Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Mike Keen on January 19, 2025, 09:30:33 AM
-
I'm just after a little Dino reed information. Sorry if this has been discussed before.
Probably most melodeon player end up acquiring a number of boxes. I have (courtesy of Lester) a GC Hohner, and also Serenellini 213K Italian boxes (DG LMM and GC MMM) that are over 20 years old (fitted with Antonelli Dural reeds), and a Carnival 3 (from Squeezebox Marketplace) about 5 years old that I haven't looked inside yet. My modern Dino (tuned about 8 cents), and the wetter Hohner are more subtle than the 213K's (tunes 20'ish cents).
I just wondered what reeds Basic older and newer Dino Baffetti used. I'm thinking of boxes like the Carnival 2/3 and Art 85 (it's s different name for the Carnival 3 I think)? Would the older Dinos likely also be Antonelli Dural? Also (if it's possible to describe) how different the sound from is modern vociarmoniche super dural and the old Antonelli dural. All my boxes are at different degrees of wetness so I know it's difficult to compare reed sound.
Finally How do the older Baffetti Carnival 3's compare to the old Serenellinis, are they very similar or are there significant differences in sound.
Many thanks Mike [
Mike ps I didn't mentioned the lovely Excelsior GC box I bought from Lars as I didn't want to give the impression I've got a collecting habit.
-
I have a little Dino from the early 90s, DG, and can't make out the reed brand, so I'm interested to hear any answers to this. I'd guess Cagnoni. They're not Binci or anything fancy like that…but they're super loud ..almost deafening (though not quite as thuggish as Binci reeds) and respond better than a modern bog standard Dino Carnival. The box itself is quite small..a bit bigger than a Lilly, but two voice. And with floral bellows paper, so one of the early imports, i was informed (by a customer who seemed to know the history of Dinos in the UK).
-
Dino Baffetti and some other makers don’t provide a lot of information about the reeds they use. Sometimes you can see makers marks on the reeds but most of the time this is only on high end boxes. Reed makers have changed their production methods over time which also complicates matters. So most of the time I don’t know who has made the reeds in a box that I have in front of me. Generally it doesn’t matter because you can tell all you need to know by playing the instrument. Also bear in mind that it’s not just the make of reed that determines the sound and responsiveness. The whole design of the instrument and the way the reeds are set up are just as important.
Going back to the Carnival - I had one of these early on in my playing. I had a Hohner but I wanted an Italian box with a wood finish. I soon regretted trading the Hohner for the Dino because it just didn’t play so well and I didn’t keep it much longer. I traded it for a Saltarelle Berry which was much more responsive. On paper both had similar quality Cagnoni reeds, but in practice they were very different.