Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: ladydetemps on December 22, 2009, 11:24:11 AM

Title: Respecting other instruments
Post by: ladydetemps on December 22, 2009, 11:24:11 AM
Just something I was pondering the other day. When you play with other instruments do work within their limitations or do you play what's easy for you and have them keep up with you? Or is it a bit of both.
how do you know the limitations of other instruments without knowing how to play them...or maybe is that why so many folk musicians seem to play so many different instruments? ;)
Because I always worry if I play with others that I pick tunes everyone can play.

Discuss....

FYI I'm cross-posting this on concertina.net (http://www.concertina.net/forums/index.php?showtopic=10525&pid=105749&st=0&#entry105749) too to maximise answers.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Lester on December 22, 2009, 11:39:12 AM
Most the instruments I run up against at sessions are more flexible than a melodeon in terms of keys etc so most anything I play can be accompanied (ruined  ;D ) by as many guitarists/banjoists/fiddlers/drummers as are present. Sometimes I play a tune no one else knows and mostly people don't mind, in fact they seem to appreciate something new and it may well trigger them off to learn it.

Tricky instruments are pipes and possibly hurdygurdys which seem to be in a world of their own when it comes to tuning.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 22, 2009, 11:57:52 AM
French bagpipes always seem to play 'true' but some Northumbrian and more commonly Scottish ones may only be able to play with other pipes - eg "between B and Bb" seems to be common for highlands. Small pipes are often made in F, which can be a challenge on a D/G box!

All the gurdies I've come across play in true keys. However they can be buggers to tune and might not be set up right. They sound as "unusual key"s to some ears because gurdy players tend to play in exotic modes against what is after all a single note bass (in our terms).  

However those gurdy notes are straightforward white and black ones. eg Cliff Stapleton's "Blue Sausage Island" uses the 4th mode of the (A)harrmonic minor. You can play the whole of this on a basic D/G/accidentals - but not in Cliff's D minor. But if you play it in Em with corresponding Bb and F "accidentals", you'll lock the gurdy out.

I really wouldn't worry too much about it unless someone pulls out a set of ethnic bagpipes. Then the etiquette is to sit and listen, say how nice it was, and get back to sessioning tunes for a while.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: ladydetemps on December 22, 2009, 12:02:11 PM
The situation is a small group of people who let me play one tune at a barn dance, and I've finally managed to pursuade them to do a 'practice' with me. Got asked if I had some tunes I wanted to play....and I'm worried what to choose (I think they all read music). My friend (Violin) says she's picked out some tunes that were played in the titanic film. Having never seen the film I don't know what to expect. :-\
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: george garside on December 22, 2009, 12:33:55 PM
The situation is a small group of people who let me play one tune at a barn dance, and I've finally managed to pursuade them to do a 'practice' with me. Got asked if I had some tunes I wanted to play....and I'm worried what to choose (I think they all read music). My friend (Violin) says she's picked out some tunes that were played in the titanic film. Having never seen the film I don't know what to expect. :-\


I am fairly sure one of them was Ryans polkawhich goes well with egans polka as a set.
george
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: george garside on December 22, 2009, 12:40:28 PM
Just something I was pondering the other day. When you play with other instruments do work within their limitations or do you play what's easy for you and have them keep up with you? Or is it a bit of both.
how do you know the limitations of other instruments without knowing how to play them...or maybe is that why so many folk musicians seem to play so many different instruments? ;)
Because I always worry if I play with others that I pick tunes everyone can play.

Discuss....
 &pid=105749&st=0&#entry105749]concertina.net[/url] too to maximise answers.

I tink its all a question of a bit of give & take.  Most 'session' instruments can cope ok with D & G  & often those are the keys played throughout the proceedings.  However is somebody wants to haave a go with an instrument that all present can't play in  its often worth listening to & ddrumms & other percussiion + capo equiped guitars can joing in.    BUT at the end of the day a good session is about as many playing together at any given time as possible & a session is not a concert!  so keys suitable for the majority of instruments should prevail most of the time - and if that be D &G so be it!!

george
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Theo on December 22, 2009, 01:14:48 PM
I think you should just ask the people you play with, rather than asking us here.   Its probably more to do with the people and what they are comfortable playing, than what the instruments are theoretically capable of.  For example I know some fiddle players who are happy to play in any key they love to play in Eb, Bb and F, and anything else, but I know of other fiddle players who only want to play in D and G.   So its the people more than the instruments, and by the sound of it yours are a friendly bunch who are making positive moves to encourage you, so just suggest your favourite tunes to them and see what they say.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: TonyRussellDavis on December 22, 2009, 04:04:56 PM
Tunes from Titanic? Should go down well. Tony.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Accordion Dave on December 22, 2009, 05:01:33 PM
The format of our monthly jam session is that we sit in a circle. The microphone is passed around. Each person takes his or her turn selecting a tune for the group to play.

With my piano accordion, I tend to avoid songs with a lot of chord changes. I also transpose songs into keys that are more comfortable for the group. I might ask: How about Jingle Bells in "F"? Usually I will hear a faint groaning when I suggest playing in anything to the flat side of "C" (F, Bb, Eb, Ab, etc.) I have found that transposing to "G" works better for guitars and mandolins. (I also switch out the extremely wet 3-reed French Musette to a dryer 2-reed register.)

Fortunately my 2-row melodeon is "G" and "C". The majority of songs are in "G" so it works out well.

Obviously the chord accompaniment is limited on the diatonic box. I change from the piano accordion to the melodeon when I know it is one particular gentleman's turn. Most of his song selections stick with simple chord changes in the key of "G".

Next month I am going to bring along my G/C concertina. There is a fellow who used to play the concertina and wondered if I had one.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: ganderbox on December 23, 2009, 09:51:09 PM
If we're talking about keys, then in most sessions, the melodeon is the most limited instrument there. A D/G melodeon player rarely needs to worry about playing in keys that others can't join in with.
If we are talking about the sort of tunes you play, then it depends on the circumstances. In most sessions, there is scope for doing solos and playing tunes that nobody else knows, as well as tunes that everybody can join in on.
 If we all just played tunes that everyone else knows, life could get very boring!
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 24, 2009, 07:56:27 AM
In the end neither the instuments or keys matter too much (OK perhaps not Bb+¼tone bagpipes).  It comes down to respecting the other musicians, listening, repecting their music, hopefully reciprocated.

20 years ago I met a bearded old canal barger on the Shopshire union and about 5 of us had a really good session in the pub. We ended up back in our barge with a bottle of whiskey. Afterwards I realised a lot of it had been Blues in E. I hadn't pushed that too far on my D/G Lilly and had tried to listen, and come in with sometimes just 2 notes when I could. Seemed to work - though I'm sure that empty whiskey bottle helped.

So respecting the 'instruments' is perhaps the wrong slant.   And there's nothing wrong with yours.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 24, 2009, 11:43:01 AM
As a fiddler, I tend to both play within the limits of my own instrument (dificulty in getting "punch") and with the limitations of what I'm playing against (usually a melodeon  :||:, which means less legato and only "fixed notes" available). Which is why I decided to learn to play the melodeon!  >:E
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Owen Woods on December 24, 2009, 12:08:34 PM
Our sessions have a sort of cold war going on between me and the fiddlers. The wind players are sort of on my side but I can't rely on them. The thing is that I like playing in D and G, with tunes with lots of arpeggios in, because they are easy. The fiddlers like playing in D or A with lots of runs and fiddly bits in them. The wind players don't care as long as it doesn't go over the break. So from time to time I play tunes that I like but which are horrendously difficult on fiddle and more often they play tunes that are horrendously difficult on the melodeon and in A, E, B, G minor or F. You could cut the tension with a plectrum.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Steve_freereeder on December 24, 2009, 04:09:49 PM
Our sessions have a sort of cold war going on between me and the fiddlers. The wind players are sort of on my side but I can't rely on them. The thing is that I like playing in D and G, with tunes with lots of arpeggios in, because they are easy. The fiddlers like playing in D or A with lots of runs and fiddly bits in them. The wind players don't care as long as it doesn't go over the break. So from time to time I play tunes that I like but which are horrendously difficult on fiddle and more often they play tunes that are horrendously difficult on the melodeon and in A, E, B, G minor or F. You could cut the tension with a plectrum.
Perhaps you should find (or start) a new session?
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Theo on December 24, 2009, 04:16:04 PM
Our sessions have a sort of cold war going on between me and the fiddlers. The wind players are sort of on my side but I can't rely on them. The thing is that I like playing in D and G, with tunes with lots of arpeggios in, because they are easy. The fiddlers like playing in D or A with lots of runs and fiddly bits in them. The wind players don't care as long as it doesn't go over the break. So from time to time I play tunes that I like but which are horrendously difficult on fiddle and more often they play tunes that are horrendously difficult on the melodeon and in A, E, B, G minor or F. You could cut the tension with a plectrum.
Perhaps you should find (or start) a new session?

Yea, sounds terrible, why do you still go?
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Ebor_fiddler on December 24, 2009, 09:46:54 PM
A, E, B, G minor or F.
There are no such keys on the fiddle (apart from possibly "A") hence the D/G melodeon! You are playing, regretfully, with showoffs who may even (dangerous!) learn their tunes from the printed page (which reminds me, did anybody find the dots for "Tiger Rag"?).  >:E  :|glug
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: old geezer on December 25, 2009, 09:50:33 AM
at the last session I attended, a banjo player sat-in, (I find that the banjo is are very domineering).
the banjo was into blues, whilst we button wheezer's play more of the english, irish & oz folk music,
hence many tinas' and squeeze boxes fell silent,  some just moved away for a chat an' others moved on

me!  Kev' an' I went to the pub.... for a couple of quite ones
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Owen Woods on December 26, 2009, 11:37:40 PM
Haha, don't worry, it's all very good natured and tongue in cheek. They make fun of me for not being able to play in any sharps outside the range 1-3, I make fun of them for not being able to play arpeggios :P It's all good fun.
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: juker on December 27, 2009, 03:01:26 AM
Tunes from Titanic? Should go down well. Tony.

Hahaha!
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: triskel on December 30, 2009, 01:06:10 AM
Tunes from Titanic? Should go down well.

"Nearer, My God, to Thee" then?  ???
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: Pete of Ebor on January 09, 2010, 06:21:36 PM
If we're talking about keys, then in most sessions, the melodeon is the most limited instrument there. A D/G melodeon player rarely needs to worry about playing in keys that others can't join in with.


There's got to be some give & take. Yes, there are some keys a D/G can't cope with like E & Bb and some that are doable but a bit limited  like A & C which have some missing notes and/or wrongly directional bases, (..and I didn't even mention D-bl00dy-minor!) but I have no qualms about re-keying a tune fo fit my box. Most fiddle players play Atholl Highlanders in A. I can play it in A but I much prefer to play it in D as I feel it fits better on the box. Incidentally, I also have a smart-arse version in Em just in case anyone complains.... only tried it once and cocked it up big-time... Why is it that you can play a tune all day long at home then as soon as you start it in a session it all goes sh*t-shaped...
Title: Re: Respecting other instruments
Post by: ganderbox on January 09, 2010, 07:50:16 PM

and I didn't even mention D-bl00dy-minor

A lovely key, and worth investing in a C/F box to do it justice instead of struggling on a D/G.

Why is it that you can play a tune all day long at home then as soon as you start it in a session it all goes sh*t-shaped...

I've learnt the hard way that you never know whether you can play a tune properly until you've successfully played it in public.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal