Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => General Discussion => Topic started by: Sebastian Trudgian on December 22, 2025, 09:44:00 AM

Title: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on December 22, 2025, 09:44:00 AM
I was watching some amazing videos of people singing and playing the melodeon today + people having full conversations.

Personally I struggle to even say “Hup” when playing, my brain is fully engaged/somewhere else and my playing crashes if someone try’s to talk to me.

I was wondering what the breakdown of this is for people… how many people can use their brain enough when playing to sing/talk etc, how many (like me) can’t despite trying, and how many are somewhere in the middle (think they probably could with a bit of practice)
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Squeezebox Of Delights on December 22, 2025, 09:53:08 AM
I can sing while playing quite confidently, but I find it nearly impossible to talk while playing, unless it's one or two words! I'm envious of people who can hold a full conversation while playing.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Guy on December 22, 2025, 10:07:41 AM
I can just about manage to say "change" when the band need to move on to another tune, but fortunately we've played together for a long time so now I usually just nod. Singing...no. I'm fine with the guitar (though opinions differ on this) so melodeon should be ok...nope. I guess I could practice, but it's low on the priority list...

Cheers,
Guy
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Helena Handcart on December 22, 2025, 10:20:32 AM
If I could sing, I mean actually really sing, then I wouldn't have needed to spend aaaaalllll that money on melodeons.

However, such as my vocal ability is, I actually find it easier to sing while playing than I do to talk. Like others, I can just about manage 'change', 'hup' or 'one more' - the latter a useful cover when I forget how many times we've played a tune - and yet I can 'sing' what I want to say more easily.

The brain is a weird thing. The melodeon is also a weird thing.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: rees on December 22, 2025, 10:26:40 AM
It took me years to master it.
A good way to start is to learn the chords of the song then sing along to a left hand accompaniment only.
The right hand can be used for decoration between the verses.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Winston Smith on December 22, 2025, 10:38:59 AM
I can sing whilst playing, but not at all well! The singing doesn't go wrong, but the playing always does, eventually.
My first squeezey thing was an English concertina, about 58 years ago, but never got past playing by myself, and mostly in the house. Which was a shame, as I'd really wanted to accompany myself singing. I'd previously managed to with the banjo and guitar, so why was this a stumbling block?
Just now, I'm trying to sing carols whilst playing, mainly in case I lose the ability to sing when we're out carol singing on Christmas Eve. I've sung these carols for 60 years, and played them on melodeon for about 10, so know them well in both cases. Why won't my brain do both together? Am I related to Paddington Bear, and am therefore a "Bloke with little brain"? (That's rhetorical!!!)
I cannot answer your poll.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: CAB on December 22, 2025, 11:39:22 AM
This is a fascinating topic, as captured by Helena  ;D
The brain is a weird thing. The melodeon is also a weird thing.

We're often told you shouldn't play the tune when accompanying yourself singing.  Unfortunately, that's all I can do. I find it easy enough to sing and play the same thing.  As I said recently in a different thread, you should be hearing the tune in your head as you play it.  The tricky thing is to play something different from what you're singing.  Michael Turner (of " -'s Waltz" fame) would sing one part while playing another in church.  Clever trick if you can do it!  "The second, too, he sang full true, His viol played the tune," his gravestone says.

A few guitar chords - no problem; but a squeezy accompaniment is another ballgame.  I used to sing to a Crane Duet concertina:  (1) same note both ways and (2) I could play the tune on the right hand, which informed my left hand which harmonies/chords were possible.  The melodeon has the second of those advantages but, as previously discussed on this forum, there's a temptation to suck and blow along with the bellows on a bisonoric instrument.

These days, I prefer to sing unaccomplished  ;) or get someone else to accompany me!
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Thrupenny Bit on December 22, 2025, 12:06:30 PM
I can just about utter 'change' but find waggling a foot in the air best for signifying the end of a tune!

I remember watching Kirkophany play a couple of Sidmouths ago, John Kirkpatrick's band along with his sons.
John was playing his BCC# box, leading some of his self penned tricky tunes and calling properly, almost conversationally,  at the same time.
I asked one of his sons who I know ( and plays melodeon ) how he does it. ' I have no idea!' came the reply!
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Matthew B on December 22, 2025, 02:24:20 PM
I've started on this journey in the last year or so, having joined a pub sing which happens locally once a month.  I've got a lot to learn, of course.  But it's fun figuring out how to put in little fills between verses and lines, how to switch between right- and left-hand chords, and how to add in some simple harmonies.  Three things really helped me get started:

After that, it's just a mater of practicing until it doesn't require thought.

My current challenge is remembering the arrangements I've come up with when I move onto a new song.  I'm hoping to find a few days over the holidays to start a little film library of the best results.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Ignatius Blumenfeld on December 22, 2025, 03:21:30 PM
I cannot really explain anything to people if I am playing the melodeon and if I try, I lose my fingering and have to begin a certain part of the tune over again. I think that the only song to which I have both played and sung at the same time is "It's a Long Way to Tipperary" only because I memorized the words and was alone in the house. I would eventually like to learn some more lyrics, but when I play, my mind is basically just a jumble of notes and music...nothing else.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 22, 2025, 03:34:45 PM

  I'm primarily a singer. Found it really hard for a long time as I tended to breath with the bellows 😵‍💫

  20 years ago I swapped subtitling french videos for a week in/near Grenoble with Stéph Milleret, an PA player Patrick Reboud.

  Learned how to arrange and importantly, voice right-end chords to accompany song, and I … never looked back.

  Basically this style requires a helper row. Rees is being far too modest!  He can sing to a single row!  👏
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: IanD on December 22, 2025, 03:43:20 PM
It's down to getting playing the tunes down to be largely automatic so you can do something else at the same time, like talking or calling or singing.

Or play for a prizewinning Morris jig -- very well, I'm told! -- in a state that means you can't remember doing it the following morning... ;-)
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 22, 2025, 03:54:38 PM

  I once did Tennessee Ernie Ford's "16 tons", in its original D minor, in the flat session, at Abbots Bromley. No one joined in 🙁

  … which is a real shame because the "built in" blues scale on our instrument is a ½-tone below inner row key (= F# on a D/G).

  So, on a Bb/Eb, you have a full D-blues scale  on the pull 😎

  Maybe next time?
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Julian S on December 22, 2025, 06:53:57 PM
People keep telling me that everyone can sing to which I respond some definitely shouldn't - including myself (unless the listeners have earplugs).

It took me over thirty years playing before I could even say 'change' or 'one more time' whilst playing. I have tried calling at the same time but I try to forget that not to be repeated experience... ::)

Julian



Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Fionn on December 22, 2025, 07:48:55 PM
Interesting to hear the responses. ;D I can't answer yet, I only started learning in August.

If the poll was "Can you make the list for your monthly grocery order while playing the tin whistle?" the answer would be yes, and it's quite helpful if I do. Nothing's more likely to make my playing go to pot than my thinking brain getting involved in proceedings.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: rileycat on December 22, 2025, 09:43:19 PM
Honestly, Fionn, don't fret at this stage. If you've only been playing since August, you don't need to put pressure on yourself to play and sing all at the same time in the same place!! It really does take time to get that skill.

In response to Sebastian, I play and sing with anglo and melodeon and can talk fairly coherently, but I've over 50 years doing it,under my belt. Just try to hum or la, la along with your tune to start with and see where that takes you. Relaxing the inevitable 'blow/suck breathing with the bellows' reflex, to free up your singing/breathing is hard, but the above can help to break the link. Try very simple tunes you know well - Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star etc. Be aware of your chest - is it relaxed as you play or tense? Its that tension, which prevents your singing.  The humming/la-ing or any other vocalisation you fancy, helps that relaxation.  Hope that helps a wee bit. I also asked John K. how he did it and how he played one thing whilst singing a harmony. He said ' I've been doing it a long time!'  I guess its a case of 'don't try to run before you can walk easily' - or is that a bit harsh!? anyhow, good luck on your continuing journey to melodeon joy.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Mcgrooger on December 22, 2025, 10:21:57 PM
I can sing and play at the same time  but I can't talk and play. On some tunes I can't even shout 'change' intelligibly. Odd, eh?
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 23, 2025, 09:42:03 AM

  I can't talk either.  Though I suppose I could do a "King's Speech"  and sing a conversation?
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Anahata on December 23, 2025, 11:30:59 AM
John was playing his BCC# box, leading some of his self penned tricky tunes and calling properly, almost conversationally,  at the same time.
I asked one of his sons who I know ( and plays melodeon ) how he does it. ' I have no idea!' came the reply!

Bob Cann was famous for calling dances while playing too. I'm told he taught himself to do it during a long convalescence. Also, and more amazingly, for holding a full conversation while playing in a tune session.

I agree than it can be harder to speak while playing than to sing while playing - that may be simply down to the fact you you practised singing while playing, while something like answering a question somebody's just asked you while you're mid-tune is going to be unrehearsed. I can call changes and "out" while playing in a band, but I think it took a while to learn.

I don't sing much, but I did once learn to play the tune + LH chords in the chorus of Sweet Chiming Bells * on Anglo concertina while singing a bass harmony. So I think I could learn sing and to play melodeon if I wanted/needed to.

* PS since it's that time of year, link to a video that's showing its age now: Sweet Chiming Bells (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Se8NJkqVJw)
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Sebastian Trudgian on December 23, 2025, 04:58:32 PM
Thanks everyone for all the responses (and wishes of ongoing melodeon joy 🥰). Super interesting to hear how different we all find the experience with this!
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Howard Jones on December 24, 2025, 02:21:49 PM
I can sing and play at the same time, but I started out on guitar so that was normal from the beginning. When I started on anglo concertina I struggled with breathing along with the bellows but soon broke myself from that, so when I later started on melodeon that was never a problem.  However I'd been playing both for quite a while before I began singing with them. I find them both more complex than guitar for that purpose.

On any instrument it's essential that most of your attention is on delivering the song, so any accompaniment has to be something that doesn't demant much brain-power. However over-complicated arrangements distract from the song, so that is no bad thing. A few twiddly bits between verses or at the end of a line can give the impression you're playing a more sophisticated arrangement than is actually the case.

Talking and playing though? No chance, although I might manage a strangled "Mine's a pint" in an emergency.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Anahata on December 24, 2025, 03:39:59 PM
A few twiddly bits between verses or at the end of a line can give the impression you're playing a more sophisticated arrangement than is actually the case.

Nic Jones's trick, I've heard, when someone asked how he managed to play such complicated guitar parts and sing at the same time.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Chris Ryall on December 24, 2025, 05:39:27 PM
A few twiddly bits between verses or at the end of a line can give the impression you're playing a more sophisticated arrangement than is actually the case.
Nic Jones's trick, I've heard, when someone asked how he managed to play such complicated guitar parts and sing at the same time.

 Nic said as much in his performance at Loughborough FF in 1980.
 "If you watch carefully, I don't sing, and do flash guitar, at the same time"

 As for calling a dance, while playing, I think I could probably do that.
 Different area of brain I suppose. There's no syntax involved.
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Hans Lemmen on February 07, 2026, 05:24:26 PM
I cannot do it yet but my goal is to play the box, brush my teeth and comb my hair at the same time (no singing). Just started to practice but I think I should be able to show you the video where I am doing it. (with some help of AI)
Title: Re: Poll: Can/could YOU sing and play melodeon at the same time?
Post by: Jesse Smith on February 19, 2026, 11:30:02 PM
It is something I keep trying to crack but I need to really put more effort into it. I don't find it difficult to play and sing at the same time, so much as moderating the volume of the melodeon (or anglo concertina) so that it doesn't drown out my voice.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal