Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: DoninOhio on February 14, 2008, 09:42:54 PM

Title: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: DoninOhio on February 14, 2008, 09:42:54 PM
Hello:

I am considering buying either a Hohner Morgane D/G, or a Gabbanelli D/G. I know the Gab costs more than the Morgane, but is the quality that much better to justify the price difference? Which has better keyboard speed, reed response, bellows quality, etc.?  The Gab looks more solid (online), but.....Any personal experiences with each box, and your recommendation, pros and cons?
Thank you in advance,

Don
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 12:50:31 PM
I can tell you about the Morgane D/G, I had one for about 2 months and I love it. It's probably one of the best deals around for this price point (I paid CAD 950 taxes included) and it looks really good. It has nice wood inlays and a chrome grille. The sound is very powerful, clear trebles, deep basses, not too wet and not too dry, perfect for most music styles. The action is very fast and the mushroom buttons are nice to use. All plastic though. The bellows is very supple and has real fabric protective tape. Looks cool too (red and black).

Of course if you look closely you may find very little imperfections or things that might need improvement (e.g. a note on the first row sounds very slightly different than the same note on the other row), plastic buttons, etc, but for a thousand dollars you can't find a better deal. All-wood body and keyboard, chrome corners. Comes with a decent hard case and two straps (a bit short to my liking).

Of course, if I had $2000 or $3000 to spend I would have bought something else, I really like Bernard Loffet's boxes (www.diato.org). Gabbanelli boxes (in North America) seem to be addressing mostly the Tex-Mex and latin market, I find their boxes ugly, but that's just my opinion. The Morgane looks a lot more "celtic" with its "marine" style.

Remember the adage: you get what you pay for. However I would rate the Morgane as the best you can get for the sub-1000 dollars boxes, and it's backed by Hohner's warranty and service network.

 
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: rees on February 15, 2008, 01:19:28 PM
The Gabbanelli that you mention is probably the small 21 button 2 voice box. This was originally my idea. Around eight years ago I took a Hohner Pokerwork to Mr Gabbanelli in Castelfidardo and asked him to copy it. He came up with the aforementioned melodeon. I was pretty impressed as it played very nicely and was reasonably priced at around £850. I've since sold a few of these but it never really caught on big time. I think the main thing that discouraged customers was the celluloid finish.

Then, along came the Hohner Morgane which literally blew the Gabbanelli out of the water. With a natural wood finish and a price tag of £595 it has become a very popular melodeon. For quality and playability I would say it's every bit as good as the Gabbanelli - my customers certainly seem to think so.

The Morgane is also slightly lighter than the Gabbanelli.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 02:33:37 PM
For those interested, this is the Gabbanelli stuff we have in North America:
http://www.gabbanelliaccordions.com
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Dazbo on February 15, 2008, 02:35:44 PM

Gabbanelli boxes (in North America) seem to be addressing mostly the Tex-Mex and latin market, I find their boxes ugly, but that's just my opinion


My understanding is that although Gabbenelli in the US and Italy are related, at some point there was a falling out in the family and they are now basically different, unconnected, companies.  From what I've heard the US boxes are not as good as the Italian made.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 02:38:18 PM

My understanding is that although Gabbenelli in the US and Italy are related, at some point there was a falling out in the family and they are now basically different, unconnected, companies.  From what I've heard the US boxes are not as good as the Italian made.
Family ties, that's it! Some of the Gabbanelli USA boxes are outsourced and not very impressive IMHO. See the link to their web site I posted earlier. The only model I find interesting is their Cajun King.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: rees on February 15, 2008, 03:04:17 PM
I think the Cajun King is made by Polverini in Porto Recanati, Italy.
It is not available from the Italian branch of Gabbanelli.

Then again the 21/8 model I mentioned earlier is not available through Gabbanelli, USA.
It is apparently very popular in Norway.
Bargeman is currently selling a blue one in D/G on eBay.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Quebecois on February 15, 2008, 05:10:47 PM
<snip>
Then again the 21/8 model I mentioned earlier is not available through Gabbanelli, USA.
It is apparently very popular in Norway.
Bargeman is currently selling a blue one in D/G on eBay.
Would look so much better in natural wood finish!
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Malcolm Clapp on February 16, 2008, 02:15:30 PM

But it's so hard to find natural blue wood    :( :( :(
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Pete Dunk on June 04, 2008, 09:31:44 PM
Do my eyes deceive me or is this a 2 1/2 row 10 bass Morgane? uk.youtube.com/watch?v=FfTVUdNuHbU&feature=related (http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=FfTVUdNuHbU&feature=related)
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: risto on June 04, 2008, 10:23:34 PM

.... not too wet and not too dry, perfect for most music styles. ...

.....The action is very fast ......

.... All-wood body ...

 

Don, just remember that these opinions are very subjective and properties can vary between different instruments. For instance the wetness varies a lot as I and other players have noted and some commented about that in youtube. The action in my opinion is not fast, the springs are extremely stiff and the travel too long. I just wonder if anyone can ever play fast dance tunes with Morgane if left in the standard setup. Just the other day I was testing a Roland 3b and there you have a fast action: short button travel and light springs. And well yes, the body of the Morgane is wood, it is genuine veneer.

PS. The Morgane I bought a year ago was the first Hohner instrument I ever bought, then had to return the second Hohner instrument, the Nova I bought later, back to the factory and now I have decided never to buy another Hohner accordion ever, was just waste of time and money for me.
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Stiamh on June 04, 2008, 10:29:22 PM
Do my eyes deceive me or is this a 2 1/2 row 10 bass Morgane?

They do. It has 12 basses. And unless my ears are deceiving me, that there ain't no "polka irlandaise".
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: EeeJay on June 04, 2008, 11:07:27 PM
Do my eyes deceive me or is this a 2 1/2 row 10 bass Morgane?

They do. It has 12 basses. And unless my ears are deceiving me, that there ain't no "polka irlandaise".

It's called the Hohner Galaad. And it's fitted with a third stop too...

Indeed, this clip might sound somewhat nicer with the thirds out... ;D

Ed J
Title: Re: Hohner Morgane or Gabbanelli box?
Post by: Theo on June 04, 2008, 11:11:03 PM
It is the Galaad II (http://www.hohner.fr/Mod_Guit.asp?ooof_idproduit=294) one of  the big brothers of the Morgane.  Only available in France I believe.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal