Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: callmemario on December 15, 2009, 09:38:30 PM

Title: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: callmemario on December 15, 2009, 09:38:30 PM
Here's a great subject that sure to get quite a few replies (well, I would think  it would).  How do most people control  the humidity level of their accordion in the cold DRY winter months?.  Do most prefer an in room humidifier? or humidifier inside the case like a "Dampit", "Planet Waves" or   just a wet sponge in a plastic bag?.  With my guitars, I always use a "planet waves" humidifier  inside the soundhole of every instruments and I just keep their cases closed.  I find, this way they are less subject to  quick or sudden changes in temperature/humidity.

But I'm not sure about the delicate aspect of the accordion:  Metal reeds, lot's of leather, bellows...

Thanks!

Mario
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: graememackay on December 16, 2009, 12:14:51 AM
It's never entered my head.  My accordion under the stairs when it's at home.  Tumble dryer is used all year round tho...

Although humidity is an issue with all reed instruments, I think it would need to be a pretty extreme change to make any difference.  Not as delicate as you may think.  Does help if the instrument gets played lots tho.
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: Bob Ellis on December 16, 2009, 01:00:52 AM
How do most people control  the humidity level of their accordion in the cold DRY winter months?  Mario

Sorry, I don't understand the question. What are cold DRY winter months? Here in the Yorkshire Dales we get five kinds of winter weather; vertical rain, horizontal rain, sleet, snow and hail!
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: callmemario on December 16, 2009, 03:19:30 AM
OK, here's the situation.  Here in Eastern Canada we have like 5 months of colder weather and snow and the temperatures  can drop down  quite  a bit.  This means that the colder it gets outside the dryer it gets inside the house because we have to turn up the heat.  Heat= drying.   Therefore  owning several musical instruments means that one has to take care of the environment  they are in.  Generally speaking, whatever is comfortable for us will be alright for our instruments.  A comfotable level of indoor humidity for the winter months is about 45-50%.

Hope this helps.

Mario

**********************************************************quite a bit.  It can easily drop down to -30 celcius
How do most people control  the humidity level of their accordion in the cold DRY winter months?  Mario

Sorry, I don't understand the question. What are cold DRY winter months? Here in the Yorkshire Dales we get five kinds of winter weather; vertical rain, horizontal rain, sleet, snow and hail!
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: callmemario on December 16, 2009, 03:20:30 AM
Well at least it's reassuring to know that accordions are much tougher than I thought! :-)

It's never entered my head.  My accordion under the stairs when it's at home.  Tumble dryer is used all year round tho...

Although humidity is an issue with all reed instruments, I think it would need to be a pretty extreme change to make any difference.  Not as delicate as you may think.  Does help if the instrument gets played lots tho.
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 16, 2009, 04:19:33 AM
I've already posted my calamatous playing for morris as the air dropped to dew point on he dee Estuary.

I think the real killer is to take a cold box into a humid environment and then play it. Seems to put points of rust right on the most sensitive parts of the reeds - perhaps a combination of cold and wierd fluid dynamics as the thing vibrates in its slot.

Now if I drive to a winter session I spend a little time 'breathing' the bellows via the air hole. seems to work, though in theory I'm allowing humidity inside. I should probably simply have a pint and a chat and go back to it.   I've also stopped transporting kit in the boot. Car body is warmer.
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: graememackay on December 16, 2009, 01:33:31 PM
I do put on the rear heater in my van on cold nights, although it's more for my PA system than my box as it lives there.
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: Stiamh on December 16, 2009, 02:28:14 PM
I used to use "Dampits" in my fiddles before I consigned them to the basement (can't play them any more). A piper I know uses damp sponges in plastic bags in the pipes box.

But I'd go for a good humidifier in the house and wouldn't bother with anything in the accordion case. The trouble with humidifiers is that they never last more than a year or two in my experience. The ultrasound variety are a total hassle - you have to filter the water and clean them religiously if you don't want white dust settling on everything in the house. The kind that boil the water seem healthier but again require regular descaling and seem to break down within two years, guaranteed.

A couple of friends of mine in Montreal (one a piper, the other a concertina player) use what seems like by far the best system. German, of course, and considerably more expensive than anything else, but no boiling, no ultrasound, just mechanical action, and guaranteed for 10 years if I remember correctly.

http://venta-airwasher.com/#
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: callmemario on December 18, 2009, 01:45:26 AM
That's interesting Steve.

Personally, I've given  up  using  electric humidifiers of all kinds.  I've tried them all.  They're either too noisy, they can produce bacterias if not cleaned VERY regularly...I was always filling it up like once a day.I guess, winter is winter and we just have to adapt to it and so do our instruments.  My acoustic guitars however, are well taken care with "Planet Waves" in the soudhole/case closed.  The advantage of the Planet waves is that it NEVER touches any wood surfaces unlike the Dampit.

I used to use "Dampits" in my fiddles before I consigned them to the basement (can't play them any more). A piper I know uses damp sponges in plastic bags in the pipes box.../// ...But I'd go for a good humidifier in the house and wouldn't bother with anything in the accordion case...///
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 18, 2009, 08:11:48 AM
Personally, I've given  up  using  electric humidifiers of all kinds.  I've tried them all.  They're either too noisy, they can produce bacterias if not cleaned VERY regularly.

Just a quick health warning: Legionella is the bad bug here and it just loves humidifiers and air conditioners of all kinds. Pneumonia. A lot more dangerous than flu. So clean water is important. And if you are going to do that regularly .. a bowl on a radiator might be cheaper. D3R
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: callmemario on December 21, 2009, 04:20:51 AM
VERY good advice Chris!

Personally, I've given  up  using  electric humidifiers of all kinds.  I've tried them all.  They're either too noisy, they can produce bacterias if not cleaned VERY regularly.

Just a quick health warning: Legionella is the bad bug here and it just loves humidifiers and air conditioners of all kinds. Pneumonia. A lot more dangerous than flu. So clean water is important. And if you are going to do that regularly .. a bowl on a radiator might be cheaper. D3R
Title: Re: HUMIDITY CONTROL
Post by: Steve C. on January 21, 2010, 11:46:29 PM
I usually drop in at Button Box in Massachusetts around Xmas time, and notice they always have a humidifier in the box room, tho I did not notice one in the concertina manufacturing/tuning rooms.  May have been.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal