Looking at one list I have, it seems (for example) the Hohner Club III BS and the Hohner Club III M might be voiced LMM.I've seem examples of both of those models, all were LMM. I assume the 'S' is for 'switch' in IIIBS
However, if I am reading the list correctly, this III B F would not have the low octave reed; maybe the coupler behind the keyboard pulls out the 2 musette reeds for a single voice tone:
http://www.elderly.com/vintage/items/160U-405.htm
http://www.elderly.com/vintage/items/160U-405.htm
Elderley's gradings always crack me up (for all their instruments). To me VGC (very good condition) would imply an immediately playable instrument with some cosmetic problems. in this case it means -
"VGC except needs some work (bellows leak, all notes are kind of wheezy and some are weak, plus needs cleanup, etc. - sold AS-IS), keys of Bb-Eb, red pearloid covering, red bellows with gold trim, 30 buttons in three rows, 8 bass buttons, "Original Hohner" imprint on back, used for Tex-Mex and other styles, with worn straps and beat semi-HSC, price reduced"
How would anyone else grade it? Me? Poor/Medium at best.
Steve
Elderley's gradings always crack me up (for all their instruments). To me VGC (very good condition) would imply an immediately playable instrument with some cosmetic problems. in this case it means -
"VGC except needs some work (bellows leak, all notes are kind of wheezy and some are weak, plus needs cleanup, etc. - sold AS-IS), keys of Bb-Eb, red pearloid covering, red bellows with gold trim, 30 buttons in three rows, 8 bass buttons, "Original Hohner" imprint on back, used for Tex-Mex and other styles, with worn straps and beat semi-HSC, price reduced"
How would anyone else grade it? Me? Poor/Medium at best.
Steve
I'm thinking of buying an old three-reed LMM Hohner off ebay.Looking at one list I have, it seems (for example) the Hohner Club III BS and the Hohner Club III M might be voiced LMM.I've seem examples of both of those models, all were LMM. I assume the 'S' is for 'switch' in IIIBS
If it has a switch behind the keyboard it is likely to be LMM, if no switch it is likely to be MMM, but there may be exceptions.Thanks Theo. I think this is an MMM. Miki
I think this is an MMM.
QuoteI think this is an MMM.
I've got one that looks exactly the same which is MMM. Theo has recently overhauled it for me and it is a lovely box.
Hohner 235 on german ebay ... 8 hours to go ... €1999 starting price :o
http://cgi.ebay.de/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=180471027466&
Pete Grassby had one on his stall at Witney this year.
That I would have liked to hear.
Looking at one list I have, it seems (for example) the Hohner Club III BS and the Hohner Club III M might be voiced LMM.I've seem examples of both of those models, all were LMM. I assume the 'S' is for 'switch' in IIIBSQuoteHowever, if I am reading the list correctly, this III B F would not have the low octave reed; maybe the coupler behind the keyboard pulls out the 2 musette reeds for a single voice tone:
Where 'F'='flute' perhaps, though modern accordion terminology usually uses 'clarinet' for a single M reed.
Quote from: LesterPete Grassby had one on his stall at Witney this year.That I would have liked to hear.
Your wish etc
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GndDixyw8iU (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GndDixyw8iU)
Here is a pair of very similar boxes but these are both 3 voice LMM with three switches. This gives any combination of reeds including none. Build quality is excellent.
Scott [...]
Here is a pair of very similar boxes but these are both 3 voice LMM with three switches. This gives any combination of reeds including none. Build quality is excellent.
Scott [...]
The red one looks exactly like my "pre-Morino".
three switches including none too - M, L, MM and one switch for helicon basses.
Can not understand reason of poor sound :(
Here is a pair of very similar boxes but these are both 3 voice LMM with three switches. This gives any combination of reeds including none. Build quality is excellent.
Scott [...]
The red one looks exactly like my "pre-Morino".
three switches including none too - M, L, MM and one switch for helicon basses.
Can not understand reason of poor sound :(
Maybe the bing could be better???
Corrected toâ€tuningâ€(:)
I am tuning only a little and only for myself. It takes too long for me to do it for money. My problems are perfectionism and lack of time, so lot of my instruments are tuned not by me but by (I think) the best craftsman in Lithuania (only one in Lithuania who can tune in non-equal tuning like old Hohners), but all my bandoneons are tuned by me.
Hi Andrius,
OK then: I suggest that you transplant a few of those reeds into another box, and transplant a few other "good sounding" reeds into your fancy 1930s box, to see whether it is those reeds or the box that is causing the problem you perceive.
[...]
I like the "HOHNER GERMANY" reeds. When in good condition and in a good box they are great IMO (responsive and with a beautiful tone quality)! [...]
PG
I’ve also noticed a higher incidence of breakage with Made in Germany reeds. I can’t tell if the steel is more brittle, but the reed profile is certainly thinner than Hohner T reeds, which might make them more proud be to break.
I’ve also noticed that not at Made in Germany reeds are the same. The best ones are length ground, whereas standard reeds are ground across. This is something you can easily see and f you look at the surface of the reed tongue.
[...]
I would be very interested to learn more about this "non-equal tuning like old Hohners". Were the old Hohners (1930s, etc.) tuned in, say, 1/4-comma meantone or similar? What were/are the offsets from Equal Temperament? Can you enlighten me please, Andrius, or anyone. Thanks!
[...]
I would be very interested to learn more about this "non-equal tuning like old Hohners". Were the old Hohners (1930s, etc.) tuned in, say, 1/4-comma meantone or similar? What were/are the offsets from Equal Temperament? Can you enlighten me please, Andrius, or anyone. Thanks!
Non-equal tuned melodeons sounds more lovely. Lot of pre-war Hohners (most important part of my instruments) were [factory?] tuned in this way Main idea is to lower some sounds from "well tempered" keys. It can be used in melodeons only - not in PA or full scale button accordions or bandoneons that must be tuned in tempered key.
Easy level - 3, 6 and 7 tones (mi, la and ti[si] in C key) are a little lowered; Do+mi+sol in tempered key not sounds so sweet like with lowered mi; the same for do+mi and mi+sol. Other two lowered tones are for dominant and sub-dominant chords.
BTW in old Hohners sometimes lowered tones are only in low octave, so octaves are not in tune...
More complicated level - to tune nice fifths too (lowered V); have not seen any instrument factory tuned this way. It is kind of tuning like pipe-organ with one forbidden interval; it is possible to tune 2 row melodeon almost perfect
Thanks Paul and Andrius for your replies.
I must admit I am slightly surprised by the notion of lowering the pitch of the fifths in order to make the thirds sound in tune. This doesn't seem right to my accustomed way of thinking. The interval of a fifth is too narrow in ET. It needs to be sharpened by about 2 cents to obtain a beatless interval. Similarly, a major third is too wide in ET and sounds sweetest when about 15 cents flat from ET. I don't see how those sorts of 'in-tuneness' are achieved by making the fifths even narrower. But I may be misunderstanding your explanations here.
Maybe one thing which comes out of this is that what we mean by 'in tune' is different for different people. I don't mean people who are not able to distinguish pitch accurately; it's more of a cultural 'what we've grown accustomed to hearing' thing, and has changed over the centuries since Bach's time. In general western music, we are far more accepting of the overall slight dissonances of ET than perhaps people were in the past.
Hi Steve,
If you are going for pure fifths in the basses, that's even more reason that 1/4 comma meantone on the melody side could be disadvantageous!
To summarize my comment to which you responded, my personal opinion is that 1/4 meantone temperament is overkill in narrowing the fifths on a diatonic melodeon....
Hi Steve,
If you are going for pure fifths in the basses, that's even more reason that 1/4 comma meantone on the melody side could be disadvantageous!
To summarize my comment to which you responded, my personal opinion is that 1/4 meantone temperament is overkill in narrowing the fifths on a diatonic melodeon....
Relieved to read that. Thanks!
Basically, I'll carry on as I have been doing for the past few years then. :Ph
[...]
Some Hohners from this pre-WW2 period were tuned in equal temperament, some were just not very well tuned at all, but many of the diatonic boxes were tuned to very precise non-equal temperaments designed to optimize certain intervals. I think it's incorrect to call the entire instrument or even the scale for one diatonic row "just tuned" but I'm a stickler about that. However, some intervals do approach "just" tuning. In the two-and three-row boxes you will often see that the same named note when found on different rows and/or different bellows directions is assigned a different pitch.
One possible minor disagreement with Andrius' statements (if I understand you correctly): in my experience, when a box is properly tuned in this way, the octaves *along the same button row and in the same bellows direction* are well in tune, allowing for a different beat frequency of the tremolo or musette. However, octave notes chosen between different button rows and/or different bellows directions may be different in the "center / target perceived pitch."
[...]
PG
Thank you Paul for perfect explanations about tuning, my English is not so good to do it :(
Most important part of my Hohners are from Germany, and lot of them seems never be serviced after factory.
6 or 7 accordions (of more than 30) were with "sweet thirds" only in low (main) octave (now higher thirds are corrected).
This lets me think about factory tuning this way.
Another interesting discovery - sometimes bass side is not in tune (a little lower) with melody side. IMO it was factory trick.
When testing this way tuned accordion it seems wrong tuned, but when other person is playing, sound seems to be OK. My friend and I were testing two Hohner Club III BS accordions, where one was with lower bass side, another - bass side was tuned with melody side. When another person plays accordion with lower bass side sounds more rich; may be this adds a little more tremolo.
It seems part about tuning can be moved to different place, may be Theo will find the way how to do it to help others to find really actual posts.
[...]
Finally, my apologies for the off-topic posts.
[...]
PG
- off-topic started by me and Steve 8)
"sounds fantastic"As requested. Customer Terrence doing some proper squeezing:
Might we have little demonstration, then? I'd love to hear it in all its glory.