari and the answer was 'no, the Rik end wouldn't fit onto a Dony...' so I went for a standard Dony ( Paul Young layout ) and a thirds stop to take out the thirds on the left hand.
With a 12 bass instrument with Bb/F and Eb/F#m as the extra basses, you need to be able to remove the thirds to enable full use of the accidentals and bass if going 'beyond' the normal keys of D and G.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 19, 2025, 01:23:58 PM

   "No thirds" is easier, lighter on the left arm, and frankly, cheaper.  Amazing how soon you get used to that, and playing in e.g A, you'll find that when you need to "assert the key" … the C or C# is already being played in the tune itself.  Otherwise you quickly learn to stick a spare finger onto it.

  That is to play the instrument "as a whole". It's one of the most useful steps that you will make.

   Underlying … a melodeon is not a piano! And that also underlies why 1-rows work so well. e.g Québecoise music? I'd never go back to a 2½/3 row instrument with chord 3rds. I'd find it restricting 🥴
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 19, 2025, 01:43:17 PM
I'm taking out thirds far more than ever I used to, though still prefer the sound of 'full fat thirds in' chords for normal rumpty English tunes that I'd normally play on a 2 row 8  bass box.
... but yes anything beyond that I take thirds out.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: tirpous on January 19, 2025, 04:49:40 PM
Following this with interest. It's not my type of playing but I have a friend looking for one of these 2.5 or 3 row boxes.

One thing I notice is the discussion has drifted to become quite Castagnari-centric. Are their other brands/models worthy of consideration ?? (possibly at less exalted prices...  ;))
 
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on January 19, 2025, 05:21:43 PM
As ever it depends what you want to play as others makes give differing options for the extra bass buttons.
Saltarelle give reversals for A and G, plus F# which to my mind gives it a sort of 'super DG' tag.
The likes if Castagnari give you Bb, F, Eb and F#m which if you remove thirds allow you to reasonably explore the flat keys, Bb, F, Am, Gm.

Therefore you can eliminate makers by matching their bass layout with what you want to play.
Then comes the tricky part of choosing a keyboard layout!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Squeaky Pete on January 19, 2025, 06:37:23 PM
Following this with interest. It's not my type of playing but I have a friend looking for one of these 2.5 or 3 row boxes.

One thing I notice is the discussion has drifted to become quite Castagnari-centric. Are their other brands/models worthy of consideration ?? (possibly at less exalted prices...  ;))
A reordered Hohner club box will do all this at a much cheaper cost.
If course you'll need a 12 bass conversion too, but we're not talking about 2.5-3K.
Also Pariselle boxes are occasionally available, 14 bass and 25 button right hand. Course boxes will be LM or MM with very nice reeds and as Emmanuel supervises, the quality will be there.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: pete /acorn on January 19, 2025, 07:41:33 PM
Hi.
I have several Castagnari 3 row boxes in stock new.
Castagnari Evo,Matris,Rik,Handry,Benny and Big 18.
I also have Handry 12 and 18, 2 Benny pre owned.
DG and GC.
Al pre owned to go on web site next week
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Juni Hag on January 20, 2025, 06:49:32 PM
Thanks again for all your wisdom!

Regarding the registers and voice choices: I have LM with solo and master registers on my current 3 row which undoubtly is nice to have but miss the sweet dry MM sound castagnaris use to have so that's what I aim for this time. Guess it could be a case of blindness of what you got and "grass is greener on the other side", but it at least narrows the options down. LMM would be nice to have but is sorted out this time to save weight (and money).

when it comes to 3rds I totally agree with whoever it was talking about not missing them. the 3 row lacks them totally and both the Lilly and Pokerwork has them taped away, very rarely miss them at all and when I do I most often can play them in the treble side. Maybe should consider ordering them removed to save weight this time too.  (:)


I actually have planned a trip to the Bellows and Buttons weekend in April, much of it to catch Acorn instruments and try them all out. Haven't completely decided though, and still have to decide on if I want to pay 4 extra days and quite some more money to take the train, or commit the deadly sin of flying. But based on your answers it sounds as it would be worth it either way!

Other strong contenders when I bought the Rik - a Mas -but I didn't completely like it's LM as opposed to MM.

Julian
The Mas is my current end game when it comes to GC I think. I'm satisfied enough with my current to stay with it for the moment, though.  (:)


I’ve had a DG Benny for a couple of years, and feel it fits what you’re looking for in your first post. It has a bright and lively sound on the treble, and is quite light. The lightness comes from it being a smaller case, and the button spacing is narrower than full sized boxes. It’s not quite as a narrow as a Lilly though.
The basses aren’t huge but it’s quite well balanced with the treble ( I think the earliest model Benny had a different bass end which was sometimes criticised for its lightness.)

I can play everything I want on it, most of my repertoire is D or G but I have tried tunes in Gm, Bb, A, Dm since I’ve had it with reasonable success.  Mine is Bob Ellis layout, which has G scale with an extra button  down to a lower D and G. Chas Blacker, “CAB” on this forum, has a very similar Benny. His recent klezmerised Atholl Highlanders post is an amazing demonstration of the possibilities.

I have recently been playing a DG Mory, and it is a magnificent beast, the three voice sound is deep and resonant and allows you to play further up the keyboard. Its heaviness is only an issue for me when first lifting it into a playing position or carrying it around in its case. On the lap it’s less noticeable, and from having read the various comments on this site, I was very surprised at how easy it is to play up and down the row. The bellows move a lot of air, and it only takes a delicate pulse to change direction back and forth.
I’m less keen on its 2 voice sound, the Benny just sounds a lot more fun.

I miss a couple of reversals that come with the full three row, but I feel that having the accidentals in around the right position relative to the other rows makes off piste playing less of a drama. I’ve never really been able to properly cope with accidentals on a 4th start 2 row.

I did try a Rik at the time of buying the Benny, and at the time the lightness and the “perky” sound of the Benny drew me in that direction.

This discussion does of course highlight the reason we all need more melodeons, there is no single box that ticks all the boxes.

I think you have to try them for yourself, and do some hard thinking on layout. A pilgrimage to Pete at Acorn would give you the opportunity to try several Castagnaris for sound and feel.

Good luck!
Gren

Thank you for your opinions! It speaks much in favor for the Benny, but it sounds as I must do the pilgrimage at some point, yes!

Hi.
I have several Castagnari 3 row boxes in stock new.
Castagnari Evo,Matris,Rik,Handry,Benny and Big 18.
I also have Handry 12 and 18, 2 Benny pre owned.
DG and GC.
Al pre owned to go on web site next week

Sounds great! Hope some of them are still left for the course weekend in april, if I make it there!   ;D
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Ignatius Blumenfeld on September 23, 2025, 06:37:14 PM
I came across this thread as I am currently thinking of buying a nice DG melodeon. Which melodeon making company is the "best"? I am looking at Castagnari, but they are pretty expensive. Are there any companies that might be better for a more reasonable price?

Unfortunately, there aren't really any DG Pokerworks around here in the US.

Thanks!
    Ignatius Blumenfeld

EDIT:

Also, just for reference, I am looking for a three or more voice melodeon with 2 or more rows, but a reasonable price.

Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Theo on September 23, 2025, 07:04:42 PM
With melodeons as with most things you get what you pay for. And what is best depends to a great extent on personal preference.  What to you play now?
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Ignatius Blumenfeld on September 23, 2025, 07:58:38 PM
What to you play now?

I play a GC Pokerwork right now. I really like the loud Hohner sound even if Pokerworks, in general, have problems. I ask these questions because I have never played anything else, therefore, I haven't much of a preference as I have only played one Hohner.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: mChavez on September 23, 2025, 08:00:42 PM
Why do you think that Casta price is unreasonable then?
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Ignatius Blumenfeld on September 23, 2025, 08:21:04 PM
Why do you think that Casta price is unreasonable then?

Sorry, I guess I should have said that it is a little expensive for me. If I can save enough money, I may get myself one, but I was just wondering about any of the other makers, if they were better or worse or if it just depends on the models (is it just a matter of opinion?).

To be clearer, I am wondering what you all think is the better company so that I can narrow my search for melodeons.

Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Squeezebox Of Delights on September 24, 2025, 08:07:15 AM
If you like the Hohner sound then you could consider getting a refurbished Hohner Club box? They came in various sizes and numbers of voices, they're pretty high quality, and there are multiple fettlers who can upgrade them into very nice D/G boxes. Jut a thought!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Toby B on September 24, 2025, 08:22:18 AM
I have a very pleasing Serenellini Gold ... you could check out their 273 or Donna models?

https://www.serenellini.com/diatonic.aspx?lang=en
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: GBbox on September 25, 2025, 10:22:11 AM
I have a very pleasing Serenellini Gold ... you could check out their 273...

https://www.serenellini.com/diatonic.aspx?lang=en

The 273 in the Serenellini advertised in their catalogue is a 3 short row box: 10/9/8 buttons. I play one tuned in A/D/G, but the layout could work well for a 3 row D/G based RH layout.

The model, although as far as I can remember it has ever been officially advertaised in the catalogues, can be customised as a 21/10/6 two and  1/2 row box. My G/C instrument is  one of those boxes, and I've seen others on YouTube.

Excellent instuments, not too heavy in case you wish to play them press and draw. with three banks of reeds. 
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Ignatius Blumenfeld on September 25, 2025, 03:43:00 PM
Thanks!
The Serenellini melodeons look pretty nice! As for Castagnari, would the VAT price on Acorn Instruments be the one I would pay (I being in the US) or would it be the price excluding VAT? I am asking this so that I can then compare prices converted to USD.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 25, 2025, 03:53:59 PM
If you are comparing melodeons, be aware that the extra basses fit into 2 broad categories.
The likes of Castagnari's extra bass buttons give you Bb/F and Eb/F#m.
With thirds out this enables you to play in the flat keys, Bb, Gm, Am etc.

Others such as Saltarelle have a different set of extra buttons that broadly reinforce the home keys of D and G, sometimes being reversals of the basses found on the 8 bass DG.

It's not just a question of what fits your budget, it is also a question of which musical road you wish to go along.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Joan Kureczka on September 26, 2025, 06:07:08 AM
Ignatius -- Emilio Accordions is the rep for Dino Baffetti in the US, and a friend in Tucson was able to get a box from them that is similar to the Oakwood-Baffetti collaboration boxes. Sounded nice and a bit lower price point to Castagnari. Look at the Series 8 boxes.


https://emilioaccordions.com/dino-baffetti-accordions/
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Helena Handcart on September 26, 2025, 01:41:03 PM
As ever it depends what you want to play as others makes give differing options for the extra bass buttons.
Saltarelle give reversals for A and G, plus F# which to my mind gives it a sort of 'super DG' tag.
The likes if Castagnari give you Bb, F, Eb and F#m which if you remove thirds allow you to reasonably explore the flat keys, Bb, F, Am, Gm.

Therefore you can eliminate makers by matching their bass layout with what you want to play.
Then comes the tricky part of choosing a keyboard layout!

Saltarelle bass layouts are not as fixed as you might think. Between us me and Mr Handcart have owned a few* Salties and all bar one have had the Bb/F/Eb/F#m bass config, the oldest these was from the '90s and the newest made just last year.

So even for second hand instruments I don't think you  can eliminate makers like this, plus of course for a new to-order instrument you can have pretty much what you fancy.

* actually four, three of which had the Bb/F/Eb/F#m basses. Only the Rivage (I think) had pull G/push A etc.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 26, 2025, 03:09:02 PM
Ah fair enough. I know you know your Salties better than me.
I bow to your knowledge ... (:)
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on September 26, 2025, 03:22:23 PM
I've just looked on the Forum's layout pages for 2.5 Saltarelle, my only reference to them.
Here they list 3 different layouts, all having a A/G reversal as one of the two extra basses.
I am now confused!
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: Theo on September 26, 2025, 05:06:12 PM
I am now confused!

So are many of us.  The ones who aren’t confused are the ones who have been playing long enough to decide what is best for their own style of playing and repertoire.
Title: Re: Advice on 2.5 or 3 row DG melodeon
Post by: -Y- on September 26, 2025, 05:20:32 PM
Saltarelle bass layouts are not as fixed as you might think.

Trying very hard not to make jokes about fixed things on Saltarelles  >:E.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal