Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Michael Driscoll on January 16, 2025, 01:23:16 AM
-
Someone has sold me a D/G which he thought was a B/C box. If I keep it and try to play it across the rows, can it be done or would I be better to play up & down the 2 rows seperately - if that makes any sense?
-
Most D/G players do a bit of both. Basically up and down the row for the key you're playing in, but with excursions to the other row when it helps with LH basses/chords, or sometimes to help with fingerings or bellows management.
-
As Anahata has explained, fluent D/G players use both rows. The two rows are in different keys, but those keys share all the same notes apart from C/C#. Most beginners start by playing along the rows but later find that it can be helpful to use the alternative note on the other row. For example, if you want to play a G chord with a G note when in the key of D you will need to cross to the G row to find the G note on the push.
However this is not the same as playing it like a semitone box, which has only a few reversals. On a B/C, as far as I can see, only the Bs and Es have alternative options and for all the other notes there is only one choice of button and bellows direction. It's a very different approach to playing.
-
I have in the past, tried lifting just the G row up to a fourth button start which then puts the C natural note from this row into the same position as it would be on a D/D# box.
This is ok if playing in the Irish-American 'outside-in' style and brings many of the available reversals a bit closer to each other.
Personally, I find that some G tunes are a challenge on the D row yet obviously sit nice'n easy on the G row. This is why I tried this system out.
There are some interesting and fluid fingering patterns that become available from either row. Needless to say though, it means learning a different way around the box and one still ends up missing the semitone notes/accidentals that are available on the semitone systems.
-
And...it devalues your melodeon!
-
Thanks to all - food for thought. “ It's a very different approach to playingâ€. -still uncertain whether to keep it or not. I tend to play Irish/Scottish,( a lot of D & G I suppose.) Not so much the “Morris dancingâ€.
-
If you’re used to playing across the rows on a semitone box but interested in exploring the possibilities of the fourth apart system (ie fuller functionality combining both hands), you could try Dutch Reversal…
-
Thanks to all - food for thought. “ It's a very different approach to playingâ€. -still uncertain whether to keep it or not. I tend to play Irish/Scottish,( a lot of D & G I suppose.) Not so much the “Morris dancingâ€.
You can certainly play Irish and Scottish music on a D/G. Scottish pipe tunes typically notated in A fit well too, as they don't need a G♯.
I remember meeting Tim Edey before he was famous and he was playing terrific Irish music on a D/G. Not to mention that there are wonderful Irish single-row players.
The question is really whether you want to learn a new system or just stick to B/C because that's what you're used to. You won't have any trouble playing both systems after a while.
-
Dave Mallinson was pretty fluent at Irish music on a D/G and … had a strong left arm. 😉🙄 He used to busk on the Baxtergate corner at Whitby, and taught some very useful seminars before he set up his music business. I think he published a book on it?
https://youtu.be/fd4DJpxsSqY
-
I shall keep it and add learning it to my lengthening bucket list.
I have now just picked up on the earlier discussions B/C v D/G 11 years ago. A lot to be looked at.
Thanks again.