Melodeon.net Forums
Discussions => Instrument Makes and Models => Topic started by: Hans Lemmen on March 09, 2026, 10:51:03 PM
-
I'm happy with my Pokerwork DG, but I find it a shame that the main note is on the third button instead of the fourth.
I assume this isn't easy to change?
Is there a general preference for fourth buttons, or is a preference for the third button also common?
-
Until recently times every 2 row DG were 3rd button start. It was a historical choice made when the first DG melodeons were ordered by a tune collector in the 1950's.
Many still are.
I started in 2010 and there was a push by some members here to change the standard box to a 4th button start.
To change a 3rd button start to 4th means loosing the reeds on the bottom button of each row ( nearest feet ) and moving every set of reeds down a button until there is space on the second button on each row. Then adding new reeds there. The common choice being G/A on the D row button and B/C on the G row button.
It is a choice thing.
It made sense to me even as a beginner as the addition means the 2 row goes down to low G, the lowest note on a fiddle, and most tunes were fiddle tunes.
In my morris side I think all the melodeon players are still using 3rd button start boxes as the tunes they play don't need the lower notes.
The tunes I play do use those notes!
-
Or, of couse, you can choose to have accidentals on those buttons, though, with a 4th button start, it's an even bigger jump to reach them.
-
I have made up a D/G box for my entertainment where the D row starts on button 3 and the G row starts on button 4!
Definitely not recommended for established D/G players, but a personal choice only by me as a semitone player, moving the C natural into a similar position as with the D/C+ system and also places some of the available reversed notes on the D/G box in nice positions for sliding triplets or other ornamentation.
Moving the G reeds up the reedblock was made easy by removing a spacer strip on the blocks that I have. This resulted in a good reedplate fit into the next chamber.
As I say, for my entertainment only and not dissimilar to some aspects of semitone system playing.
-
In reply to Clive:
Having really small hands, I've never found the accidentals too far to reach with a 4th button start.
I just rotate from the wrist and make sure your first finger is free to play the top button. This might incur finger juggling with the notes before playing the accidental but it's never been a problem.
-
To solve the big jump on the 4th button start I swap the low notes and the accidentals around. So muscle memory stays the same for the jump to an accidental but I've still got those low notes for when I need them. So chin end starts with the low note, then the accidental then the layout continues as normal.
It sounds really strange but I've quite enjoyed it! It's become my go to layout for my own boxes. I got the idea from Peter Bearon who used to play for Handsworth, he had a couple of boxes with this layout.
-
We discussed this at great length 15 years ago. Consensus was that 3rd start is just fine for GC (which is the original paradigm for the Viennese "accordéon") The furthest tonality away from that, musically, is D#/G#, and D/G … is pretty close to that?
When Melodeons were introduced in Britain in the 60s The manufacturers simply replaced European tonality reeds with a D/G set, effectively shifting all the music that we play up by a 5th interval. That's fine in the lower octave but led to very high-pitched notes in the upper octave. It was commonly referred to as the "squeaky end"
Some people had experimented with shifting all of the buttons up by one position and putting in 4 extra low notes. There was a strong consensus that this made a lot more sense for British sessions and our music. Slight concerns about it being a long stretch to the accidentals if you had small hands. We then had a debate as to what the extra extra notes might be
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7358.msg92844#msg92844
I wrote to the major manufacturers and as far as I can tell they seem to have implemented what Melnet asked for. Except Hohner … who didn't even reply to my letter.
Plenty more discussions around 2010/11 which you can find using search. 4th start is strongly recommended for any new instrument, and I actually have it on my G/C!
But if you have an instrument already, is it worth the £200 or so for somebody to convert it? I did that with one of my old Lilly, slightly cheaper in those days. But if you play your tunes in the lower octave, and don't have any great desire to do flourishes or reprises in the upper octave it might be sensible to just carry on with you've got?
-
Thanks Chris.
I came into the fold when these discussions you describe took place in 2010. As a total new beginner the change to a 4th button start made total sense to me.
I bought my first melodeon as a 3rd button start and within the year ha it converted. Since then I've made sure all my boxes are 4th button start.
-
It all depends on what you play. I have always played 3rd button start (40+ years) and never felt the lack of low notes. About 2 years ago I bought a Hascy that was 4th button so I had the low notes and accidentals swopped, for the reasons already discussed. Since then I have only found one tune that needs one of the low notes, so it really depends on what you are wanting to play. As is often the case with melodeons there is no one "right" answer!
-
Yes Tufty, as ever, it does depend on what you play so the choice of 3rd button start might have absolutely no effect on your playing.
-
After much thought I've decided to change my DG Mory to fourth button start. Not just because I miss having a middle C, but because the placement of the accidentals on the part row will be closer to that on my fourth button start Rik which I play most frequently these days.
I did wonder about the feasibility of changing my old Pastourelle 2 to fourth, and having another pair of accidentals on button 1 D row, G/C on G row. However that would mean the idiosyncratic part row accidental layout (C/D, E/Eb, F/F and C/D) would work less well fingering wise with the main rows. But more importantly getting matching reeds for the new first buttons could be very difficult - they don't make 'em like that any more !
Julian
-
After much thought I've decided to change my DG Mory to fourth button start. Not just because I miss having a middle C, but because the placement of the accidentals on the part row will be closer to that on my fourth button start Rik which I play most frequently these days.
I did wonder about the feasibility of changing my old Pastourelle 2 to fourth, and having another pair of accidentals on button 1 D row, G/C on G row. However that would mean the idiosyncratic part row accidental layout (C/D, E/Eb, F/F and C/D) would work less well fingering wise with the main rows. But more importantly getting matching reeds for the new first buttons could be very difficult - they don't make 'em like that any more !
Julian
I thought about 4th button start, but decided I didn't want, (or was too old!), to re-learn the relationship between the main rows and the 3rd row. I too missed the low C Julian, but I have learned to "borrow" the low C from the bass end when needed. It kind of works when you get used to it.
Dave
-
Very interesting replies! I did not expect the preferences for both options to be about equally strong. So there is a good change that I can get my DG Pokerwork with the 3th sold, once I would buy a better instrument one day.
-
Very interesting replies! I did not expect the preferences for both options to be about equally strong. So there is a good change that I can get my DG Pokerwork with the 3th sold, once I would buy a better instrument one day.
D/G Pokerwork is often recommended here (with good reason) as a beginner's box, and though I'm an enthusiastic advocate for 4th button start, there's a hell of a lot of music you can play on a 3rd button start D/G melodeon. So yes, you'll have no trouble selling it.
-
The real issue in this is the mechanics of steel reeds, and that the notes above octave G, inner row sound so squeaky. There is actually another solution … to get a box with LM voicing. The lower voice read stabilises things and you can play much further into the upper octave. Both my melodeons are that. But it isn't an option on a pokerwork.
Repertoire? Again it isn't an accident that popular UK melodeon tunes "work' on a DG. It was designed to suit 1960's fiddle repertoire commonly in D G or A and handles that quite well. Where a fiddle taking the lead you are often well advised to drop into chording anyway? Nor is is a problem on the D row. Its upper octave is very useful; it is very close to see which seems to be more or less "sweet spot" for steel reeds (to my ear). The problem there is that you have a more limited set of courts on the left.
I started to run into problems when I moved towards French repertoire, Which are commonly in C, or Am/D in the octave below middle C. Even in Em I seemed to need some lower notes and 4th start provides those.
That also a trick. (for 3rd start) When you want a turnaround B note below the tonic, it isn't there on the right. Just flick bellows into push mode, and hit the B base on the left, very briefly, "dabbing it in". Part of the magic of melodeons is that once you get that smooth, no one will ever notice. And only fellow melodeonistas will wonder how you did it? 😉
Don't worry. There's still a market. It probably isn't worth converting it (instrument that I converted was single voice, so ± half the cost). And if you stick to English session repertoire you won't have many problems. But then … contemporary English session repertoire has evolved around D/G 3rd start!
-
There is actually another solution … to get a box with LM voicing…. But it isn't an option on a pokerwork.
Oh yes it is !!! ( with the greatest respect, Chris!)
Mike
-
There is actually another solution … to get a box with LM voicing…. But it isn't an option on a pokerwork.
Oh yes it is !!! ( with the greatest respect, Chris!)
Mike
Don't tell my LM Erica (Banderica (:) )
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rONFTyBGCJQ (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rONFTyBGCJQ)
-
Excellent Lester!
-
I didn't know that Hohner did LM at all! So thanks.
But isn't their Erica … a different model?
[Edit]
On website, it looks that the pokerwork is no longer made. The "Vienna" looks …similar. Both Vienna and their Erica are "3-voice MMH"
But saliently, neither seems to be available from manufacturer in D/G tuning? Which was what I was talking about. Do they do D/G … at all?
-
I didn't know that Hohner did LM at all! So thanks.
But isn't their Erica … a different model?
Hohner does not make an LM Erica but I did
It most certainly is/was and Erica before I stripped the celluloid that was damaged, varnished the plywood and changed it to LM
-
It most certainly is/was and Erica before I stripped the celluloid that was damaged, varnished the plywood and changed it to LM
You have a deep skillset, Lester. I've never done more than flip a reed-plate myself. I like my Eb as push and didn't come that way.
But you also need a full set of reeds for that, and I know you have that resource too 👍 But does that answer Hans's question?
-
On website, it looks that the pokerwork is no longer made. The "Vienna" looks …similar. Both Vienna and their Erica are "3-voice MMH"
Where does it say that?
Hohner website (https://hohner.de/en/instruments/accordions/diatonic/folk-line/erica)
-
I looked through a couple of lists looking for pokerwork, And didn't find it so it's a matter of interpreting what "it doesn't say that" means?
it's one of those pretending to be a folding book website so a bit difficult to search but it flicks the efficiently and the place to look at the present manufacture is under the diatonic models. The cheaper ones are to the front front
-
Chris, Hohner have never called a Pokerwork a Pokerwork. It has always been 2915 Vienna.
I can't see how you've come by the info that Erica and Vienna are 3 voice MMH.
The technical details clearly show that they are both 2 voice as they always have been.
-
3rd button start is just fine. Most typically a tune will range from the 5th note of the scale (D4 in G major), or the 1st note off the scale (D4 in D major). The low C#5 allows certain tunes typically in G to transpose down to D, which is nice sometimes (I do this a lot because I mostly play one-row)… Modal minor (Aeolian and Dorian) most commonly range from the 7th scale note (D4 in E minor). Sometimes a major tune can range from the 3rd of the scale. Very often these are written in Bb for fiddle, to enable the same range (from D4). Ironically, the fiddle is often sited as the reason for 4th button start (ironic because these tunes originally in Bb are then played down in G).
The standard DG is therefore great for playing in D, G and E modal minor, but less good for harmonic minor (typically from 5th note of scale, B in E minor, too high or too low), hence for repertoire heavily utilising harmonic minor GC is preferable (A harmonic minor typically ranging from E4)
Don’t be too put off by ‘squeaky’ notes. Here’s am the most famous version of a recent TOTM that appears to be played from button 6 to button 9 of a G row of a DG!.. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sNlkUAlvTgQ A dryer tuning helps a bit to my ears with the higher notes…
-
As an aside, I now realise that some common English session tunes have been modified over the course of time to fit on a 3rd button start melodeon.
ie. The first note of the Gloucestershire Hornpipe is low G but commonly/usually played on an octave above, the G of the 3rd button.
Such has been the uptake of the DG melodeon since the early 1950's, tunes have been made to fit onto it.
I suspect over the course of history tunes have been tweaked to fit on whatever the new instrument was.
-
I’m not sure of the origins of the modern version of the Gloucestershire Hornpipe (possibly the Old Swan Band?..) but it’s basically a version of the Bridge of Lodi aka Nelson’s aka Saxon’s Hornpipe, the 1810 version of which is in the key of D, with the very typical range D4-B5. Full 2 octave tunes are fairly rare, and they are often pitched in Bb eg sailor’s Hornpipe (Bb3-Bb5). Those tunes are usually played in G on melodeons with low notes, but would be equally correct in D…
-
Chris, I still have no idea what LM means. Neither what the tonic is.
-
LM is Low and MIddle, and refers to one set of reeds in a middle octave and another set in a lower octave. The two notes sounding are an octave apart.
I believe that the tonic refers to the first note of a chord e.g. the tonic of a C chord would be C, followed by E and G as the third and fifth.
-
The root note is the first degree of a chord (containing the 1st, 3rd and 5th note of a scale from a given point), and this changes with each new chord. The tonic is the first note of a scale, ie the key note, and remains the same as long as you stay in the same key. I’ve heard the tonic also described as a root but I think this is an Americanism…
-
Chord descriptions are rooted in the Diatonic scale, which is what we have on-row, and corresponds to the white notes of a piano (in C)
You just count along those notes. As Winston just did.
The relativity is to that first note which normally corresponds to the note you're playing as a base. It gets a little more complicated with the other chords. For example if you're playing in C and use an Am chord, You use the A(root) minor notes that are in that Home C-scale. A=1, C=3 E=5, G=7.
Jazzers make their living 😉 by altering those other notes ±#/b, and have some other notations, but every jazz trio has a bass player who defines the active note-1. But we have our own bass on the left and you just press your pull-A bass. Whether you add the court as well it is optional but most people do initially. That's enough. Any more would take us too far off topic.
Just to add that the standard melodeon set up is absolutely brilliant 🙂 for playing in the tonic majors of your two rows, and their associated minors
I note Arnold's comment while typing. I quite like the word tonic to label the scale of your row. That stays the same whereas root always refers to whatever … chord is in play "at the moment". That avoids ambiguity 👍
3rd v. 4th start is immaterial. The notes are just in different places on each row, and your fingers get used to that.
-
I am learning the chords for the right hand on my Pokerwork DG, using the layout from this site, start on 3.
The B minor chord sounded bad and it turned out that my instrument has a different layout. On the 5 th button from the G-row the E and the D are reversed.
This is confusing, as I now will have to learn certain chords in a different way than the tutorials show. And also different than my next instrument will probably be.
-Why are the D and E reversed? I bought the instrument in the Netherlands, where I live. Is this a typical Dutch feature?
-I guess having the tongues back reversed should be not too difficult…?
-
That's commonly known as a "Dutch reversal". You can still play a push D and a pull E by reaching over to the D row, but it gives you the ability to play a pull D and a push E, which can both be very useful for some chords and for smoothing out some phrases when you want to. I wish I'd learned on a box with a Dutch reversal because it seems very useful on paper, but I can't be bothered relearning everything now.
-
Ah, so it is not necessarily a disadvantage .
However, if all the teaching material shows it differently, that does not make it easier.
The choices are: adapting the instrument now, or adapting the fingering when learning and adapting it back once I will have a new instrument (which will not have the Dutch Reversal).
-
if you are new to the melodeon then the Dutch reversal is an absolutely brilliant solution to so many problems. Do it!
But if you are already playing without much thought on the main rows then you're going to have to "unlearn" every tune that you have ever practised up. Its … forgiving if you hit the wrong button on the bull, but that push E sounds really ugly when you hit it accidentally, either in a musical phrase, or even worse, in to right-end cord.
I Dutch reversed my box in summer - it's easy. Just turn the plates over and wax them back in. It didn't survive longer than mid September
Be aware that there is also "Club" system, popular in Germany that would have a D/D button in the middle of the in a row. That is very forgiving wrt normal repertoire. I was able to pick one up in dealers having played nothing but DG and knock tunes out very quickly. It also offers a very good palate rt-end chords. Don't worry about it as you will be able to transfer to that sort of system later on.
-
if you are new to the melodeon then the Dutch reversal is an absolutely brilliant system of so many problems. Do it!
But if you are already playing without much thought on the main rows then you're going to have to "unlearn" every tune that you have ever practised
Also if you learn Dutch reversal system and get another box later, you'll have to convert that to Dutch reversal too.
-
Also if you learn Dutch reversal system and get another box later, you'll have to convert that to Dutch reversal too.
It will also screw around with right-hand chord possibilities on the G row. At least that's my excuse for ultimately not taking the plunge.
-
It massively opens up right end chords, Helen.
As I say, you can get most of the way there with a pull-D (Club system ). My own layout is idiosyncratic, but it has no push E. It's fine. It's fine 👍
We do seem to have consensus? Choose a traditional "Vienna" layout, or "Dutch reversal" early on. Then stick with that choice !!
-
This is confusing, as I now will have to learn certain chords in a different way than the tutorials show. And also different than my next instrument will probably be.
The choices are: adapting the instrument now, or adapting the fingering when learning and adapting it back once I will have a new instrument (which will not have the Dutch Reversal).
Modify the D/G now, I would say. It will simplify your way forward. Popping out 2 reedplates, flipping them around and rewaxing is no major work. There -may- be a need to tweak the tuning of the 4 notes (vibrating within the confines of a chamber is not the same as out in the open...).
The traditional layout is the most popular, probably for a good reason. I suspect the people who came up with Dutch reversal (or the Club layout, or the umpteen flavors of 2-1/2 row D/G often discussed here, etc...) felt they needed something different and went ahead with the change. So much for sticking with one's choice. You can always adjust/change later if you feel the need.
-
Thanks. But I am slowly moving towards leaving it that way. The Dutch Reversal seems to be an improval, although not picked up in every country. It increases the possibilities of the instrument.
My brain will have to work a bit whenever a D or E on the 5th button of the G row is written but I think I will quickly get used to that. Also: until now in my micro short career, I learned by ear and I have to problem to play what I hear.
As for my future “good” instrument: I am dreaming about a GC 2,5 row (I like the lower sound) and maybe it will even get the 5th reversed if I keep liking it on my current instrument.
-
I'd say it's well worth sticking with the Dutch reversal. I did this on my main instrument 4 years ago and it opened up the keyboard so much I do it on ally own boxes now.
You will learn different runs and chord shapes to take best advantage, but it costs you nothing if you learn that way from the start.
-
Also if you learn Dutch reversal system and get another box later, you'll have to convert that to Dutch reversal too.
Not necessarily, as long as you still have that reversal note on the 3rd row ;D
I was so used to playing with Dutch reversal, when I got the Pariselle box I had to convert it. I converted it back within two weeks and have been playing that way since. When I pick up the old box with Dutch reversal, I consciously note the reversal and just treat the key as the one on the 3rd row.
-
The reversed D note gives complete D and G major scales / modes on pull. Keeping the reversal on the G row frees up any # row for 4 additional notes to give full chromaticism on pull… The reversed E means you have a push Em chord and is good for ornamentation and adding a 6th to the tonic chord…
On the other hand, if you wish to play in G in the traditional push pull manner, you do need to be careful with certain notes, particularly the C# sharing a button with D!.. Slightly besides the point but I don’t really like Dutch reversal on my GC instrument though, because it lands in an awkward part of the most used range, and you end up wanting the equally useful higher G/A reversed too, which puts those notes in awkward positions. On a DG the reversal feels more comfortable in the usual positions and the higher reversal is not missed.
-
it’s lands in an awkward part of the most used range, and you end up wanting the equally useful higher G/A reversed too, which puts those notes in awkward positions…
What exactly would make that a practicle problem?
-
It’s hard to explain, but I find that when your index finger is between button 5 or 6, as it often is in GC repertoire, there is a lot of jumping about, but on a DG, the index finger rarely has to venture further than button 4, and the higher notes up to B fall into a nice little triangle… On a GC, were the equally useful higher G to be reversed, this would put the pull A all the way up on button 11, where the notes are already drifting further apart…
-
So actually it has to do with the tradional repertoires for GC and DG…? So if I’d play the DG repertoir on a GC, that disco fort would not occur?
I am planning to buy a GC in the future. Not for the traditional repertoire but only because I like the lower sound of it. As I will play alone, matching with other instruments will neither be an issue.
But now that you mentioned this, I might consider having that reversed button only with the accidentals on a 2,5row GC, like Jarviw on his 3th row.
-
If you’re just playing the same tunes but lower then it won’t make a difference. However, most traditional GC repertoire that I’m aware of is in basically the same range as that for DG (think G4 to G5 being the core octave of the range) and therefore is played further towards the knee end of the instrument. This is where I personally find the Dutch reversal to be more flawed, but others with far greater experience may disagree!..
-
I still have to get used to the fact that there are so many personally favoured layouts for this instrument. Not to mention the different keys . Imagine if that were the case with the piano or any other instrument. I am slowly building on my own dream-layout.
:-\
-
I still have to get used that there are so many personally favoured layouts for this instrument. Not to mention the different keys . Imagine if that were the case with a piano or any other instrument. I am slowly building on my own dream-layout.
:-\
I strongly recommend collecting at least 15 years of experience/repertoire before deciding on your "ideal" layout. In the interim you might well want to simply add another 2-row box in a different key or perhaps a 3-row (I recommend ADG) to aid you in your explorations.
-
I’ll second Dick’s advice. As a repairer I see many examples of idiosyncratic layouts, often designed to make a limited range of phrases “easier”. The most extreme example I can think of was a DG 2.5 row instrument where the owner wanted a pull C# on the half row because they couldn’t always find the C# on the D row!
-
Dick is right, just starting playing and get some tunes under your belt.
Your tune choice may well be different once you play. I have gone off on a different road since starting playing as I've become interested in tunes not normally played in common sessions, simply because they interest me!
Give yourself time and just enjoy playing and see where you go... it might not be where you think when first starting off.
-
They all work! They're all straightforward in the major keys.
minor cadences are more complicated on a simple non-chromatic instrument like ours.
Get some experience and decide whether you like simple folk harmonies, or those based on the harmonic minors, Klesmer etc.
I got in with a Jewish session in St Chartier once. Ended up playing Hava Nagila in about five different keys!
That's to say that matters who you're playing with. If you just do solos you'll have far fewer constraints.
-
Dick, Why ADG? In 15 year I don’t need another instrument anymore. Unfortunately I did not start when I was 20. So I am very keen in reading your opinions and advices.
Theo, Would you see a Dutch reversal on a DG as a bizar feature (in the case that I described)? On a 2,5 row DG would it make more sense to have it on the 3th row?
Chrys an Thrupenny Bit: I watched many video’s these last month. There is so much interesting material! I noticed that I prefer “strange” challeging tunes a bit more than the average folk music. (My this weeks’ tune to learn was a klesmer tune).
But I certainly want to learn playing Irish music and a number of morris tunes to learn the pulsing bass. For now, I will skip jazz. A man’s lifespan is limited……
-
Why ADG?
Fiddlers
-
Why ADG?
Fiddlers
Yup! We have up to five on a rough night. ;D
I'm learning Irish tunes in all those keys on a C#/D, and it's really straightforward – but it does help that the basses aren't usually used in pub sessions. Makes life less complicated when playing across keys and modes.
-
Why ADG?
I am very much in the beginners camp, but I have acquired a 3-row because I'm primarily a mandolin and fiddle player and play UK & Scandi tunes ... but my additional perceived use is that I can use the same cross-row patterns I have on the G row available on the D row?
-
Back to the start on 3 or 4 topic:
I saw a clip with somebody playing P&O Polka on BC and I decided to try it on my DG start on 3th, as my new project for the week. But when I tried it, I missed a low tone (maybe even more). So I can only play it on one octave higher which I don’t like. A Pokerwork only hs the high register so it sounds awfully high. Is this one the occasions where I could have played it one octave lower if I had a start on 4 instrument?
Off topic: asked AI to mention the origins of the tune title “P&O polka”. It presented this typical example of an AI forgery:
“The abbreviation P&O refers to the famous duo Pels & Onrust, who popularized the song in Dutch folk and entertainment music at the time.”
When asked to show proof, it replied
“I am sorry, but on second thought, I must correct my earlier assertion. There is no evidence to be found that a musical duo existed with the names "Pels en Onrust".
The abbreviation P&O in the context of the P&O polka usually refers to the shipping company Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company.” Never trust AI.
-
But when I tried it, I missed a low tone (maybe even more). So I can only play it on one octave higher which I don’t like.
Or you can stay at pitch and replace only the missing low tones with the same note an octave up, or some other note that sounds good (call it a variation). This is what flute and pennywhistle players do all the time.
-
If you like Klezmer, and harmonic minors in general then you should look at the Heim-2 layout. François is very into that sort of thing too (plus generic Eastern music, TBH).
He plays a full 3-row, with dutch inversion, and 18-bass. The whole thing hangs together really nicely … in a surprising number of harmonic minor scales, and their modes too, obviously.. Big box, so quite an investment; you have to be fairly sure where you're going before you buy one.
There probably quite a few on the secondhand markets by now as the layout has been around for about 25 years.
Video to assess - he has plenty more! https://youtu.be/0HHIE00E780
-
But when I tried it, I missed a low tone (maybe even more). So I can only play it on one octave higher which I don’t like.
Or you can stay at pitch and replace only the missing low tones with the same note an octave up, or some other note that sounds good (call it a variation). This is what flute and pennywhistle players do all the time.
If you look up the P&O Polka on The Session you will see that quite a few of the versions substitute that initial low B for the B in the next octave.
-
Or you can stay at pitch and replace only the missing low tones with the same note an octave up, or some other note that sounds good (call it a variation). This is what flute and pennywhistle players do all the time.
Yup.
No one plays tunes the same way every time anyway. You first adjust it to suit your instrument (apart from anything else, whistlers and fluters have to create breath spaces), then you make small changes every time so you don't get bored.
As long as it works with the spirit of the tune and it won't cut across what your fellow players are doing, it's fine.
-
If you like Klezmer, and harmonic minors in general then you should look at the Heim-2 layout. François is very into that sort of thing too (plus generic Eastern music, TBH).
He plays a full 3-row, with dutch inversion, and 18-bass. The whole thing hangs together really nicely … in a surprising number of harmonic minor scales, and their modes too, obviously.. Big box, so quite an investment; you have to be fairly sure where you're going before you buy one.
There probably quite a few on the secondhand markets by now as the layout has been around for about 25 years.
Video to assess - he has plenty more! https://youtu.be/0HHIE00E780
[/quote
Ummm, will put that on the wishlist for my next life, together with jazz. But thank you!
-
Or you can stay at pitch and replace only the missing low tones with the same note an octave up, or some other note that sounds good (call it a variation). This is what flute and pennywhistle players do all the time.
Yup.
No one plays tunes the same way every time anyway. You first adjust it to suit your instrument (apart from anything else, whistlers and fluters have to create breath spaces), then you make small changes every time so you don't get bored.
As long as it works with the spirit of the tune and it won't cut across what your fellow players are doing, it's fine.
Yup. Music is more than playing "all the right notes in the right order". The challenge and the JOY of playing an instrument is to express the essential nature of a tune/song/theme with what you're given to produce the sounds you desire. Packaging a musical theme into/onto a melodeon requires ( or engenders) what I term DIATONIC ORIGAMI which incorporates the phenomenon of diatonic sleight of hand to use phrasing, harmonization, dynamics and articulation to coax a tonal impression from the listener rooted in their personal music experience. This is the ART of musical endeavor apart from the mere mechanical manipulation of an instrument