Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Design, Construction and Repair => Topic started by: Andrew Culwell on December 27, 2009, 06:57:56 PM
-
So I took delivery of the Club II that I got on Fleabay. I have posted some Pix. I'm of a mind to Restore this box. It is in very nice condition with some exceptions. Those are the following:
1. The box looks to have been stored in a Dry place and been exposed to some heat. It came from Utah a desert state. The Celluloid has shrunk and has become warped and detached from the plywood of the box. The celluloid is otherwise in very nice condition. Not sure if this is restorable or should I just strip the celluloid off?
2. The box mechanisms seem to be in outstanding condition. The Button mechanisms work smoothly and the action is nice, no serious rust or corrosion that I can detect. However I believe the reeds need to be re-waxed and tuned, When the bellows are pushed or pulled 3-4 of them sound, this could be stuck valves, some of the leather valves have dropped off due to the extreme drying of the glue holding them in.
The box is in C/F and it is completely original, the original owner must have played it but it's straps are nearly pristine and aside from the lack of care in storing the box it obviously was at one time played and loved as it does have some original wear,not much though. I looked for a serial number but being a novice at this kind of thing I'm not sure as to where to look for a serial number. I did find a mark on the treble side of the box and the same mark on the bass side on the inside of the box. I have enclosed pix of that mark. Not sure what this mark is possibly a factory mark of some kind it looks like personal initials stamped though.
Any advice as to what I should do with the celluloid would be helpful. I'm thinking this box is well worth restoring. Any and all advice and ideas would be appreciated.
--Drew
Here is the link to the remaining photos:
http://s815.photobucket.com/albums/zz72/ajay38/ClubII-restoration/
-
1. Celluloid goes soft with the application of acetone so you might be able to apply some and then reshape/stretch. That would be my first port of call as once you remove it, its off, where as if it doesn't reshape well you can then take it off afterward.
2. If 3 or 4 reeds sound at once its most likely to be treble pallets letting air into more than one reed chamber. Check the pallets under the treble grill are firmly closing the hole, you might need to reface them with felt and leather. It's probably worth revalving, waxing and tuning anyway just to get the best out of it. Limit the treble action as well whilst your at it.
-
1. Celluloid goes soft with the application of acetone so you might be able to apply some and then reshape/stretch. That would be my first port of call as once you remove it, its off, where as if it doesn't reshape well you can then take it off afterward.
2. If 3 or 4 reeds sound at once its most likely to be treble pallets letting air into more than one reed chamber. Check the pallets under the treble grill are firmly closing the hole, you might need to reface them with felt and leather. It's probably worth revalving, waxing and tuning anyway just to get the best out of it. Limit the treble action as well whilst your at it.
Should the acetone be applied directly to the celluloid while it's on the box? If so should I just use a brush to apply the acetone onto the celluloid then stretch it and fit it back to the box? Once applied does the acetone just soften the celluloid thus allowing one to manipulate it as needed? Also would this dull the sheen of the celluloid once it's manipulated back into shape?
-
I would try it with the celuloide on the box and applying directly. I've not tried it myself on melodeons but have elsewhere - I see no reason why it wouldn't react the same. Any dull areas can just be buffed up. See http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=485.0 (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=485.0).
-
Well my attempt at applying acetone seemed to dissolve the Celluloid as opposed to just softening it. I immediately had to Peel off the Celluloid that I attempted to soften and stretch. This in turn turned into a celluloid stripping excercise, most of the Celluloid came free quite easily even without the application of aceton, except for the bit around the Bass buttons which I cut off using an exacto blade. Now I have a presswood Club II. I really didn't want to remove that celluloid but it really had shrunk a great deal and was coming off in whole slabs anyway.
I took out the Reed Blocks, and those will probably go to the tuner for total redoing. Not sure if I want to "declub" this box since I really don't know what that means (more research to do). I found that the treble and bass Pallets are leaking due to old seals so those will need replacing (more research). As for the bellows they are practically perfect except for age, the tape looks good and the bellows corner clamps ( Not sure what those metal brackets are called) just need a bit of touching up with steel wool. I will also have to sand smooth the now bare presswood and stain it. Any ideas about what I should use to do this part of the project would be very helpful. Probably a light to medium stain and then an application of varnish of some kind.
-
With respect, always get a second opinion about any major repairs. If you have ever seen celluloid/acetone application (new manufacturing) you would know that what you did would be suicide.
-
I did say I've never tried it on melodeons! - sorry to hear it didn't work out. The club button is called a gleichon (spelling?) and its the key with hashing on it on the F row. Basically it plays the same same note either way giving your more fingering options. De-clubbing just involves tuning it to the expected note for on the row playing.
You can make your own pallet facing by gluing a layer of felt to a layer of fine suede leather. The felt dampens the clacking and the suede provides an air proof seal. Take the white muslin dots off of the tops of the pallets and then gently ease the wooden pallets off. If they are waxed on or the glue is brittle you can normally just prise them off. If they are well and truly stuck you'll need to take the whole mechanism off and soak the pallet and the ends of the leavers in warm water to relax the glue.
Once off you can then soak the pallets in warm water to get the existing material off (or just pull it if it is loose). Dry and sand flat, then stick to new felt/leather layers. Once they are dry you can cut around them to get them off. I quite like waxing the pallets back on with reed wax as it allows for adjustments later on.
It's also worth removing the old rope seal around the bellows frame and replacing with a self adhesive neoprene strip.
For re-vanishing I found a pretty good match for the Hohner Erika red - a deep red stain and a slightly yellow tinted varnish provides a good finish. The next time I have to re-varnish I'm going to try the Cajun style finishing of using coloured ink under a clear varnish to try and get a blue/aquamarnie colour similar to the one Saltarelle use. If the grain of the wood isn't that interesting then a good colour could really make the box stand out.
-
With respect, always get a second opinion about any major repairs. If you have ever seen celluloid/acetone application (new manufacturing) you would know that what you did would be suicide.
I was thinking that I should have got a second opinion but I was impatient and I also figured that as much shrinkage and debonding (not sure that is a word) that had occurred was not fixable or would take too much time and effort. I've been wanting to strip one of these boxes anyway and this one seemed ideal since the Celluloid was already practically peeling off. It took very little effort to remove it. So now I will attempt to restore it but without celluloid. No harm was done, as I think the Celluloid had to come off anyway. The Plywood underneath the celluloid is in good condition.
So next Question is where to get Reed wax? Also I'm assuming that the felt and the Suede needs to be quite fine and thin for this use?
-
another celluloid suicide moment
-
To soften celluloid to enable re shaping you must never use net acetone. As you discovered this will simply disslove the celluloid. The acetone must be diluted with water first.
-
I used some acetone based nail varnish remover - it must have been pre-diluted. :-\
-
I used some acetone based nail varnish remover - it must have been pre-diluted. :-\
Perhaps it would have been wise to give the full details in your original advice?
If they are well and truly stuck you'll need to take the whole mechanism off and soak the pallet and the ends of the leavers in warm water to relax the glue.
Once off you can then soak the pallets in warm water to get the existing material off (or just pull it if it is loose). Dry and sand flat, then stick to new felt/leather layers. Once they are dry you can cut around them to get them off. I quite like waxing the pallets back on with reed wax as it allows for adjustments later on.
I think that soaking the pallets in water is a pretty bad thing to do (though not as bad as using neat acetone on celluloid :(), and quite unnecessary. The pallets on pre-war Hohners usually come of very easily, I've renovated dozens of them and never needed to use water, sometimes if the steel is badly rusted they can be a tight fit, in those cases I find that a hot soldering iron applied to the lever end for half a minute or so usually frees things enough. To remove the pallet facings, just ease a blade under a corner and pull the leather off, then scrape and sand off what remains, leaving a smooth surface for the new material. And don't forget to clean out the slot in the pallet where the lever fits.
Another good way of fixing the pallets back on is to fit all the pallets in place, then apply a small dollop of hot-melt glue to the top of each pallet. This is easy to peel of at a later date, but if you do the job right you should not need to make any adjustments later on.
-
I've not had pallets expand from adding water which is always a concern when water is involved. I've found it helpful in getting newer glues off without sheering bits of wood from the pallets.
Completely agree with giving full advice - I didn't realise myself about the diluted acetone and would never have recommended it otherwise! :-[ :-X :-\ :'( :-*
-
I hold no one to blame but myself as far as the Acetone disaster goes. So no apologies necessary, I think the cellulose came off rather nicely and I'm going to try something new and different. What that is I'm not sure but the experiment continues. The reed blocks are going to be refurbished and tuned by Theo and I'm thinking of going dry on the tuning. ALthough some might think that is a waste on a Club box. I'm also not going with the de-clubbing as I'm a relatively new player so I figure the club system might turn out to be something that I can try out! Next is the Pallets I have to figure out where to get the Felt and leather for those!
-
What about covering the naked melodon with something like that ;D
https://secure.aspects-supplies.co.uk/products/showproduct/470
-
and I'm thinking of going dry on the tuning. ALthough some might think that is a waste on a Club box.
Waste not, whatnot!
I have an old Double Ray in Bb/Eb that I have seriously dry tuned, zero zero throughout, no thirds. It doesn't sound like a Hohner for sure but I'm using it more and more these days, especially in my new Welsh band, Parti Gungrog, where its hard grinding dryness sits Druidically against the the softness of the mountain flute and the punky funky reggae ukelele.
-
What about covering the naked melodon with something like that ;D
https://secure.aspects-supplies.co.uk/products/showproduct/470
oh lush!
-
cgmmusical dot co dot uk will oblige very reasonably with self adhesive felt/leather pallet facing
-
What about covering the naked melodon with something like that ;D
https://secure.aspects-supplies.co.uk/products/showproduct/470
Wow that is an idea! I'd have to keep the footballers off the melodeon then wouldn't I!
-
With respect, always get a second opinion about any major repairs. If you have ever seen celluloid/acetone application (new manufacturing) you would know that what you did would be suicide.
For a glimpse of the process, here's a video presented by Kimric Smythe who toured the Weltmeister factory. The bit on celluloid is about 53 sec. in........... :-X
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rYsSifiDapo
-
With respect, always get a second opinion about any major repairs. If you have ever seen celluloid/acetone application (new manufacturing) you would know that what you did would be suicide.
For a glimpse of the process, here's a video presented by Kimric Smythe who toured the Weltmeister factory. The bit on celluloid is about 53 sec. in........... :-X
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rYsSifiDapo
Kimric is an Old School mate of mine, He and I two young middle school Nerds who hung about at lunchtime talking about nerdy things like accordions. He is quite the Weltmeister booster now!
-
What about covering the naked melodon with something like that ;D
https://secure.aspects-supplies.co.uk/products/showproduct/470
Wow, a melodeon that can double as a greengrocers stall!
-
I'm also not going with the de-clubbing as I'm a relatively new player so I figure the club system might turn out to be something that I can try out!
Not de-clubbing is a good idea, I think, as you can have it both ways. If you want to play it like a melodeon, you just need to learn to get the pull note for the gleichton off the other row with your pinkie, or other spare digit, plus you can get some lovely harmonic runs on the pull using the gleichton. I've now got two club boxes, and I love both of them.
-
Celluloid (and any other suicide):
Please don't follow the shop practices you are seeing on the Weltmeister clip.
At least, please, eye protection, even if you don't care about sawing/planing into your fingers, dissolving your skin or destroying (dear) brain cells.
-
Celluloid (and any other suicide):
Please don't follow the shop practices you are seeing on the Weltmeister clip.
At least, please, eye protection, even if you don't care about sawing/planing into your fingers, dissolving your skin or destroying (dear) brain cells.
I heartily agree! Seems like workplace safety is not on the top of the list at this facility! :o
-
Well I don't plan on losing any fingers or brain cells in the restoration process. However a few brain cells might go with the celebrations on New Years Eve
-
Ajay, my friend, you are right, brain cells highly over-rated. Plus my favorite Father Martin re-quote: The gift of God that gladdens the hearts of men.
-
So now further questions about removing the pallets so I can remove the pallet liner.
1.Do I remove the complete Bass and treble mechanisms then remove the pallets, this would seem to be the correct way to reface the pallets. However a problem I'm trying to figure out is the Bass buttons keep me from removing the complete mechanism.
2. Do the bass buttons come off and on with ease or are they glued to the levers? If they are glued how do I pull them off without damaging or bending the rods and levers or damaging the buttons?
Ideas?
-
It is usually easy enough to remove the pallets without removing the complete mechanism. And when it comes to replacing the pallets the mechanism must be in place first, place the pallets into their positions under the levers, with the springs holding them there, then apply the hot-melt glue, or wax that fixes them to the levers.
The mechanism only needs to be removed if there are broken springs to replace.
-
What would be the best stuff for refacing pallets on an ordinary melodeon (ie Hohner pokerwork or similar)? CGM Musical offer some ready-made felt and leather stuff, but they have at least two types "Felt glued on Special Leather" and "Felt glued on Persian Leather", and also choice of total thickness.
Any specific recommendations from anyone who's done the job recently?
I guess if its too thick then the buttons will be set too low ... or maybe the slots in the pallets could be cut a bit deeper. I'm not sure how much thickness can be accommodated before it becomes a problem.
-
I would assume that buying the stuff from CGM is safe bet considering that it is a specialized product for accordions. It's a pretty simple job, though, so a good eye not unlike judging how much salt to put in the soup should suffice in determining the thickness of the felt.
I replaced the felt and leather on the pallets of an old German rattletrap box that I bought on Ebay. The reeds are out of tune (though not corroded or rusty, so it has a chance yet!) and leave a lot to be desired but at least the pallet fix has stopped the leaking which was very bad upon arrival. I used a working Pokerwork as an example guide. The pallets on the old German box are comparable in size and shape to the pallets on the Pokerwork.
I bought some leather (shiny one side, soft the other) and two sheets of stiff felt from a craft store, sold in 8.5" x 11" cards. The store had just one thickness so I didn't have a choice. But after gluing and pressing the felt and leather together, the new materials were approximately the same thickness as what I had under the pallets in my old Pokerwork which was perfectly functional. The hardest part was replacing the bass felts because navigating the mechanism was more involved.
-
Cheers. I think on my Pokerwork there's just thin leather on the pallets, so any form of felt+leather is going to be thicker. Possibly the best thing might be for me to take off just one pallet and have a good look - see how much could be accommodated with the lever right at the bottom of the slot.
-
It's probably not worth doing if you only put on the same thickness of new material, and the old material can vary in thickness, so you must assume that you will have to adjust the height of at least some of the buttons. It is simple enough to adjust the button height by gently bending the levers - that is the 'official' method. deepening the cuts in the pallets is likely to result in some pallets splitting, so just clean out all traces of old glue, but don't remove any wood.
2 to 2.5 mm total thickness of felt and leather works for me.
-
So what kind of glue should be used to glue the new Leather/felt to the pallets also what surface should be facing the pallet head when glued. I'm assuming that the felt should be glued facing the pallet and the leather should be facing out from the pallet? Also are the round fabric pieces that go ver the glue on the top of the pallet lever need to be replaced or can simple hot glue suffice, also where do I get these round fabric pieces if they are necessary?
-
General PVA has worked fine for me when gluing leather to felt. Sometimes you need quite a lot if the felt is very absorbent. Glue the felt to the wood so that the leather is facing the holes to create a good airtight seal.
No need for fabric discs, a line of PVA or hot wax will suffice to hold the pallet firm to the arm.
Screw all of the treble mechanism into place before gluing the pallets on so that you can adjust the position relative to the holes and each other.
-
General PVA has worked fine for me when gluing leather to felt. Sometimes you need quite a lot if the felt is very absorbent.
Alternative is to apply the adhesive to the leather (and pallets) simply because the felt is absorbent.
If saturated with glue, when dry, it will have lost the resilience that it was put there to provide.
-
General PVA has worked fine for me when gluing leather to felt. Sometimes you need quite a lot if the felt is very absorbent.
No, no, no! Use the minimum amount of glue so it does not soak into the felt and harden it. Apply the glue as a thin smear to the pallet then press on to the felt side of the lining material.
-
I'm just saying that for gluing the felt to the leather you need enough so that the felt doesn't peel away at the contact surfaces because it's all soaked in. I can certainly see if you put too much onto the felt so that it hardens it's going to completely defeat the purpose of having a soft material there in the first place to shape to the holes and absorb the impacts.
-
Reading this page (http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,526.20.html) from an old thread might be helpful.
-
Latex based glue eh? I shall give that a go next time.
-
I have used 3M '77' spray adhesive quite successfully. It does not soak into the felt and is plenty strong. A light spraying is all that is needed.
-
So I am finished ....at least as far as I'm going to take the project. I kept the original bellows, the finish is not exactly as I planned (yes it's red, Mahogany) I'm no perfectionist and you can see that in the results of the finish. Although I have to say that I'm not ashamed of my efforts. The reed work though was done by Theo, I had him tune it dry, He did a magnificent job! The box may look a bit odd to some, it does to me but as I said it's my first go. Now I have put it up on ebay but now that someone has told me that the C/F box is a dime a dozen I realize I'll never get what I put into it as I knew was the case before I started. So here are some pix...be kind! The box does sound smashing if your an enthusiast of the dry sound. If there is a soul out there interested in taking this project off my hands at a reasonable price I will entertain offers. I figure I will never play this configuration, I'm just too busy learning B/C box.
-
And another
-
One more
-
And another
-
One more