Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Siri Caplan on April 04, 2025, 01:37:38 PM

Title: Choice of instrument for traditional Scottish music
Post by: Siri Caplan on April 04, 2025, 01:37:38 PM
Hello, I'm new to this forum.

I plan to take up melodeon. I played piano accordion for years, then had an enforced break due to living circumstances. Now I am free to take up playing again and I want to move to a quieter, more compact instrument. I considered getting a compact BCC# accordion with stradella bass but have always really loved the tone of melodeons and now the decision is made.

After research I have concluded that the stand-out choice for the wide range of keys needed for trad Scottish music would be (eventually) a 3-row BCC#, with 18 bass keys. I know they are on the heavy side (but not as heavy as a BCC# button accordion...).

The plan would be to start out with a decent pre-owned 2-row BC and once I know what I like/want in the way of layout, to maybe upgrade to 3 row if it still felt necessary. I am just airing my thoughts because before buying my first instrument it would be good to have a clear idea of the possible direction of travel for the future. I would appreciate experienced feedback or recommendations. Thanks!
Title: Re: Choice of instrument for traditional Scottish music
Post by: rees on April 04, 2025, 01:59:55 PM
Good plan to start on a 2 row B/C. Your best bet is a Hohner Double Ray.
See the video below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuphefLxUsM (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuphefLxUsM)

If it's good enough for Jimmy Shand .........
Title: Re: Choice of instrument for traditional Scottish music
Post by: Siri Caplan on April 05, 2025, 06:00:06 PM
Thanks for the recommendation. Is a Double Ray a better choice than a Pokerwork? I did see one B/C advertised.

I'll certainly take a look at the Double Rays - especially if I could find a 3 voice with 12 bass. I do have a prejudice against red celluloid though! (my first accordion was a dreadful Chinese red celluloid effort that sounded like cats fighting...).

Do you (or anyone else) happen to know what model of Hohner Will Allan plays (2 1/2 row with no front grill)? I love the sound of it.
Title: Re: Choice of instrument for traditional Scottish music
Post by: Theo on April 05, 2025, 07:05:57 PM
Will Allen plays a modified Hohner Club 2 originally made in the 1930s, now fitted with top quality Italian reeds on DG.
Title: Re: Choice of instrument for traditional Scottish music
Post by: Siri Caplan on April 05, 2025, 08:36:10 PM
Thanks - I did suspect he would have done a bit of an upgrade on it ... ;D
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal