Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Arnold on April 14, 2025, 05:22:11 PM
-
Hi, I’m curious about semitone boxes with Stradella bass, which would help with a potential music production… I know B/C/C# is a well established system, but I’m looking for something more compact, and so having seen a recent listing for the 4 voice l’organola, I considered something like a 2 voice B/C with Stradella bass. However, beyond the 12 bass Double Ray, such an instrument doesn’t seem to exist. To make such an instrument worthwhile, it would need to be at least a 24 bass to capture more keys… Is there such an instrument out there as far as anyone here knows?… thanks
-
Food for thought 1: I've had Darwin and I [very] briefly tried BCC# - Personally, I don't know why anyone would want a mixte. Just go unisonoric with a CBA.
Food for thought 2: 12-fundamental Stradella or 8-fundamental Stradella? If 12, where are you going to put the bass reeds? I've seen 12 bass fundamentals force-fitted into (from memory) a tiny 28cm-tall box. Result? The lower pitched reeds in my bayan's right hand side were larger than the octave-lower short bass fundamentals with grotesque braze-ons in the tiny box. No, thank you. Reeds have to get bigger as the pitch goes down, or you get severe degradation of response, volume, left-right balance and timbre.
Food for thought 3: It's not the total box weight that's bad for push-pulling. It's the weight & balance of the left hand side. So extra row of buttons or an extra voice or two + double cassotto, adding a couple kg in your right hand side is not going to have a negative effect on your push-pulling if the left hand side is the same. Perhaps, just go for a small B/C/C#.
Food for thought 4: You can get a fettler to fit an 8-fundamental Stradella into a 32-cm tall box and have the RHS as BC if you really want it. But do you really need all of them chord buttons in a melodeon (3rds fundamental, fundamental, maj, min, 7th, dim)? Even an 8-bass stradella is a bit of a pig to set up. And, thinking about it, you're not getting any more fundamentals than a 12-bass bisonoric.
-
HOHNER PIROL, easy to modify treble.
Treble 3 rows 34 buttons 2 voice.
Bass 24 (8x3) bass - major - minor.
Weight 3,3 kgs.
-
Food for thought 1: I've had Darwin and I [very] briefly tried BCC# - Personally, I don't know why anyone would want a mixte. Just go unisonoric with a CBA.
Food for thought 2: 12-fundamental Stradella or 8-fundamental Stradella? If 12, where are you going to put the bass reeds? I've seen 12 bass fundamentals force-fitted into (from memory) a tiny 28cm-tall box. Result? The lower pitched reeds in my bayan's right hand side were larger than the octave-lower short bass fundamentals with grotesque braze-ons in the tiny box. No, thank you. Reeds have to get bigger as the pitch goes down, or you get severe degradation of response, volume, left-right balance and timbre.
Food for thought 3: It's not the total box weight that's bad for push-pulling. It's the weight & balance of the left hand side. So extra row of buttons or an extra voice or two + double cassotto, adding a couple kg in your right hand side is not going to have a negative effect on your push-pulling if the left hand side is the same. Perhaps, just go for a small B/C/C#.
Food for thought 4: You can get a fettler to fit an 8-fundamental Stradella into a 32-cm tall box and have the RHS as BC if you really want it. But do you really need all of them chord buttons in a melodeon (3rds fundamental, fundamental, maj, min, 7th, dim)? Even an 8-bass stradella is a bit of a pig to set up. And, thinking about it, you're not getting any more fundamentals than a 12-bass bisonoric.
I’m not sure I’m completely ready for the unisonoric conversation… :Ph Good points. I expected that a full 12 fundamental Stradella would probably not fit in a Pokerwork sized body!.. I understand the thing about RH weight but overall size and weight is still a consideration for me for various reasons… The 8 fundamental bass in my mind would just be, fundamental bass, major chord and minor chord, ie 24 bass… (probably F to F#)
-
8-fundamental, 24-bass makes sense, particularly if you can already play stradella. But would you not want the third C# row in addition to your BC for playing in other keys?
12-fundamental needs a box that's 38cm high.
With mixte, it's definitely worth trying. I tried and decided it's not for me, but your mileage may vary. Some people like them.
