Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Rob2Hook on December 15, 2009, 11:38:17 AM
-
Looking at pictures of reeds being tuned and remembering all the dire warnings about not touching them or they'll rust, I was reminded of the years i spent in a mechanical inspection department. During the interview, I was surprised that everyone insisted on shaking hand. It transpired that they were making sure I didn't have sweaty hands! The supervisor was a redhead and wasn't allowed to touch any of the micrometers or gauges without gloves as they would be red with rust by the next morning.
I presume the same applies to reeds, being basically a spring steel?
For those who tune boxes, do you clean the reeds after tuning?
Rob.
-
Do you need dairy maids hands then? (ref to victorian farm)
-
For those who tune boxes, do you clean the reeds after tuning?
Rob.
Simple answer is no, but I clean my hands before starting.
New reeds come from the factory with the surfaces chemically treated to protect against corrosion, cleaning with any sort of solvent is quite likely to compromise this protection. I've not seen evidence of fingers causing rust on reeds. I've just been working on an a 1930s Hohner this week where I can actually see fingerprints on some reeds, and although there is slight rust on some reeds it is not related to the fingerprints.
If reed cleaning is ever needed it would be after playing in a smoky atmosphere, or after playing near the sea. The worst case of rusty reeds I've come across is from a busker who regularly plays on the sea front.
-
I don't clean after tuning, but if I'm going to rewax and revalve I will always give them a clean with some white spirit and I've usually had grubby fingers near the tongues. I'm also careful not to touch the tongue as I'm tuning anyway. It's probably best to err on the side of caution as you never know what 50 years of finger acid will do in the future.
-
Good question Rob!