Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Recordings and Videos => Topic started by: mChavez on April 05, 2025, 03:13:47 PM
-
As some of you know, I've gone unisonoric about half a year ago. >:E
I'm sure there's a couple folks here who play the so called "hromka" or "garmoshka", so I figured I'd create a separate thread for it in case anyone else wants to join the fun (as long as we don't start arguing whether it's a "melodeon" or not ;D)
Finally spent some time figuring out how to connect my field recorder to the new Linux PC and how to get the audio on youtube, so here's the test track.
Since it's a Russian "Shuya" box in G-D that I'm currently playing, I've gone with the traditional Russian "Oi moroz moroz" tune for it.
https://youtu.be/VptsrzCMXvo
-
I assume everyone's gone quiet because they are waiting for amazon to deliver the pitchforks. "Your unisonoric kind not welcome around here". :-[
Anyway, here's the layout for a Cmaj hromka, with G being the secondary key. Standard ones only have 3 accidentals. What you really want, is an extended range one which gives a full chromatic middle octave.
(https://i.ibb.co/dsBTHPr6/Hromka-Layout.png) (https://ibb.co/HL7S9tVY)
-
I'll show few of my garmoshkas then :D
Is your's the one on the youtube video photo? Looks to be the same one as I have, just in a restored and refreshed shape :D
https://youtu.be/3g4ADmDANws (https://youtu.be/3g4ADmDANws) A tune from Udmurtia played on a C# Tula
https://youtu.be/nBh0UMPDrcQ (https://youtu.be/nBh0UMPDrcQ) a dance tune from Setomaa, Estonia played on a G garmon
-
Ha! There's at least two of us! That's a club.
Yes, it's the 1960s "woody" shuya. There was some nice beech under that old brown paint. I've gone full monty on it, including replacing the old warped fondo and converting it from MMH to LMM.
-
I like what you have done visually with it, the bass buttons look real nice. The original buttons are a bit shit.
Did notice that it didn't really sound like a garmoshka ;)
If I'll remember, I will post pictures of all my garmons. Both of the ones i used in the videos I got for a steal, the Tula in really good shape was only 50 eur and the shuya i got for 180eur.
-
The M reeds are original and the L ones are from a Soviet bayan (just a factory job "era" I think), so the sound in real life is still very "hromka"-ish. I just don't play it in a traditional style.
I do need to play about with my mic placement though - this was the first time I recorded this shuya and first time I tried recording anything this year and into my new linux PC, so a lot of factors to tweak.
How are you finding the C#maj? Is it not too high-pitched? Do you ever venture into the 3rd octave, or do you mainly sit around the 1st?
I'm deciding between going high with Cmaj LLH or going low with Fmaj LMH but I haven't tried either yet, just Gmaj and Amaj.
Buttons - yes, larger bass (10mm is the max you can fit there unless you go for mushroom-tops) bushed with melton cloth, larger treble buttons, all mother of pearl 8). The bigger job was to make new springs to drop the keyboard tension to more acceptable levels, and I've bushed the bass mech with ptfe. It's smooth and very pleasant to play, but it's still not at the same level as a high end Italian accordion, and I don't think it will ever get there.
-
Here's a VanderAa from Estonia:
https://youtu.be/Qh6BL35D9c0?si=KVYTTXyBATUz744D
-
Very interesting!
Looks like a custom layout left & right. I'm struggling to understand the 3-row configuration or how it can possibly work on a hromka.
Tyshkevich had an idea of a 2.5-row hromka in the 70s but it never took off. The "third" row was all accidentals. This one's different.
-
Frans certainly made some hromkas. But his light G/C/accs were also popular
-
Very interesting!
Looks like a custom layout left & right. I'm struggling to understand the 3-row configuration or how it can possibly work on a hromka.
Tyshkevich had an idea of a 2.5-row hromka in the 70s but it never took off. The "third" row was all accidentals. This one's different.
You can find a topic here about this very instrument if you search "Dutch garmoshka?". There you will find a layout for it.
-
Frans said in a makers' FB forum that he'd had an Estonian system commission … about 4 years back.
-
Dutch garmoshka?
Nothing comes up :-\
-
I think the client may have been Estonian, but never mind.
-
I think the client may have been Estonian, but never mind.
Yes, the owner of the instrument is Estonian, I know him personally.
-
Dutch garmoshka?
Nothing comes up :-\
Try searching "Toomas Valk" on the forum, should come up.
-
Still doesn't work r >:(
-
https://youtu.be/KXIkdh5dd2E?si=YYcEshRL8y2pTLs
Toomas Valk : VanderAa
Try using Google search rather than a Forum search.
"Dutch garmoshka? "
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=28043.msg336359#msg336359
-
Ah, thank you very much, I thought it might be the case of quint-apart and I see how the high end of RHS is fudged now.
A bit pointless if you ask me, because regular hromka in Cmaj plays Gmaj as its secondary key anyway. But this 3-row layout does give you a deeper-sounding Amin (which is the only benefit I see) and a lower octave for Gmaj.
And it looks like you're losing the V step A+ for Dmaj in the bass, so you're losing the secondary key of a Gmaj hromka too.
Bizarre and different - yes. But I'm not sure I'd call this an "improvement".
I'll stick to my layout 8)
-
Found a recording of Derbenko's concert.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUb6rcwHJFQ
-
A bit more Derbenko, this time with a bossa nova tune
https://youtu.be/RzZqN06nO4g?list=RDRzZqN06nO4g&t=1939
-
And a lovely organ-like prelude played by one of Derbenko's students.
Quite a nice & refreshing change from the usual 300-notes-a-minute bashing done by professional hromka players these days.
https://youtu.be/kPcp6SBGxIU?list=RDkPcp6SBGxIU&t=1354
-
A fantastic version of "Stepan Razin's dream" by Dmitriy Nesterov (Derbenko's arrangement).
On Tula's top of the line box.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxT0U0YjFro
-
:|||:
Lia Bragina playing a Sergei Smetanin tune.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wMgPlQfs-E