Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Alexander Domagalsky on April 06, 2025, 03:46:40 PM
-
Hello
Beyond the standard G/C diatonic accordions (21 treble + 8 bass buttons), one ca see accordions with more buttons.
The accordion Castagnari G/C with 12 basses comes with chords Ab, Bmi, Eb, Bb.
The chord Bmi is useful when playing tunes in the scale Gmajor/Eminor.
But, on G/C accordion, what is the need for the chords Ab, Eb and Bb? Why just these chords are selected?
Alexander
-
Doesn't make sense to me. Bm is very useful playing in D mode (eg B minor 😉) but the others seem a bit alien
I had F#/Bm and A/F. Used them all …
-
But, on G/C accordion, what is the need for the chords Ab, Eb and Bb? Why just these chords are selected?
Looking at the keyboard layout on Castagnari's site, there are G#/Bb and Eb/C# accidentals buttons provided.
- With the Bb and Eb, it's possible to play a melody in Bb, for which the I-IV-V chords are Bb, Eb and F.
- With the G#, C# and Eb (= D#), it's possible to play in E, for which the I-IV-V chords are E, A, and B.
- With the Eb, G# (= Ab) and Bb, it's possible to play in Eb, for which the I-IV-V chords are Eb, Ab, Bb.
-
Bm, Ab, Eb and Bb here on the continent are the standard four additional chords for the 2 ½ and the 3 row G/C based instruments.
Bm is an obvious choice to play in G and the related modal scales, since it's the missing diatonic minor triad. To play in E minor – tonal harmonic or melodic scales - you actually need a B major chord.
As tirpous says, you can use the other chords to play in different keys, although just using the chin accidentals on a standard two row G/C box you can't really go far.
Than, on a two row instrument I would be definitely fit a C pull chord along the Bm, that eventually could be chosen as a second unisonoric chord.
Yet moving around in thirds, and eventually in fifths, you can use Ab, Eb and Bn both playing in C and G. Chromatic chord progressions aren't common stock among the two row players, but if non diatonic triads are available - beyond the F chord playing in G and the d chord playing in C -, why not using them?
-
Guys thank you for replies.
Sometimes, I try to play simple melodies in scales Bb, Eb to use those chords.
Yet moving around in thirds, and eventually in fifths, you can use Ab, Eb and Bn both playing in C and G. Chromatic chord progressions aren't common stock among the two row players, but if non diatonic triads are available - beyond the F chord playing in G and the d chord playing in C -, why not using them?
What does it mean moving around in thirds, in fifths. Can I see some examples for using chords Ab, Eb and Bb both playing in the scales Cmajor and Gmajor?
-
It's also useful in order to play in Gm and Cm, which are quite common if a bagpipe or a hurdy-gurdy or a bombarde is involved at some point.