Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Eric Barker on December 15, 2009, 04:43:20 AM

Title: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: Eric Barker on December 15, 2009, 04:43:20 AM
Yes, I know there is a big similarity between these two boxes.  My question: Is the Cajun accordion only usable for Cajun music?  Does the special tuning limit the instrument?  Or can one play anything they want-that is possible on a one-row instrument by changing the stops and thus changing the Cajun sound of the tuning?  Likewise, if I found a cool one-row in C with 4 stops can I use it in Cajun music without the special tuning? 
Just curious,  Eric in Montana
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: melodeon on December 15, 2009, 05:16:20 AM
First some hair splitting

A "Cajun" accordeon is an accordeon made by a Cajun, everything else is a one row 10 button bisonoric diatonic aerophone commonly known as a melodeon or accordeon.

However since reality has little to do wiith perception...
A "Cajun" accordeon is now usually a one row with 10 buttons and 4 reeds configured LMMH and being tuned to "just" tuning which
many if not most Cajuns claim as their own.

From personal experience a "Cajun" tuned box sounds good for Cajun music played in the Cajun style and rarley sounds good with other types of music..opinions vary and exceptions exist.

A Tempered tuned ( !2 TET ) box  can play most anything and can pass for Cajun .

Were I to choose one box and Cajun muisc was not my first or only music choice, I would not have a just/Cajun tuned accordeon.

Also, most Cajun music is played on a "C" box... and most other music styles favor a one row in D  though many exceptions exist.

A "Cajun" box would be way down on my list of box choices as being too specialized

I like playing themn and like the sound, but only for Cajun/Zydeco music.


 
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: Bob Ellis on December 15, 2009, 11:45:23 AM
First some hair splitting

A "Cajun" accordeon is an accordeon made by a Cajun, everything else is a one row 10 button bisonoric diatonic aerophone commonly known as a melodeon or accordeon.

A bit more hair splitting.......From what I have read on various Cajun websites, Cajun muscians use the word melodeon exclusively to describe a Cajun-tuned one-row. They do not use the word to describe other diatonic accordions.
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: rees on December 15, 2009, 01:32:37 PM
Zydeco musicians tend to favour a B flat accordion.
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: Accordion Dave on December 22, 2009, 05:22:56 PM
I mentioned in other posts my mystery 1-row Hohner pokerwork that had been changed from the key of "C" to "Bb". Two of the chord buttons had been disabled, the holes were taped off and corresponding reeds were missing.

In other words the only bass and chords available were on two buttons "Bb" on press and "F" on draw. I scrounged some reeds from an old piano accordion and it now has "Eb" press AND draw on the other two buttons.

I will have to borrow my brother's tuning meter and see if this box is tuned equal temperment or the "Cajun" way.
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: Andrel on December 22, 2009, 05:54:00 PM
  Actually, Cajun players call their boxes *accordions*, not melodeons. It seems like the term melodeon for a one-row is used mostly in France and Ireland. Québec players also play on accordions.
  Eric, if  you really want a one-row, I'd say go with a D box. It will be more versatile for trad. And don't forget that a fair number of Cajun players play in D, like these guys: I love the logo ! It would make a great bumper sticker.

   http://www.lostbayouramblers.com/bio.asp
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: sqwzboxstudent on January 01, 2010, 12:20:03 AM
surely if u play an irish jig on a cajun box ur playing irish if you play cajun on an irish box u play cajun?
i went to a session a while back and the top man there said to me "no irish" i said i dont play irish, he looked my soprani up and down and said "u got an irish box", and i said no, its italian!!! true story tho...
Title: Re: Cajun accordion or one row melodeon
Post by: juker on January 01, 2010, 12:34:42 AM
surely if u play an irish jig on a cajun box ur playing irish if you play cajun on an irish box u play cajun?
i went to a session a while back and the top man there said to me "no irish" i said i dont play irish, he looked my soprani up and down and said "u got an irish box", and i said no, its italian!!! true story tho...

Hahaha! This sounds like a classic 'irish' joke.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal