Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Arnold on December 14, 2025, 05:40:20 PM

Title: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Arnold on December 14, 2025, 05:40:20 PM
Hi, I’ve increasingly been using the Welty D 4-stopper for Irish tunes, and so naturally becoming more interested in the semitone system. The default choice would be C#D of course, but thinking about it I quite like the idea of DC#… So in this system, are the rows both 3rd button start, ie the C# note being where the G note is on a DG box, or is the C# row 2nd button start, keeping the inside row higher in pitch?.. I like the idea of the former, since in that case both cut and pat can be performed with the same finger, rather that having to use two fingers (one above and one below the main note)…
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Fionn on December 14, 2025, 07:56:44 PM
I think the answer's probably that it's up to you, since you'd be lucky to come across an existing D/C# box.

It's not easy to find secondhand C#/Ds, at least at the more affordable end of the market. You'd probably have to ask a fettler to set up something like a refurbished Hohner for you, meaning you could have it arranged like that.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Arnold on December 14, 2025, 07:59:53 PM
True, I could have it set up like that anyway, but I’m wondering what the standard way is… I have an old AD zinc set for a potential conversion…
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: gettabettabox on December 15, 2025, 12:14:24 AM
On a 19 button 2 row, the outer 10 D row would have D push on button 3, the inner row would have C# push on button 2.
A 21 button set up (allowing for 4th and 3rd button starts) gives the useful option of a low D/G pair on button one of the D row.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Arnold on December 15, 2025, 07:36:27 AM
On a 19 button 2 row, the outer 10 D row would have D push on button 3, the inner row would have C# push on button 2.
A 21 button set up (allowing for 4th and 3rd button starts) gives the useful option of a low D/G pair on button one of the D row.

I see, thanks for the info!
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: folkloristmark on December 15, 2025, 09:06:14 AM
Get your hands on a c csharp to try before you comit.They are more common and not popular. I can play Csharp D and its quite easy I find bc much more challenging, I also have a gsharp g . The advantage is the spare notes are in the same direction to be a semitone sharp. It is all influenced by what you are playing which keys you really want to play in and what you played before. i was coming from dg.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Stiamh on December 15, 2025, 01:59:06 PM
The advantage is the spare notes are in the same direction to be a semitone sharp.

If you are talking about C#/D, or B/C, or any semitone system in which the main row is sharper than the helper row, the accidentals (notes on the C# row) in the same direction are a semitone FLAT, not sharp. This is a huge advantage. It also applies in the case of the D/C# - but not to C/C# or D/D# played with the outer row as the main row.

Unless you particularly want to sound like Joe Derrane, I would recommend C#/D over D/C#. If the latter were more advantageous, it would have taken off in Ireland, where virtually nobody plays the system. D/C# has (barely) survived in the US - and has recently become more popular here in Québec - basically because of the influence of Joe Derrane.

D/C# does have the advantage of giving you a longer outside row, and a clearer tone on the main row. But for the practicalities of playing, I don't know what the advantages over C#/D are, if there are any at all.

Matt Selic could advise. He championed D/C# for a few years but has recently converted to C#/D.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Andrel on December 15, 2025, 04:35:58 PM
I play both C#/D and D/C#. I would not get rid of my D/C#s for the world.(Gaillard and Castagnari Sharon, an unbelievably nimble box.)
The main challenge on the D/C# is mastering the Cnat on the inside row, as it requires reaching up on the pull. But it's worth investing in the practice; you will reap the benefits. I understand it's one of the deterrents for aspiring D/C# players, and the reason why it hasn't become more popular.
I love both layouts for different reasons.
The bright sound of the outer row (D) is a delight.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: tirpous on December 15, 2025, 05:21:22 PM
Quote
I quite like the idea of ...

Quote
I like the idea of

I would agree with (Folklorist)Mark, if you can rent or borrow a C#/D (or B/C, C/C#, D/D#, G/G#, ***) or D/C#, it would help validate your ideas and orient your decision.

*** they're all basically the same, so you can pretend they're in any key you want to try fingering-wise.

 

 
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Arnold on December 15, 2025, 08:13:21 PM
Thanks for sharing your thoughts everyone. I found a very reasonably priced Double Ray which is on its way to me for Christmas. I am intrigued by the inherent fluidity in the B/C system (coming from chromatic harmonica, which is effectively CC# and excels in the flat keys) but I think I may struggle not to fall back into playing along the row!..
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: -Y- on December 16, 2025, 10:11:59 AM
If the latter were more advantageous, it would have taken off in Ireland [...]

D/C# does have the advantage of giving you a longer outside row, and a clearer tone on the main row. But for the practicalities of playing, I don't know what the advantages over C#/D are, if there are any at all.

Being an all-time 4th apart player, whenever I play on C#/D I always struggle with cross-row fingering, I have to reach the altered note "backwards". On a D/C# the fingering is easier for me, it's sort of like it was where I expect the note to be (for instance, the C nat Andrel speaks of is much easier to use on a D/C# layout than on a C#/D, to me).
I don't know if the whole "evolutionary" argument about advantages yielding higher use works well for diatonic accordions ;D. I'm under the impression that custom and influential players do more to influence usage than sheer practicality and rationality.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: CAB on December 16, 2025, 11:13:51 AM
Being an all-time 4th apart player, whenever I play on C#/D I always struggle with cross-row fingering, I have to reach the altered note "backwards". On a D/C# the fingering is easier for me, it's sort of like it was where I expect the note to be (for instance, the C nat Andrel speaks of is much easier to use on a D/C# layout than on a C#/D, to me).
Exactly my experience.  Before trying a C#/D, I experimented by playing in G on the D row of a DG, snatching the C nat from the G row.  This felt very natural, reaching out for the C.  When I eventually tried a C#/D, it felt cramped having to curl a finger to reach the C on the C# row.  I never got to try a D/C# but I bet I'd have found it much comfier to play. 
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Andrel on December 16, 2025, 05:05:58 PM
Hmm. Goes to show we are all different. I find the Cnat on a C#/D a breeze to play. It took me for ever to master it on the D/C#.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: mselic on December 16, 2025, 05:19:52 PM
As Steve mentioned, I was briefly a proponent of D/C#.  I started and played for many years on a one row in D, then shifted over to D/C# in what felt like a natural progression from a one-row to a one-row+notes.    At the time I found C#/D awkward so I stuck with what I was used to (D as 'outside' row) and reached to the inside row for the other notes and reversals.  Eventually I switched over to C#/D and have stuck with that ever since.  I'm glad I did.  When I try to play D/C# now, I find it awkward.  There are some things which seem a little easier to pull off on one system over the other, but on the whole I find C#/D flows better and is more comfortable.

And yes, for those new to C#/D, grabbing the Cnat in some passages can be a bit awkward (but it's not really any different on D/C#, and can often be even more awkward on that system).  This is why playing in the key of G on a B/C is the cat's ass - it's a lot easier than on C#/D.
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: pgroff on December 16, 2025, 08:40:12 PM
On a 19 button 2 row, the outer 10 D row would have D push on button 3, the inner row would have C# push on button 2.
A 21 button set up (allowing for 4th and 3rd button starts) gives the useful option of a low D/G pair on button one of the D row.

this
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: KLR on December 17, 2025, 02:50:14 AM
D/C# are rarer than hen's teeth.  You can have one built - by Gaillard.  So $6000 USD or something, and 3+ years wait.  Or Casta, those are very, shall we say, distinctive in ways you might not be crazy about. 

Or you can buy a little Hohner C#/D or B/C and see what you think - you might even play that and call it good, like Josephine Marsh - and Billy McComiskey recorded an LP on a Black Dot instead of his Paolo. 

That alone would recommend C#/D or B/C,  Neither of these systems are free of headaches - getting at your C is much easier on the latter, scales are a lot smoother, but a D arpeggio is a million times simpler on the former, and it's a lot punchier on some types of tunes.  This has been discussed to death here and at the session dot org too. 

I bought an old D/C# for fun's - it's super cool to look at, and has a lot of old time charm, shall we say - but leaks like a sieve and is one tough cookie to play, too.  Matt has really compared that system well with C#/D in his post. 
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Arnold on December 17, 2025, 07:50:59 AM
The original question regarding whether the C# row of a DC# box is 2nd or 3rd button start being answered, any significant difference/advantage I perceived in having the C# row on the inside (eg performing rolls with 2 fingers) is lost, so I probably would go for C#D in this instance. As a conversion though, I wouldn’t expect it to be any more costly either way.

I have a few C-less G tunes down on the D 4-stop, the obvious ones being The Kesh, Out on the Ocean and Off to California. It will be interesting to find how these compare on a BC box. I’m fairly comfortable with them (and to my ear the C# note still makes an acceptable cut on the B note)
Title: Re: How do rows line up on DC# boxes?
Post by: Lars on December 17, 2025, 08:53:27 AM
D/C# are rarer than hen's teeth.

I've had a good few through my hands, not just Baldoni price range, so they're out there.

This is why playing in the key of G on a B/C is the cat's ass - it's a lot easier than on C#/D.

I disagree. I switched from B/C to C#/D about 20 years ago as the main system, but still play both - and I'd much prefer playing in G on a C#/D. We're all different it seems :)

A 21 button set up (allowing for 4th and 3rd button starts) gives the useful option of a low D/G pair on button one of the D row.

I've almost always had D/G on the first (lowest) note on my C# row on my 21-button C#/Ds to get that low D/G. Much more useful than the 'standard' F/Bb. Shouldn't be the reason for choosing one system over the other, though - so many other factors involved.

I think generally, it's a matter of how you want to play, and how you want to sound. D/C# is a whole lot of fun, but I tend to sound much more 'square' in my rhythm with less chromatic ornamentation, than when I play C#/D.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal