Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Louis Leger on March 22, 2025, 04:22:05 PM
-
Hi. I'm working on a Marcel Messervier accordion and I noticed that there is a mixture of Binci and Hohner reeds inside. Most of the reeds are Binci but there is one bank that has mostly Hohner gold anodized reeds, marked with an "H". I'm wondering if this was intentional on the part of the builder, maybe he ran out of Bincis, or maybe wanted a different sound for that bank. Then again, maybe someone substituted the Hohners later. Any thoughts or comments?
-
"H" means B natural on Germany. Here that's probably the scale CDEFGABC
B defaults to having a Bb, ie = diatonic scale of F major.
Unlikely to refer to Binci v. Hohner 😉
-
Obviously Hohner used to stamp H on H-scale plates, but I am not aware of H-plated gold anodized Hohner reeds. Is the H stamped on the plates?
I am aware of Artiste Gold reeds - I'd say early generations of them were somewhere between TAM and AM quality wise. Later on the quality dropped to the bottom range of TAM in Italian grading equivalents.
Funny, I was just thinking about this the other day - you don't see reed brands mixed, but I think there can be interesting effects if one was to combine a set of fundamental-focused Russian or Dix reeds with something more overtone-rich, like Italians or Hohners.
Anything special in the accordion sound?
-
I doubt the H has anything to do with key/tuning. H like Hohner...
Examining the waxing and the valves on these non-Binci reeds may help you find if they are original or a later modification. Obviously, the older the accordion is the more likely it could have been modified.
-
I agree with Tirpous’ notes.
I’ve worked on a number of Messervier boxes (both newer and older) and have never seen a mix of reeds in any of them. I’ve occasionally seen Quebec-made boxes that had a mix of Binci and Salpa reeds, and I presumed in these cases the builder just used up what they had available at the time (rather than making an intentional choice to use two different make of reeds).
Photos?
-
He is a photo of the reed mix in the Messervier
-
On the photo that looks like brass, not gold aluminium.
The rivets are Italian-style, hand-riveted.
The shape of the reeds does not immediately strike me as Hohner H-scale.
I don't think this is a Hohner.
Looking at how far back the reed steel was filed, it might be even the same brand as the rest of the box. Going by the sexy rivet shape and the blued steel edge, the rest are a-mano.
It could be that the reed supplier ran out of a-manos in that spec and replaced a part of them with their other a-mano or high end TAM model?
-
I agree that those look like Italian brass plate reeds, not anodised aluminium. But it’s very curious that they are mated with “Hâ€.
-
But is it an 'H' ? It's hard to say for sure from the photo, but it may well be an 'M'. Messerviers are sometimes fitted with M-stamped Italian reeds instead of Bincis.
Later: Ooops sorry, H it is ! (I was viewing with a phone earlier - limited resolution).
-
How about recycled plates re worked reeds?
-
Here's is a close-up of the "H" reed. There are 4 banks of reeds: H,L,M,M and the "H" reeds are all in the last M bank, the one that is tuned to pitch rather than the other M bank which is tuned about 10 cents sharper for the tremolo effect. The two different reeds seem compatible and the sound is consistent throughout. It has that nice loud, punchy sound of a Messervier Quebec accordion. I just can't figure out why there would be a mixture of different types of reeds in one of the banks.
-
@folkloristmark
Why? Plates are cheap as chips.
All the labour goes into fitting the reed to the slot, profiling the reed tongue, fine-tuning and set-up.
By the time you've carefully filed off the old rivet and freed up the plate you'll take about as long as making new plates.
-
Why ? because you can. :|||:
-
"Because you can" is a common explanation for doing things for which more 'normal' people can see no reason.
You either get it, or you don't!
-
There used to be several models of Hohner piano accordions that were made using TAM/A-Mano reeds instead of the standard Hohner reed. I’ve seen a few examples although I can’t recall if they were stamped with an H or T. It’s possible that these were repurposed by Marcel in this case, the reason quite possibly being that he had to make use of what he had available at the time, if he happened to not have a full set of Bincis on hand to complete the instrument.
-
Hohners sometimes used a-mano Italian reeds, for example for some Morinos - those reeds had nothing to do with Hohner.
They also had so-called "super-Artistes" where italian a mano reeds were riveted onto Artiste plates. But these are marked with a dot, not letter, and they are regular Artiste scale.
In any case, interesting box & interesting observation re mysterious H reeds.
-
Hohners sometimes used a-mano Italian reeds, for example for some Morinos - those reeds had nothing to do with Hohner.
They also had so-called "super-Artistes" where italian a mano reeds were riveted onto Artiste plates. But these are marked with a dot, not letter, and they are regular Artiste scale.
In any case, interesting box & interesting observation re mysterious H reeds.
I do realize they were not reeds made by Hohner, but it’s possible they were stamped with an ‘H’ by the maker for Hohner, in the same way that a (presumably) Italian maker had ‘M’ stamped onto reeds destined for some of Messervier’s instruments (I mean, that could be coincidental, but I’m doubtful).
-
Fair enough.
The only "M"-stamped reeds I've seen were Meinel & Herold.
It sure is confusing - stamping letters on reedplates. ;D
-
M-reeds (possibly Salpas) in a Messervier.