Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Teaching and Learning => Topic started by: David Robinson on December 18, 2025, 09:53:50 PM

Title: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: David Robinson on December 18, 2025, 09:53:50 PM
I don't have any slow music sessions locally and apart from workshop weekends my only experience playing outside the house is in folk club 'singarounds'. I have been playing for just over a year and have a number of tunes I can play at home reasonably well. When performing for others I make more mistakes (as expected in a different environment) but my difficulty is carrying on after a mistake. I keep hearing advice to the effect of, "most of the audience won't notice a wrong note if you carry on playing but everyone will notice if you hesitate". But how to learn how to carry on? The trouble is I seem to memorise tunes as a sort of chain, with each note leading on to the next. If I play a wrong note the chain is broken and I don't know what comes next. My instinctive response is to pause and re-try the phrase. If I do try to carry on I usually end up playing a random mash-up of notes for a bar or so until I manage to pick up the tune again. Either way, it rather spoils the performance.
 
So how can I train myself to elegantly cope with those inevitable mistakes?

David
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 18, 2025, 10:29:10 PM
You might shift your focus to the mechanical side.  Fingering, bellows changes and such can serve as "non-musical" sequences offer alternative checkpoints. 

Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Anahata on December 18, 2025, 10:33:40 PM
It might help to practice playing along with something that isn't going to stop even if you make a mistake, such as a recording of the same tune (whether played by yourself or someone else)
Playing solo for dancers (e.g. a morris team) is an excellent way of developing a steady rhythm and learning to keep going regardless of whether you're playing the right notes or not, but with your current level of experience it might be hard to find an opportunity for that.

If I do try to carry on I usually end up playing a random mash-up of notes for a bar or so until I manage to pick up the tune again.
I think you need make a point of doing that when you make a mistake while practising at home, instead of stopping. You may find the "random mashup" gets better and less random as you get more used to ignoring mistakes.

The other thing is you have already observed that things are more likely to go wrong in front of an audience. The cure is to keep playing/practising a tune, long after you think you can play it perfectly. That extra practice reinforces the mechanical memory that gets you though the distraction of an audience, missed notes or a different environment.
The applicable proverb is: "an amateur practices until they can play it right; a professional practises until they can't play it wrong" (attributed to several famous musicians....)

Some people advise practising in different places, even if it's in the same room but in a different seat (if you sit down to play) or maybe even facing in a different direction.

Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Lizzy on December 18, 2025, 10:44:03 PM
You speak of playing the music like a chain and when it breaks then it is difficult to regain the flow. I understand that totally. It might be worth taking phrases and playing them in a sequence that is not necessarily in the order that the tune goes, then phrases are more individual or bars of music are more individual and not a complete chain that is learnt from rote.

Lizzy
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Fionn on December 19, 2025, 01:00:25 AM
Anahata has it, I'd say.

Playing along with recordings really helped me when I came back to music after years away. I found a useful app (the Amazing SlowDowner) that played recordings at whatever speed I needed.

I also used to stop when I hit a wrong note, and couldn't pick up again until the start of the next line. Now, as soon as I really know a tune I can carry on. It's hard to get that level of familiarity when you're relatively new to playing, but it does come. I wouldn't focus on it too much, just trust that it's a phase nearly everyone goes through.

Playing more with others would help too. If there isn't a slow session, could you start one? I know from experience that four or five people meeting up round a kitchen table once a week can really boost progress – not only at getting used to playing together, but also learning tunes.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: PeterBRC on December 19, 2025, 10:16:32 AM
What a very interesting post you have started !  Right up my street
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: CAB on December 19, 2025, 10:35:21 AM
All excellent advice above.  I recognise the problem.  Not just making a mistake but even trying to add an ornament or variation can throw me off course because it breaks the chain of notes I've learned.  As Fionn says, it's all about familiarity with the tune.  Do you make sure you can sing the tune before trying to play it?  If it's going on in your head as you play, then it's easy enough to get back into it.

I wouldn't contradict Dick but for me the best thing is to try and focus a bit less on the mechanical side and think about the tune itself.  Actually, it's about positioning your mind somewhere between those two things:  "that high bit in the tune" versus "the point where I have to use my little finger".  If I go wrong in a session, it's often because I'm thinking too much about my fingers and not focusing enough on the instrument as my voice.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 19, 2025, 11:05:22 AM

  I think most of us have been there. What helped me was a "never stop" approach. The fear of failure is what leads to the fear of failure and we've all experience that slight anxiety build-up as you approach the phrase where you … made a mistake last time.

  So I would say, just do it. Practising music is basically about building up muscle memory. And it's perfectly okay to make the same mistake again. There's nobody listening anyway?  Let the mistake happen. Focus on the music around it which you were previously ignoring because of anxiety and build up your fluency.

   When you can play the whole thing reasonably well (but still have the mistake) is the time to really focus on that glitch, but it is so much easier if your heart rate is normal 😉 

  Festive note. Alcohol helps too! I don't think it helps in avoiding mistakes but it stops you worrying about them 😉
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Theo on December 19, 2025, 11:51:41 AM
I recall that stage very clearly.  Like you I was pleased to get a lot of very good a supportive advice.  I don’t recall a point where the problem was “solved”. It just sort of receded and became unimportant.  I still make mistakes, but usually recover without thinking. 
Just keep playing as advised above and things will improve. It’s a gradual process though and I doubt you will ever get to the point where you think it’s fixed, it will just happen less and less.

With music the learning never ends.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: PeterBRC on December 19, 2025, 12:44:12 PM
I find sometimes even after complete learning a tune suddenly a phrases goes. My solution is to look out of the window and think of something completely different as in.   And now for something completely different. Lo and behold it’s all in the memory again



Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Fionn on December 19, 2025, 01:04:34 PM
Another thought: some phrases become really obstinate stumbling blocks. There seem to be two main types of these.

The first is tripping over a sequence for no reason, then finding you can't stop doing it. One solution is to paste the ABC into Michael Eskin's web tool, highlight the eight bars around the phrase, open the tune trainer, and play it over and over again. If I do that till I'm insanely bored it's usually a permanent cure.

The second is the tricky sequence that's genuinely hard to get your fingers round. Don't be afraid to simplify bars like that. As long as you get the important notes, it's fine. The main thing is being able to hit the groove so you can explore the tune, make it yours, and play it confidently. The awkward bit can go back in when you're solid on it; if it's part of your mental version of the tune it'll sometimes appear spontaneously, specially when you're playing with others or to a recording.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Howard Jones on December 19, 2025, 01:44:20 PM
It seems to me that you may be learning how to play the tune rather than learning the tune itself. By that I mean you may be more focussed on the mechanics of playing it, so when that goes wrong you have nothing to fall back on. I see learning a tune as two distinct processes - one is getting to know the tune and get it embedded in your brain, which can happen quite independent from the instrument by repeated listening and humming along. Once you have done that, working out how to play it becomes much easier, and because you know the tune and not just the fingering it is easier to get back on track.

I agree with those who say play along to recordings so you are forced to carry on whatever happens. Learn to relax, so that when it does go wrong you don't panic and can play your way through it. That takes experience, but treat every mistake as a learning opportunity.  With experience you can often find a way to turn a mistake into a variation which brings you back to the tune.  The really good players make more mistakes than you realise, but they are often very good at navigating around them so most of the audience doesn't notice, and if it really crashes they are confident enough to shrug it off and carry on.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: David Robinson on December 19, 2025, 09:36:51 PM
Thanks to all for your responses. I really appreciate being able to call upon your collective experience.

Lots of thought provoking and comforting comments.
Lots of helpful suggestions that I will certainly aim to work into my practice routine.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 19, 2025, 10:53:16 PM
I'm curious as to how you work up a tune.  What steps do you go through?
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 20, 2025, 10:30:29 AM

  A video from a USA piano teacher just popped up my feed. She seems to agree about the importance of getting the whole tune into your head, but councils "not to practice the mistake".  So opinions differ …
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Fionn on December 20, 2025, 11:50:31 AM

  A video from a USA piano teacher just popped up my feed. She seems to agree about the importance of getting the whole tune into your head, but councils "not to practice the mistake".  So opinions differ …

Hmmm ... I'd argue you tend to get better at what you practise, so if you keep playing the mistake you risk embedding it deeper or never getting past the mental block. It's the same with going too fast too soon: you're teaching yourself to play sloppily with no lift or swing. Sorting out a stumble doesn't take long once you know what works for you.

Another idea for a stubborn one: play only the last three notes of the bar. Repeat several times, voicing them well and at the right values. Then do the last four notes, then the last five, etc. When you've worked back through the whole bar, think about how the pulse runs, where the melody lifts or descends, what accents it needs. Make it sing or dance or lament as it should. Then add the bar before, then the bar before that.

By treating a few notes like a whole tune, you often learn something new about the whole tune. You might be reminded of a weakness that needs work, or realise you could improve how you go about tune learning. Doing stuff like this can feel like time wasted, but it never is.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 20, 2025, 12:39:30 PM
Two things to commit to memory:

1.  The music.
2.  The fingering.

Once you knit them together you're good to go. 
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Theo on December 20, 2025, 01:01:09 PM
You could get a lot of useful tips from Judy Minot’s book Best Practice.
It’s not a conventional “how to play” instruction book, but it’s full of short items with practical tips on all aspects of learning to make music.  You will find it useful throughout your playing career.

Just is a member here if you want to contact her.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Best-Practice-Inspiration-Traditional-Musicians/dp/0578870444/
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: David Robinson on December 20, 2025, 10:00:07 PM
Quote
You could get a lot of useful tips from Judy Minot’s book Best Practice

Thanks Theo, I will order a copy.

Quote
I'm curious as to how you work up a tune.  What steps do you go through?

I choose something that inspires me, sometimes from a tutor book, often something I have heard before and I like. I find a recording of the tune, listen though it a few times, then slow it down using 'Music Speed Changer' app and start off by playing it on a loop while trying to play along, initially just on the row. After a few sessions of this when I have the tune in my head and can just about get through it slowly on my own I look at the printed music for the chords. I work out where I need to cross rows and concentrate on learning those sequences. It takes me a while as crossing rows is still a challenge! Once I can get my fingers around those it's a matter of adding in the chords (still mostly oom-pah), then playing through again and again trying to get the whole thing to flow, which does turn into a bit of a slog to be honest. I don't tend to play along with the recording again. After I can play through the whole tune comfortably, I regard it as 'learned' and it goes on the list to be played like a 'performance' about once a week. Anything I struggle with at that stage goes back for further work.

I've adopted a practice routine based on some of the principles that Molly Gebrian writes about in "Learn Faster, Perform Better - A Musician's Guide to the Neuroscience of Practicing". I do interval practice, working on one tune each day, twice during each of two 20min sessions a day on an expanding schedule, working on 3 pieces interleaved. In other words I have an increasing number of days off between the days I practice a particular tune, during which I work on other tunes. I also interleave anything that needs extra work into the middle segment of the 20min session. Difficult to explain - it sounds more complicated than it is!

Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Fionn on December 21, 2025, 12:02:16 AM
What you're doing's quite an ask, David, playing tunes in performance mode.

Not sure I could have done that. I play Irish, so I could go to a slow session and hide behind people for a few months, before trying a pub session and hiding behind people there. If I really lost my way in a tune I could stop playing and pick it up again at the repeat, and it'd make no difference because there were nine or 10 others ripping into it.

So don't be too hard on yourself or feel you haven't made enough progress. You're doing something tough for a player in their first year, and you're not even benefitting from the accelerated learning people get from playing with others.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 21, 2025, 09:53:54 AM

   Here's Ms Bogart's video. I didn't post it before as it is quite long, and a lot of it is piano specific.

   https://youtu.be/Rdx_N7n7OYk

   It fits my own general philosophy, which is that we play "music' rather than an instrument, but there are always technicalities at the start?
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Anahata on December 21, 2025, 12:02:40 PM
   Here's Ms Bogart's video. I didn't post it before as it is quite long, and a lot of it is piano specific.

   https://youtu.be/Rdx_N7n7OYk

That's excellent. Lots of stuff that resonates with my experience, even though I might never have thought to put it into words as clearly as she has.
I'm certainly familiar with the part near the end where she says "you don't get better while you're playing, you get better while you're resting" and the experience of practising something hard, going away for a weekend and finding you're playing it better when you come back.
And the idea of switching to playing something else in between practice sessions on the thing you're learning.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 21, 2025, 02:19:23 PM

  I've always advised "sleep on it, start again next evening" because that worked for me.

  Moreover … it worked again if you do it again. 👍
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 21, 2025, 04:37:13 PM
" And the idea of switching to playing something else in between practice sessions on the thing you're learning...."

I'm glad you've said this!
I often will try and learn a couple of tunes at a time, so can switch between them. Perhaps with one more or less in the memory, then flip to something else requiring more work. I've found in the past just constantly banging on with one tune becomes boring and then counter productive.
I find it better to switch off to known tunes and have a play, or noodle around something that might have caught my interest rather than totally concentrating on something to the exclusion of everything else.
The process of learning is a strange thing!
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: CAB on December 22, 2025, 11:10:33 AM

  A video from a USA piano teacher just popped up my feed. She seems to agree about the importance of getting the whole tune into your head, but councils "not to practice the mistake".  So opinions differ …

Hmmm ... I'd argue you tend to get better at what you practise, so if you keep playing the mistake you risk embedding it deeper or never getting past the mental block. It's the same with going too fast too soon: you're teaching yourself to play sloppily with no lift or swing.

I once heard Karen Tweed say she tried to avoid making mistakes when learning a tune.  She'd play it slowly enough to get it right.  Once she had it comfortably at the ultra-slow speed, she'd move up a gear... and so on.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 22, 2025, 11:58:57 AM
That's the ideal way to learn a tune.
I find the errors can start when trying to commit the tune to memory. Then I try to make sure I don't learn the errors and keep referring back to the dots.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 22, 2025, 12:45:58 PM
Quote
You could get a lot of useful tips from Judy Minot’s book Best Practice

Thanks Theo, I will order a copy.

Quote
I'm curious as to how you work up a tune.  What steps do you go through?

I choose something that inspires me, sometimes from a tutor book, often something I have heard before and I like. I find a recording of the tune, listen though it a few times, then slow it down using 'Music Speed Changer' app and start off by playing it on a loop while trying to play along, initially just on the row. After a few sessions of this when I have the tune in my head and can just about get through it slowly on my own I look at the printed music for the chords. I work out where I need to cross rows and concentrate on learning those sequences. It takes me a while as crossing rows is still a challenge! Once I can get my fingers around those it's a matter of adding in the chords (still mostly oom-pah), then playing through again and again trying to get the whole thing to flow, which does turn into a bit of a slog to be honest. I don't tend to play along with the recording again. After I can play through the whole tune comfortably, I regard it as 'learned' and it goes on the list to be played like a 'performance' about once a week. Anything I struggle with at that stage goes back for further work.

I've adopted a practice routine based on some of the principles that Molly Gebrian writes about in "Learn Faster, Perform Better - A Musician's Guide to the Neuroscience of Practicing". I do interval practice, working on one tune each day, twice during each of two 20min sessions a day on an expanding schedule, working on 3 pieces interleaved. In other words I have an increasing number of days off between the days I practice a particular tune, during which I work on other tunes. I also interleave anything that needs extra work into the middle segment of the 20min session. Difficult to explain - it sounds more complicated than it is!

It seems to me that you're learning one thing, then changing or unlearning it.  That's time wasted and mistake prone.

Starting out with the chords helps eliminate this.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: David Robinson on December 22, 2025, 08:52:41 PM
Quote
Starting out with the chords helps eliminate this.

I can see the merit in this but in practical terms how does one go about this when learning by ear?

I can hear the melody and learn that easily but the left hand is often a complex mixture of different bass-chord effects. Even with the recording played very slowly I find it very difficult to distinguish which chord is being played when and hence the bellows direction.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 22, 2025, 10:05:17 PM
You say you choose a tune, listen to it a few times, then start working on it.  I'd say listen to it until you have completely committed it to memory before trying to reproduce it on an instrument.  This is pretty much mandatory and takes less time the longer you work at it.

Fully training your ear takes years...one tune at a time. If you have no other players to sit down with, consider video lessons. Do you have access to sessions or workshops?
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 23, 2025, 09:39:46 AM


  I just play flat chords on the left initially because that divides the direction of the Bellows.

  On a DG you have D&C both ways, and can substitute Em for G, which offers some flexibility

  Then I get the right hand going against that. Then refine the chords dum cha, cha {add bass} {off} whatever sounds nice.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Michael Eskin on December 24, 2025, 02:02:48 PM
Perhaps the Tune Trainer in my ABC Transcription Tools might be useful for this sort of thing, particularly the new Phrase Builder functionality:

https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/userguide.html#tune_trainer
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 24, 2025, 03:37:28 PM

  I don't think this is about cybernetics Michael.  That sort of thing comes much later in one's journey.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Michael Eskin on December 24, 2025, 04:10:48 PM
My post wasn't about cybernetics or whatever that comment implied, it was about tools that might help one overcome the tendency to stop after a mistake.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on December 24, 2025, 05:47:00 PM
Just if helpful, I experience this too… but only with the Melodeon.

With a whistle/flute I feel the instrument kind of disappears and I’m just playing sounds almost directly from my head.

If I miss a note or someone talks to me or similar, it’s pretty much an unconscious effort to turn it into something jazzy and return to the core tune (as long as I know that tune well)

With the melodeon it’s nothing like that and I’m very aware of “playing an instrument” that then goes on to play sound. If I lose my fingering, it’s very difficult to regain it and I can’t say a single word whilst playing.

For some cross rowy tunes, I actually find if I even stop playing the basses I make more mistakes with the right as, presumably, my fingers are operating differently.

I’m not sure how much of this is because I’m a kinaesthetic learner and how much is just because I haven’t go to the same proficiency on the melodeon yet.

One thing that’s helped me a lot (in all sorts of ways) is playing a drone on some speakers (D or Em etc) and then noodling around with it in the background.

I think this has got my brain linking the buttons to “music” rather than subconsciously learning finger patterns?
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Howard Jones on December 25, 2025, 01:12:45 PM
It seems to me that you're learning one thing, then changing or unlearning it.  That's time wasted and mistake prone.

Possibly, but I find that arranging a tune is an evolutionary process which involves trying out different fingering patterns and chord choices. This includes a degree of trial and error.

Quote
Starting out with the chords helps eliminate this.

I agree that choice of chords should dictate how you play the melody, rather than vice versa. But unless you are following some else's written arrangement, deciding which chords can be a process of exploration.

I think the important thing with an instrument like melodeon, where there are usually several different ways to play the same phrase, is to treat learning a tune as an exploration, and not to get too committed to a particular way of playing something until you are satisfied with your arrangement. I only commit to thoroughly learning it once I have worked out what I want to play, and how.  Until then I am flexible and open to changing how I play something if I want to try a different idea. That is not to say it is then fixed forever, the arrangement may then evolve further over a period of time as the tune gets played out. Once it is embedded I have more freedom to try out other ideas.

Coming back to the original question, if you can build that flexibility into your playing you are more likely to be able to improvise your way out of trouble when things go wrong. However it does require familiarity with the instrument, which takes time to build. Experience of performance is also important, playing in front of an audience always brings pressure and you have to learn how to ignore that. That only comes from playing in public, and making mistakes in public.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 25, 2025, 06:40:04 PM
I tackle a new tune in exactly the same way as Howard.
I find a pencil and rubber an essential tool to begin with when my original ideas on chords might well change.
As Howard does, my original way of playing, the one I committ to memory might well evolve as I really get to know it when playing it often.
Title: Re: Learning how to Play On after a Mistake
Post by: Dick Rees on December 25, 2025, 06:43:28 PM
Howard...

I agree that there are more ways than one in problem solving.  I generally say that it takes 5 years experience to become comfortable with a fairly comprehensive view of interfacing the music and the instrument. The two most important components are...

Listening and LISTENING.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal