Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: Huw Adamson on April 01, 2025, 05:04:16 AM
-
Good morning/afternoon/evening all.
I am a longtime D/G box player, and have recently picked up a lovely HA-114, a one-row hohner in D with a spoon bass. On my D/G, I am used to having my thumb on the air button, and maintaining strap pressure with a slight curve of my hand between my thumb and the bottom of my palm. This allows my to 'relieve' the pressure by straightening my palm, allowing my hand to move a little in the strap to reach different bass buttons.
On my new spoon bass, my air button is now in a totally different position, behind the keyboard, which ruins my usual technique. Short of tightening the left hand strap so that it's completely pressing against my hand, holding it in place, I'm not sure how to keep the left hand feeling tight. Does anyone have any suggestions, or even know what I'm talking about? Are there any existing threads on this question I haven't been able to find with my mediocre search terms?
Lots of love,
Huw
-
I've seen a carefully carved wooden insert used on a Hohner growl box, providing a very comfortable fit and, no slippage. There was a man in Suffolk who used to make them, but I doubt he's still even alive now.
It's so different from a conventional melodeon bass box that you'll have to develop a different hold and get used to it, in any case.
-
To operate the air button you need to use the fleshy part of the hand at the bass of your thumb.
It's a different technique to a two row box where you use the end of your thumb.
-
I'm somewhat surprised at your query, Huw.
I had the advantage of starting off with a 1 row, but it seems to me that when the growl box is grasped; the spoons are just there in the correct place to operate with fingers and thumb 'root'.
-
Like Winston, I was surprised in the same way when I got my 114. The fat part of the thumb pad was sitting right there.
I did pad the distance tween the spoon and the wood so there's some limit to stop the smoosh.
-
On my new spoon bass, my air button is now in a totally different position, behind the keyboard, which ruins my usual technique. Short of tightening the left hand strap so that it's completely pressing against my hand, holding it in place, I'm not sure how to keep the left hand feeling tight. Does anyone have any suggestions, or even know what I'm talking about?
If you have the strap reasonably tight (without strangling your hand!), it's very possible to 'cam-lock' the hand in position by slightly bending the fingers so that they form an angle with the palm and fingers of the hand (like: ---^), especially if the knuckles are under the strap. To me, this is basically the same as on a 2-row except the contact points and strap adjustement are different.
I seem to operate the spoons with whatever part of the finger happens to be at hand (pun intended), making no effort to use finger tips. Base of thumb was mentioned for the air spoon, but likewise it's maybe more the 2nd finger joint for bass/chords. I've never felt a need to install a travel limit or padding on the spoons - my finger tips almost touching the fondo-baseplate act as a stop.
Anyway, this is what works for me. I encourage you to experiment and maybe watch videos to get ideas. Soon enough you will hopefully find your own comfort-zone !
-
Also, don't forget to take a look at Tufty Swiftts mini-treatise on the one row.
-
Also, don't forget to take a look at Tufty Swiftts mini-treatise on the one row.
http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/catalogues/Hints%20and%20tips%20Tufty%20Swift.pdf (http://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/catalogues/Hints%20and%20tips%20Tufty%20Swift.pdf)