-
From my understanding, based on other discussions here and my own experience playing chromatic harmonica (effectively C/C#), the C# row would be most helpful when playing the flat keys, which the 24 bass (F to F#) wouldn’t cater for anyway… if I were to go 3 rows, I would probably favour Mixte or CBA over B/C/C#…
-
If you really want something compact, maybe you could modify a Double Ray to have 12 unisonoric basses on the LH side (maybe fitted with a register to remove the low-bass reeds).
Everything is a compromise.
-
That’s an interesting idea Tirpous… I think I’d prefer to have the chords, especially since they aren’t mostly available on the RH… I think I would need to try the 12 bass Double Ray before I gave the idea any further consideration, but those things are quite rare it seems…
-
With low-bass removed you could play chords (make up your own) on the left. That's what I meant about the register.
-
Food for thought 1: I've had Darwin and I [very] briefly tried BCC# - Personally, I don't know why anyone would want a mixte. Just go unisonoric with a CBA.
For playing both systems (uni- and bisonoric, chromatic and diatonic) I for one would know why anyone would want a mixte accordion: you'd get the same phrasing induced by the bisonoric layout (which, I believe, is great) without having to bother with thinking that much about the left-hand. Also makes life easier for drone-based accompaniment, which is dead useful for modal music (as can, and is most of the time, traditional music).
12-fundamental needs a box that's 38cm high.
Really depends on the reed size and number of voice, and reed spacing. You could be fine with 2 voice, small-size basses (any Gaillard owner is, for instance). I have the 12 fundamentals on a 36 cm box, and I think it could be manageable to go much lower than that, even with proper sized reeds.
-
With low-bass removed you could play chords (make up your own) on the left. That's what I meant about the register.
Ah yes, that sounds pretty neat but possibly a little too left field for what I’m considering…
-
If you really want something compact, maybe you could modify a Double Ray to have 12 unisonoric basses on the LH side (maybe fitted with a register to remove the low-bass reeds).
Everything is a compromise.
They made some like that, so no need to modify.
-
Might it be easier to find a small PA or CBA with a bass end that will work and retrofit the treble side?
-
I was mostly thinking of commercially available instruments, but I do have an old 24 bass Hohner Carmen in the loft, so I’ll hang on to it just in case…
-
Joe Derrane played a D/C# button box with an hybrid LH keyboard made for him by bertrand Gaillard.
A possible compromise?
-
Not sure of the dimensions, but mating a BC or even a BCC# (e.g. the Hohner Trichord) with a 48 bass stradella from a Hohner Student, might be one way to go. The little 2 octave PAs are readily available, though old ones tend to need stripping and having the corrosion removed from the reeds (something to do with the valve glue perhaps). Or even an ancient Student 2 with 24 or 32 bass (not seen one for a while…I restored several a few years ago…i think in fact I may have one…let me know if you are interested). TBH the combo of bisonoric semitone on the RH and stradella on the left is horrible (i think). The Hohner Gaelic is basically PA size and weight but with the rubics cube of bcc# on the RH and 120 stradella on the left, and weighing as much as a wardrobe. I restored one of these once. Impossible to play…
-
Interesting stuff. To make it worthwhile, 24 bass would be the minimum, or else there would be little point, although a 12 bass Double Ray would give me the feel for it. If I could get the Bluebell Polka out of one of those, then the idea might be worth pursuing…
-
To make it worthwhile, 24 bass would be the minimum, or else there would be little point, although a 12 bass Double Ray would give me the feel for it. If I could get the Bluebell Polka out of one of those, then the idea might be worth pursuing…
I should hope so. Bluebell Polka is possible on a D/G 8 bass, including the C music in the correct key of C.
-
Yes (although I think a standard D/G is missing a high G#?), I mean it’s more a case of whether it feels natural to me playing the keys of G and D major on a B/C box (with a little work). I picked that tune because it’s all tonic and dominant chords, so would be manageable on the 12 bass Double Ray…
-
The Hohner Gaelic [...] Impossible to play…
I'm sure I would find it impossible too, but I have sat opposite someone who could play one very well indeed, and the sound of the thing was absolutely glorious.
-
This is a Hohner Nova I converted to BCC#.(2 voice)
Weight is 4.9kg. I did change the buttons because the original ones were too plasticky.
-
Yes (although I think a standard D/G is missing a high G#?),
True!
-
The Hohner Gaelic [...] Impossible to play…
I'm sure I would find it impossible too, but I have sat opposite someone who could play one very well indeed, and the sound of the thing was absolutely glorious.
I’m interested to know whether as a semitone player yourself, you ever considered going for unisonoric basses with your C#/D setup (something like Joe Derrane’s outlined by GBbox), and the whys and whynots?..
-
I’m interested to know whether as a semitone player yourself, you ever considered going for unisonoric basses with your C#/D setup (something like Joe Derrane’s outlined by GBbox), and the whys and whynots?..
I haven't given the matter much thought (I'm not much of a bass player by the way). The 8-bass bisonoric setup I use seems very logical in some ways and downright perverse in others. Not surprising, I suppose, when you consider that it is borrowed from the A/D system... which is why it's basically useless for accompanying tunes in G.
Jackie Daly made himself a box with unisonoric basses at one point but says that in practice he found the advantages were outweighed by the disadvantages - presumably the fact that you have to move around a lot more and cannot exploit the D/A push/pull pair that works really well for tunes in D (most of the time, i.e. except when you need an A on the push!).
Joe Derrane played piano accordion for many years between his early days as a D/C# wizard and his later days in the same capacity, which might explain his preference for a basically unisonoric left hand system.
-
Mengascini built the Bocsa Dubh, 23/60 LMMM = Link to FB video of Daniel McPhee playing one. (https://www.facebook.com/highlandaccordions/videos/daniel-mcphee-plays-the-bluebell-polka-on-the-mengascini-bocsa-dubh-5050/1659063827513943/) But that was 7 years ago, and they don't show it on their catalog anymore.
Someone here showed off a Double Ray with a 12 or 24 bass from a PA grafted onto it. Had to build a matching frame.
I'll quote George Garside, and advise you to just find an old Trichord. 12 basses, 2 voice B/C/C#. But it might be in a sorry state, mine sure is.
Funny that you'd bring this up as I'm playing a bit on my Paolo 3 row, haven't picked it up in a while.
-
I’m interested to know whether as a semitone player yourself, you ever considered going for unisonoric basses with your C#/D setup (something like Joe Derrane’s outlined by GBbox), and the whys and whynots?..
I haven't given the matter much thought (I'm not much of a bass player by the way). The 8-bass bisonoric setup I use seems very logical in some ways and downright perverse in others. Not surprising, I suppose, when you consider that it is borrowed from the A/D system... which is why it's basically useless for accompanying tunes in G.
Jackie Daly made himself a box with unisonoric basses at one point but says that in practice he found the advantages were outweighed by the disadvantages - presumably the fact that you have to move around a lot more and cannot exploit the D/A push/pull pair that works really well for tunes in D (most of the time, i.e. except when you need an A on the push!).
Joe Derrane played piano accordion for many years between his early days as a D/C# wizard and his later days in the same capacity, which might explain his preference for a basically unisonoric left hand system.
Thanks for responding!.. It’s interesting to consider the C#/D because in that system there is a definite home row ie D, and so therefore a stronger inclination to traditional basses, particularly the D/A pair… However, playing the same typical keys (centred around G, D and A) across the rows on a B/C, that partnership between the left and right hand (the traditional melodeon paradigm) is broken, and therefore Stradella bass becomes a different and perhaps preferable proposition…
-
I recently converted a BC box to a 'Joe Burke’ bass layout, half of which is unisoric, it's D/D, G/G, E/A and C/F. It's not one of the layouts included in the ref section of MelNet.
-
Mengascini built the Bocsa Dubh, 23/60 LMMM = Link to FB video of Daniel McPhee playing one. (https://www.facebook.com/highlandaccordions/videos/daniel-mcphee-plays-the-bluebell-polka-on-the-mengascini-bocsa-dubh-5050/1659063827513943/) But that was 7 years ago, and they don't show it on their catalog anymore.
Someone here showed off a Double Ray with a 12 or 24 bass from a PA grafted onto it. Had to build a matching frame.
I'll quote George Garside, and advise you to just find an old Trichord. 12 basses, 2 voice B/C/C#. But it might be in a sorry state, mine sure is.
Funny that you'd bring this up as I'm playing a bit on my Paolo 3 row, haven't picked it up in a while.
Thanks for finding that, I knew there must be something out there (Mengascini would most definitely be out of my price range though!..) I wouldn’t get a Trichord, since I’m not looking to get into the B/C/C# system (in my mind there would be better uses for a third row!), but a Double Ray with 12 bass would be a potential step towards building something more on the left hand if I got on with it…
-
I recently converted a BC box to a 'Joe Burke’ bass layout, half of which is unisoric, it's D/D, G/G, E/A and C/F. It's not one of the layouts included in the ref section of MelNet.
This is not too far from the 12-bass Double Ray which has E/E, A/A, D/D, G/G, C/C and F/F (same as a Trichord).
And in what may be considered an improvement to the above, B/C player John Williams uses the following 12-bass setup:
E/E, A/A, D/D, G/G, C/F and B/B.
-
It seems that there is a general tendency towards unisonoricism… it’s a clever shoehorning in of the extra bass by John Williams (all C chord tones being available on the push)
-
I forgot about John Williams after posting - he plays a Saltarelle Connemara III, 2 1/2 rows and unisonoric 12 bass. The only thing missing is an F chord, you could substitute the B for that I suppose.
Another sort of possibility is the setup on Dubliner Peter Browne's Gaillard, where there are individual notes, not chords - not that he uses them much, it seems. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hzz56PCKNpY) In the PA/CBA world this is called "free bass." So you just mash a few buttons down, and voila, any chord you'd care to hear - including things which were heretofore simply out of our reach, sus4, maj7, etc. I play PAs with this setup and it's very liberating, to say the least.
I think Peter's box has 18 basses, too. Read about that years ago here, or at thesession.org.
-
Here is an example of a 12 bass double Ray
(https://theboxplace.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/IMG_9784.jpeg)
-
There are also things like the Hohner Organola Deluxe B/C with 36 Stradella Bass. I believe Jimmy Shand recorded on one pre- World War II.
I've just come by a 4 voice one one. A very interesting box. It's old but the Basses are in great order, probably because they've never been used.
I think it's essentially a PA bass end. The air button is miles from where it needs to be and even if you can reach it (and not play the basses), the hole is very narrow.
I've set up a non-destructive air bar to work the button (If I ever feel the need to return it to it's original configuration) but still fear I will need to enlarge the air hole. That's not something I'm keen to try for a while.
A brilliant idea in principle though.
-
Frankenakkordeon
“Learn from me, if not by my precepts, at least by my example, how dangerous is the acquirement of knowledge and how much happier that man is who believes his native town to be the world, than he who aspires to become greater than his nature will allow”
Transplanted the 12-button bass end from a too-small-to-be-useful piano accordion (Weltmeister Mini) onto the 8-bass BC melodeon I have unrealistic plans of eventually playing for my molly side.
But it gets more ridiculous! To save weight, the 'chords' don't have a full set of their own reeds, but also sound the corresponding bass reed, AND are only two notes - the major third - so to get a full major chord you also need to press the next bass button up. But this is good for playing mostly in minor keys - I would add the major key's relative minor bass instead of the fifth above. And I had to add an air button (bass button mechanism from toy melodeon), as they didn't bother with one on the original PA.
Furthermore, I have shifted the reeds over a couple of places (was Bb F C G D A) to start on C - I don't care about playing in Bb, and do want to have E and B. But instead of a B major chord, I have put the F bass reed there and blocked off the hole that would also sound the B at the same time. If I want an F Chord, I just press the buttons for C + A + F.
I have cut a cork-backed plastic register that cut out all the bass notes from the chord buttons to give me a tiny free-bass mode with a stop knob to dis/engage this, but didn't get it to work well enough (even worse air leak than this bass end + casing adapter already has). In any case, I seriously doubt whether I would be playing anything fancy enough to need this rather than just bass+chord of the five or so keys I actually play in.
C......G......D.........A........E........B
..C+E..G+B..D+F#..A+C#..E+G#..just F
-
For those reading this thread interested in B/C box with stradella bass I have a used Marc Sérafini in BC with his Darwin bass setup.
https://bellingersbuttonboxes.com/product-detail.php?prod_id=532 (https://bellingersbuttonboxes.com/product-detail.php?prod_id=532)
My listing includes the keyboard layout so you can see the configuration.
From his website: "Left hand: 24 unisonoric basses, chords without thirds (12 basses, 12 chords)"
Scott