Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: kenthorseman on December 09, 2009, 03:47:50 PM
-
:M :M :M I nhave been trying to find someone who is willing to try and teach an old dog new tricks, it seems up in this part of kent, melodeon is a secret society, i see plenty of morris sides of which im a member of one, but trying to learn the box is driving me mad, the new year must be a turning point, surely there is some one who teaches around here.
-
North Kent? Isn't that called ESSEX.
-
Nah theres wet stuff and a pipe in the way, on an hitorical note you are correct much of what is now essex was kent. as was much of londinium.
-
Nah theres wet stuff and a pipe in the way,
*waves from other side of the wet stuff*
-
Yes, I was born in SE5 and moved a week later to Kent, which another week later became SE9. Everything in my early memories has GLC stamped on it (even the loo paper).
Rob.
-
Might be worth asking some of the box players from Morris for a few tips and hints. That's what I did when I was learning fiddle and it worked fine for me.
-
Might be worth asking some of the box players from Morris for a few tips and hints. That's what I did when I was learning fiddle and it worked fine for me.
Tried that, seems they must be in the national secret melodeon society, at festivals, etc all sweetness and tips on what to learn in fact even showing how to, but then everything goes dark and distant until the naxt festival or such like, i think this part of the world is a melodeon free zone, bloody boris is behind it i bet.
-
I taught myself and found that I could play a tune almost immediately but had to learn how to add the bass notes. This lucky break happened because I could already play the mouth organ (I was no Larry Adler though).
So, if you play the old gob iron you have a head start.
-
:|glug :M ??? think i will stick to drumming and drinking not always in that order and sod the erica it can live in the bloody loft. I give up
off to the boozer might get snowed in, oh what a shame, snowed into the pub.
-
Come on melnetters! surely there must be one person in Kent who can give Kenthorseman a leg up into box playing. You don't need any certificates! Just an ability to play one more tune that the person you are helping!
-
Another vote for Mally!
Get the first book and the CD that goes with it.
Work through it page by page in order and and you will be as good as (or better than) 1/2 of the players on YouTube. (might be slight exageration).
But really, Kentsman, when you get even 1/2 way through Mally, you will be able to learn all kinds of stuff off of a combination of melnet, youtube and the tune sites, such as Loffet's.
Mally has the key stuff, crossing over, crossing row, basic bass, etc. in the first 1/2.
Good luck.
-
:|glug :|glug :|glug :-\ :-\ sits there looking at beer then erica then beer then erica oh sod it get the book out again , its just i am one of those that seems to learn by watching step by step rather than look at book then try and make it all work, scales cords wwwhhhhaaatttt theys for measureing and tying aint they, so am sitting on the edge of becoming a boozing drummer, (no im already one of them) or having one last go at the box, which incidently i love but sadly cant drive. oh well, bring out the sambuka chaser.
-
I agree, John Kirkpatrick's video tutorials are really useful; they, along with Mally, helped me get going playing box.
-
I agree, John Kirkpatrick's video tutorials are really useful; they, along with Mally, helped me get going playing box.
Yeah most of the time I've only got books, DVD and the lovely people on melnet.
Have you signed up for any workshops?
-
I used Mally's book, self taught in the kitchen (cooking and box playing but not at the same time :Ph)
I ventured to a session without my box as I was way too nervous but got talking to a box player there who was so helpful and arranged a get together with another box player too for some tune playing. It helped so much. I think, there's a different approach to learning music in the folk world which isn't usually paying money for lessons. Self taught is fine for some people, and if you go to a few sessions, you will find, like on here, box players that are more than willing to give you guidance and prob the odd free lesson. Think it's a continuous process, I still feel very much a beginner, the more I learn, the more I realise I have to learn, but that's great. :|||:
Cheers
Sandy
p.s. I also think a good workshop can give you a lifetime of things to be working on !!
(:)
-
I'm about as far west and south as it's possible to be in Kent, just six miles from Rye, and presume kenthorseman is somewhere up on the Medway or the Isle of Grain. Also I'm not much of a melodeon player really, but would be happy to have a get together when the weather is a bit better if it would help.
Pete. :||:
-
Im nearer the bridge and tunnel than rye im afraid, in fact about five minutes by horse and cart from the tunnel so even bottom end of essex is closer if i could still walk on water, mind you with the weather as it is i could probably walk over to essex, Have i signed up for workshops, what workshops, seems everywhere i go in this part of kent there are box players, but as soon as i say how do you do that, huh its a secret, i got john kirkpatricks dvd but find it hard to follow as i cant slow the bloody player down, got georges book, yup seems easy but i cant get the tune im tryin to play, god i must be bloody slow dim or ****ing stupid. really i do so want to get to play this devils spawn box but need a leg up , im just about on the point of selling my lovely black kraut made box. thanks for all the tips but please ive tried most of em, but seems im here in a melodeon desert.
-
Not wanting to be too pc about it, but, geez, "kraut made"??
-
and pc sorry pc im not, one of romany parentage i get far worse, but hey ho ifn i crossed a line sorry but thats me im afraid
-
If you were to be more forthcoming about what you're trying to play and why it isn't working, maybe people here could give you a some more specific assistance? Forum members here have proven to be of great help during my own learning process, so I know, first hand, that asking questions can work well in this way. However, you can't really expect to get a useful answer unless you're explicit about what's going wrong. For instance, is it bellows technique, a particular type of tune, fingering, rhythms?
Whilst I'm sure that finding an appropriate teacher would be a great step forward, as others have mentioned before, there are other options to take that can and do work if you stay positive and realistic about what you can achieve. Going by past comments, it would seem that many of us have learned without a teacher, instead picking up tips and techniques from whatever source is available along the way. Technology, for sure, has opened up a pool of knowledge that would have previously been very difficult to acquire, so the alternative options for learning now are far greater than they ever could have been a decade ago.
From what you've said previously, it seems you've tried at least some of this too, but without success. So, is there something you're missing in terms of how you go about remembering and applying such knowledge? Maybe just something as simple as keeping a notebook or log would help you? Or perhaps making brief audio or video recordings, so you can hear/see what's happening after the event? Or just being more analytical when you listen to other players? Of course, sometimes a big problem is much easier to solve if you break it down to lots of little ones.
-
So here I was thinking that in the UK you couldn't swing a dead cat without hitting a box player (southern Colloquialism) Maybe it's a box player who is willing to teach is rare. I remember the first player I asked to teach me, his reply was "what and waste all my hard earned skill on a beginner!" I think it's really hard to find someone who has the patience to sit for a half hour and actually teach.
-
Ken--another idea: maybe you are setting your goals too high too fast.
In some ways, that's what a lot of players have gained from the Mally book. Don't try too hard, don't worry about not being the next John K or R Tesi (or even DTN!). Just try to learn some scales on each row, learn Row Row Row your Boat, etc.
I remember when I could actually play Egan's Polka and Cock of the North from Mally's book, with "um cha" basses, I thought "I am the ruler of the melodeon universe". And it took MONTHS to get there.
-
i think my prob is i get a tune in my head mainly morris tunes (border) i may get a few of the notes then as soon as i make a mistake i cant get back to where i was to start with, i dont think im aiming too high but all i want is to pick the box up and play a tune or two, nothing hard, winster processional or such will be a good start, i cant even get that. ooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh sambuca and beer chasers seem really good at the mo. cheers to all for the suggestions. :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug :|glug ;D
-
One of the great things about playing for border is that the rythm is so much more important than getting all the notes right. Indeed it is a common belief in Hook Eagle's band that the tune should never sound the same twice over - improvisation and rythmic variation is the order of the day. I'm the one without the brain to achieve this and they use my "boring" playing to bounce off! The more you join in with the band, the more you can relax about the whole thing and it comes easy after a while.
Rob.
-
all i want is to pick the box up and play a tune or two, nothing hard, winster processional or such will be a good start,
I think that is what many of us want, but it does entail a certain investment of time and energy to learn and internalise the patterns of finger/button/bellows movements.
I'm guessing here but maybe you are expecting to achieve things too quickly?
Have you tried working on the same tune for 20 minutes a day for say a month? I think that is a reasonable amount of time to have to spend in initially, though individuals vary, and some need more or less time.
-
i try to practicce daily but and its not an excuse , i do get dragged into other things such as the horse needs feeding etc, but i do honestly try to practice, but i get as already said lost in what im trying to play, i dont read dots so am using mallys book, but then i get lost in what the bloomin tune is , oh im a lost cause, back to the drums and booze
-
Even with a teacher it took me about two weeks of serious nightly .5 to 1 hour repetitious practice to get my first tune down. It gets easier after that but I still work on a tune 1-2 weeks before I can play it somewhat well. It's easy to get discouraged if you think that your going to have your first real tune aside from Mary Had a Little Lamb or Row Row Row. Maybe I'm just slow but in 8 months I've memorized only 8 tunes and that has taken all my patience but I feel it is worth it. Do like Theo recommends and you will make progress then things will start to click. Also try using the Abc notation system which there are links to on this site. It helped me a great deal.
-
I find it very difficult to learrn a tune on the box unless I can whistle it without conscious thought. To that end, I like to find a recording of the tune I want and play it in the car either until I've got it or no-one will accept a lift anymore! Trying to actually learn the tune and learn to play it is an overload for me.
Rob.
-
I find it very difficult to learrn a tune on the box unless I can whistle it without conscious thought. To that end, I like to find a recording of the tune I want and play it in the car either until I've got it or no-one will accept a lift anymore! Trying to actually learn the tune and learn to play it is an overload for me.
Rob.
Actually that's a good point. I sometimes have to listen to a tune ad nausea um (sp) to finally get it right.
