Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Hans Lemmen on January 27, 2026, 01:00:42 PM
-
I had an idea but I don’t know if it makes sense.
In the youtube videos, there often are very subtle and fast push & draw changes that the eye can hardly see. You have to find out by trying it yourself.
Would it be an idea for instruction on and teaching, to equip an instrument with a system of a green and a red light at the front, going on and off alternating, depending on the direction of the bellow? Technically that should be possible I think.
I can imagine it makes practicing easier.
-
That doesn't seem like too bad an idea actually. It would be pretty easy to rig something up using MIDI signals from a Roland or a Streb.
-
You have to find out by trying it yourself.
There's great value in that exercise, you know! 😉
Have you tried slowing down the YouTube playback rate for these hard-to-decipher passages?
-
Are you aware that you can slowdown the playback speed of youtube videos. Useful if (a) you are trying to follow bellows movements and/or (b) learning by ear. You need to suss out the box tuning for (a).
-
Yeah... I'm not sure about the wisdom of doing this. I am sure though that red and green is not the best combination to choose due to the prevalence of red/green colourblindness. Approximately 1 in 12 men and 1 in 200 women have this issue.
For reference, Ed Rennie's tutor system uses colour codes for push and pull, albeit in the more manageable form of print. Ed uses Red for push ('push the red button') and blue for pull, thus avoiding this common accessibility issue.
-
Technically all that is required is a light that shows "on" when the musician is pulling, or pushing, whatever.
But you can work that out from watching the lie of the bellows (with a bit of practice). And doing it that way it's probably better for you?
Another aspect (assuming you are learning a tune and own a box with similar layout) is to watch the fingers and be aware of the note that is being played. On a GC, inner row, sounding an E note has to be push, and if it's out of row it has to be pull. The principal is that you build up awareness of looks like your instrument. And that has much more musicality in the long run than a "mechanical" approach.
-
What about a yellow light for the rests? I've always dreamed of playing a traffic light.
Sorry... couldn't resist it! ;)
-
I dunno. On the odd occasion i have given intro to diatonic box i tell people to listen…and that is your cue.
-
I had the idea because, as a beginner, when watching a slowed down video, I can only focus at ONE thing at the time: RH, LH or bellows. The lights might be an extra to find of a button is on the pull or on the draw. I can imagine you would see the light signal “by the way” , while focussing on the buttons.
It would maybe be also be benificial for those tiny moves, when you can hardly see the bellow move. But that maybe only is valuable for a beginner, like me. I maybe would have to repeat the video only 200 times instead of 400 before I can start to reproduce it very slow. :P
-
There are some programs that read abc that can produce a system of tab for the melodeon. These usually have button numbers and annotations to show which row and which bellows direction. I don’t have exact details but someone here will know.
-
If the bellows movements are too fast to follow I doubt whether a rapidly changing sequence of lights would be much easier.
Since this would be a specially adapted instrument used by a teacher they should be able to explain it to the pupil, or provide accompanying tablature such as the CADB system. Atelier Loffet has some tunes written using this system.
https://www.atelierloffet.com/tablature/elements
-
Thank you. But as she is French there is probably not much for BC or C#D written in her system.
-
There are some programs that read abc that can produce a system of tab for the melodeon. These usually have button numbers and annotations to show which row and which bellows direction. I don’t have exact details but someone here will know.
It's possible to export accordion tab from Michael Eskin's tools, though the notes are in the form of staff music. The bellows direction is indicated by arrows below the stave. You'd need to find the ABC for the tune, then paste it in here:
https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html
Then look for the "More Tools" button. You'll see that one of the options is "Inject Tablature". There are very comprehensive instructions, or you could do what I did – try things and see what happens. It's pretty intuitive.
At some point every learner will need to make a mental map of their fingerboard and which bellows directions produce which notes. I used tab for two or three tunes to help me start to get a sense of it, but after that I found it quicker to use the muscle memory I was developing than to read the tab.
-
“ I used tab for two or three tunes to help me start to get a sense of it, but after that I found it quicker to use the muscle memory I was developing than to read the tab.”
Unless you were a very slow reader, that sounds as a time to look forward to. ::)
-
“ I used tab for two or three tunes to help me start to get a sense of it, but after that I found it quicker to use the muscle memory I was developing than to read the tab.”
Unless you were a very slow reader, that sounds as a time to look forward to. ::)
Yep, reading tab is another skill to learn. So you could choose to cut it out and work on mapping your keyboard instead, and then you can either learn tunes by ear or use standard staff notation.
-
Here are the first three essential items to learn when taking up the melodeon:
1. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
2. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
3. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
-
If you are learning tab you may as well learn to read music..which in and of itself isn't that difficult for a single treble melody line. Plus it means you can browse music books and try hundreds of tunes.
But here is the thing: if you see a D you know it's a push (assuming it's a DG), an E and it's a pull. It gets a bit more complex on row swapping..but the key is to stick to one row and learn that (which is what learners do anyway).
After a while this becomes internalised and the bellows direction is baked in. So if you are learning any system just go for the dots.
-
Here are the first three essential items to learn when taking up the melodeon:
1. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
2. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
3. Learn where all the notes are on the keyboard so that you can find them instinctively.
This.
-
learn to read music..which in and of itself isn't that difficult for a single treble melody line.
Yes it is, well it is in my world
-
…well perhaps..but i did qualify it …if you are learning a tab system…which is arguably harder to understand than basic dots.
-
I've sung in choirs as a kid, and could basically follow a tune up and down with help from the dots. It all evolved from monastic plain chant, right?
Melodeon is more complicated because of the pull-push factor. "tab" - which I think started amongst the French Trad magazine community - tries to address that. But it didn't work for me.
So in the late 90's I sat down with my box and basically played scales up and down on push and pull, speaking out the notes as I played them. After about three sessions I found it was becoming really embedded in my head and a week or so later I could put my finger on a button and know what note that was. One of the best investments I ever made.
So that's Helena 👍 and Rees 👍👍👍
-
I quite like the lights idea, for that stage in the learning process.
I remember we discussed using push/pull mnemonics for adding to written music (of any variety) some years ago. As Rees says, and if there's no alternative way of playing a note, internalising where notes are is the best way. However, for bigger boxes, with alternative fingerings for the same note, this idea isn't really sufficient. The thing is, it's very often a good idea to go 'off-row' to find a different way of fingering a note - even for a simple two-row box you have some notes which can be played on different rows, or in different directions on different rows. This greatly helps with ease of playing, not running out of puff, and dynamics selection.
I started out with the idea of putting the row number above the note, thinking that this would be easy and unambiguous (since you rarely in any box design, if ever, get two ways of playing a note on any row). Sure, that works, but after a bit I found that the problem is that it requires the poor overworked brain to do just one more thing, to translate the number into finger-shift. So after a bit I realised that the important thing is whether it's push or pull, since practice has meant you've learnt where best to find it already. So I now add v or ^ above the note, which I find is completely intuitive. Then I learnt that you only need it where there's any doubt, so I just add it there, and that also shows me I need to concentrate on that bit. The aim is to develop a muscle-memory mnemonic that brings up the right pattern of fingers and bellows.
At the risk of serious controversy, can I add my small ha'porth to the 'abc vs stave' debate? Traditional staves are highly intuitive - up means up and down means down, and the note lengths are shown. Which is why they have been an international language for many centuries. The only snag for me seems to me to be that instead of rejecting it without trying it, you need to understand what the dots mean first, which takes about an hour to get your brain round. Now, was that really all that difficult? And what are the advantages?
1. It's intuitive. Musicians reading it are directly transferring what they see to their fingers without conscious thinking.
2. It conveys note lengths, and is time-based, and obviously structured intuitively.
3. It's easy to show several notes played together - harmony.
4. You have a wealth of other musical expressions at your disposal.
5. You can easily add lyrics and accompanying chords where they should be.
6. Once you understand it, you immediately have access to a whole world of music, literally at your fingertips.
What's not to like?
-
I agree with both Rees and Chris's comments.
Whenever I see the effort and complexity involved with learning a tab system it always sounds far more complicated than actually learning how to read music.
-
Whenever I see the effort and complexity involved with learning a tab system it always sounds far more complicated than actually learning how to read music.
I don't know if you would call this a tab system, but some tutor books add a line under standard notation that indicates which button to press, and which bellows direction. When I was starting I found this to be a useful short term method to associate a note on the staff with a button.
Standard notation s great and reading the dots themself is only the first easy step. For an instrument like a two row box the notes are not all arranged in sequence so as others have made clear you do have to learn where the notes are on the keyboard. A useful aid to this process is to keep a keyboard diagram by you when you are practicing.
-
At the risk of serious controversy, can I add my small ha'porth to the 'abc vs stave' debate?
I'm not sure there's really much of a debate, is there? ABC was created to enable computers to process music, not to be read by humans as an alternative to staff. It was designed to be written by humans as a simple and accessible form of code, and computers would then render it as staff.
A few people discovered it was easier for them to read the ABC than the staff, but they seem to be a small minority. Best guess would be that 99% of people who use ABC do so to produce conventional notation.
Some of them augment it with tab, particularly those who never learned to read dots or are teaching young children. But tab doesn't work on its own; as you say, you still need to know what the key and time signature are, what the note lengths and groupings are, whether there are accidentals. That information's usually read from the staff that accompanies tab.
I didn't learn to read dots till my mid-60s, so I'd never argue against ABC or tab if it's more accessible. I just don't think there's really a debate about the relative merits. For the majority, staff is more intuitive and less clunky than most of the alternatives, and the only thing superior to it is ear learning. Anyone who can still do that as fast in their later years as they could when they were kids (I wish!) doesn't need any of this gubbins. (:)
-
For the majority, staff is more intuitive and less clunky than most of the alternatives, and the only thing superior to it is ear learning. Anyone who can still do that as fast in their later years as they could when they were kids (I wish!) doesn't need any of this gubbins. (:)
Oh so true. I'm 74 years old and have just joined a Pogues tribute band (Pogue McClone).
25 new songs to learn on the melodeon ....... blood, sweat and tears!
First rehearsal on Saturday :o
-
Defo something to look forward to, Rees 👍
-
What about a yellow light for the rests? I've always dreamed of playing a traffic light.
Sorry... couldn't resist it! ;)
The trouble is that yellow means 'go very fast'. ;D
-
Oh so true. I'm 74 years old and have just joined a Pogues tribute band (Pogue McClone).
25 new songs to learn on the melodeon ....... blood, sweat and tears!
First rehearsal on Saturday :o
That sounds brilliant! Hope it goes well. ;D
-
As primarily a player of fretted stringed things, tab is really useful for indicating how to play something when you have a variety of possibilities ... keyboard players have only one option for a middle C ... guitars and mando's have more possibilities, and indications of how a specific riff can be played may make something you thought ridiculously impossible become relatively straight forward.
As Fionn suggests ... much of the time the dots are best, but an accompanying tab for the complicated bits is invaluable to me ... learning to read ABC isn't something I'm going to attempt ... that's what computers are for!
-
I agree with both Rees and Chris's comments.
Whenever I see the effort and complexity involved with learning a tab system it always sounds far more complicated than actually learning how to read music.
Tablature and notation serve different purposes. Notation gives you the tune, it is universal and can be applied to any instrument or none. Tab shows you how to play it on a specific instrument. On instruments like melodeon or anglo concertina where the same note can be found in several different locations and there may be several alternative ways to finger a phrase or a chord that can be extremely useful (and even more so on fretted instruments where there are even more choices).
My problem with notation is not the dots, which I sort of understand, but that I've never got round to learning where the notes are on my instruments. I know where the sounds are, but not the names, so I can't relate the dots to the buttons. I suppose I could knuckle down and learn them, but as I have melodeons and concertinas in several different keys I worry that would only confuse me even further!
-
So..a coloured light comes on to indicate which direction you are moving the bellows?
This doesn’t make any sense really. If I pull the bellows a red light tells me…what..that i am pulling the bellows? I am pushing the bellows and a green light tells me…something I already know, because I am already doing it..I am pushing the bellows. Of am I missing something?
-
My problem with notation is not the dots, which I sort of understand, but that I've never got round to learning where the notes are on my instruments. I know where the sounds are, but not the names, so I can't relate the dots to the buttons. I suppose I could knuckle down and learn them, but as I have melodeons and concertinas in several different keys I worry that would only confuse me even further!
And this depends so much on the instruments you play. On flute and English concertina, I'm never in any doubt as to which note I'm playing. On melodeon, I'm far less aware of which note I'm playing unless I make a conscious effort to think about it.
-
So..a coloured light comes on to indicate which direction you are moving the bellows?
This doesn’t make any sense really. If I pull the bellows a red light tells me…what..that i am pulling the bellows? I am pushing the bellows and a green light tells me…something I already know, because I am already doing it..I am pushing the bellows. Of am I missing something?
I ment only to be used for teachers. Not for players. It tells a beginning student in which direction the bellow is moving while conscentrating in the teachers fingers. Sometimes the change of direction is too small to notice at knce
-
At my beginning I printed off the keyboard layout and coloured in notes on the push and notes on the pull.
From that I started to build up my understanding of which button produced which note. That basic idea was an enormous help.
It's taken me ages to go from the 'which note... which button' to understanding of note length etc, but I've got there.
As CAB says, the relationship between button and note is easier to understand on English Concertina, where I started.
As far as notation and bellows direction is concerned, I still notate my score to help remind me how best to play a section.
It often involves the D chord which can be pushed or pulled.
After trying it both ways as I'm learning the tune I will mark it "D >" for a pushed chord and "D <" to pull it.
ABC still sounds the chord and ignores the '>' or '<' parts.
I find it helps me to not have to remember which bellows direction to use when learning.
-
Here's an example of tab for a B/C box automagically created using my ABC Transcription Tools at:
https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html
Numbers alone are button numbers on the C row. Numbers in circles are button numbers on the B row. Bellows direction is shown by the arrows:
https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html?lzw=BoLgBAjAUApDCGA7RB7ALvNBLFiBmuaYACvADaZaqQAMUAKuPQBYCmYA0qwM7NQDCTAE7wAJlmy5yUAErgAUlgDmUALLgAbAHoAHFAAy4CLqgBFcAGZdAXgg0ArFA7gA4gFt4AK1iwwAVW52NDYwPDIAVyxRMG4UcMRRAkQ0EFhY+MTCUIionxh-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&format=noten&ssp=10&name=The_Kesh&play=1
Another example:
https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html?lzw=BoLgBAjAUApDCGA7RB7ALvNBLFiBmuaYACvADaZaqQAMsM2aZApgYkaRdtRABz0BnAK4AjRizYdylHgGZ6VApJLTuKSPLgAHeACc0A5ZxnqImhswC2WlEdVVT5tMwAeaO1wcaoAFXA+AC2YwAGEA+Dw8GxQyEhQBNCgAJXAAIT1EABMkAGNmKABZcAAWAHpiqAAZcAhS-gBFEAAmcoBeAE46GAEAdyoAczAaADomqABpcABxS3gAK1gwAGUUISzJcDxMERQAT1gBVfXCMC20Hf2YMALmMhRM3bAtXRR+3XhLcABBHJyUXUyOEQ9AKAEkACKgp4vN4fMBNaBwBIRPACZhaMC8OgAH3AACIAPoANgA3IBEwjxqSahMApiTkvEAPS+hNJFNSYEJAHYSYBkwjxzGpBO5FMyLPpqWxHKF9MygtJfJyhIArPSvlLiry8QBRQWAExJNQAxZWaqaSqUqinMgn6ikMqbGy1itlS+V4xUEi14q36vlGj2qyXGvn2-2O4nioN4qZS2T08GCprigA0hNjFPB2KgLvFgrptqtrMpUu5fIFXJlTspgelIrlmvdnrVhI1fJ1hJ9eL9KuD1cb7fpdodXsr7LFCqH3sNE+xEDA5pNgu7Uf7vvnweKIGxTTnkamgt4mv628JB75-VkhMA5iSavDYzO44ua5iEwBmJJqGaLpaWrzepae8f0P58ngJ6HoS7T0vA1YQDQ9IiIKwp4rKj4isU1auu6hapBOI7ZuONZIeW34EtewHVv+R4jseBIUfuYEkTemaPsRb58h+RH8kBeJ4H+9GkdxoFnuBkHQbBFLweWtYoUhaF4W6I44eGzpjvJBGfiWnEMWRs68Wegr8SBBIQRS8C6QBdFCVp3GbtuZmUVZhnGXipmCQBaEALpAA&format=noten&ssp=10&name=The_Chaffpool_Post&play=1
-
Another idea with lights: electric pianos sometimes have the option for keys to light up to indicate the correct key of a pre-inserted tune. But I don’t know if that would make you learn faster or slower than finding the keys by yourself. I makes me think of the paintings where you have to fill in the section with the right color . Actually I think that a degree of difficulty is beneficial for learning.
-
Personal view here, but I think it is much more valuable to learn by listening. Visual cues can assist, but it’s listening that is fundamental. If you are struggling to pick out the pitch of short notes and ornaments then you may need to pick a different piece to start learning that has a simpler structure.
-
Even though I build a tool that can automatically create B/C or C#/D box tablature for any tune, I completely agree with Theo.
Tablature can be useful to brand new players to help bootstrap them into finding the notes on the button board or for those who don't read music to help them start to make the button to notation association, but I strongly suggest moving away from it as soon as you can.
-
Even though I build a tool that can automatically create B/C or C#/D box tablature for any tune, I completely agree with Theo.
Tablature can be useful to brand new players to help bootstrap them into finding the notes on the button board or for those who don't read music to help them start to make the button to notation association, but I strongly suggest moving away from it as soon as you can.
-
Personal view here, but I think it is much more valuable to learn by listening.
This.
Visual cues can assist, but it’s listening that is fundamental. If you are struggling to pick out the pitch of short notes and ornaments then you may need to pick a different piece to start learning that has a simpler structure.
Or at least slow the recordings down. YouTube will do that, and there's proprietary software like the Amazing SlowDowner. The latter was a big help when I picked up my whistle again in retirement after decades of thinking I was too busy for music.
If you're playing folk tunes it might also help to find the notation. Often ABC transcripts just give the bare bones of tunes, and it's probably best to start playing them in that stripped down form. Learning them by ear well enough to hum in the shower, and following notation as you listen will give you a good grounding for when you come to pick up your box.
If that sounds a bit long-winded, it is at the outset. But the more tunes you learn, the faster you pick them up. I still have to work hard to get a set of tunes fluent enough to practise with others inside a couple of days, but it's not so long ago that I'd have needed a couple of months.
-
Thanks, sounds encouraging. Is there also abook that you’d definitly advice to get? Or maybe you used no book at all?
I started learning notation this weekend. After one day I can name the notes within two seconds. It only can become better from now on….. After a while I may be able to skip learning tabs. I will kill the time until I find and by a BC box by learning notation. That is my plan. And in the mean time doing things on my old Hohner BbEb, which I,ve never toughed before. But if I understood it well, it has the same fingersetting as DG. So learning that may not be a total waist of time in case my BC will have a little DG brother in the future.
-
Sounds like you're doing brilliantly, Hans 👍 i've been playing since 1986 and I wouldn't know what to do with a B/C.
Bb/Eb's are great fun, especially if you play with anyone with a brass instrument.
Tip: There is a built-in D-blues scale on it, totally on the pull.
Your left end is useless, but D-blue on the right end is incredibly fluid.
You use your index middle and ring fingers only in little triangles, see attached.
Yes, it'sincredible what you can do with a melodeon!
-
Bb/Eb's are great fun, especially if you play with anyone with a brass instrument.
Aha: BRASS. I already wondered why they were invented….
Tip: There is a built-in D-blues scale on it, totally on the pull.
Your left end is useless, but D-blue on the right end is incredibly fluid.
You use your index middle and ring fingers only in little triangles, see attached.
[/quote]
Thanks, all new for me! It’s fascinating to find and practice the Bb and Eb scales on my old Hohner right now. I was happy to notice that my fingers have kept the memory of movement and some of the speed of my freewheeling on a little CF that I did 45 years ago. I makes me feel a bit less helpless than somebody who would never have touched a melodeon before. Now it’s a matter of getting familiar with where to find what.
Would you also have a simple tune for this instrument for me to practice? I could not find anything. A Youtube video or something on gabs or simple notation? Anything goes……
-
The Price of My Pig (a simple jig) sounds lovely in a flat minor key. Here's the transcript in Eb min, but you could just as well play it on your Bb row by starting on the second degree of the scale (F) and carrying on from there.
X:1
T:Price of My Pig
R:jig
M:6/8
L:1/8
K:Ebmin
|:B,EE EDE|F3 DEF|G3 F3|EDB, B,2 A,|
B,EE EDE|F/G/AF DEF|G3 F3|EDB, B,3:|
|:BcB ABA|G3 F3|G3 F3|EDB, B,2 A,|
B,EE EDE|F3 DEF|BFG F3|EDB, B,3:|
I think the following recording is in the more usual key of Amin, but I thought I'd link so you can hear the melody line (only the first half is Price of My Pig, they go into Scattery Island after that).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nlCkHykpgIE&list=RDnlCkHykpgIE&start_radio=1
If you want to hear a simple auto-generated rendition in Eb min, paste the ABC above into Michael Eskin's ABC tool and press "play".
Having said that, you could play anything to be honest. It's a transposing instrument, so even if you got the dots for a tune in G major, the same fingering will produce the same tune – just in a different key.
Whatever you decide, have fun!
-
Another thought: I wouldn't worry too much about learning tunes by ear in one key and playing them in another.
Most people can transpose melody lines without even realising they're doing it. If a five-year-old sings a nursery rhyme with their father, they'll often transpose it up an octave. If the next day they sing it with their grandmother, they have no difficulty even though this time it's in a different key.
We tend to memorise the pitch intervals rather than the notes, so our brains register it as the same tune.
-
Whatever you decide, have fun!
Thanks very much for the tune and the link: I will start tomorrow!!
Tonight I installed my daughters’ electric piano to help me find the melodeon buttons. It was overwhelming:I never played a piano but to my surprise I could just play about every melody line that is in my head almost at once and at reasonable speed. The smallest amount of theory (only this weekend) was enough for a backbone. Finally the music finds a way out. Feels like a little miracle. I can imagine that the piano will be a help during my first months with a melodeon.
Really wish I had learned some music theory and notation while I was young. It has always looked like Chinese to me.
Although there probably are no sessions held within a few hours driving from my home, with a teacher and a lot of playing I will find my way. Can’t wait for the neurological wiring for melodeon in my brain to develop.
Being a professional visual artist for 40 years, I’ve experienced tons of disappointments while working with museums, commissions, galleries etc. The book I could write about that would read as if it were fantasy. But I prefer to switch towards making music as my main occupation from now on.
Great forum: already learned a lot!
Nb Maybe if Damien Conolly does this, my idea of the lights indicating the bellow direction is not that stupid after all?
“….ABC that Damien calls “BoxTab”. In both systems colored highlighting is used to indicate bellows direction..”
(Does anybody in Europe or GB want to sell their copy?)
-
You have to find out by trying it yourself.
Hi Steve, in a 2014 conversation in “ the session” I saw you recommending a way to buy the O’Connolly’s tutor in Ireland, in order to avoid the buzz of buying it in the US. However the link that you have there seems to have expired. (http://kincoraaccordions.com/) Would you know another possibility? Thanks in advance.
-
To echo what Hans says, when my kids were young we set up a music room which was full of (mostly junk shop) instruments for them to pick up and use to knock out a tune. And so they did. They're all musical now.
… I picked up my wife's bagpipes and hurdy-gurdy, and to my surprise was able to do the same. Though that did involve my already knowing how to hold the damn thing!
A few years along your musical journey, you end up playing "music" rather than notes. e.g.I was at Embraud about 10 years ago. Top french melodeonista, Frédéric Paris also plays hurdy-gurdy, bagpipes and C clarinet. But not that night. He was on an electric guitar!
-
My tool also automagically generates B/C or C#/D tab with color coding if you want it:
https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html?lzw=KQAgQgpg5glgdiALgQwEYgMYHsA2WBOIAwgMokBQwwq08GAzveQHQAOArvQBYgDeAZjBw4AXAGIiABmnSAviwAm+ZAHc+g4eJmSp8qhDgKGTUAFFDSNJlwFiZcuQAaIkAEZKwZHDhYUiGFhw-IGIIAAKyDjI-j5ukuQAKi4JXBAgANIQ3OREycoKMP6BkeQASi4AUjBQ5ACyLgBsAPQAHOQAMi6ureQAii4AzK0AvK6SAKzk6S4A4gC2yABWlJQgAKr0aYipIPw47DAKIPRY7IbBcIgilCdnChehewcKK6AbaV4gAILYnP4YIBmygsYRgXiwx1OFmChG2aTmEDwCgAntcqLUAJIAEQxIFY+CwUGUcxA8WAq3eIE+P1O9H+gOBR1B4N2tjhmC4BAU9DRwExOI5XPxhNJr3WmypCBIyMuPDAyEYkLurNhO1QCp5Hn5uPVjGFUBAAza5NAJAgoWQx1YEAwMEEAOQcyhoSw-GOKngUDR9A9cANkmYACZJibgHTkPx+JtWCAWmSQCQofcQi5+NFUFhkTckw9dunM6taoisCi8QSiY6XD9sPgCoEtdjcfriSBA+4AD4iABEAH1xgBuQDJhF2AIQcbgjma9geARMJR0pVCOvtOh6Px1xJyAV8Ox5wN1O+-25yOFyol72Gkf58oz2B2yvj6fzz3L4+byOwA-r4uvlvD2+fwvK8T3fT8ewAdmAp8FHvCDV13CcIF7SCALPBRkKg98jl7Fp4PXEcoAw1CTyI780NgyCd3wpC4OI9CX0wxcwD-FCyJIhjiLA2c2K+dtyG3Nc90nL8QMAw8qKEmY-wHCSJwPbjRLPZcOLYu8RKfZTX1U9T31-HSxK0xSP1IoyYIw2SNxo1jTJM6C-1wiyCNsrCgM42CFI0gSEP3XtABMSPChIAMWkgK5IGEQ+M7VztP-HjoqM5jnMXejDKfMDrOgijQssnDsqcuDHLSJK0PitL9KU2DUtA8rnyqpiWMYkqVISrz8JmdzGtqzquM6vTYqM5SZMEuSat4-jmrK-rPIm0CGro0rqtotizIK4acp7By1vyyitqKpabJmpjipPWDNu8-LAHMSPL+FyxyDV7ABOTrkFurbCJ7J7iOQWCxk61BXvO96rsct0AfwqBwr48ggA&format=noten&ssp=10&name=The_Kesh&play=1
-
I see. Can’t wait to get a BC machine! The BbEb is also fine for the moment. As is the electric piano that I “discovered” yesterday.
I’m on a mission: catch up on 40 years of not playing music!! Maybe skip the sleeping. ;)
-
The tutor is available from Amazon but without a DVD.
I thought Kincora accordions had closed but there's a phone number here https://www.goldenpages.ie/kincora-accordions-ennis/
You could contact Custy's in Ennis