Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Clifton Schlicher on April 07, 2025, 01:13:07 AM

Title: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Clifton Schlicher on April 07, 2025, 01:13:07 AM
Is there any advantage to taping thirds on a one row, 4 stop, 2 bass melodeon? Particularly for modal tunes.

Thanks.
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 07, 2025, 09:15:30 AM

  Only if you like the more "raw" sound you'll get. Try it?  Don't use glue 😉
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Anahata on April 07, 2025, 09:36:19 AM
I can't see any point in it. I can stop the 3rds in my D/G, and that's really useful for playing in A minor or anything that needs a B minor chord, or slow tunes that suit a sustained chord accompaniment (the latter to make the chords quieter more than to take the thirds out)
None of the above really applies to a 1 row box.

"Modal tunes" ? No modes on a 1 row have thirds that clash with the thirds in the LH chords.
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: CAB on April 07, 2025, 10:56:47 AM
Exactly.  You can certainly play modal tunes on your one row but you need to stick to the right hand and forget about basses & chords.

For example, on a one row in D, you can play in A mixolydian but the A bass will only work occasionally because it's on the draw and your right hand A note is on the press.  On the same instrument, you can play in E dorian but you don't have an E chord.

So stick to using the left hand on major tunes only.
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Chris Ryall on April 07, 2025, 12:38:13 PM

  I once stood under a chestnut tree in St Chartier watching the late Philippe Bruneau with a protegé. One of the legendary Québec 1-row players

  He played that thing in FIVE different keys!  Some of the notes … weren't actually on the single row but he missed them out.  I the listener knows the tune they ear hears them anyway. Best demonstration of melodeon prestidigitation I have ever witnessed. but it's more about timing are there anything else.

   Cajun players do very similar tricks, further south.
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Steve C. on April 07, 2025, 05:02:00 PM
Chris and I seem of the vintage sometimes.
There is a great Phillppe Bruneau "Hommage" page on Facebook that you do not need Facebook to access.  See below.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/234650539906411/posts/9361972347174139/
About 3/4 down in a massive load of great stuff is a video of the great one with at least 4 or 5 melodeons at his feet.  I saw him one time at Mariposa  or Festival des Deux Mondes (?) (1974?) and even though green as a gourd he attempted to show me a waltz and I am "almost sure" his box did not have the same notes as mine (!)
BTW the page is FULL of great Franco and French-Canadian stuff.  Hugh Totally.
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Dick Rees on April 07, 2025, 05:41:54 PM

  I once stood under a chestnut tree in St Chartier watching the late Philippe Bruneau with a protegé. One of the legendary Québec 1-row players

  He played that thing in FIVE different keys!  Some of the notes … weren't actually on the single row but he missed them out.  I the listener knows the tune they ear hears them anyway. Best demonstration of melodeon prestidigitation I have ever witnessed. but it's more about timing are there anything else.


Yes, music is more than playing the "right" notes in proper order...
Title: Re: one row, 4 stop, 2 bass taping thirds
Post by: Steve C. on April 08, 2025, 01:00:50 PM
BTW, my bad on the Facebook. The link will lock you up.
Although I do not use FB, you can go there through your Google. Cannot live in States w/o a G acct.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal