Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Dan Warden on April 19, 2025, 02:38:37 PM
-
I wanted to make this post for others who are looking to begin their journey of playing the b/c accordion. This is a pitch for John Nolan's beginner box. I am new to playing just a couple of months now and was having difficult time finding anything in the US and was about to buy a AAA garvey while also looking for old hohners (without success).
I came across john's website and made a purchase after speaking to John on the phone and talking through my options:
https://www.buttonsandbellows.com/category/new-accordion/
I've since become a student of John's, but he did not ask me to make this post to advertise.
Recently I purchased couple more boxes for family including a used Linnet b/c box (box place in Massachusetts) and an old 3 voice double ray from the 30s. Both of these sound nice, but the Nolan box feels of a better quality and the buttons have a nice action and are more responsive and overall it just sounds better in my opinion.
Take this as a grain of salt as I recognize I'm a complete beginner, but I have 3 accordions at my disposal at the moment including a good quality double ray and the Nolan Box has been my favorite. Of course I will upgrade at some point in the coming years when I get better, but for now it's been a lot of fun to play and has been reliable for several hours a day of playing.
-
I'm glad to hear that you are enjoying the journey, Dan, and are happy with your instrument. For those outside the USA, the McNeela student accordion and the red Lisheen model offered by Martin Quinn appear to be identical to the Nolan box.
-
Yes, the Nolan beginner box, the McNeela student box and Martin Quinn's red Lisheen model are all rebranded versions of the same Chinese-made box, at least terms of the casework, keyboard, etc. It's possible that there may be different reeds installed in some of them (McNeela boasts that they have 'top quality' Czech reeds theirs, so probably some version of TAM Harmonikas at a guess) but you'd have to ask each of them to know if that's the case.
-
I'm glad to hear that you are enjoying the journey, Dan, and are happy with your instrument. For those outside the USA, the McNeela student accordion and the red Lisheen model offered by Martin Quinn appear to be identical to the Nolan box.
That's what I gathered from my conversation with him. I don't see anyone ever mentioning his as an option, so I just wanted to put it out there as a good starter.
-
I've only had the pleasure of 2 Chinese boxes, and they were both absolute dogs! I understand that some are now much better, but I purposely steer clear of them after those 2.
Does anyone with more experience rate any of them as being of better quality, or easier to play, than a Hohner at a similar price? (Either restored or needing work to improve, either type.)
By the way; Happy Easter to all Squeezers who celebrate this momentous time!
-
I've only had the pleasure of 2 Chinese boxes, and they were both absolute dogs! I understand that some are now much better, but I purposely steer clear of them after those 2.
Does anyone with more experience rate any of them as being of better quality, or easier to play, than a Hohner at a similar price? (Either restored or needing work to improve, either type.)
By the way; Happy Easter to all Squeezers who celebrate this momentous time!
My D/G is a Chinese Pokerwork....Probably Circa 2018. Nothing wrong with it. Tone Dumb Greg (late of this parish) also had one and said the same.
-
Sorry Peader, I mustn't have make myself plain.
I'm not talking about Chinese Hohners. I'm referring to other (poorer quality) Chinese manufactured boxes which have been made without any real input from an otherwise recognised and experienced name in the accordion world. A logo of the buyer's choice can be added at a small extra cost.
I would have imagined that you must know of these things? The outward appearance tends to be similar to the Hohner Erica, or any plain wooden instrument, whilst the internals are pretty ropey, to say the least.