Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: MomyA on December 19, 2025, 10:22:27 AM
-
Matris or Evo differences, can anyone who owns them give me reviews and opinions. MM or LM? Which is better?
-
LM or MM is entirely a personal choice. Get the sound you prefer.
I’m not familiar enough with those Castagnari models to comment on the instruments.
-
LM or MM is entirely a personal choice. Get the sound you prefer.
I’m not familiar enough with those Castagnari models to comment on the instruments.
Thanks Teo. Now I have a 12 bass with 5 registers and I usually use MM I like that sound better, but above all I like the registers, I can't decide
-
As Theo says, this is an intensely personal choice. However, I see from your other post that you are looking for a G/C box so perhaps having the lower register is less important if your box doesn't have a squeaky end to start with.
As a D/G player I prefer to have MM/MML options so I can play things in the upper octave without causing all the dogs in the neighbourhood to become overexcited - presumably this is less of an issue with lower-toned boxes?
-
.As a D/G player I prefer to have MM/MML options so I can play things in the upper octave without causing all the dogs in the neighbourhood to become overexcited - presumably this is less of an issue with lower-toned boxes?
Certainly my experience, Helena. Playing a tune on my accs/D/G I always use LM or L voicing as those solved the squeaky end problem
On my accs/G/C I only have 2 voices M+L, but all combinations of those play through comfortably.
-
I'd never buy an LM box unseen, without trying it out for as long as possible. LM register ranges from incredible to godawful, depending on reeds and box design.
Play both and see what you like more? MM favours slow legato, LM favours fast staccato.
PS my current main box is LM fixed and I'm loving it.
-
I would say, it entirely depends on what you want to play, from time to time. To accompany a subtle singer, or to play a sweet and gentle plaintive air, I feel a single voice works best, and for gutsier tunes or songs, perhaps a LM combination. But a dance player will want to cut through, with two voices in a higher register. It's so useful to have options to select the RH voices as you think appropriate.
-
That's exactly what I do, Chris (as when I got to the Checkers). Accompanying a song, I virtually always use a single voice.
Because you can nuance it any way you choose.
Unless it's a belter like (temporarily off-line) Warlike Lads of Russia …
When I pull in LM. I can't remember the last time I used LMM for song
-
The Matris and the Evo are quite different beasts; while the Matris is a fixed two voice, the Evo has registers to allow selection of M, L or ML settings and as you'd expect is larger than the Matris. As usual there are weight and size trade-offs between the two.
For me, this really underscores how personal these choices are. Usual advice would be to play the two side-by-side but with such rare models that's going to be a very tall order. Unless, of course, you live in Recanti.
-
I have both examples of these in stock on the shelf to try.