Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Theo on September 11, 2025, 05:04:43 PM
-
My first trial of making a repair video.
Please feel free to comment here with positives and ideas for improvement and development.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uWkhn_VlrL8
For the moment the video is unlisted so you must use the link above.
-
Interesting video, informative and well done ! I liked the idea of bending levers to get the whole action out in one piece. You said the new springs were thinner and had a different angle, which made me curious about the actual diameters (not sure how relevant this info would be for the video).
-
The original springs were .65mm, the replacements .55mm. If I were doing it again I would include the measurements. I might add it to the notes.
-
great video. option 2 which might have been worth a mention is obviously remove the levers instead of bending them and put in new pins (model railway track pins) on reaaasembly. Saves bending and rebending levers but more time consuming. other thing worth a mention is maybe diameter of old spring vs new spring. Using old rod to replace the springs one at a time is a genius idea.....thats the kind of stuff folks need to know. great stuff.
-
Chris, yes I’ve tried that method too. There are pros and cons both ways. I prefer the way I do it because it’s a bit quicker, the levers are stay connected in the correct positions, and I never manage to find pins that were as good as the originals.
-
And comments on the quality of filming, focus, sound etc?
-
And comments on the quality of filming, focus, sound etc?
Since you asked, Theo ... FWIW I thought it an excellent instructional video. However, as an ex-pro photographer I'm puzzled by the low contrast and low colour saturation, which must surely be down to the lighting. It's even enough, but it seems very "flat" (to use the technical term), which seems to have resulted in a video which is quite "low-key" visually.
Having said that, I'm stuck for a sensible way of improving matters without a great deal of experimentation, so by all means feel free to disregard my opinion and crack on with your next one!
-
Thanks Dan, that’s very helpful. I need to look again at lighting.
-
Thanks Dan, that’s very helpful. I need to look again at lighting.
I'm not sure about that Theo. I just ran it from the start again and on this screen (a bog-standard Chromebook running Chrome browser), it's flat right from the opening shot outside your premises.
If anyone else comments along the same lines, I wonder if there's some setting somewhere that is affecting the colour management at your end - or at YouTube. Unfortunately with video and browsers, I have zero expert knowledge on which to base suggestions.
ETA - Just checked it on my wife's Windows 11 Laptop running Chrome. With the screen brightness turned up it still lacks contrast and saturation by my standards (and compared to similar offerings). But obviously that's very much one opinion FWIW ...
-
It would have been good to see a close up of the springs in situ, to see how they’re mounted and bear on the button rods. Presumably the axle runs through the loop in the springs, explaining why it’s necessary to remove it. And where do you get weaker springs?
-
Enjoyed the video, wouldn,t mind it being a bit longer.
Was the bass end from a Corona 3?- The pattern of holes on the bassplate is different to mine.
-
The bass end was from a 12 bass Double Ray.
-
Ok not a Hollywood production, but vastly more professional than any of my ramblings.
All the essentials are there, but the details are missing - how the spring hook works and a close-up of the axle follower would help.
And it's difficult to keep the work centre of shot and not get your head in the way.
But it does the job very well. I'm being picky. A series of videos of this quality would be very welcome
-
So I loved it, particularly the charming intro!
I’ve recently started tweaking my own melodeons (pallets, basic tuning, springs etc), which I’m loving, but wish I’d known this first (particularly the trick of using a second axel)
Since you asked specifically re filming/sound, this is a super personal thing, but personally I prefer a narrower aperture.
Apologies if you know all this (or I’ve forgotten my filming days), but when you have a wide aperture (like I think you have set here), you get more “realism” with a narrow “depth of field” effect (ie a small area in focus and an elegant blurring of areas just outside this short depth that’s in focus)
This works well when the box is on the desk, but when at the start (when I guess you want people most engaged in watching), the box is slightly out of focus, whilst the desk stays in focus.
Most cameras will also have a “autofocus” feature, but I find these tend to do unreliable things eg would have focused on your head etc.
If you set a narrow aperture, everything is in focus (a bit like in your intro sequence of your house) and I think might work better for this sort of detailed video.
The only downside of narrow apertures is you need more light (as there’s hole in the lense is smaller) or else the camera will try and compensate by increasing its sensitivity but can lead to a grainier image.
Just a personal thing though, LOVED the video Thankyou for your time putting it together (and intrigued how you get air to your tuning box, am currently planning making one)
-
Loved it Theo. You've put a lot of work into that, and a series of similar films will be a great resource for aspiring repairers. I thought the lighting in general was ok, but the work inside the box could do with extra lighting. One of those circle LED light things so beloved of influencers (of which you are now one!) might produce a diffuse light where you need it. And zoom ins of the spring work before removal, and after. Also close zoom ins when you're replacing the springs would be great. No issues with sound; it was great.
But in general, great - please keep doing them.
-
Please feel free to comment here with positives and ideas for improvement and development.
Lovely video. I sure couldn't produce anything like this.
A few thoughts (since you've asked!):
Video:
My personal bench is abysmal and I am notorious for being a lot worse than average for leaving stuff on it :-[ but for the video purposes, I'd keep the bench free of tools & parts that are not relevant to this particular job - it lets the viewer focus on what's actually needed. Makes it a bit easier to scroll through the video too if looking for a particular step.
Putting a white sheet on the bench creates a good contrast of parts vs bench compared to a wooden surface. But it might call for some experimenting with lightling.
Try experimenting with a lamp/torch so that it would light up the insides of the box, especially when doing fiddly steps like fitting springs.
If there are any lengths of the video that don't require commentary, add some good background melodeon music, like the one in the intro :||:.
Content:
Really depends on how deep down the rabbit hole you intend to go.
There's two topics in one here. 1) Taking the mech out & putting it back in. 2) Adjusting spring tension.
You can split them into 2 videos, e.g.:
1) In-Out
- Types of mechs. E.g. Direct drive, "Flat" Roller, "Raised" roller, explain how different types of linkages work.
- Points already covered
- What to do when you do get a stripped screw. E.g. try a drop of CA into the hole. If it doesn't help, then glue in a wood chip/toothpick and make a hole in it with a hand drill.
- Adjusting axle mounting points for levers to take out any lever sideshake (by bending the posts that hold the axle)
- Maybe cover axle wear (and push rod pistons wear on roller mechs) as it's quite relevant for melodeons where the same button is pressed over & over again, compared to Stradella.
- How to put it all back in.
- Check for bent pallet levers after installation (happens with aluminium and soft steel just from taking the mech out) and show how to adjust them.
- Check for even button height after installation. Explain why it can change (pallet lever bent, pallet thickness altered). Adjusting the levers vs heating up the rod and adjusting the button. Probably worth mentioning acceptable range for button height & travel.
2) Spring tension.
You already have the expertise what springs to install into this bass end, but you're not explaining how you arrived at it, which is what most beginners would really struggle with.
- Check original tension by placing weights on buttons.
- Explain trade-off between playability and box becoming self-playing on the push.
- Propose target weights for a professionally set-up box (this is very box-specific, but, say, I'd aim for 220-240g as the first point of call on a roller bass machine. This is probably significantly lower on a direct drive mech in the video but I never worked with these.
- Talk about bass machine leverage. Button travel & pallet lift vs pallet resistance on push & playability.
- Adjusting spring tension: bending springs vs making new springs from different wire gauge.
- Testing adjusted spring in the box to measure the tension/weight & check for self-playing on push.
- Ensuring all buttons have as equal tension as possible.
- Worth explaining that this set up is what makes the difference between a professional-grade box and an attic find/barely usable cheapo beginner box. Definitely worth explaining that this work can take a lot of hours, (if not days for bass and treble) and this is what a professional melodeon player will be paying for when they buy a high end melodeon or are paying a fettler to regulate an existing box.
All of the above is a bit of idealistic knowledge-share content. I fully appreciate that not all customers who want their box "done" are willing to pay for the hours & hours that have to go into such set up.
-
Thanks, Theo, it's a great video.
I didn't have any problems with the lighting either, but if you wanted to lift it a bit, a ring light on a cantilever stand would bring up the bench illumination without bouncing back. You can get the sort that clamp to desks like anglepoise lamps, or ones that stand on the floor.
I like messy workbench too. It's interesting and sometimes useful to see what people keep within reach. I've used a small paintbrush to get dust out assemblies before, but they can be a bit feeble; I hadn't thought of using pastry brushes.
As someone who can take on some small repair tasks, I always find the hardest thing by far is identifying the size of any fixtures and hand tools needed. I've been held up by two days trying to work out the size of a single screw and then find a match for it! So it would be nice at the end of videos to have a stationary screen listing any key bits you used. In this one, what gauge was the temporary axle rod? What sort of little clamp did you use to handle the springs? What springs were they?
-
"messy workbench"
I was going to comment that his workbench was nice and tidy!
-
"messy workbench"
I was going to comment that his workbench was nice and tidy!
Thank you. It is much clearer than it was before we started filming!
-
Hi Theo, the video is fine as it is, FWIW. Personally i wouldn't bother with any 'box opening' (pet hate of mine) and though charming, i'd keep any intro to a minimum and dispense with the 'who i am and this is what I do’. Most YTubers don't actually bother with it and start 'in medias res' (in the middle of the action). The instructional content is solid and it's obvious what you are doing and how you reach the goal, which is what people want to know about. When you have 250k followers you can hire a camera person to monkey about with the aperture settings and fancy lighting. I do however particularly like the overhead camera. What camera and how did you suspend it?
-
You might like to sort out a little close ups camera, or, insert stills perhaps, or some other way to be confident that fine details aren't missed out. For example, the sequence of unhooking the springs around 2:30 is decidedly not in focus, so, I'd ask, do you feel completely satisfied you've shown how to unhook them, with this footage?
Also, I agree with Disparate Dan, but, is the flat colour grade in the intro a stylistic choice? The same exterior shot of the property in the outro at:
https://youtu.be/uWkhn_VlrL8?t=620
vs
https://youtu.be/uWkhn_VlrL8?t=1
You can see clearly the patch of sky in the upper right corner, and, just the image in general, in the opening it's presented with a flatter contrast but the outro version has had its levels adjusted so eg the white fluffy clouds are... white, the sky is blue, and life is worth living etc. Colour grading in general is super worth while but the intro is the most... apparently flat, section.
Also, are those exterior shots are also 50fps, and all the other indoor footage is 25, with each frame doubled? Blessingly it seems to have been shot at 25. And, you indeed probably will want more lighting.
From just the story of the video, it would have been nice to see it all put back together again, before it was sent off.
-
Just uploaded the next short video about a simple reed holding device. Will be live from 18:00 GMT today.
https://youtu.be/re9BBmXOYQs
-
Next video is shot and now editing. It shows the process of stripping and reassembling a keyboard with wooden levers.
I welcome suggestions for future topics.
-
Theo, you are a paradigm 👏
-
Hi Theo, I would love to see how to repurpose piano accordion reeds to use in melodeon repair. How to add some solder to the tip to drop the pitch. Also when filing the tip of a p/a reed and it curls down a bit or up how to straighten the reed. Great videos thanks.
-
Thanks Polkadot, I’m already planning something similar next. How to approach changing the pitch of reeds. That will be equally applicable to PA reeds.
-
Thanks for your last video Theo, most interesting! Regarding your tuning table: did you built it yourself? Do you plan to make a video on it too?
-
Thanks for your last video Theo, most interesting! Regarding your tuning table: did you built it yourself? Do you plan to make a video on it too?
I did make it myself, and yes I can make a video about that. Thank you, I'll add it to the list.
Incidentally I think of it as a "test" table/bellows, rather than "tuning" table.
-
I've started a new topic in Recordings and Videos (https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=31933.msg367640#msg367640) where I'll post links to videos as I publish them. There is a new one this morning.
-
Two more videos on the way. The first is available now, the second should be available later today.
I'm still experimenting and learning about how best to present things. The main innovation this time is using a vertical camera over the work bench to show more detail. I think is still need to improve the way I use the camera for speaking direct. I'll probably get a second camera for this with a monitor of some kind so the shots are better framed. I've also used to different mics so the sound quality and levels ar a bit variable.
As before all comments welcome, on either the content or the videography.
The topic is pallet refacing. First video (https://youtu.be/v5EH-f-VUo8) shows preparing, removing and cleaning pallets.
Second video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wBvnSogjew) shows the reassembly, leak checking and testing.
-
two more great videos. i need one of those files for cleaning out the pallet slots! i find a dab of warm water on a brush can make getting all the old glue off the top of the pallet much easier (and the disc of retaining fabric on pokerworks and ericas)...but it depends on what glue has been used. Likewise acetone on a brush can make getting the felt off the bottom of the pallet nice and easy. lots of great tips. you make it all look so relaxing!
-
Thanks Chris.
Most Hohner melodeon pallets have a narrower slot so that file is too big. A hacksaw blade or a junior hacksaw is about right for them.
-
I have a junior hacksaw but I doubt I'll ever make my own repairs to my Hohner. The video was good to watch but I'll leave repairs to you experts if I ever need it.
There are some things that are not difficult that are useful for all players to know. The obvious one is reeds that go silent because of some airborne fibres jamming them. I should do a short video on that.
Any suggestions or requests for future videos?
I already have a list including:
- Changing the pitch of a reed. I often see the question: how far up or down can I tune a reed? There isn't a simple answer. The short answer is -"It all depends". I've already started planning a video on this.
- Replacing a bellows gasket
- Isolating an individual reed for tuning
- Reed block inspection and repair
- Warped fondo repair
- Making a test bellows
- Fixing a reed that sounds wrong
- Replacing a broken reed
And then there are the big subjects like reed overhaul, tuning, waxing
Please reply if there is something you would like to see, either a topic from this list or something else.
-
(...) The obvious one is reeds that go silent because of some airborne fibres jamming them. I should do a short video on that.
Would that cover a note that plays fine then, partway through the tune, it stops sounding?
-
Possibly
Repair is a process that starts with identifying a problem. You’ve done that. Next you have to identify the cause, then correct it, then check its fixed. If not fixed repeat the process. In a video I can’t fix your specific problem, but what I try to do is show a method that should allow you to investigate your case and fix it.
There is more than one possible cause for most symptoms so you have to be a bit of a detective.
-
Thanks Theo, all good stuff, keep 'em coming ;)
-
Warped fondo repair would be very useful to see!
-
I think while interesting … a warped fondo is actually an 'edge case' for plain vanilla repair and maintenance. Just knowing what you are looking at inside is helpful. Also..some Hohners have sliders in the foot of the reed block (like the ones in the Hohner PA you just repaired). Safely extracting and replacing the blocks and locating the pin at the end (and not bending the slider) is useful to know for first timers inside a box.
Having set of 'sounding bellows' etc and the efficacy of pinging…how to ping the inside reed…often something which fixes issues..would be v helpful for casual owners who want to be able to help themselves (IMO). Or flattening one raised key (although that's more of a PA issue).
-
Thanks for the ideas Rog.
I agree that dealing with a warped fondo is not a common repair, but it does happen and even an inexperience repairer should know how to recognise it because if left it can compromise further reed work.
Point taken about safety removing and replacing reed blocks - I’ll add that to my list.
-
Excellent videos - as an aspiring repairer, seeing how others do different repair tasks is invaluable both to compare different methods used and to discover a what makes a good workflow.
What would be useful to me is an index of different repair areas with clickable links to the videos - if that makes sense. E.g. keyboard, reeds, reed blocks, stops, bellows, mic mounting etc with different links in each section of different repairs if that makes sense?
I think I may have to repair a set of bellows soon, so that would also be invaluable!
Thanks for all your hard work Theo!
-
What would be useful to me is an index of different repair areas with clickable links to the videos - if that makes sense. E.g. keyboard, reeds, reed blocks, stops, bellows, mic mounting etc with different links in each section of different repairs if that makes sense?
Thank you for the kind words.
At some point, when time allows, I will create a video index on my website.
-
Theo's repair-a-day?
-
For newcomers (and I was one once) a brilliant resource in addition to all these great videos, is accordionrevival…it's PA centric but covers just about everything you need to know for tuning, maintenance, repair etc…and what applies to a PA pretty much applies to a melodeon, with one or two caveats. It amazes me that this old but valuable resource still exists…so here it is
https://accordionrevival.com/Home.php
-
Just published a very short video with a simple maintenance process that every player should use.
https://youtu.be/6wcZ7w205gY
-
... a simple maintenance process that every player should use ...
OK, I'm the first to admit that with me having emphysema I'm a bit keen on airborne dust and whatnot (especially other people's), but I reckon it's not a bad idea to wear some kind of mask when doing that sort of thing.