-
Hook Eagle's band that the tune should never sound the same twice over - improvisation and rythmic variation is the order of the day. I'm the one without the brain to achieve this and they use my "boring" playing to bounce off!
Rob.
Thanks for making this possible Rob! ... ;D ;D ;D
DTN (Hook Eagle) 8)
-
My daughter is looking for someone to teach some fundamentals too. She lives in Wooton Basset , near Swindon if someone is up for it. :|glug
-
... i dont read dots ...
I'm sure it would be worth your while learning to read music. Forget (for the moment) any idea of being able to learn a tune straight from music, but think of it as a way to remind yourself of what exact notes make up the tune that you have in your head.
-
... i dont read dots ...
I'm sure it would be worth your while learning to read music. Forget (for the moment) any idea of being able to learn a tune straight from music, but think of it as a way to remind yourself of what exact notes make up the tune that you have in your head.
I really don't understand why people don't just learn which button does which note, its not hard the keyboard layouts are here. Once you have that in your head playing tunes from music (I write the notes under the stave to save me having to work out which is which) can be purely mechanical - I need to play a B it's the 4 button down push on the inside row etc. When I started I had a keyboard layout and the tune in front of me and just hacked through it. Mind you I'm an engineer by trade so may be this is not an artists way of working.
-
... i dont read dots ...
I'm sure it would be worth your while learning to read music. Forget (for the moment) any idea of being able to learn a tune straight from music, but think of it as a way to remind yourself of what exact notes make up the tune that you have in your head.
I really don't understand why people don't just learn which button does which note, its not hard the keyboard layouts are here. Once you have that in your head playing tunes from music (I write the notes under the stave to save me having to work out which is which) can be purely mechanical - I need to play a B it's the 4 button down push on the inside row etc. When I started I had a keyboard layout and the tune in front of me and just hacked through it. Mind you I'm an engineer by trade so may be this is not an artists way of working.
As an Electrician (retired) Lester you have it right.
I don't read. so I write the button numbers over the notes with an up arrow if it's a pull. Easy Peasy. :|glug
-
now that i can do, all i gotta do is translate the dots to nombers and arrows, easy peasy, ah wots a g dot look like so i can give it a number and an arrow, well got mallys book out and havin another go :|glug :|glug :|glug ??? ??? ???
-
Go to http://info.melodeon.net/files/site/DG21acc.gif , memorise it completely and follow the instructions on the cover of "The Hitch-hiker's Guide to The Galaxy" ini large friendly letters. ;D :||: ;D
Chris-the-not-very-good-yet-but-getting-better-honest!
-
I would say that it is better to learn the relative distances between buttons from say the G on the G row than learn which button does which. Otherwise you end up glancing down at your hands all the time. Much better to know that from G the nearest B pull is there and the nearest F# push is there.
-
Imho it's not about whether you read music or play by ear, follow Mally's book or Kirkpatricks's DVD or whatever. It's about whether you actually want to practice the melodeon. Learning any musical instrument gets harder the older you are, we're just not hard-wired to do it. So you have to enjoy wrestling with the bloody thing until you get a tune out of it and you have to enjoy it more than watching TV, going to work, drinking sambuccas, sleeping, eating cheese and pickle sandwiches, anything. I'm a drummer too and the box is the only other instrument I've ever felt like that about. Don't put it away, leave it out where you'll fall over it if you don't pick it up, then pick it up and play it every day and don't stop playing it until someone threatens you with physical violence. Keep doing that for two years and you'll surprise yourself.
-
Imho it's not about whether you read music or play by ear, follow Mally's book or Kirkpatricks's DVD or whatever. It's about whether you actually want to practice the melodeon. Learning any musical instrument gets harder the older you are, we're just not hard-wired to do it. So you have to enjoy wrestling with the bloody thing until you get a tune out of it and you have to enjoy it more than watching TV, going to work, drinking sambuccas, sleeping, eating cheese and pickle sandwiches, anything. I'm a drummer too and the box is the only other instrument I've ever felt like that about. Don't put it away, leave it out where you'll fall over it if you don't pick it up, then pick it up and play it every day and don't stop playing it until someone threatens you with physical violence. Keep doing that for two years and you'll surprise yourself.
Totally agree, it's about perseverance and sheer bl**dyminded stubborness. Ya really got to want to learn it otherwise you will quit before you get started!
-
Very much in agreement. Unfortunately, no pain, no gain.
On the good side, there is a steepening of the learning curve, after that initial, painful first, many months, almost flat space. Once you have a little of the basics, many things seem to come a lot easier and faster.
Unfortunately, then you hit another plateau where you realize that you will never/may never play like the great players. For sheer crazy coolness, DTN has now replaced Tony Hall in my pantheon. Where does he get these musical ideas?
-
yeh bring it on you bloody box or become a door stop
-
I'll give you a fiver for that doorstop mate. >:E
-
in ya dreams buddyboy sooner bin it