Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Pat McInnis on January 11, 2026, 06:07:28 PM

Title: Replace Thirds?
Post by: Pat McInnis on January 11, 2026, 06:07:28 PM
So I'm ordering reeds for a new Casali project that I'm working on and it has a pretty similar chord layout to Hohner Corso. So two 1st in different octaves, A 3rd (typically masked off) and a fifth. The two first reeds are also shared with the bass to give it four voices. Gotta love that big growly A!! So in lieu of masking my thirds, I thought I would add a voice to the 5th. I know this isn't a new trick but it is to me. I guess the question is: do I simply repeat the 5th or do another octave like the first? Or is there another option?

Thanks in advance for opinions

Title: Re: Replace Thirds?
Post by: Lars on January 11, 2026, 06:47:39 PM
Instead of just blocking off the 3rds, I always prefer to double the root note, same octave as the notes shared between the bass and chord. A Corso also has one of the shared an octave higher, which is nice for some boxes, if systematically used on all basses.

I know 3 x root notes and 1 x 5th might seem too much of one note, but I like the fatness it gives me, whereas 2 x root and 2 x 5th might suit others - but I find one 5th to be plenty.
Title: Re: Replace Thirds?
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 11, 2026, 07:53:19 PM

   never heard of that variation on "power chord"!  Has anyone else used it?
Title: Re: Replace Thirds?
Post by: Pat McInnis on January 11, 2026, 09:01:33 PM
Instead of just blocking off the 3rds, I always prefer to double the root note, same octave as the notes shared between the bass and chord. A Corso also has one of the shared an octave higher, which is nice for some boxes, if systematically used on all basses.

I know 3 x root notes and 1 x 5th might seem too much of one note, but I like the fatness it gives me, whereas 2 x root and 2 x 5th might suit others - but I find one 5th to be plenty.

That does seem excessive on the root but I have no reference point besides those that have tried it. Lets hear what the mob thinks.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal