Melodeon.net Forums

Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: odonovanchris on January 24, 2026, 06:16:35 PM

Title: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: odonovanchris on January 24, 2026, 06:16:35 PM
I'd like to get a conversation going on the current market for vintage Paolo Soprani boxes. Ever since covid the ability to get a nice Paolo has really dried up and I am wondering peoples' thoughts on why this might be the case. Here are my observations:

- Prices of 1960s 4 voice Paolos have gone up from roughly 2500 Euro pre covid to around 3500 minimum nowadays.
- Very few listings are showing up, and the ones that do show up get snapped up in minutes.
- A recent auction for an unrestored 4v Grey Paolo got bid up to 6500 pounds (not including 25% commission and price of restoration).
- This demand seems to be for a very specific type of box (1950s to early 70s 3v and 4v paolos). Hohners and other brands don't seem to be moving much.

I'm thinking it might be an influx of more players into the Irish Trad scene who want to compete in Fleadhs with "legit" boxes in the eyes of Comhaltas. Or investors buying up all the supply - kind of like what was happening in the vintage guitar market during covid.

I'd be interested to hear if this demand has carried over into modern boxes that mimic the look of the old Paolos (i.e. Manfrini and even Paolo Soprani's current offerings).

Would love to hear other peoples experiences with this.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Theo on January 24, 2026, 06:25:26 PM
I’ve not seen one of these in the UK recently.
I do get phone calls from Ireland from people looking, so there’s certainly an unmet demand. 
I also know one collector who has several nice Paolo Sopranis, and numerous other semitone boxes.  It’s possible that there are numbers of other boxes in the hands of collectors too.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Rog on January 24, 2026, 08:54:40 PM
This is my own opinion…but having seen a few Paolo S boxes, often in poor shape after decades of hard playing, I don't understand what people see in them. Ok..they can sound pretty good but they are heavy blighters to play.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on January 25, 2026, 05:54:47 AM
If Saltarelle boxes (or anything else for that matter) were what was around and available for Irish players in the 50s, 60s and 70s, I suspect it would be those boxes that would be highly desirable today.  I don't believe there were a lot of choices back in the day for an Irish box player - it was mostly Hohner or Paolo, and the latter was a better build.  They've become so popular because that's what was around back in the day and now they're no longer available.  The Paolo became iconic because so many of our favourite players played them and that's what was heard, that's what Irish box playing sounded like, and there's a desire to emulate/replicate that.  If the pedigree wasn't there, I'm not sure the Paolo would be as revered today based on its own merits.  I've owned and worked on several, and even recently played a 'holy grey' (apparently it was one of the 'good ones' according to it's owner, a well-known Irish box player).  I get the appeal - the Paolo has character and a certain charm, but in and of itself it's not necessarily inherently worth what people are paying for them.  They've become so desirable because we've decided they're special, we want to sound like our musical heroes that played them, and they're hard to acquire (and wanting something that's rare and hard to acquire only makes us want it more!)  The prices for some of these have gone up to absurdly high amounts in many cases simply because they are rare and desirable, not because the build quality is such that the inherent value demands it.  We've done this to ourselves...!  Having said that, the prices of accordions everywhere have skyrocketed since the pandemic.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Tamba on January 25, 2026, 07:40:46 AM
 https://youtu.be/C3emwPOXezc?si=DQZvJUxjn-vPxndR (https://youtu.be/C3emwPOXezc?si=DQZvJUxjn-vPxndR)

Yes, it seems that the dearth of those old Paolos is making other boxes of a certain vintage more desirable. This is a fantastic example of how to fettle an old Hohner. It sounds great for it age!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 25, 2026, 11:07:31 AM
During my internship with the accordion maker that taught me, one project over the duration of the internship was making an homage of sorts to those boxes (https://vanglabeke.fr/cambium/). I don't think it was ever intended to be an imitation or a strict copy of old Paolos (which would not make sense IMO), it's just a modern-made accordion that has inspirations. I'm under the impression that it's the same for Manfrinis. Not sure about the modern Jubilee models though.
I concur with what Matt has said earlier, it's not a particular testimony to the build quality. Look what Seamus Begley did also with a battered Hohner 3v, it's not a particularly high-end box, but the result is glorious.
Mind you I think these kind of Hohners are also starting to be sought out, but not in the same extent (and frankly out of proportions) than old Paolos.
I've yet to try a Paolo from the 40s/50s, the one I tried was from the 60s or 70s (I don't remember) and it was quite underwhelming as a box (dead heavy and on the 'asthmatic' side of the spectrum).
I had a little chat on Facebook with people justifying the speculation around old Paolos, I didn't quite managed to understand how one could find those prices normal or just.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Winston Smith on January 25, 2026, 01:06:12 PM
"I didn't quite managed to understand how one could find those prices normal or just."

It's pretty easy really! And the same reason abounds in any and every niche market, whether it's Land Rovers, instruments or china ornaments; some people have enough spare cash to just have whatever they fancy, and at any price! Inflation isn't necessarily driven by a shortage or inherent value, it's more to do with someone being willing, and able, to pay more than others for an article or service which they want.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 25, 2026, 03:12:46 PM
Yet while this explains it, it doesn't justify or warrant that this is a normal or just phenomenon.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: tirpous on January 25, 2026, 04:44:34 PM
These generally were (and still are, when in good condition) good instruments. They are plentiful on stage, in sessions, etc... but rare on the market. People seem to keep them, often to make music. Go figure !

Asking prices are all over the place, from quite reasonable to outrageous. There are still good deals out there for a patient buyer.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on January 25, 2026, 05:17:32 PM
https://youtu.be/C3emwPOXezc?si=DQZvJUxjn-vPxndR (https://youtu.be/C3emwPOXezc?si=DQZvJUxjn-vPxndR)

Yes, it seems that the dearth of those old Paolos is making other boxes of a certain vintage more desirable. This is a fantastic example of how to fettle an old Hohner. It sounds great for it age!

Conor Connolly now plays an old Paolo!
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on January 25, 2026, 05:20:25 PM
Asking prices are all over the place, from quite reasonable to outrageous. There are still good deals out there for a patient buyer.

I think that was the case up until very recently. I’m not sure ‘good deals’ on Paolos are to be found at the moment. Martin Quinn recently mentioned that they’re hard to come by at all these days.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: tirpous on January 25, 2026, 05:36:54 PM
Quote
Quote from: tirpous on Today at 04:44:34 PM

    Asking prices are all over the place, from quite reasonable to outrageous. There are still good deals out there for a patient buyer.


I think that was the case up until very recently. I’m not sure ‘good deals’ on Paolos are to be found at the moment. Martin Quinn recently mentioned that they’re hard to come by at all these days.

Well time is of the essence, this is why I mentioned being a patient buyer. There was little out there early last year, then some boxes were offered for sale in the summer and early fall, and then it got quiet again. That type of thing. Waiting game...
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Paul Bryan on January 26, 2026, 02:35:00 PM
ive heard that there are several people that have collected many of these grey paolos and as a result the high price of any of them that are for sale here in ireland .the paolos are in demand for fleadh compatitions  as it seems its the only box to play they are hard to get therefore the market price will rise
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 26, 2026, 07:56:02 PM
It's also a bit odd that the ranking at the Fleadh should be that much dependent on the box: one would think the music is more important than the instrument itself.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Winston Smith on January 26, 2026, 09:18:29 PM
"Fleadh"
I've always wondered how that's pronounced, anyone?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Toby B on January 26, 2026, 09:56:54 PM
Flaah (flar?) I have heard ... but ... Stiamh will correct?
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Fionn on January 27, 2026, 02:08:13 AM
"Fleadh"
I've always wondered how that's pronounced, anyone?

With an English accent it rhymes with blah.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on January 28, 2026, 03:14:12 PM
Ever since covid the ability to get a nice Paolo has really dried up

Hi Chris and all,

I guess "ability to get" could relate to availability of instruments offered for sale, and also the market price relative to one's personal budget, and perhaps other factors such as geography, willingness to buy unrestored projects, etc.

There's availability, although certainly not abundance. Even from Miami FL USA (a desert for these instruments, though there have been rare exceptions over the past 2 decades), I've been able to use the web to see several prime-period semitone-tuned Paolo Soprani 2-row button accordions offered for sale, and then sold, over the past year, in the UK, Ireland, and the US. One on ebay from the US, one listed on facebook from Ireland, one recently auctioned in the UK etc

Price of course is going to be related to availability. When many many players want a particular type of instrument that has limited availability (e.g. no longer made) then it's only natural for prices to go up. But also, when market prices rise that can increase availability -- bringing instruments on the market that were previously not for sale because their owners valued them more than the market had. Thus when examples of a particular model that are for sale become very rare, that may signal that the owners believe the market is undervaluing them. If prices correct upward, the scarcity may diminish.

As someone who remembers the world before the internet, I think that since the 1990s the "ability" to find almost any model of vintage musical instrument has increased exponentially, although maybe with a somewhat bumpy curve. Today, via search engines, social media, online marketplaces etc, if a rare instrument is for sale almost anywhere in the world we can find out about it, if we are searching diligently. I searched for 20 years (1988 to 2008) to find a great one-row Irish-American box, spent thousands of hours and a lot of money in the process (including travel and buying boxes that were "almost" what I wanted), but since 2007 newly-offered ones for sale are coming to my attention every year. Sometimes we might have to travel to buy / collect -- I can think of two cases where friends have traveled internationally to buy Baldonis  in the past year or two. Talk about added costs! Faint heart ne'er won fair Baldoni, as I often say. But sometimes they can be bought remotely and shipped also.

It's possible that, depending on your geographic location, there was a "golden age" in which grey Paolos were abundant and cheap in real terms (compared to incomes at the time). But I suspect that the "cheapness" is mainly seen in hindsight. I remember in the mid 1990s they were hard to find in Boston (USA) but  being able to trade for two of them for an agreed value around $2000 each, but that money could buy a really nice concertina at that time and in fact I traded several concertinas for the two grey boxes. Both later sold from my shop. I think the concertinas would be worth more today than the two Paolos, which were playable but not in fine condition.

Once you find one for sale, you can get in the game if you pay a price that's competitive with what others are willing to pay. Or you can search diligently for bargains (my own usual strategy!), or become more flexible about what kind of instrument you need (e.g. consider Paolos from less desirable periods, other makes of vintage instruments, or new ones).

With the antique wooden flutes, I think that we are at a point where the best new ones have many advantages over even the superb antique ones that were once the best option for traditional players. 

Maybe that day will come with ever-improving new button accordions rendering the old grey boxes much less desirable, and if so you might have your chance at that point to find a vintage Paolo in a less competitive market for buyers. Judging from the Briggs, Paddy Clancy, etc however new boxes are not necessarily going to be cheaper than vintage Paolos. To the commenter who is making new accordions: a challenge would be to see if you can make one great enough that someone who owns and plays a great vintage Paolo would gladly trade it for one of yours!

I suspect you'll find a beauty Chris if you save up for it, keep your eyes peeled, and strike while the iron is hot when you have the opportunity.

Best

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 28, 2026, 09:15:37 PM
Maybe that day will come with ever-improving new button accordions rendering the old grey boxes much less desirable, and if so you might have your chance at that point to find a vintage Paolo in a less competitive market for buyers. Judging from the Briggs, Paddy Clancy, etc however new boxes are not necessarily going to be cheaper than vintage Paolos. To the commenter who is making new accordions: a challenge would be to see if you can make one great enough that someone who owns and plays a great vintage Paolo would gladly trade it for one of yours!

I don't really subscribe to the framing here, as I'm not under the impression that wanting a better accordion is the reason why Paolos are so popular (it's a bit like saying that people would buy cars from the 50s because they are better, they're just different animals). Also, it'd be pretending that this is all rational (wich it is not, and it's perfectly fine). Different makers and brands make different accordions, that have their handling, look & feel, sound, and so on, and it's great that people have the choice of what kind of box they want. IMO, as a maker, wanting to 'best' (if that even makes sense) Paolos is a wild-goose chase.
Seeing the ludicrous amounts at which some Paolos were advertised recently, even a Briggs is cheap.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on January 28, 2026, 09:56:23 PM
Maybe that day will come with ever-improving new button accordions rendering the old grey boxes much less desirable, and if so you might have your chance at that point to find a vintage Paolo in a less competitive market for buyers. Judging from the Briggs, Paddy Clancy, etc however new boxes are not necessarily going to be cheaper than vintage Paolos. To the commenter who is making new accordions: a challenge would be to see if you can make one great enough that someone who owns and plays a great vintage Paolo would gladly trade it for one of yours!

I don't really subscribe to the framing here, as I'm not under the impression that wanting a better accordion is the reason why Paolos are so popular (it's a bit like saying that people would buy cars from the 50s because they are better, they're just different animals). Also, it'd be pretending that this is all rational (wich it is not, and it's perfectly fine). Different makers and brands make different accordions, that have their handling, look & feel, sound, and so on, and it's great that people have the choice of what kind of box they want. IMO, as a maker, wanting to 'best' (if that even makes sense) Paolos is a wild-goose chase.
Seeing the ludicrous amounts at which some Paolos were advertised recently, even a Briggs is cheap.

I didn't use the words "better" or "best." But I think it is a practical matter for some excellent players, especially professionals: what model of instrument do they choose to play. Of course their choice of instrument might be influenced by many factors including rewards for endorsing a modern brand, or appearance / mystique. But I think it's notable that some excellent flute players have chosen to play mainly modern instruments instead of antique Rudall & Rose (etc). And some exceptional and/or professional box players who could afford to play a vintage Paolo Soprani (and may actually own one or more of them) are mainly using Gaillard, or Briggs, or Paddy Clancy boxes (etc) in their work.  I think those choices are informative and (IMO) if someone wanted to make an accordion that would be useful in traditional Irish music (such as Gaillard, or Briggs, or Paddy Clancy or perhaps yourself), I think that maker could  take pride if they could create an instrument that was so preferred by an excellent player that he or she would trade a vintage Paolo for it. That was the point of my comment about a possible goal for modern makers.

But I also encourage you to consider whether *your* framing of the current respect / demand / love for vintage Paolo Sopranis, and the prices that many players have been willing to pay for them, is respectful to the current and former players of these instruments.  Do you think that someone who has sacrificed to invest in such an instrument, or whose parents have done so, has been dying for you to share your wisdom that they paid a "ludicrous" price, or that the general market prices for these instruments are not "normal or just" according to . . . some accordion maker who has an anonymous profile, complaining on a web forum?

Wishing you every success in making great instruments that are highly valued by their players, whatever price you choose to ask for them! 

And actually I wish you good luck also if your goal is to convince thousands of players that vintage Paolo Sopranis are overvalued. If their prices come down, as sometimes happens with musical instruments (see vintage piano accordions),  I think there might still be a few players who want them and who will appreciate the discount.

Best

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 29, 2026, 09:13:22 AM
That was the point of my comment about a possible goal for modern makers.
That's what I understood, and I agree with you that any maker would be glad if someone preferred their box to a vintage Paolo. I was merely discussing if it's preferable for a maker to make accordion with that purpose in mind, or just making accordions that they're happy with. It's not a statement that Paolos are not desirable (they are, and for good reason). While one can (and IMO should, any great box is a good source of inspiration) draw inspiration from them, I'm not sure it's possible to compete with them, as I'm under the impression that if people want Paolos, they want the 'real deal'. Which does not mean that the same people won't see the merit of a modern, Paolo-inspired box such as Manfrinis for instance.

But I also encourage you to consider whether *your* framing of the current respect / demand / love for vintage Paolo Sopranis, and the prices that many players have been willing to pay for them, is respectful to the current and former players of these instruments.
I don't really see what it'd have to do with respect. I'm perfectly comfortable with my position that 10k€ and more (as was recently advertised) is too much for any used 2-row 4v or 3v. This has nothing to do with disrespecting anyone.

Do you think that someone who has sacrificed to invest in such an instrument, or whose parents have done so, has been dying for you to share your wisdom that they paid a "ludicrous" price, or that the general market prices for these instruments are not "normal or just" according to . . . some accordion maker who has an anonymous profile, complaining on a web forum?
Precisely my point: I'm not really wishing that people have to sacrifice anything (interesting choice of words) when buying an accordion (put money aside, yes; sacrifice, no). That's why I think that kind of price is too much. But I don't think that we'll agree on the 'benefits' of a market-based economy.
Also: I'm not a maker (I made only one box during an internship); and not really here anonymously either.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on January 29, 2026, 09:39:18 AM
But I don't think that we'll agree on the 'benefits' of a market-based economy.
Also: I'm not a maker (I made only one box during an internship); and not really here anonymously either.

Good to meet you -Y-  ! Paul Groff here. So you won't be able to offer us your own instruments for your own chosen "normal and just" prices? This means you have less power to influence the accordion market than I had hoped :(

I haven't said anything to imply that a market-based economy has "benefits," but the questions that Chris posed in starting this thread relate to our current real world in which prices for Paolo Sopranis of the type he describes have increased while availability has decreased.

I think respect is appropriate for the precious funds that people have invested in instruments - particularly, parents who have invested in providing their kids an instrument to inspire them, and one hopes that will retain a lasting value. No one can predict the future but those parents have often consulted with music teachers, professional players, accordion techs, and in some cases trusted instrument dealers before spending what they hope will be a fair price. The community of people who have played and cherished the accordions associated with Irish traditional music as a whole is really influencing the prices. Who are you calling ludicrous?

I love some accordions that are much more abundant and inexpensive, such as the Hohner Corso models that someone mentioned in regard to the late Seamus Begley (although he did switch to an early 50s Paolo). Josephine Marsh and many more players are a joy to hear on 2 voice Hohners. You, I, or Chris can find all of those that we might want and can trust that bargains will show up regularly, even below the typical low market price for these models. This is great news for all who are budget-conscious! But Chris is looking for an old Paolo Soprani and the market for those rarer and more expensive instruments was the topic he chose. As Theo pointed out, Chris is not the only one.

All the best

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 29, 2026, 10:00:29 AM
Who are you calling ludicrous?
The price, which, afaik, is not a person.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Chris Ryall on January 29, 2026, 10:13:44 AM

  The same thing happened with vintage concertinas. I had to invest some £'s to rescue my Wheatstone Linota. But after 20 years I sold it for roughly 10x what I paid for it in 1982.

  My two present melodeons were both from the makers … but I had owned about 6 secondhand instruments, and 2 new ones previously.  In all cases I ended up selling them for more than I paid for them.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 29, 2026, 10:41:58 AM
Good to meet you -Y-  ! Paul Groff here. So you won't be able to offer us your own instruments for your own chosen "normal and just" prices? This means you have less power to influence the accordion market than I had hoped :(
You're confusing anonymity and pseudonymity; and all it takes to know the name registered at the civil state (if that's really that important to you) is one (1) click on a link at the bottom of each message I post here (bad ninja skills from my part, I know).

And for instruments with a normal price tag, thankfully we live a glorious time for accordions, there are plenty of them, plenty of brands and makers, for all tastes and budgets. See a (non-exhaustive) list of similar models here  (https://dia.to/accordeons?field_marque_tid=All&field_rangees_value=3&field_boutons_mg_value=All&field_voix_md_value=3&field_registres_mg_value=All&field_anches_value=All&field_prix_value=All&field_poids_value=All&field_occasion_value=All&field_boutons_md_value=&field_boutons_md_value_1=&field_clavier_value%5B%5D=Plat&field_clavier_value%5B%5D=Au+choix)and here (https://dia.to/accordeons?field_marque_tid=All&field_rangees_value=3&field_boutons_mg_value=All&field_voix_md_value=4&field_registres_mg_value=All&field_anches_value=All&field_prix_value=All&field_poids_value=All&field_occasion_value=All&field_boutons_md_value=&field_boutons_md_value_1=&field_clavier_value%5B%5D=Plat&field_clavier_value%5B%5D=Au+choix).
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Theo on January 29, 2026, 10:59:48 AM

And for instruments with a normal price tag, thankfully we live a glorious time for accordions, there are plenty of them, plenty of brands and makers, for all tastes and budgets.

Yes indeed, over the time I've been playing the availability of diatonic boxes has blossomed.  Several new makers have appeared, some have prospered, a few have gone, and the well known Italian names continue to innovate.  For many player, especially new starters,  it's almost become a problem to choose from the plethora of new and used instruments.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on January 29, 2026, 01:03:39 PM

Yes indeed, over the time I've been playing the availability of diatonic boxes has blossomed.  Several new makers have appeared, some have prospered, a few have gone, and the well known Italian names continue to innovate.  For many player, especially new starters,  it's almost become a problem to choose from the plethora of new and used instruments.

Agreed! All the more reason that it's interesting to me as an observer (like Chris) of the market for vintage Paolos that the latter are still increasingly valued!

(Getting us back on topic).

My own personal interest would be that they all would be very inexpensive and highly available. I'd love to get a great grey C#D or DD# 3 voice box. The last grey Paolo I sold was around 20 years ago, for $3500 and that was a consignment sale where I was obligated to the owner to get the best fair price that I could for him. *
But it's not for me to shout at clouds nor to declare what prices are "ludicrous," remembering that a price represents an agreement between two real people.

There's an entire ecosystem of players, repairers, makers, and also other people who may have inherited or stumbled on a rare and valuable box, all of whom can  influence prices, in a musical tradition such as traditional Irish box playing.  Fair pricing for an instrument at any one time doesn't come from one person's more or less informed opinion. It will often reflect a balance among those multiple interests and sometimes best estimates of future values. Beyond those interests just mentioned, for a community supporting a musical tradition to be sustainable, it can also require a balance among other interests including teachers, organizations that run competitions, and of course the venues and other sources of income for the professionals. When more people are making a living playing the accordion, it's more likely that some will consider an accordion as a business expense like a symphony player's violin or a plumber's truck and tools. Considering all these participants, there can be problems if the instruments are very expensive but also negative consequences if they are not valued highly. For example when old Paolo Sopranis were very cheap by today's standards people didn't invest the same quality of restoration work into them, and there are stories at least in the US of good instruments put out with the trash. Then, IMO it's the increase in valuation of professional instruments (and in part the scarcity of some kinds of Paolo Sopranis) that helped encourage a market for some of the modern boutique makers. If no one would pay more than "used Hohner" prices for a nice box, I'm not sure many if any modern makers would bother.

All the best

PG


* Edited to add: I still hear from the guy who bought that grey box for $3500 ("When I think about it I want to give you a hug."). Fair play to the consignor, he has never complained to me that he should have asked for more, or that he should have just kept the box. He chose to sell it, he chose the asking price, and he received more in selling the box (after my modest commission) than he had paid me for it some years earlier. We can't know the future.


Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Theo on January 29, 2026, 01:13:48 PM
, and there are stories at least in the US of good instruments put out with the trash.

It happens in UK too Paul.  A good few years ago a bin man phoned me to get information on a Wheatstone Aeola that he had rescued from a household waste bin. I was able to confirm that he had found something valuable.  I assume it found its way to a better home.  It was too far away for me to acquire.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 29, 2026, 02:25:14 PM
I think prices should reflect the amount of work people have put into making an instrument. It should provide makers, manufactures, with enough to make a living, and also allow them some sort of prospective work. Which the current pricing of accordions do.
If we take modern-built boxes that have similar 'technical sheet' (namely 2r 3v, 8 basses) than the old greys, they range somewhere between 4000€ and 5000€, new. All I'm saying is that, selling prices for used instruments with those specifications that are more than twice the average price of today's new equivalents is too much. It's a statistical anomaly if you prefer. I'm not 'yelling at clouds' or having a 'more or less informed opinion' here. Nor am I defending people to do whatever they want with their money, nor even defending them from speculating.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on January 29, 2026, 02:41:32 PM
I think prices should reflect the amount of work people have put into making an instrument. It should provide makers, manufactures, with enough to make a living, and also allow them some sort of prospective work. Which the current pricing of accordions do.
If we take modern-built boxes that have similar 'technical sheet' (namely 2r 3v, 8 basses) than the old greys, they range somewhere between 4000€ and 5000€, new. All I'm saying is that, selling prices for used instruments with those specifications that are more than twice the average price of today's new equivalents is too much. It's a statistical anomaly if you prefer. I'm not 'yelling at clouds' or having a 'more or less informed opinion' here (just stating facts). Nor am I defending people to do whatever they want with their money, nor even defending them from speculating.

This is a reasonable philosophy to govern your personal choices in how much you would spend on an accordion. Enjoy your life and your choices! I don't judge you for how much or how little you would spend.

However, the rule that you have articulated is not at all the way that humans as a group behave in buying and selling musical instruments. I say this from several decades' experience playing, buying, and selling musical instruments of many kinds and from historical research into instrument making and prices long before I was born. Some instruments become valued at much higher prices than it would cost to reproduce them today, and others become valued at much lower prices than it would cost to reproduce them today. (Of course those statements raise the question whether the "reproductions" are truly equal to the originals, but that's another discussion. In the case of guitars, there are some reproductions of vintage instruments that are incredibly close to the originals; less so I think with the vintage Paolos and modern attempts to clone them).

Thus your personal philosophy based on your own individual criteria may not be a good guide to understanding the current market for vintage Paolo Sopranis, which was the basis of Chris' questions. That market depends on many other people who are actually buying and/or selling them.

To the extent that you have judged other peoples' buying and selling decisions in declaring the prices that they agreed "ludicrous" I encourage you to consider whether you are respecting their agency and their own personal criteria for value, by mocking prices based on values that you happen not to share.

I would be interested to hear others' responses to Chris' questions so I'll stop replying now.

All the best

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on January 29, 2026, 03:16:16 PM
Saying a price is too high is mocking people now... OK. Maybe you're putting an intention that wasn't there in the first place.

Thus your personal philosophy based on your own individual criteria may not be a good guide to understanding the current market for vintage Paolo Sopranis, which was the basis of Chris' questions.
You and others on this thread produced a detailed picture (that seems accurate) of the current Paolo Soprani market, it's pretty interesting to read. Understanding why and how such prices are set is useful; saying I find the current prices too high doesn't invalidate these explanations, neither had it ever the aim of substituting to said explanations.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on February 03, 2026, 05:55:07 AM
What I'm going to share here is my *personal opinion*, so it's in no way intended to challenge someone's else view that may be different.  Maybe I'm at odds with the capitalist approach to buying and selling musical instruments, but in my worldview just because someone *can* charge a certain amount doesn't necessarily mean they *should* charge that amount.  I know plenty of folks who have bought accordions, done absolutely nothing to them in terms of repair, refurbishment, etc and then turned around and sold them for a huge profit.  Sometimes this has been possible because they've happily capitalized on someone selling an instrument that doesn't know the value of what they've got, or they figure they've found a good deal through someone's modest asking price and see an opportunity for profit.  I guess what constitutes greed is a line that's different for everyone. 

I tend to look upon instrument 'ownership' as more of a 'stewardship'; accordions have their own histories and stories and the people that loved them and played them.  You get to be part of that story for a time before you pass along caretakership of them to someone else.  If I've purchased something and then put time and energy into refurbishing it, I try to get my money back, but I don't necessarily always get it all back.  My own philosophy is that instruments should be getting played rather than sitting unused on a shelf.  If I'm not really using an instrument anymore, I tend to want to let it go so that someone else can get joy out of it.

A perfect example would be when I purchased a pair of Paolo Sopranis from the proprietor of a formerly well-known and respected accordion shop.  One was a black, 2-voice version of a "holy grey" (with the iconic 'grey' grill) Paolo Soprani from the late 40s, and the other a 4v model from the 60s.  The proprietor knew very well that the 'grey' Paolo would be highly coveted and that he could charge a handsome sum.  Instead, he expressed a desire to see it go to a good home to someone that would appreciate and play it for what it was (it was a D/C# original, and at the time I was a D/C# player).  He sold it to me for a very modest sum (it was a three digit figure!) because he valued it at what he figured it was actually worth, rather than valuing it due to its rarity and trying to make a huge profit.  In turn, when I decided I no longer needed the instrument, I passed it forward in the same spirit and sold it to a friend that dearly wanted it for the same price I had paid for it, plus a little bit for the work I had put into it. 

I'm not suggesting that people shouldn't be able to make money from selling their accordions, but I do think it's gotten out of hand in many cases.  I've seen so many of the instruments that I've refurbished and sold to others get immediately flipped for substantial profits.  People have a right to charge whatever they want, of course, but that kind of thing just saddens me.

Again, in the context of this thread, I'm simply sharing my own feelings on the matter and not looking to challenge anyone else's approach or views.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on February 03, 2026, 02:00:57 PM
Great point mselic,

Most of us who have been professionally involved with instruments* have sold them for cost or less at times.  Sometimes you might buy an instrument and perhaps put a lot of work into it but given the market - what's available for others to buy and the prices at which competing instruments are available - human nature / reality means that customers would not pay you for your costs in purchasing and repairing it.  When you go to sell an instrument, very few customers will generously pay you more than market prices.

Sometimes an instrument, and/or a particular customer (especially some young people who you might want to encourage) seems to deserve a re-homing at cost (similar to your anecdote). I did so a few years ago for an astonishingly promising young player who was seeking an "unobtanium" model that was actually very close to my heart as a researcher and player of that rare model. I would never have *wanted * to part with it, but in recognition of his needs and in celebration of his achievements I sold it to him for just what it cost me, which was probably 25% of market value based on later sales of similar instruments. In fact, due to a shipping glitch I had to pay the shipping cost twice so it cost me to send it to him. And when I was teaching 20 students per week, I often found ways to offer free lessons to customers who purchased an instrument or sometimes a free instrument to students who paid for lessons regularly. Perhaps that's part of the reason that over the life of that business, it was not globally profitable considering all expenses. Individual transactions were sometimes profitable, but not always, and overhead eventually killed me when I tried to keep the shop open after our family had to relocate.

Thus: obviously a professional in the music business can't make a living if they always break even or lose money on sales. The former music shop manager you mention in your anecdote sold plenty of new and used instruments at a profit during the time that shop was in business, including concertinas they sold for more than had I sold similar models (or sometimes, when they were re-selling instruments that I had previously sold!). They were not running a charity (entirely) and their prices on Jeffries and Wheatstone concertinas etc kept pace with the vanguard of rising prices.

Then, when a member of the public comes to you hoping for help in selling their property, you may feel that you owe them the best value you can get for them in consigning their instrument, in the current market.  It could often be malfeasance to encourage them to sell for less, especially if an estate is being liquidated, but also when players themselves are downsizing, perhaps in medical debt or other financial straits, or hoping to provide for a chlld's college expenses.  Are you going to tell them it's unethical for them to sell for more than they paid? I've seen all these cases.

Here's another situation: In recent years, former customers of mine (from decades ago) have sometimes sold instruments back *to me* for double or more what they paid *me* for them long ago. I guess you might criticize them as "folks who have bought accordions, done absolutely nothing to them in terms of repair, refurbishment, etc and then turned around and sold them for a huge profit."  But I don't see any reason to judge them harshly.  We are all participants in a global market in which some buyers will pay *even more than I can afford to do,* so I'm thanking them that they came to me first. My perspective is that the market has changed and if I would like to re-acquire those instruments, my offer has to be attractive to the current owner in the current market, even allowing for the loyalty and generosity of those former customers.

So I think if we pull back and consider the big picture, yes of course there are times when any of us would like to give what is essentially the gift of an instrument passed along for free, or below the current market price. I've done that but these days I also have to consider what is fair to my own family's needs.  And there are many times when despite our efforts to purchase bargains (ethically of course --  for example, in auctions or by paying a seller's full asking price), we might have to sell at a loss.  And one hopes there are times when we can get our investment back if we need to do so, and maybe even earn some fair pay for the work that we do (not only repairs, but education and communication involved in retail are work).

P



* ( I actually had a small brick-and-mortar shop, for a few years, and currently have revived that business at a low level to fill what I see as a gap in retail availability of instruments for students from a knowledgeable and ethical source).
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on February 03, 2026, 03:51:55 PM
All valid points, Paul.  Again, I'm not presenting my views as 'correct' and others' 'wrong'.  Also, just to clarify, when I mentioned any frustrations that I might have had with the flipping of accordions that had been acquired from me, it was generally a case where there had not been a passage of time wherein an instrument would have gained value - they simply turned around and put it up for sale at a substantially increased price.  But even that stuff I just have to let go...it's no longer my business what someone does with an accordion once I've passed it along.  It's just not how I would do things.

The sale of the Paolos was a transaction between myself and the accordion shop owner.  Obviously, instruments he was selling on consignment on behalf of others, and those that he was selling new through his business, were being sold for a profit.  Don't get me wrong, I've profited from selling accordions before as well.  Certainly if it's your business to sell instruments, that's the goal! 

For me, in cases where I've had good fortune to discover a used instrument in excellent condition for cheap, I've generally tried to pass that good fortune along again when selling it.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Theo on February 03, 2026, 04:25:20 PM
Something not mentioned so far I think is situation with other types of instruments.  I’ve not researched this at all but I have a distinct impression that highly regarded older models of guitars can go for even higher prices than accordions, and the most sought after old violins can go for millions.  So in some ways we are more fortunate the free reed world.  We are an obscure corner of the instrument market where, on the whole, we are not troubled by wealthy buyers looking for an investment rather than an instrument to play.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on February 03, 2026, 04:52:44 PM
Agreed, mselic!

That's why I wish that my favorite models of musical instrument were both abundant and very cheap! But those other human beings who own them won't sell them for cheap, they'd rather keep them, and the people who make them or restore them would like to be paid for doing work to the highest quality, and then there are other human beings who would also like to buy them and who would gladly outbid me if they were cheap. All those people (those who own special instruments, those who make them and/or repair them, and those who are willing to pay well to obtain one) really do influence the market. Wishes like mine that the special instruments should be abundant and cheap do not influence the markets much (if at all), if many other humans are making such selling and buying decisions based on a greater assessment of value.  I keep trying to direct this conversation away from any one person's wishes that the universe be different, to the more interesting question (to me), of why things are as they are.  This was Chris' chosen topic here.  But I understand that it's challenging for many musicians to look beyond their personal interest. I think it's too facile to blame high prices on capitalism or hoarding, and I have tried to provide some examples that may not have been considered by others here.

Fortunately,  no one really needs a Paolo Soprani, let alone a grey one.  We can all live without them and we can even enjoy a lot of music on a widely available accordion possibly obtainable for less than some families have to pay for groceries in a month. Hohner 1-row or 2-row on ebay (well chosen after a patient wait for a bargain), a small investment to get it overhauled, or DIY, you could be playing away for $600 - 800, maybe even a lot less. Of course more deluxe and expensive options are possible, even for Hohners. But that's not bad value for the years of enjoyment it can provide and might even pay for itself if you can get a gig. When I've encountered a really serious student local to me who couldn't put aside funds at that level, I've often loaned them a box. Sometimes they ran away with them, a different aspect of human nature that we can't always wish away.

More serious issues for capitalism I think, than the price of certain models of Paolo, are the factors that influence availabiity and prices of those groceries, or even more so the availability and prices of health care, and housing, and education. Those are the battles over which I have lost sleep and advocated for social and political change.

P
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on February 03, 2026, 04:55:03 PM
Something not mentioned so far I think is situation with other types of instruments.  I’ve not researched this at all but I have a distinct impression that highly regarded older models of guitars can go for even higher prices than accordions, and the most sought after old violins can go for millions.  So in some ways we are more fortunate the free reed world.  We are an obscure corner of the instrument market where, on the whole, we are not troubled by wealthy buyers looking for an investment rather than an instrument to play.


Very very true.  Here are some guitars (and other pop music instruments ) sold on Reverb.com just last month. And the $50K prices of some of these guitars is only 1/10 of the market price for an original "burst" Les Paul

https://reverb.com/news/the-top-10-collector-grade-instruments-that-sold-on-reverb-last-month-the-gear-grail-report?utm_medium=FB&utm_campaign=FBshare&utm_source=FBshare&fbclid=IwY2xjawPvB6lleHRuA2FlbQIxMQBzcnRjBmFwcF9pZBAyMjIwMzkxNzg4MjAwODkyAAEeBKUFwKqX_p3E0zQ5UxrIOZsEJqCv3hlj6pteePM4WY-YX9308JWOiimqe9o_aem_RTC700AHd2GS39v6Te_-Tw
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Disparate Dan on February 03, 2026, 05:22:31 PM
... highly regarded older models of guitars can go for even higher prices than accordions, and ... we are not troubled by wealthy buyers looking for an investment rather than an instrument to play.

One other distinction from the market in old guitars is that the melodeon market is not awash with fakes.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: mselic on February 03, 2026, 05:24:53 PM
Quote
I keep trying to direct this conversation away from any one person's wishes that the universe be different

This is a good takeaway to meditate on - no sense in wrestling with and railing against ‘what is’.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 03, 2026, 06:22:22 PM
I'm thinking it might be an influx of more players into the Irish Trad scene who want to compete in Fleadhs with "legit" boxes in the eyes of Comhaltas.

Chris, I can't imagine you actually believe this to be true.
Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann does not have a policy specifying preferred instrument brands for competition purposes. 
Your proposition might suggest that a mediocre competitor playing a Paolo would
enjoy an advantage over a superb competitor playing any other brand.
You know it doesn't make sense.

Conor Connolly now plays an old Paolo!

He's playing a gorgeous-sounding Delfini.

It's also a bit odd that the ranking at the Fleadh should be that much dependent on the box: one would think the music is more important than the instrument itself.

It would be odd if it were true; the music is always more important.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on February 03, 2026, 07:08:36 PM
I'm thinking it might be an influx of more players into the Irish Trad scene who want to compete in Fleadhs with "legit" boxes in the eyes of Comhaltas.

Chris, I can't imagine you actually believe this to be true.
Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann does not have a policy specifying preferred instrument brands for competition purposes.
Your proposition might suggest that a mediocre competitor playing a Paolo would
enjoy an advantage over a superb competitor playing any other brand.
You know it doesn't make sense.


It's also a bit odd that the ranking at the Fleadh should be that much dependent on the box: one would think the music is more important than the instrument itself.

It would be odd if it were true; the music is always more important.

Agreed 100% that the music is more important although some players do seem concerned about presenting a certain image.

But Pearse Rossa, from my own correspondence with Conor Connolly I know that he had been looking to replace the gorgeous Delfini with a 3 voice Paolo and that he did find one. Then he sold the Delfini very quickly and for much less than a typical price for a 3 voice Paolo these days.

Best

PG
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on February 03, 2026, 07:42:23 PM
It would be odd if it were true; the music is always more important.
I've had a quick look at the Fleadh winners of these past years, nearly every winner plays a Paolo. I had to go back to 2013 to find a winner with something else than a Paolo (a nice Kincora). This does not imply that the jury is partial to Paolos, but it's understandable that people might think they need a Paolo to win the Fleadh, even if it's not true.

This is a good takeaway to meditate on - no sense in wrestling with and railing against ‘what is’.
And yet, one might argue (I'll not do that) that change always come from people wanting something different than 'what is'. But as Paul stated, there are bigger issues than the price of vintage Paolos (if that was ever an issue).
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 03, 2026, 11:36:10 PM
But Pearse Rossa, from my own correspondence with Conor Connolly I know that he had been looking to replace the gorgeous Delfini with a 3 voice Paolo and that he did find one. Then he sold the Delfini very quickly and for much less than a typical price for a 3 voice Paolo these days.

Thanks for the clarification.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 04, 2026, 12:44:36 AM
I'm thinking it might be an influx of more players into the Irish Trad scene...

Irish trad and Irish traditional music are distinct entities. Paolo players are undeniably part of the latter.  When you play a Paolo Soprani, you're making a clear statement: “I'm here for the pure drop, the real deal."
Irish trad is the realm of flash harrys and gimmick merchants.

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: tirpous on February 04, 2026, 12:50:51 AM
Quote
I've had a quick look at the Fleadh winners of these past years, nearly every winner plays a Paolo. I had to go back to 2013 to find a winner with something else than a Paolo (a nice Kincora). This does not imply that the jury is partial to Paolos, but it's understandable that people might think they need a Paolo to win the Fleadh, even if it's not true.

Fair enough, but keep in mind that many of these winners may have been using Paolos not so much to impress the jury with 'the name on the box', but for the technical and music-making qualities of the boxes. I suspect you will find many of them were playing a Paolo long before the competition and are still playing one now.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on February 04, 2026, 12:09:49 PM
I wasn't implying otherwise. I was only following Chris' remark about the Fleadh. The overwhelming proportion of Paolos among the winners might increase the appeal of such accordions. But it's probably safe to say that most Paolo players don't want to compete for the All-Ireland championship and that the main reason for playing a vintage Paolo is that they're good boxes.

Comhaltas Ceoltóirí Éireann does not have a policy specifying preferred instrument brands for competition purposes. Your proposition might suggest that a mediocre competitor playing a Paolo would enjoy an advantage over a superb competitor playing any other brand.

If people are really playing Palos to make a statement about it being the 'real deal', maybe there's not only their intrinsic qualities as accordions at play, but also a part of 'social' attributes, of what status this kind of box has (which is one of -arguably deserved- prestige). While it is not part of the rules of the competition, is it unthinkable that there might be a positive preconception towards Paolos? That's not to say that it's what happens, or that it would be an issue if it were true.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Chris Ryall on February 04, 2026, 04:52:14 PM

   It was the same in the early 1990's in Britain. if you could afford (or managed to import) a Castagnari machine (aka "Costalotta") then it gave you a certain status. Although that could evaporate rapidly, once you tried to actually play the thing.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 04, 2026, 05:01:11 PM
If people are really playing Palos to make a statement about it being the 'real deal', maybe there's not only their intrinsic qualities as accordions at play, but also a part of 'social' attributes, of what status this kind of box has (which is one of -arguably deserved- prestige).

There is a fraternity, but I’m not at liberty to discuss it.
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on February 04, 2026, 08:22:45 PM
 ;D 8)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: Pearse Rossa on February 04, 2026, 11:43:31 PM
(https://i.postimg.cc/JnwFJMqg/Golden-emblem-with-Paolo-Soprani-accordion.png) (https://postimg.cc/1gHM1xbc)
Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: pgroff on February 04, 2026, 11:55:48 PM
(https://i.postimg.cc/JnwFJMqg/Golden-emblem-with-Paolo-Soprani-accordion.png) (https://postimg.cc/1gHM1xbc)

Gotta be a t shirt!

Title: Re: Paolo Soprani Market Conditions
Post by: -Y- on February 05, 2026, 03:16:30 PM
(https://i.postimg.cc/JnwFJMqg/Golden-emblem-with-Paolo-Soprani-accordion.png) (https://postimg.cc/1gHM1xbc)
Perfection!
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal