Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: BJG on December 26, 2025, 05:27:25 PM
-
I'm interested in trying to pin down standard Castagnari button spacings, if there are any, and particularly for larger models like the Mory or Handry. I was wondering if anyone might be willing to grab a ruler and take a look, perhaps across 10 buttons centre-to-centre for accuracy. (I'd be interested in any accurate measurements for different melodeon models really. There isn't much information available on the subject.)
I've read that the Castagnari Tommy has 19mm centre-to-centre along the rows, and that this is smaller than usual. I've recently been looking at CBA spacings, and 19mm seems common there, but I get the impression these are closer packed than melodeons. (?)
Thanks!
-
Can't help with castags, but CBA range from 18 (e.g. post-Soviet space) to 20mm (Hohner, some Excelsiors). I wouldn't benchmark diatonics against them, because for a CBA I much prefer 20mm to 18mm on a 5-row box, yet, 18mm feels great on my 2-row hromka. Different technique and hand position.
I think my Club Morinos were 20mm and felt great too.
-
Just measured my Casta Mory and Rik, 10 buttons centre to centre 170mm.
Julian
-
Thanks both! That's very helpful.
-
Julian has beaten me too it.
I think all standard size Castagnaris ( i.e. not the small sizes like Tommy or Lilly ) have the same sized spacing.
I went from a small size Tommy to a standard size Hascy without noticing any difference, if that helps.
... and I have very small hands too!
I remember asking a similar question when first starting up.
If memory serves, the button spacing is the same on small/standard sizes, button centre to button centre, but as the buttons are smaller on small sizes, they are closer to one another.
... but I might have mis-remembered ::)
-
Very "average". small models like the Lilly are closer. but it's amazing how quickly you adapt
-
Very "average". small models like the Lilly are closer. but it's amazing how quickly you adapt
Agreed, I borrowed a friend's Benny and found the close button spacing a problem for all of about five minutes. Surprisingly quick to adapt to.
-
I've read that the Castagnari Tommy has 19mm centre-to-centre along the rows, and that this is smaller than usual.
I don't have a Tommy but I have reedblocks from one. It's 17mm. Button spacing could be different (with a 'fanned' mechanism), but I very much doubt it.
-
FWIW the Lily is definitely tighter than a Benny. I’d assumed they would be the same but they’re not.
I think the Mory is a little tighter than the Hascy but am not in a position to measure them atm.
Either way it doesn’t take long to adjust but I find the Lily takes longest, and I’m making more errors until I’ve played my fingers in.
Gren
-
OK! Great info, thanks all. 👍
-
FWIW the Lily is definitely tighter than a Benny. I’d assumed they would be the same but they’re not.
I think the Mory is a little tighter than the Hascy but am not in a position to measure them atm.
Either way it doesn’t take long to adjust but I find the Lily takes longest, and I’m making more errors until I’ve played my fingers in.
Gren
Mory is 170mm from one side of a button to same side ten buttons along (ie same as centre to centre)
Hascy is 172mm for the 10 buttons, which is not very much difference, it’s perhaps odd that I’d noticed.
Benny is 163mm same 10 buttons
Lily is 150mm
Horner Erica is 179mm
Lilliput is 148mm
Dino Baffetti Super is 180mm
Gren